richandfleur

Joined: 3rd December 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

richandfleur
Next time it happens, remove the lens and fire off a few shots with no lens attached.

(You'll need that menu setting enabled to allow this to happen)

Worked for me when I had something similar. Quite random.

Comment by richandfleur posted on pentax k50 viewfinder problem at 31/05/2016 - 10:29

richandfleur
Agree, I've installed the options to remove the upgrade updates, having read that the official options issued by Microsoft (to avoid the Win 10 upgrade), weren't necessarily permanent.

I view this site on IE11 at Work and Home on Windows 7. Occasionally get the do you want to view all items security warning. Works well on mobile Safari apple browser.

Very often issues are around the plugin adverts, and the OPs error from websites where your responses are stored, and it picks up that you are trying to navigate away before submitting your changes. I see this on Facebook for example if you type a comment but do not submit it.

Comment by richandfleur posted on An Infuriating Nuisance! at 31/05/2016 - 00:36

richandfleur
fatspider wrote:


There's nothing wrong with manipulation of an image but surely we should all strive to capture it as best we can in the camera to start with.
There are a heap of user controlled factors on the day. Composition, exposure, shutter speed, aperture.

That gets you the base image that then gets developed.

To me they are two different steps. It's like shooting on film but never submitting it to be developed.

I struggle to see how you can have one without the other.

Comment by richandfleur posted on this will be intresting at 28/05/2016 - 04:07

richandfleur
Put another way, I don't think it's fair to judge a developed photo based on the path taken to get to it. As I said, akin to enjoying a concert performance, vs sitting through the endless practise sessions.

If it's a competition, then there are rules. Outside of that, there are no rules to photography, and I personally get quite annoyed by the constant judgements that imply that there actually are rules that must be adhered to. It's quite rude to dismiss a creation because of how it was made. Like any form of creativity/art, one is encouraged to form an opinion, express how they feel about it, but that should be on what they're observing, what's been presented to them. Depends on how open minded you are I guess.

I appreciate a good photo, and might even bug you for details around how you achieved it, so I can have a go and learn more myself

Likewise, I appreciate photos that are presented to appear as un manipulated as possible, or more specifically developed to try and reflect what was there on the day. It's all good, Shoot, Edit, Repeat as they say.

Where there are rules, then they should be adhered to. That's different. As an example, here's a recent one where some guy was disqualified for cloning out a foot. I'm fine with that, but I present it as an example of how dramatically different his contest application was from the original photo. Even if he'd left the foot in, showing the original photo would detract massively from the vibe and mystery of the shot presented.

This:
Comment Image


vs this:
Comment Image

Comment by richandfleur posted on this will be intresting at 26/05/2016 - 22:16

richandfleur
johnriley wrote:
RAW files actually do quite a bit of processing, unbeknown to us. They correct for lens defects more often than we might surmise. Not so much on DSLR lenses, but CSC lenses are something else.
Regardless RAW files offer the output with the most information and least processing and compression applied.
If you want to undertake the post processing yourself, they're the best source file to start with.

If you are happy to configure the various in camera processing options yourself, then the subsequent JPEG output if fine too, but the point is it has been processed, or as I prefer to say 'Developed'.

Posting a RAW file developed by default settings only will result in a very washed out/un sharp/low contrast image. It will appear worse than an in camera developed JPEG and will be of little use. The sensor captures colour information regardless of if you want to use it in your final image, so even black and white final images will have started life as a colour capture for example.

It's a picky point in some respects, but I think it's important to grasp that a JPEG image has been developed by the time you see it. It's straight out of camera, but it's been manipulated in a way that you could apply afterwards in post production software. Sharpening is a good example, where in software afterwards you get far more control over how much and to what part of the image this is applied. A straight out of camera RAW sunrise photo is not going to look anything like how you saw it on the day, without some post development work.

If you're talking practical category definitions, I think you've got 'presenting' changes (for want of a better word) such as contrast/saturation/sharpening, and then you've got 'manipulation' changes such as cloning / composite layer work etc. Somewhere in the middle you've got cropping, lens distortion correction, split toning, black and white conversion, HDR, C/A reduction etc etc...

I'm not sure where you draw the line on this exactly, but hey, in normal every day life it just shouldn't matter. Do what you want to create the image you envision and are happy with I say.

Comment by richandfleur posted on this will be intresting at 25/05/2016 - 23:12

richandfleur
BruceStrachan wrote:
post the original as well..
What have you got to lose?
And what has anyone got to gain?

Other than to get a feel for how someone created their final image that was then presented to you.

I guess I'd be asking do you see that elsewhere? Is there a rough outline sketch hanging next to the Mona Lisa? Are there always two photos shown on the front page of a newspaper? Do you go to a movie and see a side image showing the behind the scenes making of playing at the same time?

There are no rules to this. (Unless you're specifically entering a competition that specifically has rules).

That's skipping over the fact, as discussed quite a bit above, that a RAW file (straight from camera) looks very dull, as it has no post processing applied to it by the camera. It's exactly what it says it is, a RAW file full of information ready to be worked on by the photographer as they see fit. It has the most amount of detail present. Heck a max quality 16MP K-30 RAW file is around 26MB in size and a JPEG is around 10MB. That gives you a lot of extra information to play with, but it will look very poor straight out of camera, with essentially no processing applied. By contrast the JPEGs will look much better, as they have some typical processing applied.

Comment by richandfleur posted on this will be intresting at 25/05/2016 - 21:55

richandfleur
Dingo wrote:

neither has been processed by the way.....as they were taken at the time
One of the points raised by others above was that every photo is processed. You may not have touched these after they came out of the camera, but that final JPEG was made based on the development settings you configured within the camera, even if you didn't' realise it or play a major role in configuring those settings.

Comment by richandfleur posted on this will be intresting at 20/05/2016 - 06:58

richandfleur
I feel there is an underlying concern that you as the viewer are being deceived/lied to, and people want full disclosure around any modifications from ‘real life’.

There are the technical issues at play, in that a camera simply can't present it as you see it, without a lot of processing decisions being made. If you shoot JPEG, then the RAW image has been developed for you, and decisions have been made, even if you haven't actively menu dived and adjusted them. They simply have been made if you are viewing an image from your camera. How much you want to get involved with this shaping of the data, either in camera or afterwards, is up to you. Some brands place a lot of value on the processing systems built in, with quite complex alignment with film stock behaviours etc.

There are then also the psychological and practical aspects of it. Some of which is the photographer influencing the capture of reality through camera placement, framing etc. If you take photos of a riot/protest for example, then you are going to influence the viewers concept of reality at that location by virtue of simply which side of the line you are one when you take the photo. You could argue you're doing the same when you stop at the side of the road and take a photo of a landscape and don't chose to frame the shot to include the road, or petrol station next to you. Or where you move a leaf out of shot before you take the photo because it looked ugly. Or when you took a wildlife shot with narrow depth of field so you didn't give away that it was in a zoo enclosure.

I'd get into a disclosure discussion if it's a clearly stated requirement of a competition environment, or if someone's seen something I've done and asked how I got to that final image. Likewise I'll ask that myself where I see something I like and consider it a skill I'd like to learn more about. Forums such as this are invaluable to me in terms of saying Hey, that's cool, how did you do that please?

Personally I'm only concerned with the final image presented to me. Like a performance really, where I get one shot to look at it, and I appreciate all the hard work that's been put in to present what's now in front of me.

The only time I'm worried that it's not a depiction of real life is when they're crime scene or insurance photos for example.

Then again, I'm very anti all the 'rules' in photography. I'm a creative person, and I don't like concepts that get in the way of that for what I consider to be arbitrary reasons.

Comment by richandfleur posted on this will be intresting at 19/05/2016 - 22:05

richandfleur
Nearly straight out of camera, with just a bit of contrast adjustment...

Comment Image

Comment by richandfleur posted on this will be intresting at 19/05/2016 - 02:31

richandfleur
I think it's fair to say that Pentax does offer a wide range of in body processing tools, such that someone can have a lot of control over how a photo they take is developed.

It's all processing though, whether sharpening/contrast/brightness etc is done in camera or not. Out of camera you just be more control over the process, and have access to additional tools, and arguably a nicer work interface. Can you crop in camera for example?

I'm really anti rules around what should be a creative pastime. I get where the OP is coming from, but I just don't think it applies anymore, especially when what you've taken is solely to capture as much detail as possible, and isn't ever intended to be the final result.

Comment by richandfleur posted on this will be intresting at 19/05/2016 - 00:16

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo