Coded vs Decoded Generic Batteries - K-30

Terry1100
Posted 13/06/2015 - 11:59 Link
Hi Guys, long time since I've posted here but I have a question.

I note that generic batteries can be either "coded" or "decoded" - what's the difference in the real world (apart from about 50p)

If I've read this correctly, "coded" batteries behave exactly like the OEM battery, "decoded" batteries don't need to so - but isn't that the same thing anyway.

There plenty of threads on Can/Nik forums but they just sidetrack into OEM vs generic arguments within two posts !

Can anyone clarify.

TIA
Terry
London, England
K-30, Optio Z10, Optio S5i, LS465, Nikon P7100
wvbarnes
Posted 13/06/2015 - 12:15 Link
My wife has a Panasonic Bridge camera that has a chip in to prevent the use of third party batteries. Fortunately hers came with a spare. I'm not aware Pentax have ever tried such crippling of third party product.

I've used generic batteries, including ones (Hahnel) from pro dealer SRS in four Pentax DSLR's now with no problem. My current spare off Amazon is even higher rated than the Pentax labelled DSTS make 2000 MAh (14.8watts) but lasts the same and reads correctly on the battery indicator in my K3. Generally about a third of Pentax price. None seem to have any annotation about coded or decoded as you find for example with 'chipped' pattern ink cartridges also discussed at length on here in past.
Edited by wvbarnes: 13/06/2015 - 12:35
doingthebobs
Posted 13/06/2015 - 14:44 Link
My spare batteries for both K10 and K5 are cheap ones off of Ebay.

Both work the same as the originals. I don't remember seeing anything about chips on Pentax batteries so assume they don't have them. I haven't heard any one complaining at all. Lots of discussion about the OEM v generic but i have not seen any mention of chips being used in those discussions.
Bob
Edited by doingthebobs: 13/06/2015 - 14:45
Terry1100
Posted 13/06/2015 - 15:04 Link
Cheers all

In that case I'm guessing that the listings I have seen are using a template on listings that they use for Canon and Nikon batteries as well (I know my P7100 is fussy about having a coded battery)

Example:
link

To be honest, at this price I'm prepared to gamble.
Terry
London, England
K-30, Optio Z10, Optio S5i, LS465, Nikon P7100
Edited by Terry1100: 13/06/2015 - 15:36

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo