All Forum Comments
Comment by aminstar posted on And it's goodbye from me at 08/09/2009 - 13:51
Dear Amin,
I understand what you are saying, and appreciate that the choice of words was a wrong one. Therefore, whilst standing by the meaning of my post, I am here apologising to Feeb, and her tutor, for the use of the word 'idiot' which was inappropriate and rude.
Nathan
Now there is the sign of a wise and good man. Thanks Nathan, I am glad we got this cleared out and we are on the same level here. I am sure if there was a slip from my tongue, well in this case from my fingers you or somene else would have called my attention to it too.
Now let's try to get back to Gwyn and see if we can pursuade her to stay on. We will miss her input if she really stays away.
Gwyn, please reconsider and perhaps give it a day or two and think about it again. This is a nice bunch of people here, and even though once in a while there is a heated debate that ends up a bit nasty but overall compared to other forums this is really a great one.
Comment by aminstar posted on And it's goodbye from me at 08/09/2009 - 13:47
105 is good for portrait too ? isnt it?
But please do not take my word for it only, I am sure the more experienced members in the forum will give you a more knowledgeable feedback
Comment by aminstar posted on Macro different mm at 08/09/2009 - 13:42
and I don’t particularly appreciate being mentioned ‘behind my back’. I often prefer to say what I think, rather than hide it behind futile rhetoric.
Nathan
The only time where I personally exceeded in my wording was in this case (mis-quoted by Amin):
“"Pentax as a study camera" - your tutor is an idiot”
Nathan
Now if you ask me, that is rude calling someone idiot even as a response to "Pentax is a study camera". And even though I agree with you in principle that her tutor is wrong if he really thinks that Pentax is a study camera I would not have called him "idiot". I would have used a different way to imply that he is wrong, utterly and despicably wrong and misinformed.
So does the term "idiot" mean something lesser of a rude term in your native language? As far as I know the word is very similar even in spelling in many languages:
idiot in Dutch is idioot
idiot in French is idiot
idiot in Italian is idiota
idiot in Norwegian is idiot
idiot in Swedish is idiot
idiot in Portuguese is idiota
Which one is your native language and how does it differ from the meaning it has in english?
And finally harshness in the way you write or address to people is way different from rudeness. You can be harsh and still polite. You can just say what you want without sweetening the pill and convey your message and still maintain respectability. You just have to look at George and take a leaf out of his book. He is a self admitting harsh and direct person with what he writes but still maintains a gentlemanly attitude with whatever he writes. Whether you agree with him or not there is always a sense of respectability. I haven't seen him using terminology that falls below the standard of respectability.
Comment by aminstar posted on And it's goodbye from me at 08/09/2009 - 13:15
I have seen some extraordinary language and attitudes elsewhere, it simply NEVER happens here.
Amin, I think this is still on topic, because I want to defend a brilliant, informative and friendly forum.
I read all 13 (was it?) pages as they appeared.
But hey, I still like this forum, that's why I get withdrawals symptoms when I am away for many hours and now I have reverted to come for a fix in the middle of the night every day
Comment by aminstar posted on And it's goodbye from me at 08/09/2009 - 10:21
I don't remember anyone getting all funny about brands and picking on the op, all I remember was constructive and technically accurate advice to counter over confidence, followed by defensiveness and misunderstandings.
For me it made good reading.
It went properly sour when one of the newbies (who happens to have made thousands of posts) got all silly, but hopefully he has gone now (as he promised)
Comment by aminstar posted on And it's goodbye from me at 08/09/2009 - 09:47
But I fully understand and can relate to that feeling. I started here hardly a few months ago, not sure if these exchanges already existed before but for a good few months I didn't notice anything, it was pretty smooth, but then suddenly it all went pear shaped. Sad but true.
Its pretty sad when things come to this extreme and name calling to tutors, court action threats etc start proliferating in the forum. It just turns the once so friendly forum into a an unwelcoming place
Comment by aminstar posted on And it's goodbye from me at 08/09/2009 - 09:38
Karl I am struggling to see a mermaid . I can just about make out the alien, the fact that you said long mouth does help to visualise. But I will keep insisting. I can see the bottom part similar to mermaid but its the rest that I am struggling with.
Thanks
Comment by aminstar posted on All in the mind at 08/09/2009 - 03:53
EDITED: I see it , it was the flowing hair that helped me tune the imagination, I could see the shoulders but couldn't make sense of the rest but when you mentioned flowing hair and clear hips and shoulders I kept that image in mind and tried to allocate the parts and immediately I could see the patterns forming .
Thanks George.
Comment by aminstar posted on All in the mind at 07/09/2009 - 23:18
An Oscar (slightly melted)..?
Mat
Comment by aminstar posted on All in the mind at 07/09/2009 - 23:02


I do think that one measure of a man (or woman) is his ability to acknowledge a mistake, and then to apologise.
G