All Forum Comments
Comment by Stu-D posted on Reflector for wedding at 12/05/2010 - 17:18
So the reflector is for limited 'couple' photos only - I probably should have said that as that will influence your suggestion on reflector size.
Thanks for the comments and advice so far.
Comment by Stu-D posted on Reflector for wedding at 12/05/2010 - 13:31
Can anyone advise on:
a) The size you feel is best for wedding photos - I need it big enought to reflect to a big enough area (not sure what big enough will be yet)and still be portable and handlable (thinking if it is windy). 32" seems a good compromise, but I did start by wondering whether I shuld just get a little 12"
b) The make you have used and any feelings, positive or negative, about them.
c) They type - I am looking at 5-in-1 reflectors as I figure I could use them for a variety of things, but I am assuming for the wedding I will want to use the white or possible the silver (for higher contract B&W) panels.
Really appreciate it!
Stuart
Comment by Stu-D posted on Reflector for wedding at 12/05/2010 - 08:50
Comment by Stu-D posted on Some photos from Poland II at 11/03/2010 - 13:41
My decision as based on:
17-50 is too close to the 18-55 range from my mkII kit lens
I already have the f1.4 FA 50mm lens, so do i need the speed at the 50mm end?
70mm gives a better overlap with my 50-200mm lens
The 17-70 focuses to 20cm (from the sensor) whereas the 17-50 is about 27cm. It doesnt sound like much difference, but (unless I have misunderstood something) guess the difference from the lens front will be the difference between about 2-3 cm and about 9cm, so will feel much better.
However the Sigma 17-70 is being discountinued in its non-optical stabilised version - I think I have got in in time (but dont have the lens yet), so if I was looking now it would be a more difficult decision!
BTW Camera King did have the Tamron for £295 which seemed a pretty good price.
I hope this helps, even though I dont have direct experience of the 17-50.
Stuart
PS I was concerned about focussing issues for the Tamron, replies through this forum put my mind at ease!
Comment by Stu-D posted on Sigma 18-50mm EX F2.8 at 17/02/2010 - 13:43
Comment by Stu-D posted on DNG to JPEG in one move? at 04/02/2010 - 17:46
Comment by Stu-D posted on DNG to JPEG in one move? at 04/02/2010 - 13:32
Comment by Stu-D posted on Sigma 17-70 speed at 20/01/2010 - 23:01
Many thanks,
Stuart
Comment by Stu-D posted on Sigma 17-70 speed at 19/01/2010 - 20:43
Comment by Stu-D posted on Tamron 17-50mm f2.8 XR Di II LD at 18/01/2010 - 20:06

