Weekly competition No. 331 Windows Competition
| Title | Weekly competition No. 331 Windows |
|---|---|
| Judge | davidtrout | Closing Date | 17/11/2013 | Opting Out | If you'd like to enter but not keen on creating and judging the following competition you have the option to opt out. If you're selected as the winning photo simply create a report saying that you'd like Admin to take over and we'll do the rest. |
| Description | |
This week's subject is Windows. We've had the subject previously but not recently and its a wide enough brief to engage many photographers. Keep them interesting. Rules: They must be taken on Pentax cameras or their closely related clones. Deadline midnight next Sunday. The winner: is expected to set the following week's topic, judge the entries and offer helpful comments on each image. David PPG: http://www.pentaxphotogallery.com/artists/davidtroutPG: |
|
Winning Photograph
Competition Entries
Photographs uploaded to the Weekly competition No. 331 Windows competition.
Posted 18/11/2013 - 00:04
Link
Pentax weekly comp 331 WINDOWS
Thank you for entering this week's competition. I've really enjoyed looking at the pictures and as always I'm delighted at the wide variety of style and content you have produced from one simple subject. I would also like to say the result is purely my opinion - we all have different tastes and interests within the hobby of photography and I'm sure you will all have your own opinions on which should be winner and runners up.
The dressmaker's window by Tyronet
I love window shots like this. Hazy impressionist and intriguing images seen dimly through murky glass. There's a little distortion on the window frame and wall, no doubt caused by pointing the camera upwards but it's a lovely photo.
Mann Island by Sandinista
Fascinating image here Jim. I like the graphic treatment, the overall blueness of the picture and the perfect pyramid which comes across mainly due to your composition. The right side of the building has some gorgeous detail in the reflections.
Mrs Windsor by Perspicador
Good attempt at a snatch shot as Elizabeth 11 whizzes by in her limo. In situations like this you can't mess around with details like composition or precise focussing so it's good to see you having a go anyway. I like the impression of The Queen with her matching green hat and coat. Its pity the tree reflections mess up the simplicity of the image.
Restaurant by pipinmels
Some nice images in the reflections and I like the overall warm but not aggressive colours. Taken from your seat you say but I'd be interested to know where your seat was at the time you took it. Did you take a few from slightly different angles? I feel there might have been a better arrangement available for the details in the reflection.
Let the sunshine in by paulb531
Some great urban decay detail in this. It's one of those pictures where the eye just wanders around exploring and discovering little goodies - not one with a strong focal point but one with lots of interest. The graffiti artists have helped. There's a fine triptych within the picture, created by the three different views in the window; graffiti on the top pane, what looks like reflected brickwork in the centre and the daubed walls inside the building. Very enjoyable
Window to the stars by Cardiff Gareth
There aren't many stars in this view Gareth, it looks like a cloudy day outside, but I know what you mean. It's a mono photo but not black and white as there is a hint of wonderfully muted colour in the frames of the dome. Perhaps you were constrained by the position you had to take the picture but the angle makes the shape of the dome look awkward.
Windows by AndrewA
At first I thought it was Whitby, right county but wrong abbey. Good distortion control and fine detail in the stonework make this a fine image. The mono treatment looks a little warm on my monitor, is there a hint of a tint here Andrew? Unfortunately there are a couple of flare spots at the top edge of the picture.
Faux fenetres! by drofmit
Keenly observed this one Tim. Full marks for spotting it and sticking your camera through the gate to snatch it. The picture has a lot of appeal both in the colours and in the texture in the wall. I expect the wall was real? Details like this from beautiful locations elevate mere holiday snaps into serious travel photography.
Room with a view by John Riley
That's unusual getting up the church tower for a view of the town. The dirty windows add to the appeal of this photo, had they been spotlessly clean the effect wouldn't have been so good. The street scene isn't particularly outstanding, it seems just like dozens, if not hundreds, of other town streets right across the country but the angle of view and those dirty windows help to pull this off as an original take on the theme.
Breathing space by Dr Mhuni
Andrew has taken some outstanding street shots of people at the station in Colombo and this is one of them. I really like the contrast between the bright colour of the passengers' clothes and the drab, weather beaten train window surrounds. This is another photo in this competition where the mucky windows add to the appeal. The image is a first class travel photo depicting city life in the East with a touch of humour. Welcome back Andrew, we haven't heard from you recently. I understand you've been relocating.
Stained Glass by Aliengrove
The wonderful vibrant colours of the cathedral window have been captured perfectly. The exposure is spot on, highlights have not been burned out and the detail in all the faces is well rendered. I like the fact that there is just enough light on the surrounding stonework to give the image context.
At the Alhambra by Gary John
The light inside the room is excellent with good detail shown in the wonderful tiles, panelling and section of chair. I particularly like the detail in the two shutters. It's a pity though that the light from the windows is burned out so no detail can be seen through the aperture.
Carriage window by JAK
This is clearly a very old railway carriage in need of some careful restoration, probably Victorian by its appearance. The detail is superbly rendered with even lighting throughout the interior. Pretty good noise control with ISO 3200 recorded on the K-01. However the entire interest in this fascinating photo is centred on the marvellous upholstery inside the carriage. The windows are of minor importance with not much of interest to see through them.
Swan by Gabby
Gabby posted a note to say he entered the wrong picture. Its' a mistake I've made myself on a previous occasion.
Arezzo by Gartmore
This travel photo gives you several clues about the location, both in the view through the window and in the reflections. I could be wrong but there is a Tuscan feel to it. The building on the right and the campanile look the part and inside the shop window the figures and the terracotta pots and ornaments reinforce this. I like exploring scenes like this with my eye and keep discovering fresh detail.
Facets of the Tyne Bridge by andymat
I know this well having photographed around this location many times. You've captured the reflections in the wonderful Sage windows to perfection including the broken images of the Tyne Bridge. I love the late afternoon November light and colour in the sky.
St Peter's Dome by RNVasco
It's a magnificent view very well recorded with the dome perfectly framed. Detail is really sharp and crisp while the colour is spot on. However the windows circling the balcony high up inside the dome are very small in the frame and are incidental to the picture rather than being the main theme.
New Abbey village window
This is an intriguing window and the colourful array of bottles makes a great image. I like the harmony in the various shades and colours of the bottles. Have you tried cropping this tight into the yellow window frame to lose all that bland white wall and the distracting bush?
Storey windows by Darlene
Fantastic collection of stylish windows here Darlene and I've enjoyed looking at the wall decorations in this beautiful building. It's a pity the windows are a bit featureless with no face peering out or some interesting reflections in them.
Framed by Stevephotos
Here's a photographer who's thinking outside the box. You say it isn't a window but official letters have address windows and they are not made of glass either so I reckon this one qualifies. The fingers coming through the aperture and the soft focus, high key face one eye bright, the other in total darkness is one to stir disturbing emotions. Is this a prisoner unfairly jailed and without hope? The viewer can write his own script regardless of what the author intended. Or he can just enjoy the originality of the idea. One more thing; it works so well in black and white. I just can't visualise this in colour.
The eagle in the window by Noelcmn
I'm no bird expert but I reckon this is an eagle owl rather than an eagle. Having got that out of the way let's get on with the picture.
Full marks to Noel for seeing and photographing this. The window in the wall makes a fine frame for this piece of public artwork, enhanced by the detail in the wall, for instance bits of foliage and shadows of leaves. Perhaps exposure in this area could have been toned down a little?
Alnmouth cottage by geordie01
Lovely detail in the stonework of the fine old cottage makes a great frame for this charming window. The pot plants and the blind (view this large to see the detail there). The base area is usefully filled by the large pot plants. Much as I love black and white wouldn't this have been better in colour?
On the outside looking in by Blythman
The depiction of neglect and dereliction in this finely detailed image is powerful. Rust, rotting wood and peeling paint on the outside and furniture that looks long past it's best inside paint a an all too familiar scene in both urban and rural areas. I really like the subdued colours.
Behind the shutters by JK13
Another careworn facade with lots of detail and texture. The green shutters are superb. But the real delight in this photo is the view through the windows with the mannequin forming a terrific focal point. I also like the decrepit lace curtains. John is a brand new member of the forum so this is his first entry. There's no EXIF detail recorded so I'm taking it on trust that it's a Pentax or related camera.
When Irish eyes are smiling by JudithAnn
You don't need to see the whole of this little girl's face to know she is smiling. As the title says, her eyes are smiling in a wonderful way. That makes it an endearing picture. The framing of the old wooden porch makes a good window and an unusual but natural and candid portrait. The overall colour cast is great for the wooden structure but is it a bit too yellow for the rest of the image? I suspect you've attempted a sepia tint but for me the view through the window might have looked better with natural light and colour.
Reflections of Madeira by johnha
The huge windows at the airport look like they should have been ideal for some terrific reflections but the light was not being very helpful to you. The windows are under exposed to a degree that the reflections are barely visible. I like the sky and again this could have been improved with a tweak in post processing.
1: Framed by Stevesphotos
2: Breathing space by Dr Mhuni
3: Behind the shutters by JR13
HCs: Facets of the Tyne Bridge by andymat; Let the sunshine in by Paulb531
PPG: http://www.pentaxphotogallery.com/artists/davidtrout
Thank you for entering this week's competition. I've really enjoyed looking at the pictures and as always I'm delighted at the wide variety of style and content you have produced from one simple subject. I would also like to say the result is purely my opinion - we all have different tastes and interests within the hobby of photography and I'm sure you will all have your own opinions on which should be winner and runners up.
The dressmaker's window by Tyronet
I love window shots like this. Hazy impressionist and intriguing images seen dimly through murky glass. There's a little distortion on the window frame and wall, no doubt caused by pointing the camera upwards but it's a lovely photo.
Mann Island by Sandinista
Fascinating image here Jim. I like the graphic treatment, the overall blueness of the picture and the perfect pyramid which comes across mainly due to your composition. The right side of the building has some gorgeous detail in the reflections.
Mrs Windsor by Perspicador
Good attempt at a snatch shot as Elizabeth 11 whizzes by in her limo. In situations like this you can't mess around with details like composition or precise focussing so it's good to see you having a go anyway. I like the impression of The Queen with her matching green hat and coat. Its pity the tree reflections mess up the simplicity of the image.
Restaurant by pipinmels
Some nice images in the reflections and I like the overall warm but not aggressive colours. Taken from your seat you say but I'd be interested to know where your seat was at the time you took it. Did you take a few from slightly different angles? I feel there might have been a better arrangement available for the details in the reflection.
Let the sunshine in by paulb531
Some great urban decay detail in this. It's one of those pictures where the eye just wanders around exploring and discovering little goodies - not one with a strong focal point but one with lots of interest. The graffiti artists have helped. There's a fine triptych within the picture, created by the three different views in the window; graffiti on the top pane, what looks like reflected brickwork in the centre and the daubed walls inside the building. Very enjoyable
Window to the stars by Cardiff Gareth
There aren't many stars in this view Gareth, it looks like a cloudy day outside, but I know what you mean. It's a mono photo but not black and white as there is a hint of wonderfully muted colour in the frames of the dome. Perhaps you were constrained by the position you had to take the picture but the angle makes the shape of the dome look awkward.
Windows by AndrewA
At first I thought it was Whitby, right county but wrong abbey. Good distortion control and fine detail in the stonework make this a fine image. The mono treatment looks a little warm on my monitor, is there a hint of a tint here Andrew? Unfortunately there are a couple of flare spots at the top edge of the picture.
Faux fenetres! by drofmit
Keenly observed this one Tim. Full marks for spotting it and sticking your camera through the gate to snatch it. The picture has a lot of appeal both in the colours and in the texture in the wall. I expect the wall was real? Details like this from beautiful locations elevate mere holiday snaps into serious travel photography.
Room with a view by John Riley
That's unusual getting up the church tower for a view of the town. The dirty windows add to the appeal of this photo, had they been spotlessly clean the effect wouldn't have been so good. The street scene isn't particularly outstanding, it seems just like dozens, if not hundreds, of other town streets right across the country but the angle of view and those dirty windows help to pull this off as an original take on the theme.
Breathing space by Dr Mhuni
Andrew has taken some outstanding street shots of people at the station in Colombo and this is one of them. I really like the contrast between the bright colour of the passengers' clothes and the drab, weather beaten train window surrounds. This is another photo in this competition where the mucky windows add to the appeal. The image is a first class travel photo depicting city life in the East with a touch of humour. Welcome back Andrew, we haven't heard from you recently. I understand you've been relocating.
Stained Glass by Aliengrove
The wonderful vibrant colours of the cathedral window have been captured perfectly. The exposure is spot on, highlights have not been burned out and the detail in all the faces is well rendered. I like the fact that there is just enough light on the surrounding stonework to give the image context.
At the Alhambra by Gary John
The light inside the room is excellent with good detail shown in the wonderful tiles, panelling and section of chair. I particularly like the detail in the two shutters. It's a pity though that the light from the windows is burned out so no detail can be seen through the aperture.
Carriage window by JAK
This is clearly a very old railway carriage in need of some careful restoration, probably Victorian by its appearance. The detail is superbly rendered with even lighting throughout the interior. Pretty good noise control with ISO 3200 recorded on the K-01. However the entire interest in this fascinating photo is centred on the marvellous upholstery inside the carriage. The windows are of minor importance with not much of interest to see through them.
Swan by Gabby
Gabby posted a note to say he entered the wrong picture. Its' a mistake I've made myself on a previous occasion.
Arezzo by Gartmore
This travel photo gives you several clues about the location, both in the view through the window and in the reflections. I could be wrong but there is a Tuscan feel to it. The building on the right and the campanile look the part and inside the shop window the figures and the terracotta pots and ornaments reinforce this. I like exploring scenes like this with my eye and keep discovering fresh detail.
Facets of the Tyne Bridge by andymat
I know this well having photographed around this location many times. You've captured the reflections in the wonderful Sage windows to perfection including the broken images of the Tyne Bridge. I love the late afternoon November light and colour in the sky.
St Peter's Dome by RNVasco
It's a magnificent view very well recorded with the dome perfectly framed. Detail is really sharp and crisp while the colour is spot on. However the windows circling the balcony high up inside the dome are very small in the frame and are incidental to the picture rather than being the main theme.
New Abbey village window
This is an intriguing window and the colourful array of bottles makes a great image. I like the harmony in the various shades and colours of the bottles. Have you tried cropping this tight into the yellow window frame to lose all that bland white wall and the distracting bush?
Storey windows by Darlene
Fantastic collection of stylish windows here Darlene and I've enjoyed looking at the wall decorations in this beautiful building. It's a pity the windows are a bit featureless with no face peering out or some interesting reflections in them.
Framed by Stevephotos
Here's a photographer who's thinking outside the box. You say it isn't a window but official letters have address windows and they are not made of glass either so I reckon this one qualifies. The fingers coming through the aperture and the soft focus, high key face one eye bright, the other in total darkness is one to stir disturbing emotions. Is this a prisoner unfairly jailed and without hope? The viewer can write his own script regardless of what the author intended. Or he can just enjoy the originality of the idea. One more thing; it works so well in black and white. I just can't visualise this in colour.
The eagle in the window by Noelcmn
I'm no bird expert but I reckon this is an eagle owl rather than an eagle. Having got that out of the way let's get on with the picture.
Full marks to Noel for seeing and photographing this. The window in the wall makes a fine frame for this piece of public artwork, enhanced by the detail in the wall, for instance bits of foliage and shadows of leaves. Perhaps exposure in this area could have been toned down a little?
Alnmouth cottage by geordie01
Lovely detail in the stonework of the fine old cottage makes a great frame for this charming window. The pot plants and the blind (view this large to see the detail there). The base area is usefully filled by the large pot plants. Much as I love black and white wouldn't this have been better in colour?
On the outside looking in by Blythman
The depiction of neglect and dereliction in this finely detailed image is powerful. Rust, rotting wood and peeling paint on the outside and furniture that looks long past it's best inside paint a an all too familiar scene in both urban and rural areas. I really like the subdued colours.
Behind the shutters by JK13
Another careworn facade with lots of detail and texture. The green shutters are superb. But the real delight in this photo is the view through the windows with the mannequin forming a terrific focal point. I also like the decrepit lace curtains. John is a brand new member of the forum so this is his first entry. There's no EXIF detail recorded so I'm taking it on trust that it's a Pentax or related camera.
When Irish eyes are smiling by JudithAnn
You don't need to see the whole of this little girl's face to know she is smiling. As the title says, her eyes are smiling in a wonderful way. That makes it an endearing picture. The framing of the old wooden porch makes a good window and an unusual but natural and candid portrait. The overall colour cast is great for the wooden structure but is it a bit too yellow for the rest of the image? I suspect you've attempted a sepia tint but for me the view through the window might have looked better with natural light and colour.
Reflections of Madeira by johnha
The huge windows at the airport look like they should have been ideal for some terrific reflections but the light was not being very helpful to you. The windows are under exposed to a degree that the reflections are barely visible. I like the sky and again this could have been improved with a tweak in post processing.
1: Framed by Stevesphotos
2: Breathing space by Dr Mhuni
3: Behind the shutters by JR13
HCs: Facets of the Tyne Bridge by andymat; Let the sunshine in by Paulb531
PPG: http://www.pentaxphotogallery.com/artists/davidtrout
Posted 18/11/2013 - 10:23
Link
Good competition with excellent feedback.
Regards
paul
Regards
paul
Posted 18/11/2013 - 14:06
Link
Well done to the winners and thanks to David for the judging and the competition. I know what you mean about the colour version Tracy my partner said the colour image as well.
Posted 18/11/2013 - 23:34
Link
A good competition and thanks for the prompt and excellent judging.
Over to Stevesphotos!
Over to Stevesphotos!
Best regards, John
Posted 19/11/2013 - 14:47
Link
Ooh! Thanks very much.
Thanks David, happily enough you got the point of that picture spot on!
Congratulations to the podium placed as well.
A new competition has been started.
Thanks David, happily enough you got the point of that picture spot on!
Congratulations to the podium placed as well.
A new competition has been started.
All my photos are with 8 year old cameras ...
645D, 35mm, SDM 55mm, FA75mm, FA150mm f/2.8 and K-5, Sigma 17-50mm f/2.8, DA* 50-135mm, Samyang 8mm, other miscellaneous stuff...
645D, 35mm, SDM 55mm, FA75mm, FA150mm f/2.8 and K-5, Sigma 17-50mm f/2.8, DA* 50-135mm, Samyang 8mm, other miscellaneous stuff...
Posted 20/11/2013 - 10:41
Link
Congratulations Stevesphotos, excellent idea and excellent execution. And congrats to Dr Mhuni and JR13 and the other HC's. And as for my confusion about eagles and owls-the grey matter is not what it used to be.
Posted 20/11/2013 - 20:20
Link
Thank you to the judge, and yes David it does seem to have a really yellow cast....not sure about it either....never notice it until you pointed it out...
Congrats to our winner...on into the darkness
Regards:
JA
Congrats to our winner...on into the darkness
Regards:
JA
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


13 years
Devon
gabby