First shots with the 10-17
Posted 23/05/2007 - 22:48
Link
Very impressive and love the feel of your images.
Keep up the great work.
Keep up the great work.
Posted 23/05/2007 - 23:00
Link
They are impressive shots. I would have liked all the green base in on the first shot and there was a little room in the frame to make it so.
But that's only a minor point with two very interesting images.
But that's only a minor point with two very interesting images.
Best regards, John
Posted 24/05/2007 - 00:00
Link
Quote:
They are impressive shots.
Would you guys kindly explain what exactly you mean by "impressive", please, and (if it's not then obvious) why you found them so?They are impressive shots.
I was impressed by the abundance of colour in the one shot straight into the sun; normally with such a huge contrast I'd expect the scene generally to be underexposed, but apart from that I didn't like them at all, mostly because of the distortion.
But I would like to at least understand what it is that makes people be impressed by such shots. My reaction was "well I won't bother getting a 10-17 mm lens then".
No offence intended at all - I'm genuinely trying to understand what people like about photographs like that.
Posted 24/05/2007 - 07:36
Link
Quote:
No offence intended at all - I'm genuinely trying to understand what people like about photographs like that.
I think the fish-eye perspective is one that you either like, or don't like. Personally, I don't like it. Nevertheless, some images taken with this lens are 'impressive'. Whether it's the apparant scale of the subject, the perceived enormity of the angle of view, I don't know.No offence intended at all - I'm genuinely trying to understand what people like about photographs like that.
I much prefer the more 'normal' rectilinear perspective of the DA12-24mm lens.
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream
Posted 24/05/2007 - 07:48
Link
The word impressive simply meant I was impressed by the qualities of the images. The distortion is the whole point with a fish-eye lens - if it wasn't there I would want my money back.
Correctly used, for impact, the lens gives the tower enormous "weight" and "power" in the composition, adding drama to a scene that could have been very mundane. Our distorted view reminds me of the filming technique say of "The Avengers" at its 1960s best.
The second shot exploits the fact that horizons straight through the centre of a fish-eye will be straight. The photographer here may not have realised fully what this meant and it is not 100% straight. Then the forground looks odd so we are led up a visual path that suggests something is not quite right. Thus the image becomes more interesting as we linger on it looking for an answer.
Hopefully that expands a little on impressive.
Correctly used, for impact, the lens gives the tower enormous "weight" and "power" in the composition, adding drama to a scene that could have been very mundane. Our distorted view reminds me of the filming technique say of "The Avengers" at its 1960s best.
The second shot exploits the fact that horizons straight through the centre of a fish-eye will be straight. The photographer here may not have realised fully what this meant and it is not 100% straight. Then the forground looks odd so we are led up a visual path that suggests something is not quite right. Thus the image becomes more interesting as we linger on it looking for an answer.
Hopefully that expands a little on impressive.
Best regards, John
Posted 24/05/2007 - 08:17
Link
Oooh, controversy sparked by my images!
Well, as far as controversy goes in this civilized forum.
Please keep in mind that these were the first 20 or so shots I took with this lens and it seems it needs some getting used to.
John is right in that the base should have been fully in the frame. I guess I was so carried away with the new view through the lens.
ChrisA does have a point (no offence taken) and it demonstrates that either you love the fisheye distortion or you loathe it. Chris, at least I have saved you from considering a 10-17 as it clearly isn't for you. I wasn't even sure if it is right for me and took the plunge anyway. After one day I know it is for me, although the danger is that I get tired of it quickly and never put it on again. Only time will tell.
I also was impressed by the shot against the sun, I used -1EV in this one and pulled up the darks a bit in post processing. The intention of this shot was to get a feel for the look of the sun (and possible flare) when it is in the frame (with such a wide angle it certainly is difficult sometimes to keep the sun out of the frame). John is right that I intended to have the horizon straight in this shot and didn't quite succeed. The curvature in the foreground pulls it in the right direction, though.
Compositionwise this shot is perhaps not that interesting, for me it's a bit more interesting as I know that the concrete jetty is straight, not curved.
Certainly this lens doesn't always produces images that "work", now I can start to learn when to use it and when it's better to leave it in the bag.
Cheers,
Prieni
Well, as far as controversy goes in this civilized forum.
Please keep in mind that these were the first 20 or so shots I took with this lens and it seems it needs some getting used to.
John is right in that the base should have been fully in the frame. I guess I was so carried away with the new view through the lens.
ChrisA does have a point (no offence taken) and it demonstrates that either you love the fisheye distortion or you loathe it. Chris, at least I have saved you from considering a 10-17 as it clearly isn't for you. I wasn't even sure if it is right for me and took the plunge anyway. After one day I know it is for me, although the danger is that I get tired of it quickly and never put it on again. Only time will tell.
I also was impressed by the shot against the sun, I used -1EV in this one and pulled up the darks a bit in post processing. The intention of this shot was to get a feel for the look of the sun (and possible flare) when it is in the frame (with such a wide angle it certainly is difficult sometimes to keep the sun out of the frame). John is right that I intended to have the horizon straight in this shot and didn't quite succeed. The curvature in the foreground pulls it in the right direction, though.
Compositionwise this shot is perhaps not that interesting, for me it's a bit more interesting as I know that the concrete jetty is straight, not curved.
Certainly this lens doesn't always produces images that "work", now I can start to learn when to use it and when it's better to leave it in the bag.
Cheers,
Prieni
How inappropriate to call this planet earth when it is quite clearly Ocean. - Arthur C. Clarke
Prieni's PPG page
Prieni's PPG page
Posted 24/05/2007 - 09:55
Link
Quote:
ChrisA does have a point (no offence taken) and it demonstrates that either you love the fisheye distortion or you loathe it. Chris, at least I have saved you from considering a 10-17 as it clearly isn't for you.
Indeed. My thanks for that. ChrisA does have a point (no offence taken) and it demonstrates that either you love the fisheye distortion or you loathe it. Chris, at least I have saved you from considering a 10-17 as it clearly isn't for you.
Quote:
I also was impressed by the shot against the sun, I used -1EV in this one and pulled up the darks a bit in post processing.
It's good to see that such dynamic range is possible, certainly. Considering the intensity of the sun, the flare is surprisingly inoffensive too.
I also was impressed by the shot against the sun, I used -1EV in this one and pulled up the darks a bit in post processing.
Posted 24/05/2007 - 10:34
Link
With a little apprehension I ordered the sam elens only yesterday and having seen your shots I'm glad I did.
Just hope I can do as well as you.
Just hope I can do as well as you.
Old wood best to burn, old wine to drink, old friends to trust, and old authors to read.
Posted 24/05/2007 - 10:39
Link
Quote:
With a little apprehension I ordered the sam elens only yesterday and having seen your shots I'm glad I did.
Just hope I can do as well as you.
I'm sure you can. It will be fun to figure out how to use the 10-17 to the greatest effect. We learned over the years to "see" the frame when looking around. Now you have to imagine the distortion and it's effect as well. Maybe I should get new glasses with fish-eye vision. With a little apprehension I ordered the sam elens only yesterday and having seen your shots I'm glad I did.
Just hope I can do as well as you.
I hope to see pics taken with your new lens soon....
Prieni
How inappropriate to call this planet earth when it is quite clearly Ocean. - Arthur C. Clarke
Prieni's PPG page
Prieni's PPG page
Posted 24/05/2007 - 14:28
Link
You might also want to try one of these:
http://www.pbase.com/mark_dominic/pentax_and_spl
EDIT: THIS - I want one of these stickers! LOL!
Matt
http://www.pbase.com/mark_dominic/pentax_and_spl
EDIT: THIS - I want one of these stickers! LOL!
Matt
http://www.mattmatic.co.uk
(For gallery, tips and links)
(For gallery, tips and links)
Posted 24/05/2007 - 14:43
Link
Oh yes, now that IS cool. Trouble is that I have the istD, not the K10D
Thinking of it, building a housing shouldn't be that difficult. After all it's my day job to build instruments that are dunked in the sea.
This SPL housing does look proper, though, and you get a housing for the flash as well!
Thinking of it, building a housing shouldn't be that difficult. After all it's my day job to build instruments that are dunked in the sea.
This SPL housing does look proper, though, and you get a housing for the flash as well!
How inappropriate to call this planet earth when it is quite clearly Ocean. - Arthur C. Clarke
Prieni's PPG page
Prieni's PPG page
Posted 24/05/2007 - 15:16
Link
Also worth checking out this: http://nedbunnell.blogspot.com/2007_01_01_archive.html
Looks like they're custom made at SPL, and the shots may give you some ideas
Matt
Looks like they're custom made at SPL, and the shots may give you some ideas
Matt
http://www.mattmatic.co.uk
(For gallery, tips and links)
(For gallery, tips and links)
Posted 24/05/2007 - 15:21
Link
I like the focal length range on the 10-17, but would prefer a rectilinear lens with these focal range.
Posted 24/05/2007 - 15:28
Link
Quote:
I like the focal length range on the 10-17, but would prefer a rectilinear lens with these focal range.
How's about the Sigma 10-20? There is a thread Pentax 10-17 or Sigma 10-20 here.
I like the focal length range on the 10-17, but would prefer a rectilinear lens with these focal range.
How inappropriate to call this planet earth when it is quite clearly Ocean. - Arthur C. Clarke
Prieni's PPG page
Prieni's PPG page
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


1469 posts
22 years
Rostock,
Germany
*istD, DA 10-17, 1/500 s, A22, ISO 200
Both taken at 10mm. There is quite some CA visible in the RAW pics but with SilkyPix I got it under control. That's great with digital, you even can beat basic physics (well, to a degree that is).
I'm pretty sure that I will have a lot of fun with this lens.
Prieni's PPG page