Photographing children

  • Topic Locked - You will not be able to post to this topic. Needs cooling off
Blythman
Posted 24/01/2011 - 15:38 Link
robbie_d wrote:
Blythman wrote:
Robbie, how does the conversation go? Your little girl is on the swing with her skirt and short socks on and a guy is taking photographs of her with his 35mm slr
Why is he using film?
Thought you were all for freedom. Why not?
Alan


PPG
Flickr
robbie_d
Posted 24/01/2011 - 15:41 Link
Blythman wrote:
robbie_d wrote:
Blythman wrote:
Robbie, how does the conversation go? Your little girl is on the swing with her skirt and short socks on and a guy is taking photographs of her with his 35mm slr
Why is he using film?
Thought you were all for freedom. Why not?
I'm curious why he hasn't switched over to digital. I've edited my original response to make it more clear for you.
If you can't say something nice about Pentax, you won't say anything at all.

Apparently.
Blythman
Posted 24/01/2011 - 15:45 Link
Thanks for that Don. Not sure what you're trying to say, so I'll end this conversation with you

Don aside, I didn't start this thread. I made a single comment on another one
Alan


PPG
Flickr
johnriley
Posted 24/01/2011 - 15:48 Link
Don, too far with that, so I've removed the comment.
Don
Posted 24/01/2011 - 15:49 Link
I'll cite one more very specific example...
I worked at a Mental hospital.
There was a daycare center on the hospital grounds.
There was a forensics wing at the hospital.
3 Pedophiles at the hospital got day passes.
They did not hang around the daycare center while on day pass.
They did not own cameras.
They did however get caught trying to rent a house directly across from a grade school (same school my kids went to).....

It is idiotic to think violating Photographers rights is in any way shape or form going to protect your kids from these animals... a landlord near a park or school, checking references is much more effective.
Fired many shots. Didn't kill anything.
Edited by Don: 24/01/2011 - 15:55
Don
Posted 24/01/2011 - 15:51 Link
johnriley wrote:
Don, too far with that, so I've removed the comment.
fair.
Fired many shots. Didn't kill anything.
robbie_d
Posted 24/01/2011 - 16:02 Link
cardiff_gareth wrote:
The subject of shooting children is very emotive and it's a shame that it is but unfortunately, that's life and there's not much we can do about it. Below is the latest picture call from Fotolibra, look at the calls for teenage children shots:

Appologies but it's rather long and on iPhone so I just copied the lot over!


Hi Gareth Williams

New Inspiration

Minimum pixel dimensions: 2000x3000
Landscape, Portrait; colour or B&W
Deadline: Wednesday, February 2, 2011; 12:00 GMT
To submit images to Picture Calls in fotoLibra, simply click on the Picture Call megaphone icon below a thumbnail in your Collections, and select the relevant New Inspiration picture call from the drop-down menu which appears. Pictures must be marked as Rights Managed, and should not be sent direct to me.
This is an extremely complex (for us!) educational Picture Call and it's going to be a battle to get half these images together.

Please do your best — you will be rewarded with around £50 / $80 / €59 for each image selected and published.

The six photos on the first spread are meant to show three male and three female 16-year olds smiling and looking positive. Mixture of skin tones and hair colouring – with one black and one Hispanic teenager. Nationalities are irrelevant. Please use original as guide and select similar images.
·      Two large close up head and shoulders shots of attractive 16 year olds, 1 female (Carla) 1 male (Carlos), both smiling at camera or at each other.
·      Two more head and shoulders of 16 year olds male (Silvio) and female (Silvia)
·      Two more head and shoulders of 16 year olds M (Leo) and F (Leonie)
Shot of teenagers in a crowd reacting to something positively. Could be at a sports event (e.g. cheering at a football match) or concert (e.g. singing along in the crowd, etc).
Big stylish photo of 16-year-old girl in hoodie (with hood down, not up and covering her face), denim skirt and boots.
Big stylish photo of 15-year-old boy in shirt, jeans and trainers with a football – note: photos of Sophie and Rob should be the same size
Close up photo of 16 year old girl’s face as she talks on her mobile. The girl isn’t smiling or laughing but there is emotion on her face.
Beach scene at Newquay,
New up to date pic of Bethany Hamilton surfing: dramatic curling wave and with loss of arm clearly visible.
Crocodile swimming in a lake.
Contemporary photo of Rosa Parks – with some colour. Perhaps some kind of composite poster, including the bus
A photo of an approximately 15 year old male ice-hockey player.
Polar bear on ice
Close up photo of seated wolf at night, moonlight.
Photo of Ziad Youssef Fazah, world’s greatest polyglot, who speaks 58 languages fluently.
Photo(s) to illustrate women at work by Smita Barooah Sanyal
Colour pic of Valentina Tereshkova wearing space suit
Colour pic of Junko Tabei from Japan on top of mountain
Colour pic of Aung San Suu Kyi addressing crowd
Jennifer Murry – first woman to fly solo round the world in a helicopter
Film posters for
·      Twilight
·      High School Musical
·      Pirates of the Caribbean
·      Night at the Museum
·      Avatar
Just a thought — we are often being asked for film posters and although they are of course copyrighted the images are used editorially in these contexts, so if a poster is used in a street scene you can legitimately photograph the street scene which includes the poster — and of course Streetscapes are free uploads to fotoLibra. So every time a teen movie is advertised in your local High Street, bus shelter etc., take a photograph — including passers-by and other buildings and shops — and upload it to your Streetscape Portfolio.

Characters taking part in a reality TV show: Star School
Photo of a Simon Cowell type – 30s (presenter/director of school)
Photo of a woman in her 20s (voice coach)
Photo of a man in his 20s (dance coach)
Photo of another woman in her 20s (songwriting coach)

Montage of three teenagers – headshots, with speech bubbles. You don't have to do the speech bubbles, just allow space for them.
[Speech Bubble] This is a really cool website!
[Speech Bubble] Sharing books is a great idea!
[Speech Bubble] It’s fun, it’s green, and it’s free!
‘Luncheon of the Boating Party’ by Auguste Renoir. 1880-81.
‘Weeping Woman’ by Pablo Picasso. 1937.
‘Forget it, Forget Me’ by Roy Lichtenstein.
A teen-appeal film poster, e.g. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, OR Tron
Photo of teenage students relaxing outdoors.
Mother speaking to teenager under duvet. Calm mother is asking teenager, who is smiling, if he/she is going to stay in bed all day.
[Speech bubble from mother] Are you going to stay in bed all day?
Photo of one teenager talking/telling a story and three others listening intently.
Photo of Gliese 581g (it’s a planet)
Top section of rocket that looks like a pen/pencil
Craters on the moon that look like a chocolate chip cookie
Cloud cover from plane that could be snow or even sea
Glass section of astronaut’s space helmet with space things reflected
End section of a classic mounted telescope, e.g. AstroMaster 70AZ
A shooting star (not too long a tail)
Lively montage of numbered photos – about half the page: mix of genders
Someone using a mobile while driving
Someone dropping litter
Young teenager cycling on the pavement
Someone doing graffiti
Person walking on their hands across the road.
People in the developing world receiving aid – queuing up for bottled water.

Photo of diners in restaurant looking at menu – the menu is not legible. Modern cool restaurant with three or four diners in their early 20s. Mix of M and F no particular national style, restaurant could be anywhere.
Photo of Rocket U3 L1
Small photos of smiling teens: Asian, Hispanic, Caucasian, Japanese to depict
·      Alesha (Asian girl, who likes books with lots of exciting dramatic action).
·      Maria (Caucasian girl who enjoys romantic novels and she likes comedies).
·      Kazuo (Japanese boy who prefers non-fiction and he is interested in politics).
·      Paolo (Hispanic boy, who likes detective stories and he is keen on history.]
Images of furniture flying around. The text mentions a chest of drawers but furniture generally is also mentioned.
Colour photos illustrating these questions (they MUST include a teenage schoolchild)
Text for Question 3 –
You see a painter up a ladder on your way to school. Will you …
            A            walk round the ladder to avoid bad luck?
            B            walk under the ladder to prove it’s not unlucky?
            C            walk round the ladder because it’s safer?
Text for Question 4 –
You accidentally break a mirror. What do you say?
            A            ‘Oh dear, I’ll have seven years’ bad luck!’
            B            ‘I won’t be unlucky, touch wood.’
            C            ‘Never mind – I’ll buy another one.’
Text for Question 6 –
It’s evening and the sky is red. What do you say?
            A            ‘Oh, that’s lucky – the weather is going to be great tomorrow!’ (with girl/boy cheerful)
            B            ‘I hope it won’t rain tomorrow.’ (with girl/boy anxious)
            C            ‘I’m going to check the weather forecast.’ (with girl/boy determined)
Striking image similar to this: http://www.powerofmemory.com/Images/MemoryBrain.jpg
Photos of levitation (e.g. P.T. Plunkett)
Famous photo of levitation by Plunkett in the Illustrated London News http://bit.ly/fm48oy
Raining frogs and fish
Bigfoot
Photo of Arctic terns migrating.
Teen riding a horse (dramatic pic of horse jumping over log in wood or over a hedge in a field, but NOT in a riding school or show jumping setting)
Teen going camping with friends (teens erecting tents – more than one if both M and F — in idyllic scene)
Teen skiing with close up of high speed turn/jump (but not part of skiing competition)
Close up of teenage boy holding fairly newborn baby in arms.
Photo of Ewan McGregor and Charley Boorman who have just arrived in Kazakhstan in the TV series Long Way Round, with their bikes
Freerunning (showing wall/building)
Para-skiing (showing skier and parachute)
Zorbing (showing ball and hill)
Kite-surfing (showing kite and surfboard)
People screaming on roller coaster
Someone bungee jumping
Photo of Usain Bolt in his Lightning Bolt winning celebration pose.
Two 15/16 year old students talking to each other in class – mix English, Asian, etc.
Dramatic photo of Machu Picchu, preferably with a llama or two.
Photo of Inca Trail.
Photo of Lake Titicaca.
One photo with both the following components, i.e. a group of tourists photographing a group of Masai who are jump dancing.
[SBs from tourists.]
[Speech Bubble] Wait until the guys back home see this!
[Speech Bubble] Say cheese!
[Speech Bubble] Great! I wanted to get a picture of the Masai jump dance!
[Speech Bubble] Do you think we should give them money?
 [SBs from Masai]
[Speech Bubble] How much do you think they’ll give us?
[Speech Bubble] Do they think we’re animals in a zoo?
[Speech Bubble] Do they know that we lost our land when they built the tourist resort?
Ruth Amos
Ryan Patterson
Krysta Morlan – on waterbike in pool photo
Photo of Braille showing correspondence between alphabet and dots similar to or same as original.
Photo of footballers celebrating after scoring a goal (i.e. jumping all over each other)
Glossy stylish photo montage of:
A chair made from books
Boeing 747 made into a house: http://bit.ly/cPMXFO
T shirt from plastic bottles
Shoe as plant pot
Pencil case made from car tyre (Remarkable.co.uk)

Recycle Now logo
Photo of Leonardo’s reconstructed car on display in Florence. See original repro sketch showing side view of car from Folio812r of Atlantic Codex
Alexander Graham Bell
Painting of the Mona Lisa
The Simpsons
Collage of photos of famous inventors/sports stars/explorers/adventurers (dead or alive), even male / female gender balance.
Tanni Grey-Thompson in chair racing or winning race
Photo of crane (industrial/building crane)
Photo montage to illustrate a news survey, so it would be a news magazine, any newspaper, any newsreader, a news website and a noticeboard with notices on – as many of these items as possible:
A magazine
A newspaper
A TV newsreader
A mobile phone
A computer website
A noticeboard
Alex – African grey parrot – looking at brightly coloured numbers on tray
Kanzi the ape with Dr SR
Ray Tomlinson – suggest quite striking one of him drawing with a light wand
Photos of teenagers smiling.
Peter aged 17
Natasha aged 17
William on windmill © TED/Tom Rielly – from The Boy Who Harnessed The Wind
Photos to illustrate the following text:
Two teenagers capsized in the sea off the south coast of England and called Japan on a mobile phone to ask for help.
            Brother and sister Ken and Emily Booth were on a sailing holiday near Southampton. But because of huge waves their dinghy capsized and they were thrown into the sea.
            Ken, 17, and Emily, 16, spent 30 minutes trying to right the capsized dinghy, but without success. They couldn’t get back into the dinghy, and they couldn’t attract the attention of passing ships. After they’d been in the water for about 40 minutes, the situation was getting serious, and they felt very cold. Then Emily remembered her mobile phone in its watertight container in her pocket and reached for it.
            But she didn’t think of dialling 999, the emergency number. Instead she phoned their father, who was 6,000 miles away in Tokyo on a business trip. Emily explained: ‘I thought it would be quicker to phone someone I knew and tell them our postion. I dialled Dad’s number and he contacted the coastguard.’
            About ten minutes later, after they had held on to the dinghy for nearly an hour, they heard a helicopter. Next, everything happened very quickly, and Ken and Emily were picked up and carried to safety.
A capsized dinghy
Someone being winched to safety in helicopter
Class of very young Chinese or Indian children who are clearly learning English.
Hungry kya? poster, eg http://www.pinkpeppercorn.co.in/
Domino’s Hungry kya? poster
Call centre – but close up of a couple of telephonists rather than view of dozens, at least one woman
Gyeonggi English Village + students, eg 2nd pic on this site, but English words must be clear
One full page picture of large dam taken from low down with water pouring through
Head and shoulders photo of ‘Kate Ellis’, a fictional environmental campaigner in her 20s
Burj Khalifa Dubai with something else in the pic to give scale
Puvirnituq igloo
Shanghai Corporate Pavilion from Shanghai World Expo 2010. There are lots of shots showing it as purple but there are others showing it with a variety of colours and that is what we want as it matches the text.
Royal Villa at Grand Resort, Lagonissi, Athens. The interior is much more interesting than exterior shots
Erwin Wurm: House Attack (Vienna) – lots of images on web.
An aborigine
Coral reef
Cassowary
Niagara Falls
Polar bear in tundra
Humpback whale
Illustrate the following text:
Work in a group and make a list of extreme places – parts of the world which are difficult to live in. They can be difficult because they are very hot, cold, wet or dry, or because they are very high, or very remote. Then choose two to write about.
Research: Find out information about each place and make notes.
Where is it? Who lives there? What language(s) do they speak?
What is the landscape like? (Jungle, desert, or ice and snow? Are there hills, rivers, lakes, trees?) What kind of wildlife is there?
What is the weather like? Maximum and minimum temperatures?
How do you get there?
What’s good about the place? What problems are there?
People living in cold/snow/ice environment – perhaps Inuit people
People living in dense jungle environment
People living at high altitude
People living in very hot conditions/desert
Photo of the islands of Tristan da Cunha in the South Atlantic Ocean.
Wildlife in the rainforest of Queensland
Kind regards,
Jacqui Norman

Know someone who might have these pictures?
Then FORWARD this Picture Call
Whisky
Tango
Foxtrot
?
If you can't say something nice about Pentax, you won't say anything at all.

Apparently.
Edited by robbie_d: 24/01/2011 - 16:02
Don
Posted 24/01/2011 - 16:06 Link
Blythman wrote:
Thanks for that Don. Not sure what you're trying to say, so I'll end this conversation with you

Don aside, I didn't start this thread. I made a single comment on another one
I was trying to say: if you twist things around enough, you can make a case to violate ANYBODIES rights, for the cause of "PROTECTING THE CHILDREN".
I think you got that point even if you choose to be disingenuous about what I was saying.
you could hypothetically make an argument to ban two major religions, one for sex abuse scandals, the other for recruiting child soldiers and suicide bombers....

The actions of a few, make it ok to violate the rights of many?
Fired many shots. Didn't kill anything.
Edited by Don: 24/01/2011 - 16:09
robbie_d
Posted 24/01/2011 - 16:10 Link
Don wrote:
Blythman wrote:
Thanks for that Don. Not sure what you're trying to say, so I'll end this conversation with you

Don aside, I didn't start this thread. I made a single comment on another one
I was trying to say: if you twist things around enough, you can make a case to violate ANYBODIES rights, for the cause of "PROTECTING THE CHILDREN".
I think you got that point even if you choose to be disingenuous about what I was saying.
Absolutely.

Lock everyone up "just in case". Otherwise they might see a child and get ideas.
If you can't say something nice about Pentax, you won't say anything at all.

Apparently.
Blythman
Posted 24/01/2011 - 16:13 Link
Don wrote:
Blythman wrote:
Thanks for that Don. Not sure what you're trying to say, so I'll end this conversation with you

Don aside, I didn't start this thread. I made a single comment on another one
I was trying to say: if you twist things around enough, you can make a case to violate ANYBODIES rights, for the cause of "PROTECTING THE CHILDREN".
I think you got that point even if you choose to be disingenuous about what I was meaning.
I think I did get the point you were trying to make. So did John. And you thought its deletion was fair. Given your recognition that you were out of order, I though maybe there would be an apology. Even checked My Messages, in case you didn't want to back track in public. But instead I'm now being accused

Never mind. I'm moving on. This is my last post in this thread.
Alan


PPG
Flickr
robbie_d
Posted 24/01/2011 - 16:15 Link
cardiff_gareth wrote:
I was highlighting the fact that the latest picture call from Fotolibra had lots of calls for children shots and that photographing children wasn't a crime
I got that, it was just the format scared me! Information overload!
If you can't say something nice about Pentax, you won't say anything at all.

Apparently.
Don
Posted 24/01/2011 - 16:18 Link
Blythman wrote:
Don wrote:
Blythman wrote:
Thanks for that Don. Not sure what you're trying to say, so I'll end this conversation with you

Don aside, I didn't start this thread. I made a single comment on another one
I was trying to say: if you twist things around enough, you can make a case to violate ANYBODIES rights, for the cause of "PROTECTING THE CHILDREN".
I think you got that point even if you choose to be disingenuous about what I was meaning.
I think I did get the point you were trying to make. So did John. And you thought its deletion was fair. Given your recognition that you were out of order, I though maybe there would be an apology. Even checked My Messages, in case you didn't want to back track in public. But instead I'm now being accused

Never mind. I'm moving on. This is my last post in this thread.
Johns decision to remove the post was fair. It is his job to keep things civil.
I'll not apologize for using blunt language to make a valid point. Well maybe I owe John an apology, the forum rules are clear.
Sorry John.
Fired many shots. Didn't kill anything.
Edited by Don: 24/01/2011 - 16:20
pentaxian450
Posted 24/01/2011 - 16:59 Link
Am I ever glad I'm not in your country. I regularly take pictures of/including kids, and I never have problems. And, most of the time, I don't ask permission. Fortunately, Canada has not reached England's level of paranoia.
Yves (another one of those crazy Canucks)
Pentaxophile
Posted 24/01/2011 - 17:01 Link
I would hope that the Great British Public in general have more sense than we give them credit for, and can distinguish between a photographer taking shots where a child is not the dominant part of the scene, and actively pursuing children with the camera (or lurking in the shadows with a telephoto lens).

Comment Image


I would hope that if a concerned parent were allowed to check through the shots on the LCD monitor, they would be able to tell whether a photographer's intentions were sinister or not.

Unlike in the case of this poor guy: link
(Reminds me of that famous case in the USA where someone was arrested for taking images of his OWN kids in the bath :shock

Personally I would give in to a request for an image to be deleted, if my attempts to defend what I was doing fell on deaf ears. It's not worth my time explaining the situation to the police, although obviously as I would blatantly not be up to anything 'wrong' or 'indecent' I have nothing to fear regarding anyone pressing charges. Plus it's kind of the polite thing to do!
Edited by Pentaxophile: 24/01/2011 - 17:05
Don
Posted 24/01/2011 - 17:09 Link
pentaxian450 wrote:
Am I ever glad I'm not in your country. I regularly take pictures of/including kids, and I never have problems. And, most of the time, I don't ask permission. Fortunately, Canada has not reached England's level of paranoia.
Manitoba is significantly more hillbilly and backwards than Montreal.
Having moved here from a more civilized and educated area of this great country, I assure you, I look forward to the day when I can relocate and re-integrate into a more normal society.
it is a crap shoot out here as to whether a father gets harassed for photographing his own kids at play.
Fired many shots. Didn't kill anything.

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo