Weekly Competition #344 – Best Picture Competition Competition
| Title | Weekly Competition #344 – Best Picture Competition |
|---|---|
| Judge | bforbes | Closing Date | 16/02/2014 | Opting Out | If you'd like to enter but not keen on creating and judging the following competition you have the option to opt out. If you're selected as the winning photo simply create a report saying that you'd like Admin to take over and we'll do the rest. |
| Description | |
Last week we had a more specialised subject, so this week I thought let’s make it completely open. Do you have an image that you think is a cracker, your best shot, but the right competition subject never comes up. Well here is your chance, enter your “It’s a winner” shot and I’ll do my best to evaluate it against the other “winners” Images should follow the basic rules, that is, Pentax cameras with Samsung DSLRs made by Pentax included and Ricoh GR included. Images can be as new or old as you like. Any questions, see the guidelines in the forum section or ask in the forum thread that I will start. Have fun! |
|
Winning Photograph
Competition Entries
Photographs uploaded to the Weekly Competition #344 – Best Picture Competition competition.
Posted 17/02/2014 - 22:38
Link
Thank you for the fine judging. Yes I agree that line needs some cleaning up. Merging these photos is new...lots of fun in photo shop and other programs that I am playing with.
The winning photo was stunning!!!!
Congrats to all the podium winner! Nice set of photos in this weeks lot.
As Ever:
JA
The winning photo was stunning!!!!
Congrats to all the podium winner! Nice set of photos in this weeks lot.
As Ever:
JA
Posted 18/02/2014 - 00:24
Link
Nice, in-depth comments, you really had your work cut out...
somehow, I thought that the "Feather" would be the winner!!
I'd like it on the wall... about 60 by 80.... inches!
My second choice was "No.7"... but I am biased towards A4s!!
I've only ever seen "The Gresley" the once...
and it had the front end open, spoiling the line!!
Portrait of the right-hand side doesn't work for "Jack Frost's Space Fleet"...
you lose the best-shaped, Starwars spacecraft!!
and, therefore, the whole meaning of the picture...
For a picture entitled "Ice Crystals in Formation", it would probably work...
I'll re-work it that way with another title...
What would be nice is the ability to do what I used to be able to do in the darkroom...
set a shape on the paper-holder and move it around under the enlarger until I had just the elements I wanted...
adjusting the sliders a tad if need be!
You just can't do that in Pottyshop...
you have to redraw the whole area...
no adjustment allowed.
Four solid bars... two vertical, two horizontal...
click, Alt, Shift to nudge a bar up/down and left/right with the arrows...
Ctrl,Shift, Alt to lock all four and then Click/drag to position... it's not much to ask, shurley?
Currently I use four bits of mounting board and some Blu-tac... but the sides of the monitor get awful sticky!!!
And you can't lock them to move the rectangle...
somehow, I thought that the "Feather" would be the winner!!
I'd like it on the wall... about 60 by 80.... inches!
My second choice was "No.7"... but I am biased towards A4s!!
I've only ever seen "The Gresley" the once...
and it had the front end open, spoiling the line!!
Portrait of the right-hand side doesn't work for "Jack Frost's Space Fleet"...
you lose the best-shaped, Starwars spacecraft!!
and, therefore, the whole meaning of the picture...
For a picture entitled "Ice Crystals in Formation", it would probably work...
I'll re-work it that way with another title...
What would be nice is the ability to do what I used to be able to do in the darkroom...
set a shape on the paper-holder and move it around under the enlarger until I had just the elements I wanted...
adjusting the sliders a tad if need be!
You just can't do that in Pottyshop...
you have to redraw the whole area...
no adjustment allowed.
Four solid bars... two vertical, two horizontal...
click, Alt, Shift to nudge a bar up/down and left/right with the arrows...
Ctrl,Shift, Alt to lock all four and then Click/drag to position... it's not much to ask, shurley?
Currently I use four bits of mounting board and some Blu-tac... but the sides of the monitor get awful sticky!!!
And you can't lock them to move the rectangle...
Posted 18/02/2014 - 06:35
Link
Thanks for the thoughtful words, Barrie - and compliments to the front-runners. I concur with your nominated winner - a terrific image.
Posted 18/02/2014 - 07:55
Link
Many thanks Barrie for another great competition. The open subject certainly brought out some fantastic images. I would have worried about the amount of work it could demand but you managed it perfectly. Very well done!
Thanks of course for my HC .
Congratulations to Noelcmn for the beautiful, well deserved, winning image, the runners up and everyone else for a wonderful collection of pictures.
Glyn
Thanks of course for my HC .
Congratulations to Noelcmn for the beautiful, well deserved, winning image, the runners up and everyone else for a wonderful collection of pictures.
Glyn
Posted 18/02/2014 - 08:46
Link
What a cracking winner congrats to all who entered and thanks Barrie for the coveted 2nd place and the judging.
Posted 18/02/2014 - 12:06
Link
Oh Boy! I'm a bit floored at the moment, certainly did not expect this win, amid such a stunning collection in this Comp. Thank you Barrie for the nod. Congratulations to me fellow podium places and the HM's. Thanks too, Barrie for the detailed comments-as always these are constructive and appreciated! Now to come up with something. My day is already so hectic, but I should have something up later today!
Posted 18/02/2014 - 14:33
Link
Well done Noelcm, great winning shots! Congrats too to the other podiums and HC's.
As you said, Barrie, my entry probably doesn't work at the size the forum allows, it looks a lot better full-size. In retrospect i should probably have entered a different shot. Great judging.
As you said, Barrie, my entry probably doesn't work at the size the forum allows, it looks a lot better full-size. In retrospect i should probably have entered a different shot. Great judging.
Posted 18/02/2014 - 18:04
Link
Well done Noel
great simplicity usually wins right?
Well done to all the others
QC
great simplicity usually wins right?
Well done to all the others
QC
Learn how to live and you'll know how to die; learn how to die, and you'll know how to live.
Check out ones photographs on Flickr!
https://www.flickr.com/photos/awprentice/
Check out ones photographs on Flickr!
https://www.flickr.com/photos/awprentice/
Posted 18/02/2014 - 19:53
Link
Well done to Noel, beautiful image and to the other podiums and mentions. Thanks to Barrie for a great comp and judging.
Jim.
Jim.
Posted 18/02/2014 - 23:14
Link
Congratulations Noel, great image! Also thanks to Barrie for an excellent competition theme which really brought out the best - some very strong entries in this one!
Regards
David
Regards
David
Posted 19/02/2014 - 14:03
Link
Well done to Noel, it is indeed a great shot, I like these kind of 'simple' images.
Thanks to Barrie for setting the comp. and for your interesting comments on my photo (and the third place!) It is in fact an HDR image (but very subtle) from three shots.
They are ficticious traditional costumes at an art exhibition in Newtown, Wales.
They were actually quite unnerving and slightly scary as you walk into the room and see them! The large one is about 7ft tall and the others about 5ft
Thanks to Barrie for setting the comp. and for your interesting comments on my photo (and the third place!) It is in fact an HDR image (but very subtle) from three shots.
They are ficticious traditional costumes at an art exhibition in Newtown, Wales.
They were actually quite unnerving and slightly scary as you walk into the room and see them! The large one is about 7ft tall and the others about 5ft
Regards,
Michael
Michael
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


6913 posts
18 years
Co. Durham UK
It’s been fun looking through such a diverse set of images so thank you all for entering. With such diversity maybe I should reiterate what a number of judges point out, that is this is a very personal perspective on your work and that the comments are meant to be constructive. So on we go……
Alien Beauty – johnriley
A striking image which reveals more detail and colours as you examine its multi level composition. I did feel the crop was a little too tight, shaving off the top of the mask.
Alium – coker
Another image with an almost monochrome look, but this one is subdued and delicate. Great focus and depth of field allow you into the centre of the flower. I think it may need an extra bit of PP in the top right corner to disguise the white triangle.
Red Kite watching me – Daroni
I’ve tried to take pictures of Red Kite, not easy. It’s a powerful composition with the frame well filled and in focus. It’s difficult to get the exposure correct in this situation, so I would go for PP to bring out the detail in shadow under the wings.
Trontastic – QuestionableCarrot
A really abstract image with those natural lead lines. Even down to having the brightest light in the right spot to draw you in. One for the art galley wall
Non-Sum-Qualis-Eram – michaelblue
Very unusual, when I first looked it was a precession with people. The next time it was multiple colour pops. The one after there was one head above the rest. I wanted the image to be bigger on my screen so that I could delve further into it.
Sundance – Perspicador
Two birds with the shot well timed to freeze them in flight, never easy. I know you can’t always plan the background, but here I find it distracting, for three reasons. 1. in focus, 2. Highlights, 3. Does not isolate the subject.
BEACH HUTS IN THE SNOW – geordie01
I can’t work this one out. Normally your eye is drawn to the lighter parts of an image but here I go straight to the dark couple and the brolly. Unless it’s that pure white triangle. Anyway it works and produces a very pleasing B&W image, especially in the letter box format. I can’t remember the original, but know the huts have colour.
Changi Roof. – Jim-w
Some nice strong shapes combine well with the muted colours and diffused lighting. Have you tried turning the image 90 degrees Anti clockwise?
Antique roadshow – simonarron
What pleases me is the pin sharp car and driver with the blurred wheels and background. Super panning. Probably the sepia tones go with the era (no pun intended), shame about the helmet
A new start to the day – bigsturgeon
I’m heading for Tofino later this year and hope I catch such a wonderful scene as this. As well as the gorgeous colour I like the dark band at the top just holding you in the image. Would a smaller aperture give more definition to the land silhouette?
Early Morning Daises – GlynM
Great lighting here, bringing the flowers out of the background. This is helped by the depth of field diffusing the background, but at the same time retaining focus across most of the flowers, so you even see the Fibonacci pattern in the seed head.
Doha from the air at night. – aliengrove
I find this one difficult to judge because of the small size it’s represented at on my monitor. I’m sure, as a full screen image more of the detail and obvious colour would stand out. You have already gone for the letter box format but I wonder if reducing the very dark top and bottom would help enlarge the feel of the centre.
Northern Lights – paulb531
I would love the chance to have a go at photographing the Northern Lights. I think they are one of those phenomena you would forgive any technical short comings just to have one photo in the bag.
Anyone fancy a Pentax meet in Iceland, you seem to get good shots from there.
tree city – ken2390
I like the idea and you have done well to spot the opportunity. You must have been close as I can make out the “power lines” crossing the city. You say you are new to DSLR’s; did you take this shot hand held? if so it could account for the blur. Maybe better using a tripod and the timer when working so close with macro.
Best Night Shot – tomw
Again with light trails you have a natural lead into the image and here you have the faint glow on the horizon as a sort of focal point. Also in this image there has been enough light over the time of the exposure to put detail into the road and sky leaving a less abstract feel. Just as an aside, are the blue lights from one of the emergency services?
Into the Light – jimcousins
An unusual wildlife shot, the feather detail and face colour are outstanding, particularly against the dark background. Was it not possible to get a little more light onto the eyes, which I think would just and that extra spark?
Boris bikes – billy
I’m a sucker myself for having a go at this type of repetition shot. Well done if you went down and synchronised the pedal positions! Depth of field as well controlled as is the exposure And I like the way the light blue stands out. I seen a similar image where one bike was a different colour and it just added another element.
Feather – Noelcmn
Gorgeous colours, brilliant simple composition, lovely detail in the feather and reflection. One to be proud of
Kiess Harbour – Caithness60
A good composition and the exposure you have used is enough to freeze the drama of the breaking wave and impart some nice colour and detail into the building. The draw back is it has given a very bright highlight in the sky, drawing the eye away from the interesting main subject.
The old hedgerow - DoctorJeff
A worthy subject, with interesting forms in the trio of trees and a good sky. I’m not a black and white expert but I find this a bit too monochrome grey, in that it’s hard to define the ground, the hedge and the hills.
Number 7 – pauljay
This one really tells the story. Great detail in the engine gives way to the smoky haze of the destination passing the driver whiling away the time, waiting for his turn. A very well processed HDR.
Natural – aadixon
On both of my monitors the front wrist and the neck look to be blown out. However there is detail in the forearm and chin. To improve a good portrait shot I would look at PP to remove the halo round the head, the door knob and the white mark on the left. This may be a personal thing but I find the eyes un-natural
A Helping Hand – davidstorm
A good candid shot even in black and white the subject stands out from the background. The detail in the jacket, face and equipment is great. While there is enough detail left in the background to put Paul in context. Cold, wet, windswept and wishing he was somewhere else.
Jack Frost's Space Fleet – drofmit
Shows up the delicate nature of the crystals well, and I think you have tried to have the light showing then off to the best advantage. To that end I wonder if a portrait version of the right hand side would work.
My Little mermaid! – JudithAnn
I have no idea where you would start to produce something like this but I think it’s a real fun picture.
Your point of focus takes you straight to that beaming smile. The only thing I would suggest would be to try and brush out a feint brown line just in front of your granddaughter’s feet.
The Results
The HC’s
Trontastic – QuestionableCarrot
Number 7 – pauljay
Early Morning Daises – GlynM
Third place - Non-Sum-Qualis-Eram – michaelblue
Second place - BEACH HUTS IN THE SNOW – geordie01
The Winner - Feather – Noelcmn