Competition Topics

TOZZA27
Posted 01/06/2010 - 18:12 Link
K20D,*istD ( now a dedicated M42 digital ),K100D,MZ5N,P50,ME Super,Spotmatic 1000,Spotmatic,ESII,ES,H2.18-55 II,18-55,75-300 FAJ,35-80 FA,80-200 F,28-105 FA,Sigma 24-70 AF Aspherical,Sigma 28-300 Hyperzoom , Praotor II 500 M42,Centon 500mm mirror,and a few Pentax M42 Taks,super-Taks,smc Taks,A and M lenses.Benbo trekker,7dayshop monopod and a Lowepro rucksack.

I am now on Flickr which is nice !
Anvh
Posted 01/06/2010 - 18:17 Link
ISO wrote:
TOZZA27 wrote:
I`m a bit wary of this topic as I consider any photographic meddling - other than that which John has just mentioned - to be altering beyond the true image taken.


Tony
I totally agree with Tony. I don't own a copy of Photoshop. Apart from aforementioned tweaks, everything I have is 'straight out of the oven'. IMHO anything else is creative graphics - not photography. (Sound of stamping foot)
Photography always went hand in hand with post processing since after all it takes some chemistry to make the picture appear on any kind of light sensitive surface.

Even your camera does post process your photo, after all it makes from ones and zeros that comes from the sensor into a photo.

So I wonder what you consider to be photography?
Stefan
Comment Image

K10D, K5
DA* 16-50, DA* 50-135, D-FA 100 Macro, DA 40 Ltd, DA 18-55
AF-540FGZ
ISO
Posted 01/06/2010 - 18:22 Link
Stefan - A question of degree - Lets ask you - at what stage of manipulation do you think something no longer is a photograph?
Anvh
Posted 01/06/2010 - 18:25 Link
ISO wrote:
Stefan - A question of degree - Lets ask you - at what stage of manipulation do you think something no longer is a photograph?
First I was quite strict but now almost anything goes as long as it use a photo(s) as the basis.
Stefan
Comment Image

K10D, K5
DA* 16-50, DA* 50-135, D-FA 100 Macro, DA 40 Ltd, DA 18-55
AF-540FGZ
ISO
Posted 01/06/2010 - 18:28 Link
What changed your mind:
TOZZA27
Posted 01/06/2010 - 18:43 Link
We are heading back into the realms of my old industry again - If I buy the raw materials,prepare them,cook them,and serve them then I am a cook/chef.................
If I go to a supplier and buy the dishes ready prepared and frozen or sous-vide and reheat them then I am no longer a cook/chef surely ?

The photo - to me - is the representation of the subject as seen by the photographer ( and the lens ) using his skills and the light available at that moment - any further "fiddling" becomes a whole new art form IMHO obviously - as I think ISO is agreeing.

regards

Tony
K20D,*istD ( now a dedicated M42 digital ),K100D,MZ5N,P50,ME Super,Spotmatic 1000,Spotmatic,ESII,ES,H2.18-55 II,18-55,75-300 FAJ,35-80 FA,80-200 F,28-105 FA,Sigma 24-70 AF Aspherical,Sigma 28-300 Hyperzoom , Praotor II 500 M42,Centon 500mm mirror,and a few Pentax M42 Taks,super-Taks,smc Taks,A and M lenses.Benbo trekker,7dayshop monopod and a Lowepro rucksack.

I am now on Flickr which is nice !
Anvh
Posted 01/06/2010 - 18:51 Link
When I did bought the K10D (my first camera) almost 2 years ago I didn't knew much so made a firm line on what's a photo and what not.
Only when I look more at photos that are considered art it became apparent I draw the line to harsh.

When you think about it, no where does it say a photo must be true to life.
Photo simply means an image created by (capturing) light, if you think about it that way you can go pretty far with your processing.
Stefan
Comment Image

K10D, K5
DA* 16-50, DA* 50-135, D-FA 100 Macro, DA 40 Ltd, DA 18-55
AF-540FGZ
Anvh
Posted 01/06/2010 - 18:55 Link
TOZZA27 wrote:
The photo - to me - is the representation of the subject as seen by the photographer ( and the lens ) using his skills and the light available at that moment - any further "fiddling" becomes a whole new art form IMHO obviously - as I think ISO is agreeing.
Thank you Tony you named it: "as seen by the photographer" but what if the camera capture something different the photographers sees and the photographer use some heavy PP to get it out what he/she saw, it's still a photo according to you so yes I agree with you.

We after all all see in a different way.
Stefan
Comment Image

K10D, K5
DA* 16-50, DA* 50-135, D-FA 100 Macro, DA 40 Ltd, DA 18-55
AF-540FGZ
TOZZA27
Posted 01/06/2010 - 19:03 Link
K20D,*istD ( now a dedicated M42 digital ),K100D,MZ5N,P50,ME Super,Spotmatic 1000,Spotmatic,ESII,ES,H2.18-55 II,18-55,75-300 FAJ,35-80 FA,80-200 F,28-105 FA,Sigma 24-70 AF Aspherical,Sigma 28-300 Hyperzoom , Praotor II 500 M42,Centon 500mm mirror,and a few Pentax M42 Taks,super-Taks,smc Taks,A and M lenses.Benbo trekker,7dayshop monopod and a Lowepro rucksack.

I am now on Flickr which is nice !
ISO
Posted 01/06/2010 - 19:06 Link
Hi guys I have to leave for a meeting but for now I think we are getting into language and definitions. There comes a point when the original meaning of a word is stretched so far that another description has to be found for it.
Anvh
Posted 01/06/2010 - 19:42 Link
Take a look at Anna Bodnar, is what she made photos or is it something else? www.annabodnar.eu
Gallery 1 most will say all are photos but still some are quite heavily photo-shopped.
Gallery 2 (vision) is another story many would say it goes too far but I still believe it are photos and not photo manipulation for one reason and that is that she made the photos she used for her manipulation so it becomes more of a 50/50 matter since her focus overall is photography therefore I find it safe to say it are photos.
If someone would only do these kind of manipulations without making the photos then it surely aren't photographs.

To go on a bit.
If I understand you correctly it does not matter how much you processed as long as it looks natural it's photograph?
Don't you think it's a bit unfair that a less processed photo that comes out unnatural isn't a photo?

TOZZA27 wrote:
We are heading back into the realms of my old industry again - If I buy the raw materials,prepare them,cook them,and serve them then I am a cook/chef.................
If I go to a supplier and buy the dishes ready prepared and frozen or sous-vide and reheat them then I am no longer a cook/chef surely ?
That's precieasly photography, if you just take the JPG straight out of the camera you're doing the last one and if you're doing the first one you're still a cook but difffernt one that like to mix the things himself.
I don't say any one is better then another but Tony you know there are some experimental chefs out there and what they create you still call food I (some times) and the same is true for experimantal photography.
Stefan
Comment Image

K10D, K5
DA* 16-50, DA* 50-135, D-FA 100 Macro, DA 40 Ltd, DA 18-55
AF-540FGZ
Edited by Anvh: 01/06/2010 - 19:43
TOZZA27
Posted 01/06/2010 - 19:55 Link
Time to agree to disagree Stefan - Anna Bodnar is undoubtedly talented and creative - BUT - like the experimental chefs - the product is way beyond the skills of the ordinary photographer/cook and usually so expensive as to restrict the number of diners - plus would we want to eat at Heston Blumenthal`s restaurant EVERY night ?

Tony
K20D,*istD ( now a dedicated M42 digital ),K100D,MZ5N,P50,ME Super,Spotmatic 1000,Spotmatic,ESII,ES,H2.18-55 II,18-55,75-300 FAJ,35-80 FA,80-200 F,28-105 FA,Sigma 24-70 AF Aspherical,Sigma 28-300 Hyperzoom , Praotor II 500 M42,Centon 500mm mirror,and a few Pentax M42 Taks,super-Taks,smc Taks,A and M lenses.Benbo trekker,7dayshop monopod and a Lowepro rucksack.

I am now on Flickr which is nice !
Anvh
Posted 01/06/2010 - 20:30 Link
Tony I agree with you on that but I miss the connection about what the reachability has to do with this matter?

I don't think we would ever have a universal thought about this matter the same thing as it is with art in general.
So I can disagree with you and still we both can be right

I mean you've painters/photographers that use a photo and paint on that, I'm sure most photographers would say it's a painting and most painters would say it's a photograph... who is right?
It's the same with this matter and therefore the point that's most important is how the artist sees himself.
Stefan
Comment Image

K10D, K5
DA* 16-50, DA* 50-135, D-FA 100 Macro, DA 40 Ltd, DA 18-55
AF-540FGZ
Edited by Anvh: 01/06/2010 - 20:32
womble
Posted 01/06/2010 - 22:23 Link
So how would you lot describe this?

Clicky

K.
Kris Lockyear
It is an illusion that photos are made with the camera… they are made with the eye, heart and head. Henri Cartier-Bresson
Lots of film bodies, a couple of digital ones, too many lenses (mainly older glass) and a Horseman LE 5x4.
johnriley
Posted 01/06/2010 - 22:25 Link
Quote:
So how would you lot describe this?
A bit of harmless fun and a useful technical exercise.
Best regards, John

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo