First serious HDR attempt

fatspider
Posted 18/10/2009 - 00:00 Link
Heres my first serious attempt at HDR, I shot three images at f22 (using a tripod) at 1/8, 1/4 and 1/2 sec.

I lightened the exposure on the first two slightly in Pentax photolab before combining them with HDR software.

This is somewhere on the "Trossachs Trail" dont ask me exactly where, though no doubt Ken (gartmore) or one of our other Scots members will tell us.

Say what you think C&C will be much appreciated.

[IMG]http://i80.photobucket.com/albums/j168/impotentspider/_K209214-HDRsmll.jpg[/IMG]
My Names Alan, and I'm a lensaholic.
My PPG link
My Flckr link
lidy
Posted 18/10/2009 - 00:22 Link
Don't know anything about HDR (which software did you use by the way?), but I do like the result. Lovely picture!
Dodging and burning are steps to take care of mistakes God made in establishing tonal relationships. - Ansel Adams -
Galoot
Posted 18/10/2009 - 00:59 Link
Maybe I'm wrong, but my understanding of HDR, would be to show light tones darkened and dark tones lightened, to give an even range, i.e. nothing too light and nothing too dark ?

I maybe totally wrong, but I thought that was what HDR was all about, could someone educate me ?

I used your picture to show what I thought HDR was all about ?

I'll delete it at your request

Comment Image
K10D
Posted 18/10/2009 - 03:13 Link
Typical site, this link shows Russian locations but covers a lot more.

link

This one is Russian.

link

Regards
Too far from a shore.
Edited by K10D: 18/10/2009 - 03:18
K10D
Posted 18/10/2009 - 09:43 Link
cardiff_gareth wrote:
Yeah HDR is supposed to show detail in all shadows / midtones and highlights so I think you need to lighten up them shadow areas

Gary, how do you find these sites, that second link the first shot. That building is mahousive
Russian family and a lot of Russian photographer friends.

Regards
Too far from a shore.
fatspider
Posted 18/10/2009 - 10:19 Link
I did think the dark area on the left should have come out lighter, I used Dynamic Photo HDR for the conversion.
The darker areas are much lighter on my third exposure than shown in the finished HDR, though not quite as light as the ones in Johns example, Looks like I'll have to play around with the software a bit more or even try it with a five exposure shot.
My Names Alan, and I'm a lensaholic.
My PPG link
My Flckr link
George Lazarette
Posted 18/10/2009 - 16:43 Link
The plain fact is that your picture looks better and more true to the scene than Galoot's more exaggerated version.

The problem with most HDR pictures is that it's so obvious they are HDR. With yours it isn't obvious, and that's how it ought to be.

Rather like cosmetic surgery, in fact.

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
fatspider
Posted 18/10/2009 - 18:01 Link
Quote:
The problem with most HDR pictures is that it's so obvious they are HDR
I understand your point George, I'm not keen on overcooked HDR myself and I ran through the process again to see where I went wrong (if indeed I did).

The software has several sliders that can be adjusted after merging the images, these range from Brightness, Saturation, Vivid Colours, Dynamic Light Radius etc etc.

I didnt like the result presented to me so played around with the sliders, I actually reduced the levels on all of them till I was happy with the shot, the result is an image very close to my middle exposure (the cameras evaluation of the scene) with the exception of a darker sky and a reduction in the overall saturation of the sunlit mountain, I suppose I could have achieved the same result by adjusting the one image in Photoshop

Back to the drawing board I think as I would like to lighten that left hand side up a little more. After that I have a five shot church interior to tackle
My Names Alan, and I'm a lensaholic.
My PPG link
My Flckr link
Mongoose
Posted 18/10/2009 - 22:59 Link
When it comes to post processing, I am a great believer that when you do it right, people wont know you've done anything at all.

For me therefore Spiders original is far and away better than Galoots version.
you don't have to be mad to post here



but it does help
George Lazarette
Posted 18/10/2009 - 23:18 Link
In fairness to Galoot, I think he emphasised the effect in order to show the possibilities of HDR.

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
Mongoose
Posted 19/10/2009 - 11:29 Link
True, my post is rather more critical of Galoot than I really meant. TBH HDR isn't generally my thing because it almost inevitably ends up obviously post processed, so possibly I'm not the best commentator on the merits of an HDR shot.
you don't have to be mad to post here



but it does help
Galoot
Posted 19/10/2009 - 19:51 Link
I didn't really do any HDR conversion, it was just a 'lift' the shadow area, to show what most people produce doing HDR conversions, it took all of 10 seconds.

There are one or two HDR images I have seen that look quite natural, especially indoor shots, but most look very 'fake'.

I didn't mean to suggest my version was better, it was just to show an example of what I thought typical HDR was all about.
misiek_knm
Posted 19/10/2009 - 21:51 Link
Alan, I'd never guessed it was HDRed if you didn't say

Gary, thanks for the link to the Russian site, worth clicking
Kind regards,
Michal R. Hoffmann
K20D, DA 16-45mm, A 50mm F/1:1.4, DA 55-300mm; flash Pentax AF240Z

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo