Focus with K-5/DA*300/TC issues

jvs
Posted 07/08/2014 - 21:12 Link
Trying to determine if lack of sharpness with the DA*300, with and without Pentax 1.4 rear converter, is due to my incompetence or to possible calibration issues. As advised, I have tried to take comparison shots (please see below) and would be grateful for any insight you may have. The shots were all taken in my back garden late this afternoon, in good light, no wind, using both a tripod and remote shutter release. They were all taken using TAv setting with Auto ISO, single central AF point using the rear AF button, all focussed on the letter "a" in the centre of the image.
Do you think adjustments are needed to the camera settings?

1 K-5, DA*300 at F4 and 1/800s
Comment Image


2 Same, with 1.4TC at F5.6 and 1/800s
Comment Image


Then from a slightly more frontal view:
3 K-5, DA*300 at F4 and 1/800s
Comment Image


4 Same, with 1.4TC at F5.6 and 1/800s
Comment Image


Thanks for any observations on these,
John
wvbarnes
Posted 07/08/2014 - 21:30 Link
Hi, I don't own that gem of a lens BUT I'd have thought from a quick check of focus tables (I have a free one one on my android device) that at F4 you'd have a very shallow or non existent depth of field range if taken relatively close (say 2 metres).

Here's one online to play with http://www.dofmaster.com/dofjs.html
davidstorm
Posted 07/08/2014 - 22:08 Link
From these images the lens is back focussing. It is marginal, but that is all the error that is needed to make images look soft with a 420mm focal length, especially at wide apertures. I think you need a positive adjustment on the fine AF Adjustment menu, try '+3' at first, then do the tests again and keep repeating until the point of intended focus is sharpest.

However, there is a general lack of sharpness here, even in the area that is in focus. These images should be razor sharp and they are not. If your camera / lens are within warranty I would get them checked out. Here are three example images shot with the DA*300 and 1.4 TC, I think you will be able to see the sharpness of this combination, especially so as these are all from a significant distance from the subjects; all are with the K-3:

Comment Image


Comment Image


Comment Image


Regards
David
Flickr

Nicola's Apartments, Kassiopi, Corfu

Some cameras, some lenses, some bits 'n' bobs
jvs
Posted 07/08/2014 - 22:57 Link
Thanks, David. I'll try the adjustments first as soon as I can. I'm well aware that my results are not as sharp as I would like them to be, especially when compared to yours above and lots of others that are posted. The logistics of returning equipment are daunting, but if that what it comes to ...
John
davidstorm
Posted 07/08/2014 - 23:17 Link
jvs wrote:
Thanks, David. I'll try the adjustments first as soon as I can. I'm well aware that my results are not as sharp as I would like them to be, especially when compared to yours above and lots of others that are posted. The logistics of returning equipment are daunting, but if that what it comes to ...
I'm running out of other suggestions John, I don't think there is camera shake on your shots, so it's starting to look suspiciously like a camera or a lens issue. Do you know anyone near to you who owns a DA*300? If so you might be able to do a test comparison?

Regards
David
Flickr

Nicola's Apartments, Kassiopi, Corfu

Some cameras, some lenses, some bits 'n' bobs
derek897
Posted 08/08/2014 - 00:14 Link
Hi john. Having had a couple of lenses with back focusing issues I know how frustrating this can be. But if that's all it is, it is easily remedied. I used this http://photographylife.com/how-to-quickly-test-your-dslr-for-autofocus-issues
And I found it really easy and straight forward to do.
Looking at your sample images it's hard to tell as we have no way of knowing what you were actually focusing on. Unless you say for example the third line of writing was the focus point.
With the lenses I had, they were focusing closer to the camera instead of actual focus point indicating back focus and needing a + adjustment. If focusing further away it indicates front focusing and will need a - adjustment.
It's very easily done in the menu and is nothing to be nervous of doing.
Good luck with this and hope you get it sorted.
Derek.
I know what i like, If not always why.
PaulEvans
Posted 08/08/2014 - 06:40 Link
Just a thought - since you were on a tripod, you did turn SR off didn't you? Won't help with front or back focussing, but might explain the slight lack of sharpness. Apologies if you have this covered...

Paul
K3ii, DA16-85, DA35mm Limited, FA77mm Limited, 55mm f1.8 K, 135mm f3.5 M, DA300, DA 1.4 HD TC,
DA16-45, Sigma 15mm f2.8. Cosina 100mm f3.5 macro
jvs
Posted 08/08/2014 - 13:20 Link
Quote:
Looking at your sample images it's hard to tell as we have no way of knowing what you were actually focusing on. Unless you say for example the third line of writing was the focus point.
With the lenses I had, they were focusing closer to the camera instead of actual focus point indicating back focus and needing a + adjustment. If focusing further away it indicates front focusing and will need a - adjustment.
Derek, thanks for this. The focus point for all the tests was the lower case letter "a" which is as near to the centre of the text as I could get. The two/three lines of text to the right of the "a" line (ie further from the camera) seem sharper, suggesting back-focussing, as David pointed out. Is your second paragraph as you intended? Shouldn't your "closer" and "further away" be the other way round?

Quote:
Just a thought - since you were on a tripod, you did turn SR off didn't you?
Paul, I was so intent on setting everything up accurately for the test shots, I forgot to turn off the SR! Back to the drawing board! (With fingers crossed that the solution could be so simple - surely not!) No need to apologise!

Conditions not as good today, so may have to wait until tomorrow to repeat the tests and make the adjustments - I don't really have the indoor lighting to be sure of doing them correctly.

Thanks to everyone for your suggestions.
John
wvbarnes
Posted 08/08/2014 - 14:57 Link
Hi,

it still seems to me that much as John may have an adjustment problem the distance focused on is relevant.

At F4 at 10 metres a 300mm lens has a depth of field from 9.91 metres to 10.1 metres ie 190 millimetres. Manageable for bird shots and better still if stopped down to F5.6 where it becomes a very usable 240 millimetres

At 5 metres this reduces to 40 millimetres for F4 or at F5.6 60 millimetres Still OK for a small bird or insect but tight.

At 2 metres it is virtually nil. Tables show F4 as 10 millimetres and much the same at F5.6

So IF relatively close and not completely at 90 degrees to the sensor plane this is a painful task to be undertaking. Am I reading the tables incorrectly some one please?
Edited by wvbarnes: 08/08/2014 - 15:03
derek897
Posted 08/08/2014 - 16:47 Link
Shouldn't your "closer" and "further away" be the other way round?
Could be
The only thing i do remember is it was a + adjustment for back and a - adjustment for front.
if its a front or back focus problem it only takes about ten mins to fine tune.
Derek
I know what i like, If not always why.
Mike-P
Posted 08/08/2014 - 16:54 Link
Thread I started about it a while back here ... makes a big difference.
jvs
Posted 11/08/2014 - 22:49 Link
If anyone's following this....
did the AF fine adjustment with the DA*300mm, ran the same test again and the difference was noticeable. Have n't been able yet to get any birds or dragonflies because of the weather, but got out today in the wind and found a few cows that were reasonably still. How would you rate the level of sharpness here, please?
1
Comment Image


2
Comment Image


3
Comment Image


4
Comment Image


Thanks,
John
davidstorm
Posted 11/08/2014 - 23:09 Link
These are indeed noticeably better but it is quite difficult to assess on such large subjects that have a wide range of focus points across them. The acid test will come when focussing on a very small and defined point.

However, I still think there may be an equipment issue here. Not sure if it's my imagination, but in all of the cow images above, they appear to have a reasonably sharp area in the left portion of the image, but nothing that is sharp on the right? How does the camera perform with other lenses? If it is good and sharp I suspect the DA*300 has a problem, if there are also 'sharpness issues' with other lenses it is more likely the camera at fault, maybe a sensor that is misaligned so it is not parallel with the subject?

Regards
David
Flickr

Nicola's Apartments, Kassiopi, Corfu

Some cameras, some lenses, some bits 'n' bobs
jvs
Posted 12/08/2014 - 21:57 Link
Thanks, David. I'll dig out some old ones from before I had the DA*300. I don't recall having problems before, but your eye is better attuned than mine insofar as you know from experience what the lens should be like. I'm just beginning to realize that now.
John
jvs
Posted 13/08/2014 - 17:34 Link
Here are a few from awhile back: they seem sharp enough to me to suggest that the camera is not the root of the problem, but more experienced eyes may not agree. They are all raw files converted to jpeg and resized with no sharpening.

1. K-5 + DA 55-300mm
Comment Image


2. K-5 + DA 55-300mm
Comment Image


3. K-5 + DA 18-135mm
Comment Image


4. K-5 + DA 18-135mm
Comment Image


5. K-5 + DA 18-135mm
Comment Image


Thanks,
John

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo