paul.graber

Joined: 22nd December 2006

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

paul.graber
On a slightly different note, don't suppose anyone knows if anyone in the UK actually has stock of the 10-20 in Pentax fit? They appear to be like hen's teeth!

Comment by paul.graber posted on Pentax 10-17 or Sigma 10-20 at 30/04/2007 - 12:21

paul.graber
Thanks for directing me to those Sigma shots. The reasons I'm not really considering the Pentax 12 - 24, despite the fact that I would prefer to stay loyal, are:-
1 It's about twice the price
2 You lose 10 - 12 and gain range that will duplicate my current 18 - 55, likely to be 16 - 50 one of these days.
Cheers

Comment by paul.graber posted on Pentax 10-17 or Sigma 10-20 at 27/04/2007 - 18:37

paul.graber
Thanks again to all who have contributed. I really don't think, having looked at the test images, that a fisheye is what I'm after. Shame, since the Pentax is reasonably priced and a nice size. I think a Sigma may be on the way soon....

Comment by paul.graber posted on Pentax 10-17 or Sigma 10-20 at 27/04/2007 - 16:35

paul.graber
Yes, well, having just made a significant investment in the Cokin P system, you'll understand that I'm not hugely keen to embrace yet another!
The wide angle holder seems like the best solution at least for now. Or I just won't use filters at 10 and 11mm...

Comment by paul.graber posted on Pentax 10-17 or Sigma 10-20 at 27/04/2007 - 09:37

paul.graber
Re-reading my last post, I should have made it clearer - the vignetting at 10mm I was talking about is of the Cokin holder, not native to the Sigma lens. Actually, it's worse than vignetting, the holder itself is clearly visible.

Comment by paul.graber posted on Pentax 10-17 or Sigma 10-20 at 27/04/2007 - 09:04

paul.graber
And Matt it was who kindly helped me source Cokin P filters not so long ago! As chance would have it, someone has just posted a photo on dpreview demonstrating the degree of vignetting on a Sigma 10-20 at 10mm - it's bad! However, apparently it's gone by 12mm.

Does anyone have experience witrh the two lenses at issue here? I think I will prinicipally use whichever I buy for landscape work, so I'm still leaning Sigma-wards. Incidentally, I really appreciate the high signal-to-noise ratio of postings to this forum. People are so helpful, and only post when they have a contribution to make.

Comment by paul.graber posted on Pentax 10-17 or Sigma 10-20 at 27/04/2007 - 08:35

paul.graber
That sounds quite straightforward; and if it is that simple the Sigma gets my vote. But I have an idea it's a bit more complicated than that, and that in some circumstances a fisheye gives a truer reflection of real life. Anyone?

Comment by paul.graber posted on Pentax 10-17 or Sigma 10-20 at 26/04/2007 - 23:12

paul.graber
Anyone have any strong views on the comparison between these two fairly similarly priced lenses (for use on a K10D). And can anyone point me at a useful explanation of the significance of Pentax being a fisheye?
Thanks

Comment by paul.graber posted on Pentax 10-17 or Sigma 10-20 at 26/04/2007 - 22:44

paul.graber
Just to say thanks to Matt for the recommendation of Speedgraphic, who have fulfilled my order very efficiently. Your help is appreciated, Matt!

Comment by paul.graber posted on Filters - Cokin A or P? at 04/03/2007 - 20:22

paul.graber
Thanks, Matt - most helpful as always. And would you buy one or two adaptor rings for two 52mm lenses?

Comment by paul.graber posted on Filters - Cokin A or P? at 16/02/2007 - 09:35

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo