Weekly Competition #167 - Adults at Work or Play Competition

Title Weekly Competition #167 - Adults at Work or Play
Judge mudge
Closing Date 26/09/2010
Opting Out If you'd like to enter but not keen on creating and judging the following competition you have the option to opt out. If you're selected as the winning photo simply create a report saying that you'd like Admin to take over and we'll do the rest.
Description
I will be looking for candid unposed shots, showing the movement and vitality of people at work or play (including sporting activities) It may be of an individual or a group
Whilst the subject(s)may be fully aware of the camera, the image should not be a simple portrait type shot. There needs to be an element of action or activity involved

Winning Photograph


Competition Entries

Photographs uploaded to the Weekly Competition #167 - Adults at Work or Play competition.

bforbes
Posted 27/09/2010 - 00:38 Link
Congratulations David, you are having a busy time at the moment. Thanks mudge for an interesting competition. Will you be able to post fuller judging later?
Edited by bforbes: 27/09/2010 - 00:42
thoughton
Posted 27/09/2010 - 01:35 Link
Mudge has posted his judging under davidtrout's winning photo: http://www.pentaxuser.co.uk/photo/comp-165/the-janitor-21150
Tim
AF - Pentax K5, Sigma 10-20/4-5.6, Tamron 17-50/2.8, Sigma 30/1.4, Sigma 70-200/2.8, Tamron 70-300/4-5.6
MF - Vivitar CF 28/2.8, Tamron AD2 90/2.5, MTO 1000/11
Stuff - Metz 58 AF1, Cactus v4, Nikon SB24, Raynox 150, Sigma 1.4x TC, Sigma 2x TC, Kenko 2x macro TC, Redsnapper 283 tripod, iMac 27”, Macbook Pro 17”, iPad, iPhone 3G
Flickr • Fluidr • PPG • Street • Portfolio site
Feel free to edit any of my posted photos! If I post a photo for critique, I want brutal honesty. If you don't like it, please say so and tell me why!
Dr. Mhuni
Posted 27/09/2010 - 05:16 Link
Many thanks for the detailed judging Mudge, and congrats to David and the other winners.

Perhaps a mod can move the comments here (they're not short at all - no need to apologise, Mudge).
Mhuni

500px
sandy
Posted 27/09/2010 - 07:12 Link
Thanks Mudge for your judging and comments and congratulations David on a great image.

Sandy
AxelLuther
Posted 27/09/2010 - 07:43 Link
Hi Mudge - thanks for your proposals to improve my picture - what an irony - actually the origanl shot is very much as you described with the two man far more in the center and less background. But then I remembered that people often don't like images with a centered object (I am not always a fan of this proportius devinius methodology but many seem to be) - hence I added more background to it and put the two out of the center. It seems, this was a mistake - so next time I follow your proposal and rely more on my original shot.
_____________________________________________

Colors are the lack of darkness

You find more of my pictures here: https://pentaxphotogallery.com/artists/axelluther or on my web page: www.axel-luther.com
davidtrout
Posted 27/09/2010 - 08:03 Link
Thanks for the 1st place Mudge, it came as a surprise. You did an excellent job on judging your first weekly competition. My congratulations to the other winners, particularly 2nd placed Alun and 3rd place Barrie Forbes who was with me on a Durham Photographic Society shoot in Middlesborough on Saturday when I took my shot.
I agree with you Mudge, my picture was a tad over saturated, I just thought the subject could take it.
David
Edited by davidtrout: 27/09/2010 - 08:06
JudithAnn
Posted 27/09/2010 - 08:39 Link
A very special thank you to the judge and the fine job that was done!
Congrats to all the winner, especially David...I love his work!!
Thank you to Mudge for my HC.... I loved(my favorite) Arsen picture and am proud to be beside him: that was so nice! I was delighted you like that shot....I will take your advice and crop it a tad mor on the fore-front.

So we all wait for David BIG IDEA!!

Regards Judithann

PS...Ya Mudge, one seems to win during busy weeks....I had to help family members through a death: I too was glad that I did it day by day instead of all at the end. You did a terrific job!!

Best wishes to your daughter on her BIG day!!
Edited by JudithAnn: 27/09/2010 - 08:58
bforbes
Posted 27/09/2010 - 08:57 Link
First mudge let me apologise, I had not seen you very full judging when I posted my original comment. As David said " You did an excellent job on judging your first weekly competition.". Then let me thank you for the third place, very unexpected.
i-Berg
Posted 27/09/2010 - 10:23 Link
Congratulations David, Alun and Barrie and all the 'mentions' - 'nice work' to Mudge too.
Bill_And
Posted 27/09/2010 - 11:00 Link
congrats David
TOZZA27
Posted 27/09/2010 - 13:02 Link
Hi mudge - interesting competition and a varied entry.
Well done David and the other contenders.

I had a look at the EXIF - probably something to do with the fact that the original shot of 9.5mb would not upload ( although bigger ones have done before )and I was advised to bring the size down in a photoedit and presumably all the details got jumbled there.I always append the most important stuff anyway ( belt & braces ? ).

Regards

Tony
K20D,*istD ( now a dedicated M42 digital ),K100D,MZ5N,P50,ME Super,Spotmatic 1000,Spotmatic,ESII,ES,H2.18-55 II,18-55,75-300 FAJ,35-80 FA,80-200 F,28-105 FA,Sigma 24-70 AF Aspherical,Sigma 28-300 Hyperzoom , Praotor II 500 M42,Centon 500mm mirror,and a few Pentax M42 Taks,super-Taks,smc Taks,A and M lenses.Benbo trekker,7dayshop monopod and a Lowepro rucksack.

I am now on Flickr which is nice !
alun
Posted 27/09/2010 - 16:18 Link
Thanks Mudge, and well done David.
puma
Posted 27/09/2010 - 22:14 Link
Congratulations David,and fine job judge

Just to let you know mudge ( Rick ) is the man in the photo and he is an engineer in his workshop it’s some heavy metal plat that he was fixing to put back on a vehicle it was one of them moments taken the shot or miss it
PPG link
Edited by puma: 27/09/2010 - 22:22
johnriley
Posted 01/10/2010 - 14:57 Link
Judges comments re-sited to correct place!
Thank you all for taking the time and effort to enter this “fun” competition. The overall high standard of entry, coupled with the wide variation of subject matter, made it a difficult, but never the less a pleasant task to judge.
I’m sorry if I’ve not given such comprehensive critiques as JudithAnn did last week, but I have my daughter’s wedding next Saturday and as you can imagine there’s not been sufficient hours in the day of late. However, I would like to thank JudithAnn for suggesting to me that I write up critiques in “MS Word” as the images are received, and then copy them into the Competition Page at the end of the week, rather than leave it and try to do it all after the closing date. I took this advice and it worked really well, enabling me to spend more time on each image than I had expected to be able to do at the outset.

So, after much deliberation I am please to announce the following results:-

Winners

Ist Place: The janitor: by davidtrout

2nd Place: Traditional farming: by alun)

3rd Place: Work or Play?: by bforbs

Very Highly Commended: Sports beauty: by ArsenAl
Shooting the Shooter: by JudithAnn
Kayaking: by sandy

Commended: Palestinian/Arab artisan: by malcolm leader
Birdman: by aliengrove
Rick:bypuma
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Critiques:-

The Stare: by Bill_And
Congratulations on posting the first image! I like it very much, as a candid portrait type shot. As you say he doesn’t look that pleased about your camera pointing at him, does he? I particularly like the use of differential focusing which makes the main subject stand out from the crowd. The colours appear to be spot on.
My only reservation is that I think it just misses the brief of “Work or Play”, as I don’t think it’s work he’s doing and it’s certainly not play. Had the competition topic been “Candid Portraits” it would have been up there with the winners.

Sports beauty: by ArsenAl
A powerful sports shot that really captures the action! The colour, body detail and facial expression are all fabulous. A really well handled shot
The only thing that lets it down, as far as I am concerned, is that unavoidable white out-of-focus bar in the foreground, which is distracting and which obscures the trailing leg.
I think the image of the actual athlete is so powerful that you could crop off the bottom of the image, up to the top of that distracting bar, and then actually make the athlete larger in the frame.

(French) Men at Work: by AxelLuther
Another powerful image, with plenty of muscle on view.. A small aperture has been used to throw the background out of focus, which really puts the emphasis on the two figures. I like the cigarette dangling out of his mouth (even though I’m a non-smoker) and the improvised sunhood around the neck
I found the large expanse of white on the left hand side a little distracting (It spans across about 1/3 of the width of the image). For the purpose of this competition, I would have cropped half of it off, as well as a little bit off the top (as there is nothing of real interest in the background sky), and then make the figures larger in the frame. (lets see those muscles better!)

On patrol: by thoughton
A pleasant seaside scene, with nice pastel colouring. Sharp throughout. But I think there are too many elements vying for attention. There’s the attractive sky, the interesting pier, the foreground seashore, the chalets with their shadows on the walkway, and the colourfully dressed figure which adds human interest. Any of these elements would have made a good image in their own right.
The figure is actually the focal point of the image, which draws the eye because of the strong clothing colours, but unfortunately he seems incidental to the general scene.
When deciding upon this week’s Competition Subject I nearly chose “Primary Colours” (ie Red, Yellow and Blue) This image would have been a perfect contender if I had!


Holiday reading: by Dr. Mhuni
Another pleasant beach scene with the subjects relaxing under a very colourful sunshade, totally absorbed in their books. (Wish I was there!)
The use of a small aperture has thrown most of the background out of focus, which is great. However for competition purposes I find the part sunshade, in the top left hand corner, which is not out of focus, spoils the line of the main brolly and is distracting. I would definitely clone it out.
I might also be tempted to clone out the other background distractions (ie figure and white cars), even though they are not so distracting as the part brolly! But I know that’s being a little picky!
Unfortunately, pleasing as it is, it does lack the element of action, which is what I’m looking for.

At Work on a Play: by Couldridge
I like the play on words for the Title. Well thought up!
A splendid candid shot, which conveys the in-depth discussion taking place between the two actors. I like the concentration shown on both faces and the hand gesture that emphasises the point being made. The figures / costumes show up well, and stand out against the muted background colour
However, the plastic glasses spoil the overall effect for me. Could they be cloned out ?
I’m not quite sure what to think about the girl in the bottom left hand corner. On one hand she’s a part of the event, and has a place in the image, on the other hand I find her a little distracting.

Crab for supper: by tiger308
A well caught shot that isolates the fisherman who is starting to prepare a crab. Sufficient details have been left in the image to show he’s still on his fishing boat. The crab pot, with crabs still in it, was a particularly interesting feature to include.
The image is colourful and sharp throughout.

Palestinian/Arab at work: by malcolm leader
This image made a good initial impact. It’s well exposed, particularly as it looks to be an indoor shot, and the composition is spot on, with the dominant head/yellow headscarf positioned on the intersection of the thirds.
The subject is concentrating on his work, and seems to be enjoying it, but I suspect that the grin is because he’s aware of being photographed!
It would have been nice to know what he was making. Perhaps a hint in the title?

Directing: by thehawkerman
Monochrome works well with this image. The use of 18mm focal length, and some cropping, enabled the construction of a panoramic type image, allowing the figure on the right to be incorporated. Whilst he adds little to the image in his own right, (as he’s looking at the ground, having lost interest in whatever they’re filming), he does provide the answer to what the figure in the centre is looking at. So his inclusion was a good idea! I’ve tried enlarging the image to see what is written on the man’s shirt, but it’s out of focus. I’m sure there’s a story to tell here, but unfortunately

Birdman: by aliengrove
A powerful image, taken under difficult conditions. There’s some distortion, due to the use of a 10mm focal length, but this actually adds an interesting effect to the image, as well, as giving a good wide angled insight into the man’s working environment. The image is full of interest, but with the figure dominating the scene.
I notice a slight colour cast, caused by the type of artificial lighting (see: white on bird’s head and off colour yellow on the banner) A slight twitch of about +3 to 5 of the Hue, on the Hue/Saturation control, greatly reduces this cast

Rick:by puma
I quite like this atmospheric image, even though there’s slight exposure problems (eg hair burnout etc) This is another shot that works well in monochrome and that’s been taken under extremely difficult conditions. Actually, I’m not quite sure what’s going on, and the title “rick” doesn’t give me any clues.
However, it contains plenty of action, and has a dynamic feel with the arm/hand movement and rising steam/smoke (?) I wonder what the object in the vice is?

Sandman: by DrOrloff
An interesting and well captured sand sculpture. Unfortunately, it’s slightly under-exposed. This is most probably due to the brightness of the sand fooling the exposure meter (similar to the underexposing of snow scenes) This could easily be rectified in PS though. The actual figure is greatly underexposed (due to the use of “centre weighted average” exposure – ref. Exif data). It would have liked to have seen more of the “sandman’s” face as well.

Studio Adventure: by johnriley
I assume that this is a professional model at work, rather than an amateur one at play, not that it matters which! It has good content, and everyone seems to be enjoying themselves.
I find the glaring spotlight very distracting, and the eye is continually drawn to it. I assume the author actually wanted to include it, to demonstrate the studio set-up, but this has resulted in under-exposing the rest of the image, particularly the figures. For this competition it would have been better had the camera been further to the left, with the model positioned between it and the spotlight, thereby getting rid of the glare and getting better overall exposure.
As it is, the figures could have been selected and their exposures adjusted in PS, prior to posting. There is also scope for cropping, depending upon what the author wanted from the image

Shooting the Shooter: by JudithAnn
Wow!!! What a great shot! It’s been well seen and captured. Vivid colours. I just love the posing puffin!
Perhaps a little cropping off the bottom, to remove most of the out of focus foreground, would make a slight improvement to what is an already fabulous image..

Taking core samples: by prieni
A striking Photo Journalism type shot, taken from above. The 10mm focal length used gives an interesting fisheye effect, but I thought the half body on the rhs was distracting and spoilt the overall image (for competition purposes)
I think the image actually looks better as a vertical format, as the two peripheral figures look more realistic standing upright!



Kayaking: by sandy
Plenty of action here! The canoeist (if that’s what you call him) is generally sharp, and the bit of blurring there is, on the hands and paddle blades, is great, as it adds to the feeling of action. It’s also good to be able to see the face so clearly. It gets you asking “Is he looking where he’s been, or where he’s going?” You can almost feel the power of the water!

Early 1900: by Darlene
A very competent indoor record type shot, that’s both well composed and exposed.
Pity you didn’t take it when the water was actually pouring from the jug into the glass, which would have make the image look a little less static

Work or Play: by bforbes
Another images which works well in monochrome. The concentration on the engine driver’s face has been well caught.
Exposure of the figure is spot on, with really black blacks and white whites, without losing detail. The image is also very sharp where it needs to be, and the figure is positioned in a strong position on the left hand 1/3rd
A very competent and pleasing image

We’re going to win the cup !!: by TOZZA27
Oh no we’re not!!!!!!
A great fun shot, with vibrant colours that have initial impact. The young lady’s expression has been well captured, and conveys the feeling of happiness. I like it a lot, but unfortunately the composition lets it down
I think the figure is too central, particularly as she is looking at something else to the left and not at the camera. The composition could be improved by some serious cropping (eg crop off ½ the sky above the tower, as it doesn’t contain any detail that adds to the image; crop off the base, to just above the shadow; and crop off the rh side, to the right of the little girl entering the water). This would result in a tighter image with the main figure more dominant in the frame, thus making an even greater impact, and, as a bonus, it would not be so central.
By the way, the Exif data for the image is very weird!!!! I wonder why?

An old stager remembers: by chelseablue
A well exposed competent Photo Journalism type shot. It’s nice and sharp throughout and has strong colours. However, due to the situation it looks a bit cluttered, and it lacks third party interest.

Traditional farming: by alun
Another one which works well in monochrome. The low camera angle and flying bits of straw makes it a very powerful image, and there are good blacks and whites without loss of detail. A very pleasing image. The composition is also spot on!

Bit on the big side: by flyingpics
A good well exposed record shot of a street artist. Sharp throughout. The monochrome treatment with colour popping of the lips adds another interesting dimension to the image, and most probably gives a slightly better end effect than a completely coloured or monochrome version would

worker’s tribute: by dougf8
Whilst it fits the brief, it’s a bit cluttered and lacks interest / punch. The figure is slightly under exposed, but I like the way he’s sharp, and on the plane of focus, but with the foreground and background out of focus.
If you actually know the barman then it would serve as a very good record of him in his working environment.


The Street Band Arrives: by mecrox
A great shot of this larger than life character. The skin tone / colour and the overall exposure is excellent. Pity the raised arm obliterates the back figure’s face, but that can’t be helped. It actually adds to the action, and was therefore well worth capturing.
The only change I would be tempted to make is to clone out the yellow rattle (or whatever instrument it is) and the hand holding it, as it is very dominant and eye catching. Purist might say that was part of the event record, and should therefore be left in. But as it is a competition I think it would be better out

The janitor: by davidtrout
Just when you think it’s all over, and the die is cast, along comes this!!! The Wow factor!!! Back to the drawing board for me! What a cracking image!! Well seen and caught!
It’s full of interesting shapes and lines, which blend together perfectly. It’s also sharp, perfectly exposed, and colourful with vivid red and blue against nice pastel coloured background. (Maybe a tad over-saturated, on the red and blue fronts, but I can live with that!)
Some photographers might ask, “Would it have been better if the figure had been walking into the frame rather than out of it?” I think, probably not, as this image gives the feel of a job well done!

Photographing the Photographer: by Steve Chasey
An interesting candid portrait, with good colour and skin tones. The photographer’s expression has been well caught. It looks as if a flash was used, by the harsh shadows around the body and head, the latter which merges into his black hair spoiling the head line. It would have been a better composition if the space behind the figure was in front of it giving some space in front of the camera lens.

The Pentax’s staff in the Fair: by Jyrkira
A very competent indoor shot, with plenty of interest and colour. The salesmen are at work and the visitors are at play! So it fits the brief very well.

Racer: by Lowela
A well composed colourful shot, with plenty of initial impact. However it’s not in focus. Had it been linear speed blur it would have been acceptable, but I think this is just a depth of field problem

Feeding the sheep: by drofmit
A nice moody shot, with morning mist, which I really like. Whilst the topic of work is addressed, I think the figure is too small to warrant being in the top selection. As it stands, I think a large top crop down to just above the top of the middle tree would improve the composition, as all the real interest is at the bottom of the image
Best regards, John

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo