If you insist on keeping the bottom 1/4, I can't help but notice that in that bottom section the highlights turn from neutral to slightly yellowed, how about a shift to blue to make them neutral. Leaving that top left dot of a boat is the kind of thing I'd do just because, so keep it if you will, my feeling is it should go. In a very low contrast image the fishing boat does stand out as very h ...

Mmmmmmmmmmm, for what it is or is not worth. I'd crop about a 1/4 off the bottom and remove the annoying black speck of a boat on the horizon and correct the vignetting. And another thing, it almost looks as if the boat has been placed there. Is that the processing or has it been? It's tough to tell with such a small image. I think it works well.

I actually rather like the over vibrant colour, the image is almost surreal. The border is almost right but not quite done to my liking. A lovely very striking image but I much prefer the mono version. I hope my comments don't offend you.

Spotting your colour version has brought me here. You have photographed what is a very beautiful scene and through your processing/development turned it into an almost magical or mythical scene which seems most appropriate given your accompanying story. It is beautiful and grabs ones attention as being an individual interpretation of the scene, which I think is great. Now you ask for opinio ...

Fantastic! Everything right about this shot.

You got to blur it blur it, you got to blur it!

I agree with previous comments, beautiful light. With that wonderful graduation in the sky I don't think clouds would improve the image.

Right nice, well framed.

Certainly got yourself in the right place. Iconic springs to mind.

Wow, I think you've done a great job of handling this shot.