No change using polariser - does Ist DS compensate for it

Posted 11/05/2006 - 09:55 Link
Maybe this question has already been asked but I don't see a change in using the polariser filter on the digital. Sure, through the viewfinder but maybe I need to bypass something when shooting so its effect can be noticed (I always shoot in manual mode, so that's not it) ... any ideas?
MattMatic
Posted 11/05/2006 - 09:59 Link
What kind of change?

If you're thinking exposure change - well, you won't! Any TTL metering will automatically compensate for the polariser.
Polarisers work best with the sun at an angle to the subject (whether that's sky or water etc), so if you have the sun behind, or directly in front, you won't see a great difference. But at an angle you should have the ability to richen foliage, darken blue skies, and almost eliminate the reflections on glass and water.

If that doesn't help, let us know some more details!
Matt
johnriley
Posted 11/05/2006 - 10:44 Link
It does depend very much on the subject, so a lanscape with blue sky should show a marked effect, but a shot into the sun would not. As Matt says, the light should be coming in at an angle of 45 degrees for maximum effect.

Likewise, the polariser will remove reflections from water, but not from metal surfaces.
Best regards, John
Daniel Bridge
Posted 11/05/2006 - 11:27 Link
Hi David,

I can't comment on the DS, but I use a D. From your question, it seems you can see the difference the polariser makes in the viewfinder, but can't see the effect shown on your images once viewed on screen. To be honest, I can't see that there's any way the camera can 'compensate' for the polariser, ie cancel its effects out, as the filter physically changes the light coming into the lens, it doesn't just alter the colour balance (like a warm-up for example).

I suspect what's happening is this: As the polariser is used, and the glare from, for example, foliage is removed, you, or your camera, is increasing the exposure, and thus over-exposing. Thus the leaves look a bit washed out, and give the impression that the polarised effect has been lost.

Try 'under-exposing' by half a stop. So if you're using green grass as your average tone, underexpose this slightly.

To really see what I mean by this, try it with water (a pond or lake, not the washing up bowl!). With plenty of light reflected off it, the exposure would be fairly short to get a midtone from it. Using the polariser (at the ideal angle to the water) would produce very dark water, and therefore this is well below midtone. If you're going by the exposure meter, this would then up the exposure, and produce a midtone, which would appear washed out and perhaps seemingly unpolarised. 'Underexposing' would reproduce the true view through the polariser.

I hope that makes sense, and might help. I've certainly used a polariser with the usual expected result, both on film and digital. In fact it's on my lens 90% of the time, as it's effective, even if very subtley, in most lights.

All the best,
Dan
Anonymous
Posted 11/05/2006 - 11:37 Link
John said:

Likewise, the polariser will remove reflections from water, but not from metal surfaces.[/quote]John, why is that? And like the Thermos Bottle question - "How does it know?"

Polarisers are a pain in wide angle shots which include the sky. Only one part of the sky is at 90 degrees to the film plane vs the rest - resulting in multi-hued darkening. The wider the lens, the worse this becomes. I've often ruined otherwise beautiful landscape photos with CPL filters which cost as much as my lens.

I'm starting to agree with George anout the beauty of naked SMC lenses.

Mumble mutter
Don
Posted 11/05/2006 - 13:35 Link
think of it like passing spagetti through a slotted spoon, and thats what a polarizer does to lightwaves. the longer, straighter and more uniform the light waves are the more will pass through the slot. the less uniform ones get blocked. most surfaces will absorb some of the light that hits it and either effectively line up, or mess up, the waves that bounce off. Light from the sun is fairly uniform, Some materials like our atmosphere act like a diffuser, partially scattering the light that passes through. put on your filter and the reflected scatter gets blocked, and the effect is stronger.
then there's metal that absorbs so little and reflects so well that it renders your slotted spoon useless.
Fired many shots. Didn't kill anything.
Arthur Dent
Posted 11/05/2006 - 15:37 Link
Are you using a circular or a standard polarizer?

There's also the thumb rule (it's sort a rule of thumb :wink that if you point your thumb at the sun, and make your hand into a 90 degree angle, amfd rotate about the thumb axis, your pointer finger will point to the area where the polarizing effect is most noticable.
42 Comment Image
Posted 11/05/2006 - 16:22 Link
Thanks all of you for the input. Daniel, I think that's what happened, not that anything came out washed out but that the effect disappeared by the camera probably lessening the exposure time to compensate. In any event, I'd also completely forgotten about removing reflections from water - but I think it does help also with metal reflections, from what I remember. In any event, will experiment some more and bracket a bit to make sure the the polariser's getting the desired effect.

Now another related question, now that I've sold off the film cameras, and I realise that polarising filter, UV and ND filters are worth keeping, is there any reason whatsoever to hold onto the other filters? These are basically what I'd used for shooting B&W: yellow, green, blue (is the blue one still helpful for tungsten shots or should shooting in RAW make it redundent?). Thanks again for your input.
johnriley
Posted 11/05/2006 - 16:37 Link
To answer the question about water and metal. The light coming from the water is polarised so it can be filtered out my rotating the polariser. The light from a metal surface is not polarised so there is no effect.

The same is true of a shot into the sun. No polarisation, so no effect.
Best regards, John
gartmore
Posted 12/05/2006 - 08:17 Link
David,

Your blue filter (80A) isn't really of any use because you should be colour balancing your camera to shoot under tunsten light, an added advantage of this is that you dont lose any light - with the 80A you lose around 2 stops. This of course applies to JPEGS. This is the reason that professional motion picture film is mostly tungsten balanced using an 85B (orange) filter in daylight. The 85B only loses around 2/3 of a stop.

The reason that yellow, orange and red filters are used with B+W film is that B+W film isn't truly panchromatic i.e. it isn't equally sensitive throughout the colour spectrum particularly at the blue end, pale blue appears white.

Now the question arises, are digital sensors panchromatic? Does anyone know?

Ken
Ken
“We must avoid however, snapping away, shooting quickly and without thought, overloading ourselves with unnecessary images that clutter our memory and diminish the clarity of the whole.” - Henri Cartier-Bresson -
MattMatic
Posted 12/05/2006 - 09:44 Link
AFAIK the CCDs are panchromatic. This must depend partly on the quality of the bayer matrix filter (because the CCD just measures light levels, and the bayer matrix provides the split into RGBG - twice as many greens as reds and blues).

As you say, all white balancing should be done with the camera - not filters. Even JPGs can be white balanced - that's what the manual WB setting is for Personally I use the ExpoDisc and have had great results with RAW mode, but a much cheaper solution is the QPcard - that works a real treat on JPGs. You just take one shot of the card in the lighting, then use that as a reference and it will do an extremely good job of correcting JPGs (it's not for RAW).

What's also pertinent is that CCDs are linear, not logarithmic. Consequently exposure issues are slightly different. But then that's going off topic...

Matt
gartmore
Posted 13/05/2006 - 12:02 Link
Perfect skies over Glasgow this morning for a little experiment...

I photographed the same scene with a 1A, a Y2, an 0(G) and a polarizer. Removed the colour from the yellow and orange pics in two different ways: at RAW conversion and in photoshop. This gave me six images in total. The only picture that was different from the skylight one was the one using the polarizer. My conclusion is that the sensor is truly panchromatic and David mught as well get rid of his filters.

Matt, how does the expodisc work?

Ken
Ken
“We must avoid however, snapping away, shooting quickly and without thought, overloading ourselves with unnecessary images that clutter our memory and diminish the clarity of the whole.” - Henri Cartier-Bresson -
Mannesty
Posted 13/05/2006 - 15:58 Link
View Expodisc details at http://www.expodisc.com/

They're not cheap and you'd need several to cover all common lens sizes, or a bundle of adapter rings.

Besides, what would we find to do in the evenings if we didn't spend it colour correcting the days shooting.

I use a neat little card that came free with Scott Kelby's book "The Photoshop CS book for digital photographers". I think there's a CS2 version as well. The card is divided into three, one third each of black, grey, and white. You just shoot a pic in the prevailing light conditions and save it as the reference for the rest of the shoot. Works well for me and best of all its free . . . well you ignore the fact that the book costs £30.99 . . . don't you?
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo