K-x Bulb mode write-time slow?

amoringello
Posted 17/07/2010 - 03:11 Link
chris_jl wrote:
Exposure stacking is the usual answer. Search for Registax - it's free and lets you use multiple exposures of a single object. It has the additional feature/side effect of averaging out the noise over several exposures so you get decent inky blacks instead of a field of chroma noise.
Is less than 30sec per exposure good for stacking of night time photos?
I might be trying to get star rails in the next week or so, but am not going to sit through dark frame subtraction of fifteen minutes to two hours! I'd like to use the K7, but will likely have to fall back to the K10 unless stacking is useful. I just thought there probably would not be enough light captured in under 30 seconds to even make stacking worthwhile.

It really pissed me off that Pentax has this requirement (amongst other cripplings). I mean I can do dark frame subtraction myself after the fact with one frame rather than every time I click the shutter! Its like Pentax dangles a pro-level camera in front of your face, and just as you reach out to grab it, they kick you in the shins.
flossie
Posted 17/07/2010 - 06:52 Link
BigJacko wrote:
I've been messing around with Bulb mode on my new K-x (thanks to me managing to turn a 'One-for-All 6' TV remote control handset into a suitable trigger, via its JP1 socket, a PC, and some free software. It'll do until the UK sees some more stock of the genuine Pentax Remote Control F unit!)
Just buy one of these off Ebay for a ludicrous
£2.59 including Postage all the way from Hong Kong (!) - works perfectly with a Kx.

And at that price, if you lose it outside in the dark, its not a disaster
Still shooting in the dark (literally and metaphorically)...
Edited by flossie: 17/07/2010 - 06:57
Anvh
Posted 17/07/2010 - 11:36 Link
johnriley wrote:
Dredging up a few snippets from memory, I think CMOS sensors are noisier than CCDs. Maybe it's because the amplification occurs on the chip and is less effective.
Almost right.
CMOS use several amplifiers so you have amplifiers mismatches, this why they aren't as uniform as CCD.
Stefan
Comment Image

K10D, K5
DA* 16-50, DA* 50-135, D-FA 100 Macro, DA 40 Ltd, DA 18-55
AF-540FGZ
Anvh
Posted 17/07/2010 - 11:47 Link
amoringello wrote:
Is less than 30sec per exposure good for stacking of night time photos?
I might be trying to get star rails in the next week or so, but am not going to sit through dark frame subtraction of fifteen minutes to two hours! I'd like to use the K7, but will likely have to fall back to the K10 unless stacking is useful. I just thought there probably would not be enough light captured in under 30 seconds to even make stacking worthwhile.
There are several ways you can stack.

With exposure stacking you actually add exposure, so 2 shots of 30 seconds give you the same result as one shot of 1 minute.
Also for the star trails the brightness of them will stay the same only the length change of them with longer exposures.
http://www.tawbaware.com/imgstack.htm
Stefan
Comment Image

K10D, K5
DA* 16-50, DA* 50-135, D-FA 100 Macro, DA 40 Ltd, DA 18-55
AF-540FGZ
BigJacko
Posted 17/07/2010 - 12:12 Link
Some very interesting input into this thread - thanks everyone for the comments. It led me to do a lot more reading-up on DFS (which I'd not heard of before, I must confess), and the K-x. Of course, the same questions about "why didn't Pentax let us disable it over 30s?" have come up time and time again, but with no answer. So mote it be!

Thanks again are due to Chris for the tip-off about Registax. As luck would have it, I think I already own a copy, thanks to Sky-at-Night magazine cover CD from last year that I had laying around!

The one curious thing that strikes me is that nowhere can I find an 'official' comment from Pentax - even in the form of someone re-posting an email from them - which might explain why there's no option to disable DFS. Is it worth me emailing them directly, do you think? Or is that historically a waste of time?
Neil
≡≡≡≡
Pentax K-x ♥ Pentax DA L 18-55mm f3.5-5.6 AL ♣ Pentax DA L 55-300mm f4-5.8 ED ♦ Pentax A 50mm f2.0 ♠ Pentax AF360FGZ flash ♥ Rikenon P 50mm f1.7 ♣ Vivitar CF 28mm f2.8 (K02 Komine) ♦ Tokina 80-200mm f4 ♠ Vivitar MC 2x22 Tele Converter

"Rules are for the obedience of fools and the guidance of wise men" - Douglas 'Tin-Legs' Bader
BigJacko
Posted 17/07/2010 - 12:36 Link
Bad form to follow-up one's own post, I know... but I hadn't realised we'd got to a second page until I posted my reply above! Whoops.

Thanks are also due to flossie for the tip-off about the el-cheapo Remote Control. Ordered and (hopefully) on its way.

Having said that, I'm still going to buy a 'pukka' one from my local independent camera shop - partly because I'd already got him to back-order one and call me when it arrives (and I'll feel bad if I blow him out at that point), and partly because he's such a flippin' good shopkeeper who consistently does me internet-beating discounts - and I really don't want to see him go unsupported! Lost too many good shops round these parts because the 'big-boys' vaccuum up all the trade with p***poor service. /soapbox mode off/

But yeah - it does make sense to have a second, cheapy, "lose-able" remote for those treks across fields at dead of night, or in the hissing rain! Ta for the tip.
Neil
≡≡≡≡
Pentax K-x ♥ Pentax DA L 18-55mm f3.5-5.6 AL ♣ Pentax DA L 55-300mm f4-5.8 ED ♦ Pentax A 50mm f2.0 ♠ Pentax AF360FGZ flash ♥ Rikenon P 50mm f1.7 ♣ Vivitar CF 28mm f2.8 (K02 Komine) ♦ Tokina 80-200mm f4 ♠ Vivitar MC 2x22 Tele Converter

"Rules are for the obedience of fools and the guidance of wise men" - Douglas 'Tin-Legs' Bader
Edited by BigJacko: 17/07/2010 - 12:38
flossie
Posted 17/07/2010 - 12:45 Link
Very honourable of you Neil - I quite agree about the local shops! My local independant shop doesn't stock Pentax sadly, but I've bought a tripod and some 2nd hand items.

I can't understand how someone can post package from the other side of the world for that price, let alone manufacture, package, and market it! very puzzling... (can take a while though)
Still shooting in the dark (literally and metaphorically)...
chris_jl
Posted 18/07/2010 - 01:18 Link
amoringello wrote:


Is less than 30sec per exposure good for stacking of night time photos?
Yes it is - I have a friend who uses 300+ images stacked and each is < 5s exposure.

amoringello wrote:

It really pissed me off that Pentax has this requirement (amongst other cripplings). I mean I can do dark frame subtraction myself after the fact with one frame rather than every time I click the shutter! Its like Pentax dangles a pro-level camera in front of your face, and just as you reach out to grab it, they kick you in the shins.
I don't view it as a crippling - it's just their way of maximizing quality for a given price bracket that dictated sensor choice. They don't really seem to target a specialty market - they just go for what is middle of the road with maximal return. If you want hi speed sports photos for the papers - get a Nikon, if you want good astro-photos - get a Canon 20Da or a LN2 cooled sensor unit (or get used to hyping Kodak Tech Pan 2415 in your freezer ).

C
petrochemist
Posted 18/07/2010 - 19:14 Link
flossie wrote:

I can't understand how someone can post package from the other side of the world for that price, let alone manufacture, package, and market it! very puzzling... (can take a while though)
I've done better cost/postage wise. A SDHC card reader for 24p including postage that arrived from HK in ~1week & works fine.
Mind you I haven't yet dared upgrade the firmware on my camera so the 4GB card I got it for is still blank.
Mike
Mike
.
Pentax:K5ii, K7, K100D, DA18-55, DA10-17, DA55-300, DA50-200, F100-300, F50, DA35 AL, 4* M50, 2* M135, Helicoid extension, Tak 300 f4 (& 6 film bodies)
3rd Party: Bigmos (Sigma 150-500mm OS HSM),2* 28mm, 100mm macro, 28-200 zoom, 35-80 zoom, 80-200 zoom, 80-210 zoom, 300mm M42, 600 mirror, 1000-4000 scope, 50mm M42, enlarger lenses, Sony & micro 4/3 cameras with various PK mounts, Zenit E...
Far to many tele-converters, adapters, project parts & extension tubes etc.

.[size=11:].Flickr• WPF• Panoramio
Smeggypants
Posted 19/07/2010 - 01:20 Link
amoringello wrote:
Sadly, with the K7 this cannot be fully turned off, probably the same with Kx (I believe K20 is the same way).
As I understand, in ANY bulb photo over 30 seconds the frame subtraction is forced!
In some photos over the specified maximum ISO and shutter speed, this also happen. I do believe this action is what can be turned off. At least I have not yet seen the dark frame subtraction come on... but I stay away from Bulb mode over 30 seconds on that camera. I go back to my K10D for very long shutter speeds.
I have recently bought a K10D as a 2nd body to my K20D. And yup I use the K10D for long exposures with the dreaded NR turned off. frankly there's no difference between the same long exposure noise wise when comparing K20D - 'forced on' and K10D - 'optional off'

I bought the K10D as a 2nd body to avoid swapping lenses and losing shots, but being able to shoot long exposures without tearing one's hair out is a bonus.
[i]Bodies: 1x K-5IIs, 2x K-5, Sony TX-5, Nokia 808
Lenses: Pentax DA 10-17mm ED(IF) Fish Eye, Pentax DA 14mm f/2.8, Sigma 17-70mm f/2.8, Pentax-A 28mm f/2.8, Sigma 30mm F1.4 EX DC, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.2, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-FA 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.7, Pentax DA* 50-135mm f/2.8, Sigma 135-400mm APO DG, and more ..
Flash: AF-540FGZ, Vivitar 283
BigJacko
Posted 19/07/2010 - 11:23 Link
I'm intrigued... given that we're all here on a Pentax-supported 'official magazine' forum, can anyone tell me whether the PU magazine team have challenged Pentax about this inability to turn off the Noise Reduction issue?

/nostalgia mode on/
I was Technical Editor on a couple of national computer magazines back in the dark ages (ST Format / Amiga Format), plus freelance for various others in review/technical roles - and this kind of question would've been just the sort of thing that would've been bounced at Atari/Commmodore for an 'official statement'. And if the reasons behind the decision were clear and precise, an in-depth feature (into the subject-at-hand, the problems resulting, and the solutions or reasons for lack thereof) would've been next, dealing with it in as interesting and educational way as possible.
/nostalgia mode off/

The point is, clearly, many, many people out there are bemoaning the fact that the later Ks don't allow NR to be switched off above 30sec, and that all these people seem (a) aware of the possibility of noise being an issue, but are prepared to do their own dark frame preparation and subtraction to counter it and (b) don't like being restricted in their choice of how to use the kit they've paid for.

An option in the firmware would seem like a piece of cake solution - but it's not forthcoming for any of the cameras it affects. Which at the very least, begs the question: why? I'm perfectly prepared to accept that there might be a deeper reason why this simply isn't possible... but I'd like to know it, first!

So... Pentax User Mag crew... please give me a reason to take out a subscription to your paper mag, because I'm on the fence at the mo'. I buy a lot of paper mags already, and (without casting any individual aspertions) many of them offer a lot of the same stuff as each other, and it'd be hard to slot a fag paper between them in terms of 'unique selling points'. But in theory, PU Magazine's USP should be that it has the edge in getting close to 'official sources', shouldn't it? Or does it just rewrite press-releases and act as a shop-window? I hope the former - so, please - go sic Pentax, and ask them why (if you haven't already), and don't stop till you get the skinny! You'll have my utmost respect (and a new sub), and the same from a lot of other readers, no doubt.

And forgive me if you think I'm being deliberately contentious. I'm not - really honestly. I'm merely looking at angles. It's just that with a subject like this, which causes widespread fury around the net, it seems strange that nobody from the mag team* has popped up yet and said "Oh, yeah, this old chestnut... It comes up a lot. This is why: /insert sensible sounding technical reason here for why a 'turn-off' option is pointless/impossible/" Which in turn made me wonder if the mag team knew the answer... and if not, then heck... it's a half-page of a future issue done and dusted in no time, eh? Every hack likes an article that writes itself, eh?

Regards

*(notwithstanding John Riley's input... but with respect, he didn't really seem to know, did he?)
Neil
≡≡≡≡
Pentax K-x ♥ Pentax DA L 18-55mm f3.5-5.6 AL ♣ Pentax DA L 55-300mm f4-5.8 ED ♦ Pentax A 50mm f2.0 ♠ Pentax AF360FGZ flash ♥ Rikenon P 50mm f1.7 ♣ Vivitar CF 28mm f2.8 (K02 Komine) ♦ Tokina 80-200mm f4 ♠ Vivitar MC 2x22 Tele Converter

"Rules are for the obedience of fools and the guidance of wise men" - Douglas 'Tin-Legs' Bader
Edited by BigJacko: 19/07/2010 - 11:28
johnriley
Posted 19/07/2010 - 13:07 Link
Quote:
*(notwithstanding John Riley's input... but with respect, he didn't really seem to know, did he?)
I was avoiding being dogmatic...
Best regards, John
BigJacko
Posted 19/07/2010 - 19:11 Link
johnriley wrote:
Quote:
*(notwithstanding John Riley's input... but with respect, he didn't really seem to know, did he?)
I was avoiding being dogmatic...
Point taken, John (and thanks for responding - both times).

But does this mean it's something the mag might consider worth of at least a query to Pentax HQ, in order to find the pragmatic answer?

Or are you not allowed to ask potentially 'difficult' questions? Having had colleagues working on an old official N*n**n*o magazine in the past, I'm aware there are sometimes invisible lines drawn that determine how far one can probe into company decisions...

Regards
Neil
≡≡≡≡
Pentax K-x ♥ Pentax DA L 18-55mm f3.5-5.6 AL ♣ Pentax DA L 55-300mm f4-5.8 ED ♦ Pentax A 50mm f2.0 ♠ Pentax AF360FGZ flash ♥ Rikenon P 50mm f1.7 ♣ Vivitar CF 28mm f2.8 (K02 Komine) ♦ Tokina 80-200mm f4 ♠ Vivitar MC 2x22 Tele Converter

"Rules are for the obedience of fools and the guidance of wise men" - Douglas 'Tin-Legs' Bader
johnriley
Posted 19/07/2010 - 20:48 Link
Pentax User is independent of Pentax and there's nothing to stop anyone asking questions. It can be difficult to get answers to somethings from any company, either because you end up talking to the wrong person, or maybe the one who knows for sure is actually in Japan...

Here's a thought - what do other marques with CMOS sensors do? If they all have NR permanently on then we have the inklings of an answer anyway.

I've suggested my opinion, so I won't repeat it, so see if anyone agrees with me elsewhere. We don't have the answers to all things at our fingere tips, although probably we have a pretty good idea.

Have you e-mailed Pentax to ask the question?
Best regards, John
BigJacko
Posted 19/07/2010 - 21:46 Link
johnriley wrote:
...what do other marques with CMOS sensors do? If they all have NR permanently on then we have the inklings of an answer anyway.
Good tack, John. Alas, my knowledge of what the other marques do with CMOS (or even which ones have CMOS rather than CCD) is nil, currently. I might try and find out, though.

Don't get me wrong - I do think your original answer is perfectly valid. Steve Luck's book - The Practical Illustrated Encyclopedia of Digital Photography (which I highly recommend, btw - £5 in the remainder bookshops, if you can find a copy) says this of CMOS vs CCD:

Quote:
"Historically, CCDs, which are the more common of the two types, were more efficient at gathering light and tended to produce higher quality images, while CMOS sensors were cheaper to manufacture and were more energy efficient."
When I read that after reading your comment, I thought about posting it here in support. 'Cheap' and 'lower image quality' (implied) might well manfest themselves as 'noise'.

However, his next paragraph undercut me:
Quote:
"In recent years, manufacturers of both systems have worked hard to improve their systems and it is now difficult to say that one works significantly better than the other."
- so I held back from posting either, till now.

johnriley wrote:
Have you e-mailed Pentax to ask the question?
No, not yet, but I am quite happy to do so, if nobody else has (hence the question earlier about any replies from Pentax). Would you recommend anyone in particular, or just hit them at the UK Customer Service email, and hope that it gets passed to the right person in the firm?

Cheers,
Neil
≡≡≡≡
Pentax K-x ♥ Pentax DA L 18-55mm f3.5-5.6 AL ♣ Pentax DA L 55-300mm f4-5.8 ED ♦ Pentax A 50mm f2.0 ♠ Pentax AF360FGZ flash ♥ Rikenon P 50mm f1.7 ♣ Vivitar CF 28mm f2.8 (K02 Komine) ♦ Tokina 80-200mm f4 ♠ Vivitar MC 2x22 Tele Converter

"Rules are for the obedience of fools and the guidance of wise men" - Douglas 'Tin-Legs' Bader

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo