PFA 100mm F3.5 Macro
Posted 15/12/2006 - 11:50
Link
I think this is the same lens which was sold under Cosina and Vivitar brands. From what I've read it is acceptable optically (though no match for the DFA F2.8 or comparable lenses) but its build quality leaves something to be desired.
If you're looking to get a macro lens on the cheap, I'd look out for the Tamron SP adaptall lenses (I have the F2.5 version and I like it a lot) or the Kiron 105 F2.8 on Ebay.
The Kiron is hard to get hold of because people who have them don't often sell, but is supposed to be among if not actually the best macro lens ever made. I saw one go on Ebay for £123 recently, missed out on it by £0.50 darnit!
If you're looking to get a macro lens on the cheap, I'd look out for the Tamron SP adaptall lenses (I have the F2.5 version and I like it a lot) or the Kiron 105 F2.8 on Ebay.
The Kiron is hard to get hold of because people who have them don't often sell, but is supposed to be among if not actually the best macro lens ever made. I saw one go on Ebay for £123 recently, missed out on it by £0.50 darnit!
Posted 15/12/2006 - 12:02
Link
This lens is quite a simple one of 5 elements/4 group construction. Both the DA and FA versions are 9/8. It is a "budget" lens along the lines of the Takumar A series lenses and will only focus to half life size. If you only need a macro for the odd use or for webwork, it is probable worth it but it is not a patch on the others. It is cheap for a reason.
Kim
Kim
Posted 15/12/2006 - 12:34
Link
Don't forget that the 5/4 construction is a very well established one, and used for many years in the Takimar Screw, K and M series lenses. There is no reason why, with such a limited aperture, results shouldn't be exceprional. Open up to f2.8 on the other hand, and especially extend the focusing down to 1:1 and you need 9/8 and similar constructions to deliver a similar quality level.
50mm f4 Macro lenses survive very happily with 4 element Tessar-type construction.
50mm f4 Macro lenses survive very happily with 4 element Tessar-type construction.
Best regards, John
Posted 15/12/2006 - 13:10
Link
I may have expressed myself badly. A 5/4 construction is not bad in itself optically. The A series 100/4 macro was a very good lens. However, this is the main reason why it only goes to half life size. You can get very good life size with such a lens but you need a 50mm extension tube which would mean the loss of many of the functions on a crippled mount camera such as the dSLRs. However, it does cost a lot less to produce and is therefore cheaper.
The performance issue is slightly different. From the days of the M series lenses, Pentax have produced slightly slower lenses which were built to a budget rather than a performance level. During the A series period they came out with the Takumars which were also budget lenses but did not have the same high quality coatings as the normal A series lenses. The fact that this lens was made by cosina is irrelevent, Cosina make some of the highest quality glass going in the form of many of the Zeiss lenses! The lens will be built to the spec of Pentax but that doesn't mean that Pentax have specified the same level of coating etc. the timeline of the lens was well into the production of the 2 life size f2.8 models. Both the A series 100 macros and the 2.8 AF lens are fantastic performers. I would not expect that level of performance from this lens even putting the limt of 1/2 life size to one side.
Kim
The performance issue is slightly different. From the days of the M series lenses, Pentax have produced slightly slower lenses which were built to a budget rather than a performance level. During the A series period they came out with the Takumars which were also budget lenses but did not have the same high quality coatings as the normal A series lenses. The fact that this lens was made by cosina is irrelevent, Cosina make some of the highest quality glass going in the form of many of the Zeiss lenses! The lens will be built to the spec of Pentax but that doesn't mean that Pentax have specified the same level of coating etc. the timeline of the lens was well into the production of the 2 life size f2.8 models. Both the A series 100 macros and the 2.8 AF lens are fantastic performers. I would not expect that level of performance from this lens even putting the limt of 1/2 life size to one side.
Kim
Posted 15/12/2006 - 13:14
Link
We have a SMC Pentax-FA 100mm f2.8 Macro that is indeed excellent and gives exceptional results.
Best regards, John
Posted 15/12/2006 - 13:20
Link
Indeed. The FA 1:2.8 100mm is superb. Built to withstand a direct hit from a Trident missile.
G
G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
Posted 15/12/2006 - 20:35
Link
Thanks, so my conclusions are pretty right.
I never seriously thought about it and as I said, I'm pretty set on the AF 2.8 model.
These days I'd rather save the money I'd usually spend on 4 or 5 lenses and buy one, so long as it has the best quality Pentax can give.
I never seriously thought about it and as I said, I'm pretty set on the AF 2.8 model.
These days I'd rather save the money I'd usually spend on 4 or 5 lenses and buy one, so long as it has the best quality Pentax can give.
"Snell's law & Sheimpflug make it all worth it"
Posted 12/03/2013 - 04:16
Link
This is a re-branded Cosina/Vivitar/Phoenix/Promaster/Voightlander version that is £50.00 on the used market. It's known as the 'plastic fantastic' due to it's cheap feel body and coffee grinder AF motor, but the optics are sublime. It's a 1:2 in native format with a 1:1 adapter lens (which is next to useless). Fabulous affordable macro lens, but not at the stupid money being asked for one with Pentax on it. I have the Vivitar version (2nd copy), and it's a hum-dinger!
Posted 12/03/2013 - 07:31
Link
I had one of these and it was a great performer nothing at all wrong with it. For the money you could do a lot worse.
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


63 posts
22 years
Melbourne,
Australia
I'm pretty much set on the new DFA 2.8 version but in my daily scouring of ebay, I found a number of these PFA F3.5 100mm macro pentax lenses going for unbelievable prices.
I had a look at Bojidar Dimitrovs site and he states the lens may have been made (or designed) by Cosina but used Pentax glass, electronics and SMC coating.
On first look I couldn't believe it was Pentax, it looked so much like the phoenix and other brands of that ilk that I thought it may have even been a copy and I even double checked to see that it said PENTAX and not something like PENNTAX but, yes, it's a Pentax.
Does anyone have experience with this lens?
To me it looks like the tackiest thing Pentax have ever brought out, but I'm interested to know if the glass is actually sharp???
Thanks.