K10d: Body only or lens kit?

comsport11
Posted 21/12/2006 - 21:31 Link
What a great forum this is. I have only been looking at it for the past week, in the anticipation of the K10d, but wish I had been a member for much longer!

I currently own a istDs, which I have been very happy with over the past year and a half. It came with a Sigma 18-125 lens, which supplemented my rather poor selection of lenses from my film days: Pentax smc F zoom 35-104, Sigma 100-300 and Tokina19-35.

My question is: Should I buy a lens kit (18-55) or will I be happy with my current lenses with the new k10d?

Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Mannesty
Posted 21/12/2006 - 22:47 Link
The *istDS is a superb camera capable of producing as fine an image as any other 6MP camera. The quality of your optics and your technique might be the reason you are dissatisfied with the results. Are you shooting JPG or RAW? If RAW, are you familiar with the necessary 'finishing' required to produce good results?

There could of course be a problem with the camera. Perhaps you could expand on the reasons why you are not happy with it.

To answer your question, buy the kit with 18-55mm or preferably the 16-45mm. It's a cheap way of acquiring a decent lens.
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream
fatspider
Posted 21/12/2006 - 23:17 Link
Errr, Peter, I dont think he is unhappy with it, did you misread the post???

comsport, if your happy with the Sigma 18-125 then buying the 18-55 may be a bit daft, certainly consider the 16-45 if you think you would use the wider angle that it offers, it is reported to be a very nice bit of kit, if you do a lot of landscape then its probably a definate requirement.
My Names Alan, and I'm a lensaholic.
My PPG link
My Flckr link
Mannesty
Posted 21/12/2006 - 23:30 Link
Yes I did, it's late. Time for my medication . . . and bed.
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream
comsport11
Posted 22/12/2006 - 08:17 Link
Thank you to both Mannesty and Impotentspider for your responces late last night.

I'm not unhappy with my photographs and at the moment I shoot in jpeg mainly but, after reading the many topics in this forum, I am going to experiment much more with raw shooting over the holidays.

I agree that the 18-55 would be a silly choice, but will check into the 16-45. Thanks
MattMatic
Posted 22/12/2006 - 09:26 Link
Just to add a couple of thoughts:
The 18-55 isn't a bad lens, just not nearly as good as the 16-45. If you have a choice, go for the 16-45. SRS and Park have it for a crazy £270.

The resolution difference between the *ist-D series sensor and the K10D is astonishing - not because there are more pixels necessarily, but mostly because the K10D seems so much "cleaner" and particularly shooting RAW I can pull out an amazing amount of detail - so much so that it's getting a right pain to downsize images for the web into a decent byte-size

I've long wondered whether my current line up has higher resolving power than the *ist-D and *ist-Ds - now I know!

So, I reckon if you can get a deal with K10D+16-45 then aim for that. Otherwise, get just the body and "make do" until you get either the 16-45, or the new 16-50/f2.8 (which will probably cost more than the K10D though!)

Matt
Posted 22/12/2006 - 18:02 Link
One thing about the kit lens is that it's extremely cheap when bought with a body. So why not buy it? The general view at DP Review is that it's pretty good provided you don't use it at full aperture at either zoom extreme. The 16-45 may well be better, but there's a heck of a price difference.
comsport11
Posted 23/12/2006 - 13:09 Link
Thank you for your suggestions. I have just returned from Park Cameras with my new K10D. I decided on just getting the body with the aim of getting one of the new ultra-sonic lenses when they arrive next year.

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo