K20D versus Nikon D300

  • Topic Locked - You will not be able to post to this topic. to end continued bad feeling in the thread
Anvh
Posted 15/07/2009 - 16:00 Link
hmmm seems like I'm the only one that went out shooting some photos and spend some time with your loved one.

So were did things get so heated?

Tooks wrote:
paullucas wrote:
Tooks, I didn't realise that you changed system. Did you get the same stick as well then from a certain someone?
Yeah, I did!
Show me the thread Iain, I couldn't find it.

paullucas wrote:
I was refering to the Smaller format and I thought that was pretty obvious really, but if you want to throw in the Hassleblad then you do that, I am not commenting on it!
No it wasn't obvious since I thought at first it was only about APS-C cameras in the range of the Pentax K20D since this is a pentax forum after all and we were talking about the K20D and the D300.

paullucas wrote:
Again, The D3X is widely known as the best FF camera, I stand by what I said about Yves comment. I brought the D3 into the conversation as it was one of the cameras I was looking at. Yves was talking about Nikon in general so that is why I brought the D3 into it. DX & FX not MF.
Yves comment was an reaction on my comment that the colour of the D300 photos weren't correct. I believe that was quite clear also but you could as easily take it as a general comment if you want.
The D3X is probable the best FF camera at the moment but you didn't say that you said it was the best camera, so don't blame me for making a generalization since you weren't specific and moving the focus away from the original topic.

paullucas wrote:
I am talking about Nikon and Pentax here, I purposefully left Canon out, please read my comments properly.
That's fine but it isn't all about you Paul and you should read you comments properly since you said this.
I am well aware that other camera makes will be introducing HD Video into their cameras, but not yet. The more professional end cameras may or may not have this facility, at the moment they haven't and that is why I am choosing a model without it!
That I reacted on that with the Canon 50D mark II is quite logical or not since you said that other makes don't have HD Video into their more professional end cameras yet. I can surely read Paul so don't blame me

so, sorry for that but needed to defend myself of course.
With the Hassleblad thing was more of a joke and to show you you weren't that specific sorry you took it the wrong way though and far to personal so that you felt the need to defend Nikon

aminstar wrote:
Aah, the soothing sound of relief all over the place now What a difference George's absence makes to a thread Ooops, that was just tongue in cheek comment George, stay where you are, whether relaxing on your comfy chair or sipping a nice cuppa .
I think he is very contend with himself creating this mayhem and laughing at all of the people that swept into it and fueling it more and more.
I thought photography was a hobby for the most of us or a profession but it seems it's just something to argue about
Stefan
Comment Image

K10D, K5
DA* 16-50, DA* 50-135, D-FA 100 Macro, DA 40 Ltd, DA 18-55
AF-540FGZ
George Lazarette
Posted 15/07/2009 - 19:05 Link
Well, what a hornet's nest! I am somewhat bemused by the viciousness of some of the attacks, and can only imagine that I must have touched a raw nerve in some cases. There was also some evidence of a certain fine old British vice. No, not flagellation; I was referring to hypocrisy. Stuff like: "It's not my fault, gov. Honest. I didn't start the thread".

People are very quick to announce on here that they are switching brands, but some seem to get a bit twitchy when asked why. And, of course, people who sell their equipment without first deciding what to get instead do leave themselves open to questions about the wisdom of their strategy.

But that's water under the bridge. I'm still interested to know whether image quality from the D300 is superior to that from the K20D. (I am not interested in high ISO, and there doesn't seem to be any material difference in construction quality.) There seem to be a lot of very strongly held opinions, but also lots of disagreement. So, at present, I am none the wiser. If anybody has a link to a serious site which compares these things objectively, then I would be glad to see it.

Finally, for the avoidance of doubt, I acknowledge that the D300 has excellent AF and fast continuous shooting. Those who need these things are well advised to switch. As are those who prefer the ergonomics of the camera, having tried both it and Pentax contenders.

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
Edited by George Lazarette: 15/07/2009 - 19:06
Posted 15/07/2009 - 19:19 Link
And, of course, people who sell their equipment without first deciding what to get instead do leave themselves open to questions about the wisdom of their strategy.

Very judgemental imo! If this is aimed at scotthehat at least be man enough to say it jeez All this smoke and mirrors leads to problems. I was brought up to call a spade a spade.

But that's water under the bridge. I'm still interested to know whether image quality from the D300 is superior to that from the K20D. (I am not interested in high ISO

When you get to a certain standard it is often things like high iso performance that seperates them from being good and being very good. YOU might not have an interest in iso performance but you dont speak for everybody!

Image quality could mean colour, sharpness or high iso performance. In that case pentax hits 2 of em , nikon d300 hits all 3!

Im not slating pentax as i shoot with a samsung gx20 and love it!! I just wish the af was better and low light!
Edited by Cloudhunter: 15/07/2009 - 19:22
ericp
Posted 15/07/2009 - 19:29 Link
New and extra functionality can only enable the user. The HDR example is great. If you don't have photoshop or don't purchase any software that can create hdr pics then it is quite hard to generate the required HDR effect. The K7 now makes that easy and if an individual really like HDR then they will take a lot more pictures with it then they would with a camera that did not have HDR.

But I think the point about choices is more subtle. A lot of people assume people are moving on for bigger, faster and shiny new toys. I don't think they are. Each brand has its pros and cons much like other products. I have made it known that I am considering moving to Nikon. I do it because there are features that I want. I know I will lose out on other features but I have been pragmatic and listed out the features that are important to me and looked at the market and then made a decision.

I went through the same process before and my requirements lead me to the K10. I wanted value for money and quality.

Now with more experience I know what I like to shoot and I know what features will make a difference in my photography. I am under no illusion that a bigger or more expensive camera will make me any better. I don't think simply moving brands will take me to the next level. Any person spending this much money on a hobby has to think before spending. Those that don't have plenty of cash and are privileged. If I feel the features I am looking for are lacking in the Pentax system then that is ok as Pentax are focussing on other features and we differ. This does not mean Pentax is inferior in any way.

But let us not forget that there are certain features that the Pentax/Nikon do not have altogether. For example, if I had decided to go full frame then I would have no choice but to leave Pentax. Equally, if I wanted good quality in body IS then Pentax is the way forward. The other brand would be seemingly inferior.

After almost 2 years with Pentax I have realised I want quality and fast AF. Hence I am considering the Nikons as they offer that. I know what I will be losing and I know how much of an effort it will be to sell up and buy again. It is quite similar to moving back accounts (which I am also doing, what a nightmare!).

I also know there is no hard and fast empirical evidence to suggest the Nikon AF is faster than the Pentax AF but this is where perception kicks in. I think it is and other may disagree. I guess if I do go down the Nikon route I will post back and let you know
https://www.flickr.com/photos/_cypher/

Pentax K10D, 50, 18-55, 28-70, 100, Sigma 10-20, Tamron 18-250, 28-75
Edited by ericp: 15/07/2009 - 19:42
George Lazarette
Posted 15/07/2009 - 19:42 Link
Cloudhunter wrote:
And, of course, people who sell their equipment without first deciding what to get instead do leave themselves open to questions about the wisdom of their strategy.

Very judgemental imo! If this is aimed at scotthehat at least be man enough to say it jeez All this smoke and mirrors leads to problems. I was brought up to call a spade a spade.
I am glad to say that I have never seen a spade. It is obvious that our social spheres have been widely different.

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
George Lazarette
Posted 15/07/2009 - 19:58 Link
Cloudhunter wrote:
YOU might not have an interest in iso performance but you dont speak for everybody!
Indeed. And that is why I said: "I am", not "Nobody is". Wonderful thing, the English language. It's capable of expressing things very precisely, to those who understand it.

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
Tooks
Posted 15/07/2009 - 20:08 Link
George, I hope this helps...

link

link

It's probably about as objective as you're going to get...

For the last time, you've grasped that certain cameras have certain features that may or may not be important to you. If they are, it's logical that you buy that camera, as some of us have, or intend to. If not, then it's also obvious what you need to do.

Having owned both, I'd say that the D300 has strengths over the K20d, but also that the K20d has its strengths over the D300 - these things have been much laboured over many threads. I think others have been saying similar things.

There is no right or wrong camera, just the right or wrong camera for YOU...

I regret that you think some of the comments aimed at you were personal, (not from me I add, except a couple in jest - I hope you took them that way!), but then this was always destined to be an inflamatory thread don't you think?

Again, I remind you that nobody has said the D300 is better full stop than the K20d, other than TTK in the classifieds post - maybe you should take up your grievance directly with him before you make yourself look a grumpier git than you already are?!
George Lazarette
Posted 15/07/2009 - 20:40 Link
Hello, Tooks.

Not sure what you mean by "For the last time", but I have always acknowledged that Pentax isn't the perfect solution in every case. When people keep misquoting me on this it does get a bit irritating.

And I have always acknowledged that the D300, in fact many cameras, have faster AF than Pentax. That just isn't in dispute.

Most of my pictures, and I suspect most of many people's pictures, are taken of relativly slow-moving or static subjects, and usually in reasonably good light. For that reason it seems to me that for many people, all else being equal, image quality will be a high, if not the highest, priority.

Hence my question.

Thanks for your links; they're certainly better than nothing (and of course I have read these reviews before) but unfortunately the pictures they use are much too small to draw conclusions from, and they still haven't got their heads around the idea that all camera bodies should be tested with the same lens.

We've disagreed in the past, Tooks, but I think we have always been reasonably civil to each other, and long may that continue!

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
Posted 15/07/2009 - 20:57 Link
George Lazarette wrote:
Cloudhunter wrote:
YOU might not have an interest in iso performance but you dont speak for everybody!
Indeed. And that is why I said: "I am", not "Nobody is". Wonderful thing, the English language. It's capable of expressing things very precisely, to those who understand it.

G
I was born in the UK, family resided in the UK since as long as records began. Were you and your family?

I understand the english language perfectly thanks. I just dont understand narrow minded, pompous idiots!

You talk to people in a very condescending way but then it is easy to do over the internet. Face to face can be a different story!
Edited by Cloudhunter: 15/07/2009 - 21:05
Tooks
Posted 15/07/2009 - 21:10 Link
George Lazarette wrote:
Hello, Tooks.

Not sure what you mean by "For the last time"...
All I mean by that is, I won't labour the point anymore! I'm sure that will come as a relief to many!

George Lazarette wrote:
We've disagreed in the past, Tooks, but I think we have always been reasonably civil to each other, and long may that continue!

G
Indeed, there are a few things worth falling out over (the best whisky for one!) but cameras aren't one of them!

All I would say is that most people understand that most cameras these days are perfectly fine for 90% of most peoples photography needs, and only when you have a specialist need do you need to go to one side of the spectrum or another. For instance, I have a wedding photographer friend who swears by the Fuji S5 because of its ability to render skin tones, but it's not a camera I ever enjoyed, and I did own one briefly.

Again, if we look past the insults in this thread, then I think everybody has praised Pentax cameras, but whilst accepting that they have limitations, like all cameras I think.

Now, what were we trying to sort out again?!
Posted 15/07/2009 - 21:20 Link
Creep? For saying that hiding behind words is what kids do? I speak my mind. Perhaps a more childish forum would suit you better?

And me totally destroying the forum is a pathetic thing to say. I contribute quite alot to this forum. Do you???

Ill resay what i said to george , its so easy to shot your mouth off when its over the internet. Face to face would be a new experience again!
Posted 15/07/2009 - 21:21 Link
Just for your education calling a spade a spade means :

Meaning

To speak plainly - to describe something as it really is.
Tooks
Posted 15/07/2009 - 21:27 Link
Cloudhunter wrote:
Creep? For saying that hiding behind words is what kids do? I speak my mind. Perhaps a more childish forum would suit you better?

And me totally destroying the forum is a pathetic thing to say. I contribute quite alot to this forum. Do you???

Ill resay what i said to george , its so easy to shot your mouth off when its over the internet. Face to face would be a new experience again!
I don't think Shim was aiming that one at you Cloudhunter...
Mike-P
Posted 15/07/2009 - 21:35 Link
Whoever he was aiming it at makes no difference.
The thread has now basically changed from one that was quite interesting to something that is getting rather ugly imo.
Malo1961
Posted 15/07/2009 - 21:36 Link
Tooks wrote:
Cloudhunter wrote:
Creep? For saying that hiding behind words is what kids do? I speak my mind. Perhaps a more childish forum would suit you better?

And me totally destroying the forum is a pathetic thing to say. I contribute quite alot to this forum. Do you???

Ill resay what i said to george , its so easy to shot your mouth off when its over the internet. Face to face would be a new experience again!
I don't think Shim was aiming that one at you Cloudhunter...
Hmmmm,I'll guess if you contribute so much noise, it can be hard to hear, what is actually said. NR on, perhaps?
Best regards,

Martin.


Curious about my photography?? Just Follow the Light.

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo