Pentax 12-24

niblue
Posted 05/01/2008 - 15:58 Link
Quote:
The future can only be guessed at!
Very true. I bought a lot of old lenses in the last year or so (mainly M42 but some K-mount as well) and it's quite interesting to see what affects the value. Sometimes it's just the manufacturers name (e.g. a Sigma 24mm F2.8 is worth noticeably less than exactly the same lens with a Carl Zeiss badge on the front) but in others it's optical e.g. the SMC-M 28mm F3.5 usually sells for more than the SMC-M 28mm F2.8 because it's sharper (although the F3.5 is probably rarer).

At the moment I'm building a Pentax 645 system and the value of some of those lenses (especially the wide angles) has held up very well over the years. One of the lenses I've got coming from it is a pretty old Carl Zeiss Flektogon 50mm F4 (in Pentacon 6 fit as I've got an adaptor) that's probably worth significantly more now than it cost when new.
hefty1
Posted 05/01/2008 - 16:21 Link
Quote:
<snip> Such test results always have to be taken with a grain of salt given they're only based on a single sample of each</snip>
I couldn't have put it better myself, hence the hours I spent trawling the web looking at real photos taken by real people under real conditions - not brick walls in laboratorys...

I realise it's an entirely personal thing but at the end of my research I had to conclude that the Pentax just took a far better picture than the Sigma. As for distortion at the wide end, I find the Pentax is easily corrected in PP as it's nice and linear whereas the Sigma seems to give that moustache-like wavy distortion (from what I've seen). It could probably be corrected but would undoubtably involve more work. Maybe I just got a good sample but looking at other peoples' photos I'd say this was a general trend (although if you're primarily doing landscapes and other non-uniform subjects then this is almost certainly un-noticable and shouldn't be a factor in your buying decision).

Re-sale value was also something that I gave no thought to, rather I figured that if I just went ahead and bought the best then (barring accidental breakage) why would I ever want to sell it? If I'd bought the Sigma I'd probably still be kicking myself and wishing I'd spent the extra on the 12-24 (or I'd have sold it, swallowed a loss and ended up with the Pentax anyway).

I only carry/use 3 lenses with my camera (DA12-24, FA43 and D-FA100) so it's important to me that I have the very best glass at these focal lengths. I'm 100% confident that in all three areas that's exactly what I've got - any rubbish photos I take are entirely down to the user and not the equipment...
Joining the Q
niblue
Posted 05/01/2008 - 16:26 Link
Quote:
niblue wrote:
<snip> Such test results always have to be taken with a grain of salt given they're only based on a single sample of each</snip>
I couldn't have put it better myself, hence the hours I spent trawling the web looking at real photos taken by real people under real conditions - not brick walls in laboratorys...
That's what I do as well, primarily on pbase as you can select a lens and the site gives you random examples from all the shots posted with that lens. You have to trawl through a fair amount of crap of course but it's a good way to see the sort of results people are getting with a particular lens.
iceblinker
Posted 05/01/2008 - 17:53 Link
[quote="hefty1"]
Quote:
<snip> Such test results always have to If I'd bought the Sigma I'd probably still be kicking myself and wishing I'd spent the extra on the 12-24 (or I'd have sold it, swallowed a loss and ended up with the Pentax anyway).
Have many Sigma users done that? I think not.
~Pete
ikillrocknroll
Posted 05/01/2008 - 18:20 Link
Quote:


...I find the Pentax is easily corrected in PP as it's nice and linear whereas the Sigma seems to give that moustache-like wavy distortion (from what I've seen). It could probably be corrected but would undoubtably involve more work...
Just to let you know, the program PTlens has a database of lenses that it can automatically sort out distortion for, whether it be barrel, pincushion, or a combination (moustache; as in the sigma)

Daniel Bridge
Posted 05/01/2008 - 19:14 Link
[quote="iceblinker"]
Quote:
niblue wrote:
<snip> Such test results always have to If I'd bought the Sigma I'd probably still be kicking myself and wishing I'd spent the extra on the 12-24 (or I'd have sold it, swallowed a loss and ended up with the Pentax anyway).
Have many Sigma users done that? I think not.
Certainly not me. Bear in mind that with the Sigma the stranger distortion, where the image curves nearer the corner than in the middle, is gone by around 12mm, so like for like, as far as focal length is concerned, the Sigma could be said to have less distortion, plus the bonus of an extra 2mm of wideangleness to play with.

It's a lens I don't use a huge amount, but it would be the same if I'd bought the 12-24, so saving £300 was worthwhile for me.

Sharpness etc. with this lens is excellent, but I haven't tried the 12-24 to compare.

Dan
K-3, a macro lens and a DA*300mm...
Clarky
Posted 05/01/2008 - 20:04 Link
Thanks for all the useful information. I think either lens will be a great addition to my kit. (quality of both is very good) I have done a fair bit of research on both and i can get the Sigma for around 300quid and the Pentax for around 400quid.

I found i could haggle the price down on the Pentax but they won't shift on the price of the Sigma. Which tells me the Sigma is close too its cost price and the Pentax is being sold with a larger markup.

Availabilty has the Sigma on the shelf but i need to wait for the Pentax.

Well i will be purchasing one of these lenses this week and at this stage it looks like the Sigma but i might be swayed if my brand loyalty kicks into a higher gear

BTW my X-mas gift should arrive this week a DA*50-135 can't wait. Thanks again
Camera:|K-7|
Pentax Lenses:|DA12-24/f4 ED AL|DA35Ltd Macro|FA31Ltd|FA77Ltd|FA50/1.4|F70-210|FA20-35 f4/AL|A*200/f4 Macro ED|A50/1.7|A50 Macro f2.8|1.7xAF adapter|
Voigtlander|125/f2.5SL Macro APO Lanthar|
Sigma Lenses:|EX DG 100-300 f4|2X & 1.4X TC|
Flashes:|AF540FGZx2|RingFlash AF160FC|

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo