Monthly Competition #25 - The Human Zoo Competition

Title Monthly Competition #25 - The Human Zoo
Judge Hullman
Closing Date 31/07/2014
Opting Out If you'd like to enter but not keen on creating and judging the following competition you have the option to opt out. If you're selected as the winning photo simply create a report saying that you'd like Admin to take over and we'll do the rest.
Description
For this month’s competiton I’d like to see images that depict human nature / human behaviour. The sort of thing I have in mind are photographs that tell a story, where the viewer can draw his or her own conclusions about what’s happening in the scene, images that encourage you to pause and think. What the people depicted are doing, what they’re thinking, the emotions on display.

The technicalities of the photography (exposure, lighting, composition) whilst not ignored are not the primary focus for me, it’s all about the story the picture tells. The only rule is there must be a person or people in the photograph, apart from that use your imagination. I don’t want predicate a particular genre of photography so the images can be posed, portraits, candids, or street photos just as long as they depict the most fascinating creatures of all, us.

The usual forum rules apply - Only images shot with Pentax equipment or Samsung clones with the winner setting and judging the next months competition. Full details here Rules

Good luck, I hope you find the topic interesting...

Andy

Winning Photograph


Competition Entries

Photographs uploaded to the Monthly Competition #25 - The Human Zoo competition.

Hullman
Posted 01/08/2014 - 08:33 Link
Thank you to everyone who entered their work here. It’s a very diverse set of images with different styles and interpretations of a theme. Just what I was hoping for. This is the first time I’ve judged any sort of competition so go easy on me please. Of course, the results reflect my personal tastes and how I interpret the theme. I wanted to try to be fair but honest and I hope that hasn’t offended anyone, it’s certainly not my intention..


Forelorn - cvhennessy
Well this chap certainly looks like he has the weight of the world on his shoulders. I can almost imagine that he’s just been told that his girlfriend has left him, or that he’s just lost the biggest deal of his career. I think you did well to spot this opportunity and the lighting on his face is great, and with so much of the rest of the image in darkness it really does concentrate the eye on his woeful expression. Small points, but perhaps I would have tried to bring a little more detail into the totally black areas and also remove the highlight on the pole behind his head. Great shot.

Yes! it's 50% off - tyronet2000
This certainly made me giggle, I can just imagine these two ladies walking along chatting and the lady in the pick dress looking over to see why her friend had ignored her last comment, only to find her attention distracted by something FAR more important… It’s very well spotted and you reacted quickly to get this image so well done. Personally, I would have cropped this quite heavily and only included the bottom right hand quarter, thats where the story is and all of the interest. Everything else, and especially the bull, distract and are not part of the story…

The collapse - velimir
I can really see the pain on this guys face, he’s given his all to the race. It’s real emotion and no hiding from that. The B&W conversation works well but I wonder if a tighter crop might work a little better as you wouldn’t loose the context of the running track. But I really like this, the emotion on this chaps face just hots you.

The Three Mac-a-teers - JudithAnn
Ha, I can really relate to this photograph. I have an 11 year old son and given half a chance he’d be in there with these three. Lovely family portrait, great expressions and good posing. Isn’t nice to see boys being boys rather than glued to smartphones and computer games. Love the title too. The over exposed sky and background is a little distracting though, and I wonder if you that could be brought back a little in post processing. A real feel good picture, can’t help but smile when seeing it.

Resting in the shade - coker
My first re-action to this image was ‘Crop the top half of the picture off’ but the more I look at it I think perhaps that would the wrong decision. Yes your eye moves between the guy resting and the big sign which is competing for attention but.. One can’t help relating the two in your mind and thinking actually, this guy needs a bit of “restoration” and the vest he’s wearing might be considered “historic”. the white socks and black shoes also remind me of my home town, Hull lol. Nice image, well spotted and nice B&W conversation. Oddly the text on the mud flap is probably more distracting than anything else, its on the wrong side for me.

Primate Instincts - paulb531
I like this shot a lot, it defiantly tells the story and shows the lengths people go to to get a good view. I makes you wonder why someone would think it’s a good idea! Mind you, if I was capable of climbing a lamp post then perhaps I’d think differently. Shame he didn’t have a K3 with him, would have got some interesting shots The inclusion of the crowd, houses and countryside beyond really give it context.. Fits the theme perfectly.. Love it.

reflection - bettyswolloks
Reflections always make for interesting shots so well done for seeing this and taking the shot.. There seems to be no end of people hunched over their phones these days and I think this lady with her pronounced huch in her back really emphasises that point. The strong diagonal is a good compositional element but again I think that a tighter crop would have been more successful. The left hand side of the picture does’t really add anything to the story.

Travelling Zoo - johnriley
This really is a very literal translation of the theme, and it certainly brought a smile to my face wondering who’s watching who here. The fact that you can’t actually see what they’re looking at just strengthens the intrigue. We’ve all done it before but it really makes you wonder why one would pack themselves into such a “box”. I like the fact that the carriage is smack bang in the middle of the frame, and that the line where the window starts dissects the image on the horizontal, the whole symmetry of the image reflects the symmetry of the who’s watching who story.. If I had to be very picky, I wonder if the red reflectors draw you attention just a little and I can’t help feeling I want to see the faces of the two people behind the posts. Great shot.

Adoration - ken2390
I think my Mum would be very jealous of this shot, she's a big Des fan! I wonder what the story is here, who’s giving who the the little gift?. You've captured a nice smile on Des’s face and your partner looks very pleased to be shot with the “love of her life”. I know its difficult when there are heads other people in the shot but I think maybe the crop is a little to tight here and a looks as though the exposure could be pushed a little. Great shot for the family album..

Streets of Mongkok - aliengrove
As soon as I saw this picture pop up in the competition I knew it was going to be one of my favourites. For me it works on so many levels. Compositionally you have the three groups of people forming a triangle for the eye to wonder around, the street running away on the diagonal encourages you to dive into the picture and explore it and it’s inhabitants. First there is the well dressed guy in the middle, he looks out of place and encourages thoughts of some secret agency. Is he receiving some important information on his smartphone? The phone magazine and cigarette all point to and lead you to the second guy with the umbrella. What’s his story, he has a sort of “english gent’ style about him with his brolly, but what’s he looking at? Is he looking at the girls bottom, or is something else happening?? His gaze then leads you to the couple at the window. Are they together? what are they buying? Is it something dodgy? The more I look at this picture the more I make up stories about the scene which is exactly what I was looking for. Fantastic B&W conversation also. Brilliant picture.

Looking into her future - dinneenp
I think most of us would have walked past this photographic opportunity. Two seemingly unrelated subjects which would be boring on their own, but shoot them together as well as this and you get a whole different story. Both the young girl and the couple are well placed in the frame because of the skill of the photographer you wonder if the girl is watching the couple and why? Is is as the title suggests, perhaps she’s musing over her future and wondering if she’ll be on this beach in her twilight years. I like the horizontal divisions caused by sand, sea and sky and it helps that the girl traverses one of the boundaries to allow you eye to explore both. If I had to pick small faults, I’d say it was shame about the cloud just leaving the frame, because it’s on its own it takes your eye out of the picture. But I really like this it, a landscape with people

Buying frenzy at Tynemouth - geordie01
Well there is certainly a lot going on in this picture, and it fits the theme of the human zoo with a very clear depiction of a feeding frenzy (also know as bargain hunting). It’s nice to get a view from behind the stall as most people would probably shoot this from the other side. For me, it’s just a little bit to busy with no obvious point or points of focus for my eye to settle on and I can’t really see any expressions as almost everyone is looking away from the camera. The three brightest parts of the photo are the floor, girders and windows which form a little triangle and my eye darts between them passing by the main subject.


Where you from - davidtrout
This is great shot of one of the many street performers that inhabit our cities, I’ve tried shooting a few myself under the London eye. But rather than just take a shot for the performer (as most of us would) you’ve captured him and this other chaps reaction to him. And what a great reaction, thats a very cheeky grin and and you can’t help thinking that he must be wondering what the hell this guy dressed like a statue is doing ! The connection between the two is very strong with the guy in the blue shirt looking directly at the performer. I can’t really make my mind up about the girl in the background though, she’s looking directly at the photographer and for me I think distracts a little although she’s out of focus, on the plus side she (and the others) help set the scene and give context. Nice image.


The convenient stump - drofmit
This is another shot that portrays many aspects of the human condition with such a lot going on. There are certainly a lot of people to look at and wonder what their stories are. But I’m afraid, like ‘Buying Frenzy’ there is a little TO much going on for me and I find it difficult to isolate a subject, expect perhaps the trailer which is not where the story is. There is a lot of detail in this shot and many rich colours but the people take to much of a back seat in terms of subject. The description that accompanied the photo did make me laugh though


smile, you’re on candid Camera - noelcmn
I think we’re all conditioned to take portraits in the same way, make sure the subjects eyes are open and looking at the camera etc etc. But there are occasions when taking a shot of someone with their eyes closed works, it usually works when it adds to a story such as someone playing an instrument and is lost in the music. But I’m afraid this doesn't work for me as it looks like a mis-timed shot and the fact that his eyes are shut doesn’t tell me anything about him or his situation. It’s well taken image with exposure and focus spot on, it just doesn’t work for me…

English Midday sinners - GlynM
A very pleasing shot of the Great British seaside tradition, it certainly resonates with me as I’m sure it does with many others. I brings back memories of trying to bash poles into the sand with rocks you find on the beach, the impossible task of getting on of those little tent things back in it’s small bag, of buying yet another bucket and spade for the kids cos you forgot the last one ( and the one before that ). Thats why this pictures succeeds ( because it invokes so many happy memories) but, for me, doesn’t quite hit the mark for the theme. I don’t really engage with the people in the image, rather recall my own memories. I think the crop is about right and it’s a picture I like, it just doesn’t tell its own story that strongly.


Results

1st - aliengrove for "Streets of Mongkok” - Every time I look at this picture I notice something else and it draws me in, I want to know more about the people in it. Fantastic work

2nd - paulb531 for "Primate Instincts" - Great shot well taken, really puts the viewer into the scene and tells a great story.

3rd - velimir for ‘the collapse” - There is just so much raw, unedited, emotion here. love it.

Highly Commended, in particular order:
davidtrout for "Where you from”
dinneenp for “looking into her future”
johnriley for “travelling zoo”


p.s. Just want to say thank you all again, I had great fun judging this, I hope I get to do it again…
tyronet2000
Posted 01/08/2014 - 10:43 Link
Congratulations to the Winner and other placings. Thank to Andy for the interesting subject, the judging and comprehensive comments
Regards
Stan

PPG
GlynM
Posted 01/08/2014 - 12:39 Link
Many thanks Andy for an interesting competition, well managed with a great set of comments and judging. I hopefully look forward to you running another one .

Congratulations to Jon for the well deserved winning entry, the runners up and everyone else for another excellent set of images.

Glyn
paulb531
Posted 01/08/2014 - 13:10 Link
Thanks Andy for something different competion wise and well judged. Congratulations to a worthy winner and other fellow placings.

Regards

Paul
ken2390
Posted 01/08/2014 - 17:39 Link
Thanks for your comments Andy. The crop had to be tight as there was a crowd of people around,and the mans shoulder was nearly touching the better half. It was a gift wrapped chocolate heart that was passed to Des. Well done the winners and runner ups.
aliengrove
Posted 01/08/2014 - 18:32 Link
Congrats Paul and velimir,and the HC's! And thanks for the win!

This is probably my favourite of the street images I have taken, and it actually does have a strange story behind it, about the guy and the woman at the window. Rather than repeat it here, here's a link to it on my Facebook page for anyone who is interested.

Thanks for a great competition, there's some excellent shots and you've done a great job with your comments!
Edited by aliengrove: 01/08/2014 - 18:33
davidtrout
Posted 03/08/2014 - 18:41 Link
Many thanks Andy for an original and interesting subject.
Congratulations to podiumers Jon, Paul and Velimir and my fellow HCs.
David

PPG: http://www.pentaxphotogallery.com/artists/davidtrout
Hullman
Posted 04/08/2014 - 19:06 Link
Thanks for the comments guys, it was actually a lot more fun than I expected. Hope I didn't hurt anyone's feelings !

@ken2390, I know the feeling about crops I have loads of pictures where I can't crop them where I'd prefer !

@aliengrove, thanks for the the link, a fascinating story to go with a great image. Desperately trying to think on an original selfie to create now...

cheers
Andy
FF: Pentax K-1, D-FA* 70-200, D-FA 24-70, D-FA 100, D-FA 28-105, FA 77, FA 43
APSC: K3, K5, DA*50-135, DA*300, Sigma 17-50, Sigma 10-20, 18-55mm, DA 55-300mm, DA35, 1.4TC
4/3: Q10, Q, 01, 02, 06
Fuji XT1, XF18-55, XF27

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo