DA* lens tests - technique and advice appreciated!
Posted 05/05/2008 - 21:39
Link
First and foremost: consistent environment.
Not just consistent, but totally static and immutable in all regards other than the lens you are comparing with.
It sounds like you will have all of that covered with the mounting and studio environment your have at the shop.
RAW v.s. JPEG should not matter as long as your consistent. JPEG might give some artifacts, but that should not be easily confused with focusing, unless you have low quality and low resolution.
One note, I've noticed the focus point on my camera is off slightly from center. Rather it was... I had a repair done and they replaced all the innards. It now focuses pretty darn near to center.
Not much of an issue when on a tripod, except that different lenses may not have an exactly identical field of view at the same focal length. (My DA* 16-50 v.s. 50mm v.s. 18-200 all have significantly different views at 50mm.)
Thus the focus point may be off slightly. If your aiming at anything not totally and perfectly parallel to the sensor, your may have focusing discrepancies.
Again, it sounds like you'll have that all covered. But these little things caused me some mild headaches with getting consistent results.
Not just consistent, but totally static and immutable in all regards other than the lens you are comparing with.
It sounds like you will have all of that covered with the mounting and studio environment your have at the shop.
RAW v.s. JPEG should not matter as long as your consistent. JPEG might give some artifacts, but that should not be easily confused with focusing, unless you have low quality and low resolution.
One note, I've noticed the focus point on my camera is off slightly from center. Rather it was... I had a repair done and they replaced all the innards. It now focuses pretty darn near to center.
Not much of an issue when on a tripod, except that different lenses may not have an exactly identical field of view at the same focal length. (My DA* 16-50 v.s. 50mm v.s. 18-200 all have significantly different views at 50mm.)
Thus the focus point may be off slightly. If your aiming at anything not totally and perfectly parallel to the sensor, your may have focusing discrepancies.
Again, it sounds like you'll have that all covered. But these little things caused me some mild headaches with getting consistent results.
Posted 05/05/2008 - 23:57
Link
Quote:
Will be shooting a wedding on Aug 2nd for a friend.
How's this for a coincidence? On Saturday I did my first ever wedding for one of my customers at very short notice (sole photographer), and the reception was a bbq back at his house in..... YOUR ROAD! Will be shooting a wedding on Aug 2nd for a friend.
First time I'd been in a house on the Rivets side and was suprised how far back the gardens go (and how many people they can comfortably hold). Very impressed!
I'll post some of the pictures at some point, but the bride and groom haven't seen any of them yet so I'll wait until they're happy first.
Joining the Q
Posted 06/05/2008 - 01:14
Link
LOL, talk about small world, would be very interested how you got on!
Must admit, haven't got round to sorting out the pics yet. Combination of Aperture, Lightroom and Elements 6 trials having run out on the mac, and the discovery of wireless flash left us playing til 1 am!
Have put 2 full size JPEGs on my website though if anyone has the time etc. to have a browse
http://www.dannyewers.com/photos/1.jpg
and
http://www.dannyewers.com/photos/2.jpg
Must admit that my untrained eye isn't overwhelmed by these, so would appreciate what you make of them
(edit) both with DA* 16-50 @ 16mm and f2.8
Must admit, haven't got round to sorting out the pics yet. Combination of Aperture, Lightroom and Elements 6 trials having run out on the mac, and the discovery of wireless flash left us playing til 1 am!
Have put 2 full size JPEGs on my website though if anyone has the time etc. to have a browse
http://www.dannyewers.com/photos/1.jpg
and
http://www.dannyewers.com/photos/2.jpg
Must admit that my untrained eye isn't overwhelmed by these, so would appreciate what you make of them
(edit) both with DA* 16-50 @ 16mm and f2.8
Posted 06/05/2008 - 01:24
Link
The brick wall appears to suffer from camera shake. If the camera was on a tripod, be sure to use the 2 second timer to lock the mirror up. If not, thee's your answer.
The focus test sheet looks fine to me.
The center focus spot in camera is an + shape that extends roughly the size of the center circle in the viewfinder. It is possible you could be at either end and be in focus, therefore you won't have a perfect 1/3 v.s. 2/3 DOF from the center line on the test sheet. That ratio is also just a rough guesstimate that changes with on focal length, etc...
The focus test sheet looks fine to me.
The center focus spot in camera is an + shape that extends roughly the size of the center circle in the viewfinder. It is possible you could be at either end and be in focus, therefore you won't have a perfect 1/3 v.s. 2/3 DOF from the center line on the test sheet. That ratio is also just a rough guesstimate that changes with on focal length, etc...
Posted 06/05/2008 - 01:30
Link
The brick wall shot was on the tripod, SR off, mirror up 3 sec delay with IR Remote, so I guess that before we call it a bad sample, do the same shot again several times?
Think it was on spot metering as well, not sure if that should make a difference though?
Think it was on spot metering as well, not sure if that should make a difference though?
Posted 06/05/2008 - 01:32
Link
Just FYI, this is what I found to be the locations of focus points on my K10D.
This was before the repair, and although the focus is more centered now, I believe the basic layout/shape is still the same.
I was rather surprised at the long shape of all but the center focus spot.
I also thought all focus points were supposed to be cross points, but I did not seem to find that to be the case.
I suppose the internal processing is cross shaped (handle both vertical and horizontal contrast edges), but the focus area itself is a rather large rectangle.
Anyway, you have some leeway from perfect center and still be "in focus".

This was before the repair, and although the focus is more centered now, I believe the basic layout/shape is still the same.
I was rather surprised at the long shape of all but the center focus spot.
I also thought all focus points were supposed to be cross points, but I did not seem to find that to be the case.
I suppose the internal processing is cross shaped (handle both vertical and horizontal contrast edges), but the focus area itself is a rather large rectangle.
Anyway, you have some leeway from perfect center and still be "in focus".

Posted 06/05/2008 - 01:43
Link
Quote:
The brick wall shot was on the tripod, SR off, mirror up 3 sec delay with IR Remote, so I guess that before we call it a bad sample, do the same shot again several times?
The more I look at it, I just can't tell. Must be the odd patterns of the brick. Could just be soft focus. The brick wall shot was on the tripod, SR off, mirror up 3 sec delay with IR Remote, so I guess that before we call it a bad sample, do the same shot again several times?
Also, f2.8 is not going to give you the sharpest image, but this still seems a little soft. I'd say try again, but also more around f5.6-f8 and see how that looks and compare against the same shot at f2.8.
Posted 06/05/2008 - 11:00
Link
For the focus test chart try taking the picture again using your 43mm @f.1.9 - the smaller the depth of field the easier it is to check BF/FF problems. It looks like yours is sharp from 6mm (front) to 14mm (back) on the one you've posted which suggests it's back focussing by a very small amount (probably too small to show with most pics and most lenses). If you want to adjust for this then full instructions are here: https://www.pentaxuser.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=7203&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=15
I don't find brick walls to be particularly useful for focus checking but they do show levels of distortion up well...
I don't find brick walls to be particularly useful for focus checking but they do show levels of distortion up well...
Joining the Q
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


3062 posts
19 years
Aylesbury,
Bucks.
Have brought all my kit to the shop today (inc. our new manfrotto 405 geared head, very nice!), and when we close at 4 going to set up out the back and do some proper testing. Have decided to do the focus test chart, and the infamous brick wall tests to find out if there are any problems.
Reasons for doing this are:-
Focus tests.
Lack of experience. I have no point of reference (read: years of experience) and would appreciate your input.
Will be shooting a wedding on Aug 2nd for a friend. I'm not going to be the main photographer, but they have shots they want me to do, and I would love to have this in a portfolio. If I have BF FF issues, will need to get this lot into Pentax before then!
Think I know what I am doing to get the results, but if there is anything you can add, please feel free to do so! Main question I have at the moment is wether it makes any difference shooting Raw or JPEG for these tests.
Thanks in advance for the help!
Website・Blog・Gear・Twitter・Facebook