Camera and lens design - has it gone backwards?
Posted 28/01/2015 - 12:09
Link
Actually not really ... I find I really appreciate the ease of having aperture and time value controls literally on the finger tips, keeping the left hand primarily for handling stability. When I do have to use an aperture ring on my old M lens, I often find I lose mental track of which aperture is set. This is because the figure is not displayed (I appreciated that on a modern design, or with A series lenses, this would not be the case), and I can't see the lens aperture ring easily when shooting.
Basically I find the control wheel set up easier and more intuitive, and it does not interfere in any way with handling or take the eyes away from the subject.
I guess you get used to the aperture ring and can control it blindfolded with practice ... But then again, each lens would be different ... The advantage of the camera dials is they feel the same for every lens.
Basically I find the control wheel set up easier and more intuitive, and it does not interfere in any way with handling or take the eyes away from the subject.
I guess you get used to the aperture ring and can control it blindfolded with practice ... But then again, each lens would be different ... The advantage of the camera dials is they feel the same for every lens.
My Guides to the Pentax Digital Camera Flash Lighting System : Download here from the PentaxForums Homepage Article .... link
Pentax K7 with BG-4 Grip / Samyang 14mm f2.8 ED AS IF UMC / DA18-55mm f3.5-5.6 AL WR / SMC A28mm f2.8 / D FA 28-105mm / SMC F35-70 f3.5-4.5 / SMC A50mm f1.7 / Tamron AF70-300mm f4-5.6 Di LD macro / SMC M75-150mm f4.0 / Tamron Adaptall (CT-135) 135mm f2.8 / Asahi Takumar-A 2X tele-converter / Pentax AF-540FGZ (I & II) Flashes / Cactus RF60/X Flashes & V6/V6II Transceiver
Pentax K7 with BG-4 Grip / Samyang 14mm f2.8 ED AS IF UMC / DA18-55mm f3.5-5.6 AL WR / SMC A28mm f2.8 / D FA 28-105mm / SMC F35-70 f3.5-4.5 / SMC A50mm f1.7 / Tamron AF70-300mm f4-5.6 Di LD macro / SMC M75-150mm f4.0 / Tamron Adaptall (CT-135) 135mm f2.8 / Asahi Takumar-A 2X tele-converter / Pentax AF-540FGZ (I & II) Flashes / Cactus RF60/X Flashes & V6/V6II Transceiver
Posted 28/01/2015 - 12:26
Link
You get used to what is current but I don't see how an on lens aperture ring is superior anymore to my thumb on a wheel either. When i've had old manual lenses to play with then fair enough.
In viewfinder display could be better, as a spectacles wearer I find it hard to read especially in poor light for my K5. I tend to refer to the top LCD when adjusting settings which isn't always ideal.
In viewfinder display could be better, as a spectacles wearer I find it hard to read especially in poor light for my K5. I tend to refer to the top LCD when adjusting settings which isn't always ideal.
Posted 28/01/2015 - 14:06
Link
I thought the aperture ring on the lens was better at first, but once I had got used to my *istDS I realised it doesn't really make any difference. It might as well be on the camera body and the wheels do have click stops of their own anyway.
Best regards, John
Posted 28/01/2015 - 16:31
Link
I think Saxon does raise a good point. For my photography journey, aperture has been via the camera body, but I would really like to have the choice of this method and have an aperture ring on the lens.
I am also learning to appreciate distance scales on old lenses, I think a lot of the old skills and techniques used are still very valid today, but with a lot of modern lenses these processes are being lost.
I guess perhaps these features may increase the prices? But being able to have choices is what's important to me.
Fletcher8
I am also learning to appreciate distance scales on old lenses, I think a lot of the old skills and techniques used are still very valid today, but with a lot of modern lenses these processes are being lost.
I guess perhaps these features may increase the prices? But being able to have choices is what's important to me.
Fletcher8
Fletcher8.
Posted 28/01/2015 - 18:23
Link
I don't like 2015 at all Can we move everything back to 1975
--
--
Half Man... Half Pentax ... Half Cucumber
Pentax K-1 + K-5 and some other stuff
Algi
Pentax K-1 + K-5 and some other stuff
Algi
Posted 28/01/2015 - 19:20
Link
Algernon wrote:
I don't like 2015 at all Can we move everything back to 1975
--
what even your wages/salary
I don't like 2015 at all Can we move everything back to 1975
--
David
Posted 28/01/2015 - 19:26
Link
2015 is just fine I think. It's interesting and there certainly is a point regarding aperture rings where we consider prime lenses and DOF markings. So many lenses don't have those these days either. But I personally very, very rarely had a use for them. Eventually we learn to judge and it ends up accurate enough.
IMHO it's certainly more use than trying to judge DOF on the tiny focusing screen.
IMHO it's certainly more use than trying to judge DOF on the tiny focusing screen.
Best regards, John
Posted 28/01/2015 - 22:35
Link
There are pros and cons either way, but personally I now think that setting the aperture on the body is quicker. One has to remember that the way it used to be is very often technology related at the time, so not necessarily better. Now you can set the Aperture in the body, so there's no need for a manual ring.
Pros of the manual ring though are:
It's useable on macro tube extenders more easily.
It's got a more tactile operation, which I think adds to the enjoyment of the shooting event, (but which slows you down and leaves room for future mistakes when you forget to change it to the new setting)
The aperture is set exactly. I mention this because if you've ever tried to do a time lapse session with an auto aperture setting you'll noticed the photos exposures are all over the place, compared to having the aperture physically fixed.
Honestly I think I'd like to see a camera where you get 3 wheels across the top, one for ISO, one for shutter time and one for aperture. You would have auto options on all 3 wheels, and you make up your requirements directly from those wheels. Av mode would fix the aperture to a set value and you'd leave the other two on auto etc. Maybe two wheels on the back and one on the front etc. but it wouldn't have to cost much.
I do think that interfaces have become too cluttered recently and I see marketing games as leading to this directly. The mode dials tend to be massive considering most will only live between a few options. I've mentioned before also, but I don't get the sense of occasion that I once did when shooting with a DSLR. I don't particularly like manual focussing on todays cameras and I was excited to recently pick up a vintage camera and to just look through the massive optical viewfinder, and to see a FF field of view from the lens etc. Picking up an old lens does remind you of how solid they are and how heavy. So yeah, pros and cons as always.
Pros of the manual ring though are:
It's useable on macro tube extenders more easily.
It's got a more tactile operation, which I think adds to the enjoyment of the shooting event, (but which slows you down and leaves room for future mistakes when you forget to change it to the new setting)
The aperture is set exactly. I mention this because if you've ever tried to do a time lapse session with an auto aperture setting you'll noticed the photos exposures are all over the place, compared to having the aperture physically fixed.
Honestly I think I'd like to see a camera where you get 3 wheels across the top, one for ISO, one for shutter time and one for aperture. You would have auto options on all 3 wheels, and you make up your requirements directly from those wheels. Av mode would fix the aperture to a set value and you'd leave the other two on auto etc. Maybe two wheels on the back and one on the front etc. but it wouldn't have to cost much.
I do think that interfaces have become too cluttered recently and I see marketing games as leading to this directly. The mode dials tend to be massive considering most will only live between a few options. I've mentioned before also, but I don't get the sense of occasion that I once did when shooting with a DSLR. I don't particularly like manual focussing on todays cameras and I was excited to recently pick up a vintage camera and to just look through the massive optical viewfinder, and to see a FF field of view from the lens etc. Picking up an old lens does remind you of how solid they are and how heavy. So yeah, pros and cons as always.
Posted 29/01/2015 - 00:22
Link
I think setting the aperture on the lens, in other words stopping the lens down would reduce the brightness in the viewfinder and may cause the phase detect AF not to operate at smaller apertures.
On the other hand it would eliminate any focus shift as AF would be at the aperature being shot at.
Jeff
On the other hand it would eliminate any focus shift as AF would be at the aperature being shot at.
Jeff
Posted 29/01/2015 - 00:30
Link
saxon wrote:
Wouldn't it be great if Pentax launched their next camera and lens series with the option to use on lens aperture rings. Sure by all means keep the option of aperture control on body as well and allow the user to choose which overrides the other.
Isn't this just a K-5/K-3 with an A/F/FA lens on the front (or for a film equivalent, a Z-1 from '92)? Aperture control on the lens or the body depending on whether the ring is set to 'A' or not. The advantage of 'double dial' operation allows you to switch between P, Av & Tv by spinning one dial and allows 'Hyper-Manual' (basically offering Av, Tv, P or M from one exposure mode).Wouldn't it be great if Pentax launched their next camera and lens series with the option to use on lens aperture rings. Sure by all means keep the option of aperture control on body as well and allow the user to choose which overrides the other.
Sadly, removing the aperture ring from the lens and aperture simulator from the camera (aka crippled mount) are probably cost savings that are here to stay.
John.
Posted 29/01/2015 - 01:27
Link
Thanks for the thoughtful replies and yes John - you're right it would be sort of like shooting a K5/K3 etc with an older series lens. The issue for me is that I shoot with my left hand where the aperture ring used to be anyway so while it's there I find it more intuitive to change there than by a whizzwheel on the back of the body. What I'm proposing is that when you give the aperture ring priority it would stay fully wide open when coupled to the body for focussing and composition and then stop down to the selected value during exposure. Sprinning the back dial wouldn't change anything. If you select AE on the lens aperture dial then you have in effect handed aperture control to the whizzwheel on the camera body. That way the end user would have a choice of which interface they prefer. I think the benefits are:
1. Choice
2. Easier to select half stops etc on a large ring than a small dial
3. Easier to read selected aperture with a quick glance at the lens than a top LCD screen (if even present!) between shots
4. Classic lens design
5. Availability of depth of field markings/scales
6. Ability to slam aperture ring fully open while shooting i.e. to select max aperture just turn all the way, no need to check the indications in the viewfinder or anywhere else. With a whizzwheel you never know where you are because it doesn't have an end stop for fully open and just turns endlessly. You might be at F4 on an F2.8 lens or F3.5 or F4.5 and without checking in the viewfinder or the top LCD display you can't know.
The point some of you made about the lovely large focussing screens and construction quality of the old lenses is a good one. It seems to me that most modern lenses have an awful plastic quality with very poor manual focussing action compared to the lenses of yesteryear. I have't really noticed a huge cut in prices either despite the corners cut in construction and the manufacturing in cheaper locations compared to Japan. If you consider something like a Pentax SMC-M 50mm F1.7 lens which if memory serves in the mid 1980's sold for around £50 then adjusted for inflation http://swanlowpark.co.uk/rpiannual.jsp such a lens made fully of metal and in Japan should cost today £120. The nearest equivalent in the range I can find is the 43mm F1.9 limited and that costs a whopping £499. It's built like a SMC-M series lens and has similar optical quality but despite being made in Vietnam actually costs significantly more in relative terms.
That sort of price escalation makes no sense to me even allowing for niceties like autofocus. Also why oh why do most modern lenses have such a poor manual focussing action? I know in the days of autofocus you don't need it everyday but surely it would give a competitive edge if a manufacturer like Pentax made all their lenses capable of enjoyable manual focussing?
Finally I recently took my Pentax ME Super out for a fiddle and like others I was truly astonished how large and bright the viewfinder looked and how effective the split column focussing screen was at judging focus. By comparison looking through a K3 is like viewing the world in narrowscreen. It can't surely be that hard to match the view provided through a thirty year old budget camera costing £129 then (£301 in todays money) with todays £800 K3 surely?
I'm not that old (45) but even I have to question the way that camera design has evolved in thirty years. Autofocus is wonderful and there's no doubt the K3 takes better pictures than the ME Super did (but much of that is down to me post processing the stuff myself now compared to taking my films to Boots back then) If you put some of my old slides up against my prints today in quality terms that's a lot closer to call.
As some have said are camera designers just packing in the features without thinking about the man-machine interface? I must admit something like the Nijkon DF does hold a great deal of appeal to me and full credit to Nikon for realising that designing something so pure is a flash of genius. There seems to be a real trend (Fuji rangefinders resembling Contax and the Olympus OM-D resembling classic OM's of yesteryear) of going back towards classic design. Is it mere nostalgia or were cameras just designed not to get in the way of taking photographs then?
Views?
Saxon
1. Choice
2. Easier to select half stops etc on a large ring than a small dial
3. Easier to read selected aperture with a quick glance at the lens than a top LCD screen (if even present!) between shots
4. Classic lens design
5. Availability of depth of field markings/scales
6. Ability to slam aperture ring fully open while shooting i.e. to select max aperture just turn all the way, no need to check the indications in the viewfinder or anywhere else. With a whizzwheel you never know where you are because it doesn't have an end stop for fully open and just turns endlessly. You might be at F4 on an F2.8 lens or F3.5 or F4.5 and without checking in the viewfinder or the top LCD display you can't know.
The point some of you made about the lovely large focussing screens and construction quality of the old lenses is a good one. It seems to me that most modern lenses have an awful plastic quality with very poor manual focussing action compared to the lenses of yesteryear. I have't really noticed a huge cut in prices either despite the corners cut in construction and the manufacturing in cheaper locations compared to Japan. If you consider something like a Pentax SMC-M 50mm F1.7 lens which if memory serves in the mid 1980's sold for around £50 then adjusted for inflation http://swanlowpark.co.uk/rpiannual.jsp such a lens made fully of metal and in Japan should cost today £120. The nearest equivalent in the range I can find is the 43mm F1.9 limited and that costs a whopping £499. It's built like a SMC-M series lens and has similar optical quality but despite being made in Vietnam actually costs significantly more in relative terms.
That sort of price escalation makes no sense to me even allowing for niceties like autofocus. Also why oh why do most modern lenses have such a poor manual focussing action? I know in the days of autofocus you don't need it everyday but surely it would give a competitive edge if a manufacturer like Pentax made all their lenses capable of enjoyable manual focussing?
Finally I recently took my Pentax ME Super out for a fiddle and like others I was truly astonished how large and bright the viewfinder looked and how effective the split column focussing screen was at judging focus. By comparison looking through a K3 is like viewing the world in narrowscreen. It can't surely be that hard to match the view provided through a thirty year old budget camera costing £129 then (£301 in todays money) with todays £800 K3 surely?
I'm not that old (45) but even I have to question the way that camera design has evolved in thirty years. Autofocus is wonderful and there's no doubt the K3 takes better pictures than the ME Super did (but much of that is down to me post processing the stuff myself now compared to taking my films to Boots back then) If you put some of my old slides up against my prints today in quality terms that's a lot closer to call.
As some have said are camera designers just packing in the features without thinking about the man-machine interface? I must admit something like the Nijkon DF does hold a great deal of appeal to me and full credit to Nikon for realising that designing something so pure is a flash of genius. There seems to be a real trend (Fuji rangefinders resembling Contax and the Olympus OM-D resembling classic OM's of yesteryear) of going back towards classic design. Is it mere nostalgia or were cameras just designed not to get in the way of taking photographs then?
Views?
Saxon
Posted 29/01/2015 - 02:56
Link
Whilst I do know what you mean Saxon, there is also the business side of things to consider. As I understand it, sales of the DF have not been particularly stellar, mostly because for less you can get a lot more in the equivalent modern DSLR form factor.
I'm reminded also of that tropic thunder movie was it, when the character says never go full mental or something. Nikon actually produced a relative mismatch of old and new controls on that one. I have a personal gripe about being able to engage TAv on my K-30 whilst being set to Manual on the mode dial, by selecting a floating range ISO rather than a fixed value. I believe Nikon did something similar whereby depending on the mode dials, the extra physical dials weren't taken into consideration anymore, and I can see that annoying me and other users. If you're going to commit to a retro product, then go all in I reckon.
I'm big on user interface design, it's a part of my day job to some degree also, and I think it's the opportunity to make tech intuitive and a useful tool, or a chore and something you have to battle with. Where am I going with this? Well I do still think that there is an opening in the market for such a camera and I don't see why Pentax wouldn't be capable of filling it. The questions of will they or should they or would they make any money from it aside, no one else has successfully developed such a retro camera to date in my opinion.
I'm reminded also of that tropic thunder movie was it, when the character says never go full mental or something. Nikon actually produced a relative mismatch of old and new controls on that one. I have a personal gripe about being able to engage TAv on my K-30 whilst being set to Manual on the mode dial, by selecting a floating range ISO rather than a fixed value. I believe Nikon did something similar whereby depending on the mode dials, the extra physical dials weren't taken into consideration anymore, and I can see that annoying me and other users. If you're going to commit to a retro product, then go all in I reckon.
I'm big on user interface design, it's a part of my day job to some degree also, and I think it's the opportunity to make tech intuitive and a useful tool, or a chore and something you have to battle with. Where am I going with this? Well I do still think that there is an opening in the market for such a camera and I don't see why Pentax wouldn't be capable of filling it. The questions of will they or should they or would they make any money from it aside, no one else has successfully developed such a retro camera to date in my opinion.
Posted 29/01/2015 - 03:10
Link
Quote:
no one else has successfully developed such a retro camera to date
Not sure if I'm reading this one correctly?no one else has successfully developed such a retro camera to date
Could it mean incorporating retro camera features into a modern camera?
If so, I have several Leica outfits that fit the bill. Everything from Leica camera bodies such as the Leica Monochrom (sorry I do not wish to purchase the extra vowel) to the Leica MP, to most all of the Leica branded lenses - with a few exceptions. Even the Leica f o.95 still very much uses that front of lens aperture ring
Posted 29/01/2015 - 08:59
Link
The reason I mentioned 1975 above is that everyone seems to be stuck there! 40 years ago I expect you also go on car forums demanding that they bring back 3 speed gearboxes
Pentax moved on about 20 years ago....... so should you It wouldn't be a bad idea if you got to know something about how your camera works instead of making stuff up all the time
The in camera aperture adjustment was a big step forward. It allowed the camera to control the aperture accurately to fractions of a stop. The aperture ring on modern cameras can't tell the camera what it's set on You should have your camera set to 1/3rd stops anyway..... very useful with long lenses to be able to squeeze out a bit more DOF. f/8 f/9 f/10 etc. The camera on auto could set f/8.3 etc.
We are lucky that they have kept the green button, it's actually the most accurate method of metering..... stopped down due to lenses vignetting wide open.
Aperture rings are quite expensive to produce and need a complex cam system to control the aperture.
I actually like old lenses particularly the 'K' Series. The 'A' Series are more useful because I can control them from the camera and see the aperture on the rear LCD screen.
The first lens I ever had without an aperture ring was in the 1980's made by Tamron.... something like 28-90mm.
--
Pentax moved on about 20 years ago....... so should you It wouldn't be a bad idea if you got to know something about how your camera works instead of making stuff up all the time
The in camera aperture adjustment was a big step forward. It allowed the camera to control the aperture accurately to fractions of a stop. The aperture ring on modern cameras can't tell the camera what it's set on You should have your camera set to 1/3rd stops anyway..... very useful with long lenses to be able to squeeze out a bit more DOF. f/8 f/9 f/10 etc. The camera on auto could set f/8.3 etc.
We are lucky that they have kept the green button, it's actually the most accurate method of metering..... stopped down due to lenses vignetting wide open.
Aperture rings are quite expensive to produce and need a complex cam system to control the aperture.
I actually like old lenses particularly the 'K' Series. The 'A' Series are more useful because I can control them from the camera and see the aperture on the rear LCD screen.
The first lens I ever had without an aperture ring was in the 1980's made by Tamron.... something like 28-90mm.
--
Half Man... Half Pentax ... Half Cucumber
Pentax K-1 + K-5 and some other stuff
Algi
Pentax K-1 + K-5 and some other stuff
Algi
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


71 posts
20 years
West Sussex/Hampshire,
UK
Wouldn't it be great if Pentax launched their next camera and lens series with the option to use on lens aperture rings. Sure by all means keep the option of aperture control on body as well and allow the user to choose which overrides the other.
Anyone else feel the same?
Saxon