Pentax 17-70 owners
Posted 18/06/2009 - 14:02
Link
https://www.pentaxuser.com/forum/topic/Pentax-1770--versus-the-Sigma-1770--Quick-user-experience-required-12757
You did looked there right before you placed your question?
I'm really not mad it's just that I think you will find what you need there or do you want a 16-45 vs 17-70 thing?
they are both equal in image quality, believed that the 17-70 is a bit less sharp but you have far less aberations then with the 16-45.
The 17-70 has a far more usefull range also, it's a no brainer to behonest if the price wasn't that much higher then the 16-45.
For the price you would surely love the 16-45.
You did looked there right before you placed your question?
I'm really not mad it's just that I think you will find what you need there or do you want a 16-45 vs 17-70 thing?
they are both equal in image quality, believed that the 17-70 is a bit less sharp but you have far less aberations then with the 16-45.
The 17-70 has a far more usefull range also, it's a no brainer to behonest if the price wasn't that much higher then the 16-45.
For the price you would surely love the 16-45.
Posted 18/06/2009 - 14:18
Link
I did read as much as I could find here.The 17-70 is only about 60 pounds more so it is a close call.
Thanks mm
Thanks mm
Posted 18/06/2009 - 14:34
Link
As I said in the other thread it is my main lens, and I am very happy with it. I've never had the 16-45 so can't comment on IQ differences. I prefer the range of the 17-70 and the fact it is a constant F4 and an SDM lens. Those are the reasons I chose it over the 16-45. The extra range and lower price were the reasons for not getting the 16-50*.
Posted 18/06/2009 - 15:24
Link
I find the 17-70 a bit "snappier" in terms of contrast/sharpness/colour. I really like the 16-45 as well, and it serves well for landscapes etc.
But the 17-70, especially with the longer reach, is much, much more useful (to me at least). Additionally, the bokeh seems much smoother on the 17-70 (very much like the SMC-FA 24-90 that I also have). There may be a touch more vignetting on the 17-70 compared to the 16-45, but there's not much in it (and in any case it can all be fixed in software).
The 17-70 is SDM only, and appears to be at least partially weather sealed (it has the rubber ring on the lens mount and feels very damped on the zoom).
Overall, I'm very happy with the 17-70... while my wife is thoroughly enjoying the 16-45 as a "very nice upgrade" to the kit 18-55 on her *ist-DS
Hope that helps!
Matt
But the 17-70, especially with the longer reach, is much, much more useful (to me at least). Additionally, the bokeh seems much smoother on the 17-70 (very much like the SMC-FA 24-90 that I also have). There may be a touch more vignetting on the 17-70 compared to the 16-45, but there's not much in it (and in any case it can all be fixed in software).
The 17-70 is SDM only, and appears to be at least partially weather sealed (it has the rubber ring on the lens mount and feels very damped on the zoom).
Overall, I'm very happy with the 17-70... while my wife is thoroughly enjoying the 16-45 as a "very nice upgrade" to the kit 18-55 on her *ist-DS
Hope that helps!
Matt
http://www.mattmatic.co.uk
(For gallery, tips and links)
(For gallery, tips and links)
Posted 19/06/2009 - 11:02
Link
Thanks all for your comments.I think you have helped me make up my mind.Not easy to do when it involves me spending money.
Regards mm
Regards mm
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



192 posts
18 years
South London
Thanks mm