K20D versus Nikon D300
- Topic Locked - You will not be able to post to this topic. to end continued bad feeling in the thread
Posted 15/07/2009 - 10:05
Link
johnriley wrote:
Well you could buy a K7 body, but on the other hand a longer lens might do the trick...
now why didn't I think of that Well you could buy a K7 body, but on the other hand a longer lens might do the trick...
Great answer John.
Ok, anyone wanting to sell their longer reaching lens? Do pentax make a 500mm lens? Or how about a 600mm lens
Amin Photo Gallery
Posted 15/07/2009 - 10:06
Link
Aminstar - if you get a quieter shutter then you'll get more shots I suppose. They may not be better but there'll be more of them and from your point of view this will be a very good thing.
Therefore, an upgrade makes sense. The technology is limiting what you want to do.
That said how close do you get to these wretched birds? My cat would like some tips please - in fact I may buy a K20 just to act as a bid scarer
Mike
Therefore, an upgrade makes sense. The technology is limiting what you want to do.
That said how close do you get to these wretched birds? My cat would like some tips please - in fact I may buy a K20 just to act as a bid scarer
Mike
---------------------------------------------------
You can see some of my shots at my Flickr account.
You can see some of my shots at my Flickr account.
Posted 15/07/2009 - 10:16
Link
Mikew
Now you have just cast an insult on to the beautifully designed body of the K20D. You are calling it a cat scarer?
Watchout for the repercurssions,
now...where is George? Has anyone seen him around?
By the way, how about a small survey on which member has the highest number of comments posted within a short period of time here, hmmm ideally we could set up a time and find for example within 10 minutes of any particular given period who has posted several comments
I have a suspicion it wouldn't be difficult to find a clear winner here
anyone wants to have a guess?
Now you have just cast an insult on to the beautifully designed body of the K20D. You are calling it a cat scarer?
Watchout for the repercurssions,
now...where is George? Has anyone seen him around?
By the way, how about a small survey on which member has the highest number of comments posted within a short period of time here, hmmm ideally we could set up a time and find for example within 10 minutes of any particular given period who has posted several comments
I have a suspicion it wouldn't be difficult to find a clear winner here
anyone wants to have a guess?
Amin Photo Gallery
Posted 15/07/2009 - 10:26
Link
aminstar wrote:
The noise of the shutter release of my K20D is so loud that it scares the hell out of birds when I try to shoot them.
At the risk of boring people, I will repeat the main thrust of my argument, which is that some people are changing systems because they think a different camera with better paper specifications will make them take better pictures.The noise of the shutter release of my K20D is so loud that it scares the hell out of birds when I try to shoot them.
I take on board Bodyheat's view that a camera you enjoy using will get used more, and I have no beef with people changing for sound and specific reasons - and in your case a noisy shutter, if you shoot lots of birds, might be an example.
Perhaps, in the case of some people, with few lenses, flashguns, and other attachments (and stacks of cash) changing systems is not a big deal. For others it would be, and I am surprised some people are prepared to squander thousands on a complete new set up for what in some cases is going to make damn-all difference.
G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
Posted 15/07/2009 - 11:16
Link
Firstly I should state that any change for me is out of the question financially and don't think my ability warrants it either.
Not sure a lot of these changes are particularly image related, more to do with having the latest thing.
My main hobby (until age and injuries got me)was cycling and the same thing happened there
Don't really believe that many people thought the latest greatest bike would make them go faster, but if you have the cash and its what you enjoy why not
Its strange that there is so much brand rivalry in photography, not come across this before and can't really understand why
I would say though that if i was a Pentax rep it would be a concern that a fair amount of people are leaving the brand.
Especially strange on the back of a new camera launch (Think that Olympus Pen stole the limelight a bit along with pre production K7's being reviewed)
Personally I would buy the best I could afford with the features I wanted regardless of the name
So that's what I did
Cheers
Rich
Not sure a lot of these changes are particularly image related, more to do with having the latest thing.
My main hobby (until age and injuries got me)was cycling and the same thing happened there
Don't really believe that many people thought the latest greatest bike would make them go faster, but if you have the cash and its what you enjoy why not
Its strange that there is so much brand rivalry in photography, not come across this before and can't really understand why
I would say though that if i was a Pentax rep it would be a concern that a fair amount of people are leaving the brand.
Especially strange on the back of a new camera launch (Think that Olympus Pen stole the limelight a bit along with pre production K7's being reviewed)
Personally I would buy the best I could afford with the features I wanted regardless of the name
So that's what I did
Cheers
Rich
Posted 15/07/2009 - 11:31
Link
George Lazarette wrote:
I started to post this in the classified section in response to a post by TTK, but JR pointed out that it was the wrong place to do so. TTK was pointing out some additional virtues of the D300.
I'd also like to see a demo using the D300 with the best lens in Nikon's arsenal versus the K20D with the 31mm Ltd.
High ISO noise. Useful, no doubt, for some, but like most people, I seldom shoot above 400 ISO. 800 at the most.
In what way is the build quality "better"? A friend has a D300, and I wouldn't say the build quality was better (or worse). It's not as well sealed against water and dust.
Considering it costs more than twice as much, I would find it very difficult to justify a D300 over a K20D unless I were a sports photographer, when the AF and continuous shooting would obviously be very useful.
G
Getting back to the original post, this might be a cheeky ask, but I wonder if Chris and SRS can help out here as they sell the D300?I started to post this in the classified section in response to a post by TTK, but JR pointed out that it was the wrong place to do so. TTK was pointing out some additional virtues of the D300.
ttk wrote:
Better IQ.
Less noise at high Iso.
Better build quality.
I'd love to see a demonstration of the alleged better image quality. The demo should use the same nice SMC Takumar on both cameras, shooting RAW, and then post-processing in Silkypix.Better IQ.
Less noise at high Iso.
Better build quality.
I'd also like to see a demo using the D300 with the best lens in Nikon's arsenal versus the K20D with the 31mm Ltd.
High ISO noise. Useful, no doubt, for some, but like most people, I seldom shoot above 400 ISO. 800 at the most.
In what way is the build quality "better"? A friend has a D300, and I wouldn't say the build quality was better (or worse). It's not as well sealed against water and dust.
Considering it costs more than twice as much, I would find it very difficult to justify a D300 over a K20D unless I were a sports photographer, when the AF and continuous shooting would obviously be very useful.
G
With a the help of a forum member who owns a K20 with a DA* or FA 31 ltd it should not be too hard to set up a meaningful test.
Personally I would like to see how the two compared at various ISO's, paticularly 1600 + where the Nikon is said to excel.
I would advocate RAW files processed under a standard set of conditions in Silkypix. In camera processing is subject to taste and adds an extra degree of variability.
I am in Leicestershire and do not have a K20, but I could provide a FA 31 ltd for the exercise.
Steve
Posted 15/07/2009 - 11:37
Link
Ive been reading up onthis and i think the general opinion is this..
The main draw to the nikon is the 51 point AF and notably how utterly fast it is to lock on.
It depends on what you shoot as wether this would be a benefit.
I shoot aircraft mainly so it would be a massive benefit to me.
Matt
The main draw to the nikon is the 51 point AF and notably how utterly fast it is to lock on.
It depends on what you shoot as wether this would be a benefit.
I shoot aircraft mainly so it would be a massive benefit to me.
Matt
Posted 15/07/2009 - 11:37
Link
I agree with you 100% Rich, and like you I have gone for the K200D as a sensible compromise between quality and cost. Compromise isn't really the right word though! If I can't get the results I want with that camera, it's down to me, not my kit.
'Beginners' who upgrade to high-end kit at huge cost are chasing expensive moonbeams if they think it will improve their general photography... although of course there are pros and serious users who may need the extra features
'Beginners' who upgrade to high-end kit at huge cost are chasing expensive moonbeams if they think it will improve their general photography... although of course there are pros and serious users who may need the extra features
Posted 15/07/2009 - 11:38
Link
Anvh wrote:
So according to you a Hasselblad H3D isn't a DSLR?
Medium format only refers to the size of the film/sensor, the Hasselblad H3D use a mechanical mirror system and pentaprism to direct light from the lens to an optical viewfinder on the back of the camera, that is what a SLR is right.
So according to you a Hasselblad H3D isn't a DSLR?
Medium format only refers to the size of the film/sensor, the Hasselblad H3D use a mechanical mirror system and pentaprism to direct light from the lens to an optical viewfinder on the back of the camera, that is what a SLR is right.
I was refering to the Smaller format and I thought that was pretty obvious really, but if you want to throw in the Hassleblad then you do that, I am not commenting on it!
Anvh wrote:
The descusion was only about APS-C format at first, you introduced the Nikon D3 to it.
Yves said this "Beside, quite often, I find Nikon cameras are overrated. They are good cameras, but they're not the Holy Grail."
You argued the D3X is widely known as the best camera.
We are only talking about cameras about this point and when I said Hasselblad makes better cameras, you said that doesn't count since they are MF.
At no point it was clear we were only talking about APS-C and FF format if I'm correct, we only said cameras.
Again, The D3X is widely known as the best FF camera, I stand by what I said about Yves comment. I brought the D3 into the conversation as it was one of the cameras I was looking at. Yves was talking about Nikon in general so that is why I brought the D3 into it. DX & FX not MF.The descusion was only about APS-C format at first, you introduced the Nikon D3 to it.
Yves said this "Beside, quite often, I find Nikon cameras are overrated. They are good cameras, but they're not the Holy Grail."
You argued the D3X is widely known as the best camera.
We are only talking about cameras about this point and when I said Hasselblad makes better cameras, you said that doesn't count since they are MF.
At no point it was clear we were only talking about APS-C and FF format if I'm correct, we only said cameras.
Anvh wrote:
What do you call the Canon 5D mark II, seems quite professional to me though. Okay not a 1D but the next best thing though.
And you reason is beyond my understanding to be honest, if you don't need it just don't use it.
The hardware isn't different from a camera without video and it's only software that enables it to take videos.
Some cameras without video mode can record movies by altering the software on it, basically if the camera can handle it you can make any camera record video. The D300 and the D3X are for sure capable to record video since they have liveview.
I am talking about Nikon and Pentax here, I purposefully left Canon out, please read my comments properly.What do you call the Canon 5D mark II, seems quite professional to me though. Okay not a 1D but the next best thing though.
And you reason is beyond my understanding to be honest, if you don't need it just don't use it.
The hardware isn't different from a camera without video and it's only software that enables it to take videos.
Some cameras without video mode can record movies by altering the software on it, basically if the camera can handle it you can make any camera record video. The D300 and the D3X are for sure capable to record video since they have liveview.
George Lazarette wrote:
Paul,
What I am arguing with is the often not very good photographers who buy into a new system on the basis of paper specifications or forum rumours thinking it will make them better photographers.
G
I consider myself a very good photographer, I base that on excellent customer feedback and my own views. Me changing system has nothing to do with gaining better pictures. I know how to use a camera properly, having learnt on film back in the FM2 and F3 days. If you read my thread carefully it stated that I used to own a Nikon kit. I am merely going back to a kit that I do actually prefer. I can't see why you are making syuch a huge thing of this.Paul,
What I am arguing with is the often not very good photographers who buy into a new system on the basis of paper specifications or forum rumours thinking it will make them better photographers.
G
I have told you the reason why I am looking at the D300 first, this is purely my decision and no one else has swayed me into thinking that.
Pwynnej wrote:
But I have a K10D I am happy with, and actually contemplating a K20 - when you read many threads from people switching systems you get the sense they are not happy with Pentax, they don't like Pentax, they want to have a go at Pentax, they have an agenda, or their technical skills suck to such an extent that another system will automatically make them better. Maybe the last category applies to me, but my main point is if people switch systems thinking their images will improve dramatically then they will be disappointed. Nikon, Canon, Pentax, Sony etc aren't perfect....some are almost but the next new model is only 12-18 months away
I have been happy with Pentax for many years, In some ways I still am, I do like my K20 still and am umming and arring whether to keep it still as I do use this when I teach children photography. Yes I allow children to take photographs with my equipment (I am a Full Enhanced CRB'd Youth Worker in my spare time). I know that I will not be dissapointed when I change systems.But I have a K10D I am happy with, and actually contemplating a K20 - when you read many threads from people switching systems you get the sense they are not happy with Pentax, they don't like Pentax, they want to have a go at Pentax, they have an agenda, or their technical skills suck to such an extent that another system will automatically make them better. Maybe the last category applies to me, but my main point is if people switch systems thinking their images will improve dramatically then they will be disappointed. Nikon, Canon, Pentax, Sony etc aren't perfect....some are almost but the next new model is only 12-18 months away
Also re-read my thread for the reason I am buying a D300 first. People assume to much, assume that others are changing system as they are either hoping to get better pictures or assuming that they are leaving because their "Technical Skills Suck".
George Lazarette wrote:
Perhaps, in the case of some people, with few lenses, flashguns, and other attachments (and stacks of cash) changing systems is not a big deal. For others it would be, and I am surprised some people are prepared to squander thousands on a complete new set up for what in some cases is going to make damn-all difference.
G
I guess that in that first sentence, (paranoia maybe), you are referring to me. I am not humouring you by making a comment about that.Perhaps, in the case of some people, with few lenses, flashguns, and other attachments (and stacks of cash) changing systems is not a big deal. For others it would be, and I am surprised some people are prepared to squander thousands on a complete new set up for what in some cases is going to make damn-all difference.
G
Thing is with Pentax users is that I think certain ones (no names mentioned) are so against anyone changing systems and they will make up any rubbish to prevent them from leaving.
Imagine this, if I was in a Vauxhall members club for 10 years and wanted to buy into a different make say Saab or Subaru, do you think that the Vauxhall club would get all petty and defend their car make as much as the Pentax users do???
Oh and by the way, I used those vauxhall and saab as an example and not saying that saab were more superior in any way the same way I am not saying that Nikon is superior to Pentax.
All I am mereley doing is switching from Pentax to Nikon. It is a decision I have made for my business and business growth. Also just to clarify, I am not changing systems to improve my photography; I am buying a D300 first then will look into a FX at a later date - sometime in the new year. This is a decision I have made to further my career in photography. I will still own a K20 for a few months, maybe longer, still not sure about that. This will mean that I will have 2 systems.
I hope this long reply explains a bit more.
Oh and apologies for not replying sooner, I had a shoot first thing this morning.
Paul
Posted 15/07/2009 - 11:43
Link
Paul,
All i can say is good luck. Your business is whats most important. It pays the bills, gives you your quality of life. Some people do make it hard but ignore. I work from home and have had to make some hard decisions but i do it as i can not allow anything/anyone to erode my business.
Good luck with the Nikon
All i can say is good luck. Your business is whats most important. It pays the bills, gives you your quality of life. Some people do make it hard but ignore. I work from home and have had to make some hard decisions but i do it as i can not allow anything/anyone to erode my business.
Good luck with the Nikon
Posted 15/07/2009 - 11:48
Link
George Lazarette wrote:
At the risk of boring people, I will repeat the main thrust of my argument, which is that some people are changing systems because they think a different camera with better paper specifications will make them take better pictures.
I take on board Bodyheat's view that a camera you enjoy using will get used more, and I have no beef with people changing for sound and specific reasons - and in your case a noisy shutter, if you shoot lots of birds, might be an example.
Perhaps, in the case of some people, with few lenses, flashguns, and other attachments (and stacks of cash) changing systems is not a big deal. For others it would be, and I am surprised some people are prepared to squander thousands on a complete new set up for what in some cases is going to make damn-all difference.
G
George,At the risk of boring people, I will repeat the main thrust of my argument, which is that some people are changing systems because they think a different camera with better paper specifications will make them take better pictures.
I take on board Bodyheat's view that a camera you enjoy using will get used more, and I have no beef with people changing for sound and specific reasons - and in your case a noisy shutter, if you shoot lots of birds, might be an example.
Perhaps, in the case of some people, with few lenses, flashguns, and other attachments (and stacks of cash) changing systems is not a big deal. For others it would be, and I am surprised some people are prepared to squander thousands on a complete new set up for what in some cases is going to make damn-all difference.
G
I don't quite understand why you have quite so much of a problem with what other people do with their own money?!
But, some people DO change camera systems to gain features/spec/performance that their current camera doesn't have, and DO take better pictures as a result. No, it doesn't automatically make them a better photographer, but it removes some frustrations that result from trying to achieve something that your camera isn't the best at...
As you must know by now, as you've had a go at me in the past for doing so, I went from K20d's to a Nikon D200 and then a D300, picking up a D90 along the way for video and as a backup camera for those rare times when I work at weddings.
The AF and FPS benefits (as well as ISO performance) have allowed me to get more shots more of the time with my hobby subjects which are wildlife and aviation. As for weddings, the results are different with the Nikon kit, but not any better or worse I would say.
Before the ridculous price hikes recently, my D300 cost me £850, expensive at the time compared to what I sold my K20d's for, but worth it for me and a bit of a bargain at todays prices.
You usually come back at this point with some comment about how I'm still here because I miss Pentax and I'm regretting my purchase, so I'll save you the bother.
Some people undoubtedly change systems for the wrong reasons, but whatever, they do, so I would get used to it and then maybe you can stop stressing about it so much!
Posted 15/07/2009 - 11:52
Link
I agree Tooks!
Im into aviation in a big way and take plenty of shots. Mine is mostly daylight so the AF of my gx20 works faultlessly 99% of the time. I did try some shots in low light and it was a pig.
If my shots change and I need better af low light or I shoot faster aircraft requiring faster AF and pentax cant provide me with a camera to do it then i will change immediately.
Matt
P.S Unless i have chance to play with a d300 and fall for the AF before hand
Im into aviation in a big way and take plenty of shots. Mine is mostly daylight so the AF of my gx20 works faultlessly 99% of the time. I did try some shots in low light and it was a pig.
If my shots change and I need better af low light or I shoot faster aircraft requiring faster AF and pentax cant provide me with a camera to do it then i will change immediately.
Matt
P.S Unless i have chance to play with a d300 and fall for the AF before hand


24430 posts
24 years
Tyldesley,
Manchester