Blythman

Joined: 13th September 2010

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Blythman
Copy the contents of your card onto your pc to confirm what is present

Comment by Blythman posted on Pentax k-x stopped saving photos at 16/06/2013 - 17:38

Blythman
Quote:
Regarding the whole battery grip vs square format argument ....

Alan, for now the benefits you claim for the square format are hypothetical to us - we don't have it -
I am talking about the advantages of the grip over and above the camera on its own that I do have (a K7 - grip and handling etc are the same as K5 also). If we do get then get a chance one day to comapre the features / handling of a square format Pentax DSLR with an APS-C or FF one and try out the grips, then we could ressurrect this argument. Until then its only guesswork.
Didn't think there was an issue discussing other options. After all the grip discussion you are pushing isn't exactly on topic which is specific to the k5IIs

Quote:
I am recomending people try out the option we do actually have at the moment and consider the benefits I have listed.


As to to the grip. I use one with my Sigma 150-500 or 300mm with and sometimes without the 1.7x attached. They do improve balance. On smaller lenses, I find the grip negatively impacts on balance. And shooting with a grip in portrait mode is more of a hindrance than a benefit, if you shoot with your left eye

Comment by Blythman posted on K5IIs, how good then? at 16/06/2013 - 17:26

Blythman
johnriley wrote:
The square format has been mooted for many, many years, but when tried on film SLRs has always failed.

..........

It's odds on you'd get a square camera that used the shortest side of the APS-C format anyway, but if it was the longest side you'd end up with a very odd looking beast with little general appeal.
Square film SLRs failed, but so did APS SLRs. Funny how times change.

Don't see why we should get an odd looking beast. We'll probably never know

Comment by Blythman posted on K5IIs, how good then? at 16/06/2013 - 17:08

Blythman
I've only just given up Marathons, but I still eat Opal Fruits

Comment by Blythman posted on K-50 anyone? at 16/06/2013 - 09:24

Blythman
Quote:
Those that I listed earlier ... 'There are clear gains with the K7 / K5 conbined with battery grip - firstly the obvious extended power with an extra Li-on and 6 AAs on board.
As mentioned a deeper body needed for a square sensor could accomodate an extra battery, and also twin card slots

Quote:
But also the grip provides the key shooting controls (shutter, EC, ISO, green button, AL-L, and the two e-dials) in the same position vertically as the user would have them in normal position (as do the top Pro bodies of the competition without a grip). Once you're used to flicking the camera over into vertical and the hands hardly move you'll never want to go back.
I find this clumsy. Better suited to people who shoot with their right eye as opposed to left eye. A square format would negate the need to ever switch from landscape to portrait shooting

Quote:
And the grip adds a solidity (yes, weight) and tactile security that transforms handling - for me its just all positive'.
Obviously if the camera is bigger and with an extra battery you'd expect additional weight. Ergonomics can be designed into the body just as easily as a grip

Quote:
Plus, for tripod use, the BG-4 grip allows you to change both a camera battery and the AAs with the camera in place on the tripod - without the grip you have to remove the camera from the tripod first.
Depends where that extra battery I mention is placed doesn't it. And who takes both the spare battery and the AA holder out with them? I never used my AA holder.

Also why is a problem discarding pixels which you don't currently have on your camera in any case. Also, the current dimensions aren't ideal for many photographs. I definitely prefer a square format for lots of my photos. And 8x10 is better suited to to lots of photos too, so you'd be discarding less pixels in those situations.

So, like I said. What benefits are you missing?

Comment by Blythman posted on K5IIs, how good then? at 16/06/2013 - 09:18

Blythman
gwing wrote:
Trouble is a square sensor with sides equal to current rectangular sensor will require a larger image circle and hence potentially a new set of lenses and/or reduced corner performance.
Many DA lenses are full frame compatible in any case, and as has just been demonstrated by the Q v Q7, there may well be reasonable leeway built into DA lenses which aren't FF compatible

Comment by Blythman posted on K5IIs, how good then? at 15/06/2013 - 22:42

Blythman
McGregNi wrote:
Blythman wrote:
... We should have a square format sensor. You'd never need to switch between portrait and landscape mode. It would be bigger to accommodate the taller sensor
Yeah, I've seen pictures shot in this format - is it the Hassleblad that uses it? Sure, resolves that issue, but not all types of subjects benefit from a square format, and we'd end up cropping a lot I'd have though, so throwing pixels away.

And the other benefits I listed would still be missing.
No problem cropping. We all do that anyway. Can't see what other benefits are missing. If the camera had to be bigger to accommodate a taller sensor then there'd be room for double sd cards and an extra battery

Comment by Blythman posted on K5IIs, how good then? at 15/06/2013 - 22:07

Blythman
Agree, excellent set. The first one is perhaps a bit overexposed. In addition to the comments above about the last 3, I think it was an excellent choice of B&W for #2. It wouldn't have worked anything like as well in colour

Comment by Blythman posted on Trip to Cornwall set 2 at 15/06/2013 - 21:51

Blythman
Said it before Nigel. We should have a square format sensor. You'd never need to switch between portrait and landscape mode. The camera body would be bigger to accommodate the taller sensor

Comment by Blythman posted on K5IIs, how good then? at 15/06/2013 - 21:48

Blythman
My problem is I always stack them ... Lol. The answer is that Lee are better. But I like many others settle for Hitch because of price. Only you know how much you are prepared to pay

Comment by Blythman posted on Lee vs Hi Tech ND Grads at 15/06/2013 - 21:13

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo