All Forum Comments
Comment by mikew posted on Image puzzlement at 01/05/2009 - 22:18
I agree my images don't look all that flat but I worked on one that should have looked better than it did on the web and hence the question was raised.
I thought that the hosting might be an issue so I uploaded the JPEG to folder on my web site so that no-one else could do anything to it. I think it's my lack of understanding on how to compare the image in PS as to how it will appear as SRGB on a web page.
I'll get there!
And Peter yes it's a hell of a learning curve. Just as i think I get somewhere I realise that I haven't quite managed it!
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on Image puzzlement at 01/05/2009 - 20:40
The profile PS was using display was ARGB while I was saving as SRGB and when I switch to working profile SRGB it looks flat in PS as well.
Now I have to try and understand where this gets me!
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on Image puzzlement at 01/05/2009 - 20:07
IE7 looks better than both Firefox and Chrome but not as goos PS.
I think I'm doing something wrong when I save as JPEG but I guess PS will make a better job of rendering the JPEG within PS?
Ignorance alert! If I use soft proof in PS it doesn't seem to make any difference but if I apply gamut warning then the bits that aren't quite right come up as problematic. I guess that's part of the issue?
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on Image puzzlement at 01/05/2009 - 19:24
In Photoshop, resize, unsharp mask make sure it's SRGB save as JPEG. Looks fine.
Upload to web and view in Chrome say it looks rather flatter.
Am I doing something wrong or am I being dim?
Thanks in advance.
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on Image puzzlement at 01/05/2009 - 19:06
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on Fornightly Competition no.14 Night at 30/04/2009 - 09:15
Prieni's is an excellent shot in all ways and a worthy winner. For some reason I don't think anyone found this an easy subject when you'd have thought it would have offered a lot of freedom.
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on Fornightly Competition no.14 Night at 30/04/2009 - 07:03
Comment by mikew posted on Pentax SMC 21mm f/3.2 Limited at 30/04/2009 - 07:00
I'd buy the K10D for my son if it was dirt cheap but as I have been reminded the denizens of this forum aren't daft!
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on K10D & Kit For Sale at 29/04/2009 - 17:38
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on Should I go for the GX10? at 29/04/2009 - 15:47


Assign the profile in PS to be the working profile in PS which is set as SRGB and promptly looks flat
Fanny about until it looks like I want it to on the web and save as JPEG
Send that to web hosting
Compare the two
They're the same
This is a little embarrassing but the two images in question are:
http://www.mcwimaging.com/photos/OrangeInGate_IGP3836.jpg
and
http://www.mcwimaging.com/photos/OrangeInGatea_IGP3836.jpg
The second one is identical in PS.
I think I may have done what Matt said but by a different route. But who knows eh? I expect Matt does truth be told.
If I want to print this out then I think I'd switch back to the PSD file which would be ARGB then print from there.
Incidentally I don't like Firefox I'm afraid and I use Chrome which if you turn off the Phishing thing is pretty fast.
Mike