DA 55-300 - quick 1st impressions

simonkit
Posted 13/05/2008 - 20:14 Link
Having only owned the 55-300 for a couple of hours I've not had a proper cahnce to try it out fully but here are my first impressions..

Build quality - pretty good, nothing loose - smooth zoom action (moreso than Sigma 70-300)

size - smaller than both the sigma/tamron 70-300


Lens hood - a little on the thin size but locks in position positively & does the job

& now the most important one IQ...


As I said its early days but my initial thoughts are very positive, looks quite sharp at 300mm to me, moreso than the Sigma & I think if not equal to, then pretty damn close to the Tamron. Looks pretty good wide open too.

I've taken some quick test chart shots - unfortunately these have to be reduce 45% in quality due to photobucket limitations, image size is FULL SIZE - NO sharpening added in PP, shot in RAW

Click on thumbnail to open image, then click again for FULL SIZE


F11 @ 190mm

Comment Image


F11 @300mm

Comment Image



F5.8 @ 190mm

Comment Image


F5.8 @ 300mm

Comment Image
iceblinker
Posted 13/05/2008 - 20:26 Link
Quote:
Weight/size - smaller & lighter than both the sigma/tamron 70-300
Have you weighed them, or are you just reporting what they feel like in your hand? You previously mistakenly thought the Sigma was lighter than the Tamron.

The Tamron is 5 grams lighter than the Pentax according to www.tamron.com/lenses/prod/70300_di_a017.asp

and www.bdimitrov.de/kmp/lenses/zooms/long/DA55-300f4-5.8.html

and the Tamron is only 5mm longer.

What is the Pentax's maximum aperture at 200mm? The Tamron's is F4.5.
~Pete
simonkit
Posted 13/05/2008 - 20:34 Link
Quote:
simonkit wrote:
Weight/size - smaller & lighter than both the sigma/tamron 70-300
Have you weighed them or checked the specs this time?

The Tamron is 5 grams lighter than the Pentax according to www.tamron.com/lenses/prod/70300_di_a017.asp

and www.bdimitrov.de/kmp/lenses/zooms/long/DA55-300f4-5.8.html

and the Tamron is only 5mm longer.

What is the Pentax's maximum aperture at 200mm? The Tamron's is F4.5.
I guess the weight isn't much different then, I'll retract the comment - aperture at 200m is the same, F4.5

simon
iceblinker
Posted 13/05/2008 - 20:44 Link
Quote:
aperture at 200m is the same, F4.5
That's good, thanks.

Someone on DPR mentioned it was smaller, though I can't find the thread now.

If the Pentax is just as fast then I will think about getting one. It would be good to have a lens similar to the Tamron but without such a bad purple fringing problem (if that is the case).
~Pete
Clarky
Posted 13/05/2008 - 21:06 Link
Quote:
simonkit wrote:
aperture at 200m is the same, F4.5
That's good, thanks.

Someone on DPR mentioned it was smaller, though I can't find the thread now.

If the Pentax is just as fast then I will think about getting one. It would be good to have a lens similar to the Tamron but without such a bad purple fringing problem (if that is the case).
What about price difference compared to the Tamron & Sigma is it much more expensive :
Camera:|K-7|
Pentax Lenses:|DA12-24/f4 ED AL|DA35Ltd Macro|FA31Ltd|FA77Ltd|FA50/1.4|F70-210|FA20-35 f4/AL|A*200/f4 Macro ED|A50/1.7|A50 Macro f2.8|1.7xAF adapter|
Voigtlander|125/f2.5SL Macro APO Lanthar|
Sigma Lenses:|EX DG 100-300 f4|2X & 1.4X TC|
Flashes:|AF540FGZx2|RingFlash AF160FC|
iceblinker
Posted 13/05/2008 - 21:22 Link
...Yes, the Pentax is over twice the price of the Tamron.

(I was forgetting that! I'll just stick with my Tamron for now.)
~Pete
Mongoose
Posted 14/05/2008 - 11:05 Link
how does the CA compare to the Tamron?

As I understand the complaint against the Tamron 70-300 has always been that it suffers from CA more than the Sigma.

Also, what's the focusing speed like compared to the other two.

Thanks for your thoughts
you don't have to be mad to post here



but it does help
iceblinker
Posted 14/05/2008 - 11:10 Link
Specifically, the Tamron suffers from purple fringing - which is more difficult to remove with software than ordinary CA.

I can see some PF in Simon's example of the Pentax, too, though maybe it's not as bad as the Tamron (?).
~Pete
simonkit
Posted 14/05/2008 - 14:02 Link
Too early for me to comment on the "purple" issue, not had chance to reproduce similar situations where it was very evident on the Tamron...

regarding focus speed it seems to perform well, a bit less hunting than tamron/sigma, although again ots very early to be sure of this.

I'll continue to post my findings as I get more chance to use it

simon
Mongoose
Posted 14/05/2008 - 15:21 Link
there's an interesting comparison over on DePressing Review forums showing DA55-300 vs Tamron 70-300 vs DA*300 (obviously the latter included for an ultimate quality standard).

In those shots the Pentax looks slightly sharper than the Tamron with drastically reduced PF. It doesn't match the DA*, but then who ever thought it would?

Of course it's just one comparison and doesn't take sample-sample variation into account on either lens, but on evidence presented so far the Pentax DA 55-300 is looking like it's going on my shopping list
you don't have to be mad to post here



but it does help

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo