All Forum Comments
Comment by GrahamW posted on Sigma 28-90mm f/1:3.5-5.6 Macro Zoom at 06/04/2010 - 11:01
I'm planning to strip them down, clean and re-lube their focusing helices over the weekend, but wondered what type of grease would be best to use for re-lubing?
I have access to silicone or lithium based grease, or could get something different if neither are suitable. Having stripped down a couple of lenses in the past, the existing grease looked most like the lithium based stuff I have.
Aside from the obvious risks (polluting the lens and camera) is there a significant difference in feel or longevity between different types of grease?
Comment by GrahamW posted on Best type of grease to re-lube focusing helix? at 01/04/2010 - 13:05
What I found what that while the Pentax/Samsung 12-24 is undoubtedly a better performing lens, the Sigma 10-20 and Tamron are both pretty good and both have good reviews and very satisfied users. For me, the Tamron was much better value and the 24mm reach is useful, as I can use it as a walkaround lens (albeit a wide one).
I'm very happy with the performance; I think that it depends what you want it for. If it is to see how you get on with an ultrawide and if it suits your style, I'd recommend the Tamron or Sigma. If you get on well with it and are unhappy with the qualiy, both seem to hold their value well, so you could sell it and buy the Pentax 12-24. Whereas if you're in to pixel peeping and want the technically 'best' lens, the Pentax is probably the one to get.
From my experience, the limiting factor is my technique at such wide angles, not the lens!
Comment by GrahamW posted on which 10-20 - if at all? at 30/03/2010 - 18:09
Now to join the ranks of people trying to find a matched extension tube for their adaptall macro lenses...
Comment by GrahamW posted on What's the difference between a teleconverter and an extension tube? at 30/03/2010 - 17:53
I've got a matching 2x teleconverter, which has additional glass elements that increase the focal length to 180mm and reduces the effective speed of the lens by a couple of stops.
If I was to use it with an extension tube, I could also get 1:1 (which, as I understand it, means that an actual-size image of the subject is projected on to the sensor). This would appear, intuitively, to increase the efective focal length as well.
Do extension tubes also reduce the effecive speed of the lens? If not, what's the advantage of using optical teleconverters, other than smaller physical size for longer focal legths?
Comment by GrahamW posted on What's the difference between a teleconverter and an extension tube? at 30/03/2010 - 17:35
I won't be able to do much with it before the weekend but hope to have a play with it then. In the meantime, does anyone have one or has anyone used one and knows what it's like?
Comment by GrahamW posted on Petri 28mm f2.0 - any good? at 25/03/2010 - 16:01
Comment by GrahamW posted on How do constant aperture zooms work? at 12/03/2010 - 16:34
From what Mongoose has said, it sounds like the diaphragm is closed slightly towards the wide end to give constant f-number performance. So for the example of the 17-70mm f/2.8-4.5, presumably they could have designed it as a constant f/4.5 by closing up the diaphragm towards the wide end of the zoom?
I was a bit surprised that manufacturers do this, as I would have thought that an f/2-f/2.8 28-70 zoom might appear more useful to the uninitiated (like me) than a constant f/2.8 over the same range.
Comment by GrahamW posted on How do constant aperture zooms work? at 12/03/2010 - 15:51
After all, low light performance must be one of the main reasons people buy fast zooms (it was for me, anyway).
I'm tempted to do a bit of strategic disassembly to see how it works...
Comment by GrahamW posted on How do constant aperture zooms work? at 12/03/2010 - 15:09
So, the perception that constant f-number/aperture zooms are better is really more to do with ease of use on manual cameras than optical quality.
Comment by GrahamW posted on How do constant aperture zooms work? at 12/03/2010 - 14:39


I tried to use it to take some macro shots for work, but ended up cropping images from my A50 1.7 instead.
It depends what you want to do with it; if it's cheap or you've already got it, it is good as a means of having a go at macro photography, but otherwise, from my experience, it will be easier to get good results with a dedicated macro lens.