BODYHEAT

Joined: 27th May 2009

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

BODYHEAT
terje-l wrote:
There are a few statements in this thread that provokes me to participate in the discussion on a general basis (not K-7 related):

The LCD monitor: Of course you can use the LCD monitor to check the exposure. If you don't change the LCD brightness, you will soon learn to judge over- or underexposures. The histogram is more accurate, and can be used for more critical judgement.

RAW vs. JPG: I would expect my DSLR to be able to produce far better JPGs than my old digital P&S camera costing a fraction of the DSLR. I do understand the usefulness of RAW images for tricky situations, but please don't imply that shooting in JPG is inferior.

Its all about knowledge, as John Riley's recent thread illustrated, and thinking back to the era of colour slide film, it is possible to get a decent exposure straight out of the camera. So I guess we can either aim for a perfect JPG exposure, og go the sloppy way, thinking I can always rescue my picture from the RAW file.

Finally, I resent Iceblinker's "Green mode is the idiot mode". When I grew up we were taught never to call a person an idiot. Surely the automatic modes have their usefulness, otherwise they wouldn't be there.

Phew - good to get it off my chest
Thanks Terry. I suppose this has ended up being a topic within a topic (I suppose atopic would be off-topic ) and merits its own topic. However it seems to me there are two schools of thought and two camps, possibly depending on whether you grew up on film or have come to photography straight to DSLR.

How come I got brilliant, perfectly well exposed slide and print shots straight out of the old fashioned, out of date, prehistoric manual camera with old glass every time? Noone ever said, just shoot and then we'll send it to the retouchers (before Photoshop etc.)

You got it right because the equipment gave you what your eye saw. So I am trying to recreate that feeling and to my eye (not talking about wedding dresses or skies or shots where there is huge variance in light) the results I got from the K20D from following the instructions were underexposed (packshots in a tent with controlled even lighting and shadows).

Ok so I have learned I have to set it up in P mode and compensate with EV adjustment. Fair does. But the assumption that you can't take great photographs unless you are also competent in PP using programs like Photoshop or the Pentax Laboratory is erroneous to me and just doesn't stack up.

But IF you have only ever known DSLRs and grown up with their limitations then perhaps PP manipulation is absolutely what you expect to have to do and you think that people like me who grew up on film are out to lunch.

Comment by BODYHEAT posted on First production review of K-7 at 22/06/2009 - 13:56

BODYHEAT
Danny, I don't think the lens makes a difference except that it won't communicate with the camera. Whether it's a classic lens or a new digital lens, light travels down the barrel of the lens and hits the film plane/sensor. There is either too much light or too little. It's that simple. If there's not enough light overall (to my taste)I just need to know foolproof ways of increasing it. I also have used the DA 16-50 lens so I dont think the lens is the issue here, just the amount of light being recorded by the sensor.

...and maybe you've just justified the reason I should have the K7. It probably is less idiosyncratic in its exposures than the K20D. You have been shooting with both, would you say there's a difference in this aspect? Honestly would you have taken the exact same pictures of the parrots with the same aperture, shutter and so on and got identical results with the K20D or would they have been darker? My hunch is they would have been darker overall, all other things being equal. I'd love to see a side by side with identical settings

Comment by BODYHEAT posted on First production review of K-7 at 22/06/2009 - 12:16

BODYHEAT
Unlocker wrote:
Shaky wrote:

but to argue that in the case of Pentax this is a feature is simply a joke.
Don't think anyone is arguing that it is a feature, it's just different, with other cameras, you would do the exact opposite. For me it's better, others do not agree.

Fiddling around with Raw converters is a prerequisite for getting maximum quality. RAW converters help with exposure if you didn't get it right in camera, as there is more information in a RAW file to potentially recover from than there is in a JPEG.

It's why I always shoot RAW + JPEG, if the JPEG is fine I dump the RAW file, if it isn't I dump the JPEG and work from the RAW. I like as little PP as possible as well, prefer to spend time behind the camera at the moment as I am still learning.
For a learner, Danny you are pretty skilled and somewhat of an expert, especially if your parrot shots are anything to go by as they were simply JPEGs as I understand, which is what I am looking for: great shots straight out of the camera. Is that too much to ask or do I need to cover myself with a RAW shot on every occasion just in case the camera underexposes or I screwed up in some other way?

I hate to sound like a broken record but with my LX and K2 it was simple. I knew the ISO of the film and set that in the camera and arbitrarily set the EV slightly under or over depending of whether it was negative or positive and shot away. This EV adjustment remained constant whether I was shooting in auto (green) or set the dial for something else. In other words, even in auto (green) it would still apply one third stop under etc if set, regardless of the automatic exposure set by the camera

So question: from reading the manual the EV adjustment gets overridden in green mode in the K20D. Is this correct? Or is there a global setting to over or under expose by choice regardless of the other camera settings? IE Can I shoot with the green mode for convenience and set the camera up to overexpose by +0.7 on every occasion regardless of what the camera is trying to do?

Comment by BODYHEAT posted on First production review of K-7 at 22/06/2009 - 11:34

BODYHEAT
Shaky wrote:
BODYHEAT wrote:
Frankly, the less I have to try and tinker with it PP the better
I couldn't agree more.

In my experience my K10d underexposes between 0 and 1 1/3 EV; as far as I am concerned there is no one size fits all compensation.

What I tend to do is fire off a shot and then immediately check the histogram. Others will be able to explain its interpretation much better than I can but I am looking for a curve that doesn't fall off a cliff on the left; if that is the case I progressively bump up the compensation accordingly.

One other thing; I have no idea whether other dslr makes consistently underexpose but to argue that in the case of Pentax this is a feature is simply a joke. I shoot jpegs for the same reason as you, and if fiddling around with Raw converters is a prerequisite for getting proper exposures, Pentax shouldn't include a jpeg converter in the first place.
Maybe the critics have all got it wrong and Pentax is really a 'pro' brand after all for the people who have the time, patience, and technical expertise to spend their time in PP. Amateurs like me should stick to amateur cameras like the Canon 450D most probably which deliver amateur pictures without the need to become a lab rat/IT expert

Comment by BODYHEAT posted on First production review of K-7 at 22/06/2009 - 11:13

BODYHEAT
On another matter I always used to underexpose ektachrome (positives) to retain the detail which would be blown out with 'normal' exposure and always overexposed black and white film (negatives) by one stop for the same reason, so I understand the issues and am quite happy to compensate.

I was just asking for guidance on how to do it successfully with the K20D when there are so many parameters in the camera for doing this and like the neophyte that I am I naively expected the LCD to be representative of what my monitor would show.

Frankly, the less I have to try and tinker with it PP the better since that again is a whole new learning curve in itself....my wife already complains I spend too much time on the computer

Comment by BODYHEAT posted on First production review of K-7 at 22/06/2009 - 10:25

BODYHEAT
nathanever82 wrote:
Dear Bodyheat,

(I am really going to try not to sound arrogant, because I might get hung if I get critical again!!)

I think that the assumption is that, if a normal person without photographic experience, buys a complicated Digital SLR camera, there will be a steep learning curve, in order to achieve the best results the camera can produce. Often people buy a very well specified camera (like the K20) and expect the jpgs, shot in green auto mode to look stunning, because these should be the basic settings of a truly expensive, semi-professional camera. Unfortunately this is definitely not the case. In my opinion, the higher specifications a tool has, the more care needs to be taken whilst using it, and the steeper the learning curve is. So in order to get the best results from cameras like K10/K20, it is often necessary to set certain parameters for Jpgs, adjust exposure compensation, and mainly shoot in RAW, in order to retain the full capability of the camera, instead of compressing it with Jpgs.

TO conclude, after 2 and half years with 3 K10's, I only recently felt I have mastered the camera, and all its functions, and I basically only use M and A modes. Probably these tools are just smarter than we are (and underexposing is a very strong example of this - because it allows for more detail to be preserved).

I hope this helps, and has not in any way offended you.

Regards,
Nathan, thanks and I appreciate your response. I am very experienced with film but not at all with DSLR which is why I was asking for some guidelines. I realise it is like learning to fly a plane and all the controls can be a bit daunting so that's why I am asking for help on how to optimise it and make my learning curve as painless as possible. I have now adjusted the EV to + 0.7 to see if that makes a difference and see where else I might need to adjust.

These were packshots of very well lit products in a light tent and I really didn't expect them to be underexposed the way they are, so I am trying to understand how to make up for it so what I see is more or less what I get.

Your answer was fine and not at all patronising. I just think that when someone is asking for help and answers in a forum it is not the best way to start "surely anybody knows the answer to this...you idiot (implied)"

Comment by BODYHEAT posted on First production review of K-7 at 22/06/2009 - 10:14

BODYHEAT
amilner wrote:
Surely anybody knows not to rely on the screen of a DSLR (or any digital camera) to assess the exposure of an image.
Why should 'anybody' know this? You rely on the LCD of a P&S to see if it is exposed correctly and it is usually 100% accurate so this statement doesn't make sense for cameras which are 3-6 times the price of a P&S camera, and besides I did say I was new to the DSLR arena and that's why I am asking for guidance. If 'anybody knows' the answer then noone would ever ask it. There's a certain arrogance in your comment which I think was uncalled for

And it appears I am not alone in believing the K20D consistently underexposes - it seems like a common issue. I am not complaining or even whining, just asking for sensible input on how to compensate for how the camera sees things

Comment by BODYHEAT posted on First production review of K-7 at 22/06/2009 - 09:42

BODYHEAT
thanks Steve, but my monitor is calibrated, but we're not talking RAW here but JPGs which should look great straight out of the camera and not need any PP

Comment by BODYHEAT posted on First production review of K-7 at 22/06/2009 - 07:23

BODYHEAT
Quote: "Additionally the camera’s LCD screen equates image playback entirely different to computer screens – as tested on laptops and calibrated monitors. It’s a disappointment when an apparently well-exposed image in-camera reveals itself to be underexposed on screen. This then takes working into, and adds to time – an issue that the K20D also had. Really and truly shots should come straight from camera with little to no fuss."

I am new to digital and this is an issue I am having with my K20D. I took a load of shots for my website last night and they looked fine on the LCD but on my monitor all seemed underexposed or as if they had some sort of grey fog over the whole picture. I read somethign about this in the other pentaxforums and they said Pentax wasn't underexposing just not blowing out the whites. I get that, but white? this is like underwear thats gone grey.

Has anyone got any tips how to deal with it? Do you set the EV to automatically compensate by one third, two thirds, a full stop? or how do you deal with it in the K20D so what you see on the LCD is more or less what you see on your computer screen?

Comment by BODYHEAT posted on First production review of K-7 at 21/06/2009 - 19:54

BODYHEAT
Yes, I got a new message so I clicked on it only to find a 'Nigerian' letter offering me money to participate in helping someone with her late fathers estate...ha ha...

I understand how they manage to send spam emails but to be able to send private messages in a forum??? Amazing

Comment by BODYHEAT posted on Anyone else just get a 'Nigerian' scam email in their message inbox on this forum? at 20/06/2009 - 23:11

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo