aminstar

Joined: 30th December 2008

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

aminstar
George Lazarette wrote:
Beats me how HCB and all those other so-called great photographers managed to take any good pictures at all.

I mean, everybody knows that fast auto-focus is the sine qua non of a good photograph. Especially for still-lifes, landscapes, reclining nudes, etc., etc..

Methinks some people spend too long reading advertisements - and, what is worse, believing them!

G
You confuse me now with your comment George. Particularly with your latin phrase. If my translation is correct it stands for indispensable, essential, condition, or ingredient or if we go further and take the Wiki meaning of it "(a condition) without which it could not be" or "but for..." or "without which (there is) nothing" then you are just concurring with many of us in criticising Pentax for not having a faster AF.

Could this be a first where we see you criticising an aspect that Pentax really lags behind? Or was it just a mere confusion from yourself while using the latin terminology and what you really wanted to imply was that we who keep pointing the big AF flaw in the Pentax system should really just go and improve our technique.

And also I don't get it with regard to "still-lifes, landscapes, reclining nudes, etc., etc.." needing fast AF, I thought these are the types of photography where fast AF is not really needed.

But then again, what do I know? I am just a novice and I still have a lot to learn and worse still probably been spending too long reading advertisements - and, believing them!

Comment by aminstar posted on Slow AF? at 17/02/2010 - 09:03

aminstar
Anvh wrote:

Wasn't there a preproduction version of the K7 that was very fast, you and Mike I believed tried it at SRS.

Yes that pre-production model was fast, but to be quite honest and after trying other systems I can categorically say that even that pre-production model wasn't fast to the same standards of 7D for example.
Irony is if the K7 released for sale was at least as fast as that pre-production model then I would be using one, and me and Unlocker and the likes wouldn't be complaining so much

Hardgravity wrote:
and having seen comments on here about speed/reliability I don't think I want one!
Is speed and reliability of AF inversely proportional? Hmm, in my short experience in the field at least I haven't noticed it, everytime I have heard that beep sound and released the shutter I have nailed the focus, and the times that the shots were OOF the problem was me.
So I hope Pentax is not using that as an excuse for not coming out with a faster AF, its a feeble one and non valid. You just have to see the examples like the one Mike-P mentioned about having a dog running towards you and then firing the shutter and checking what percentage of focused shots you got.

And yess the burst rate seems like a bonus but one that I haven't got into yet. And now that you mention may be I should give it a thought and try to take advantage of it. I just can't imagine situations where it could be well used. A few times I used I just ended up bored with the number of almost similar shots that I had to process so I stopped using burst mode. But may be I should have a go again and different situations and see. In my view though the burst mode of the K7 seems far adequate. So there you go, each individual has different priorities

Comment by aminstar posted on Slow AF? at 15/02/2010 - 09:12

aminstar
Anvh wrote:

Glad to make a Canon user jealous

ps another film K7 vs 7D link
The K7 isn't doing it that bad right, I wonder if they could throw more power over the contacts to make the SDM move faster.
Hmm, Stephan I think by showing that clip you just put one more nail on the argument about Pentax sluggish AF. Watch how quick the white 70-200 f/4.0 locks in, while with the K7 seems exactly what Mike mentioned, old age pensioner would have run a 100 meters flat before it had locked in

Comment by aminstar posted on Slow AF? at 14/02/2010 - 19:57

aminstar
Anvh wrote:
I wonder if they could throw more power over the contacts to make the SDM move faster.
If they manage to make the SDM lenses faster there is certainly one person I know of who will seriously consider ditching all his Canon kit and jump back into Pentax . Specially because he bought his Canon gear at a discount and would be selling at a premium.

Oh and now that I have been told that Pentax also has multi coloured lenses (Thanks for the info Stephan) more of a reason to think about it.

So, Pentax, if you are reading this please think about making SDM lenses faster please

Comment by aminstar posted on Slow AF? at 14/02/2010 - 19:50

aminstar
K10D wrote:
as long as this video lark is a marketing priority.

Regards
Hmm, I like the ability of having video on a DSLR, what's wrong with that? Although it might not put me off buying a good video camera but knowing that its there if I ever want to use it, which I eventually will its something great. Its like the cruise control in my car, don't use it often nor I will go out to buy a car with one but certainly is a plus point when making a decision to buy one.

Besides the argument still stands, if others can make a quicker AF why can't Pentax make it too?

Comment by aminstar posted on Slow AF? at 14/02/2010 - 18:59

aminstar
Hardgravity wrote:


Last time I stood next to a Canon user my K200d and Sigma 18-200 were focussing quicker than his White thing on his 450!
Are you sure his white thing was a lens?

Hardgravity wrote:

Try comparing the K-x and standard lens with a EOS450 and standard lens then you see the difference.

I am no expert in the matter but I would have thought that SDM lenses are in the forefront of technology and one of the latest models so comparing it to some of those "white things" for example would be fair. Aren't some of those white things a few good years old? How old is the canon 70-200 IS f/4.0 for example? And in terms of price aren't they more or less similar along with a DA*60-250? So sticking one of these "white things" on an old canon model should then be similar to a K7 with an SDM lens then, isn't that right?

Let me reiterate, I am not bashing Pentax, just stating the facts.

Comment by aminstar posted on Slow AF? at 14/02/2010 - 18:14

aminstar
pink wrote:
is there any actual proof that one system is faster or is it all hearsay

James
Yes there is actual proof that one system is faster, definitely not all hearsay.

Mike-P wrote:

Whether Pentax are that far behind in the AF stakes is debatable but SDM certainly does not help the cause.
Exactly what I have been saying, fully agree with that comment Mike.

Anvh wrote:
the DA40 is a real speed demon, it can focus to close up to infinite and back in less then a second and it looks it's so because of the small focus throw.
Now this really nails the argument. If Pentax can make DA40 so fast at focusing why on earth wouldn't they make their newer and expensive SDM lenses fast also? This I fail to comprehend. In fact the sluggishness of the DA*60-250 was so annoying that I used to pull my hair everytime I tried to focus and now I have ended up with little hair. And if I had kept at it I would have lost the rest of it too.

Stephen, not sure how to compare the speed but I can reliably say that its lightning fast, and accurate. But hey, I am just a novice so what do I know? May be its just me that do not know how to focus properly and finding that the 7D AF is very fast might just be in my head and I am just imagining things.

Comment by aminstar posted on Slow AF? at 14/02/2010 - 18:07

aminstar
Mike, how come that pic of yours is not in the Pentax Gallery? How strange, I would have thought that this image is among some of your best ones

Comment by aminstar posted on pentax 50-135 f2.8 at 14/02/2010 - 12:25

aminstar
Mike-P wrote:
At least you had pictures on your Flickr site when you had a Pentax Amin .. I rarely see anything from your 7D on there.
The ones I have done lately are not suitable for my flickr page

Besides, I just did it because I like white lenses ....
hey,,,, just joking, I am not racist

Comment by aminstar posted on Slow AF? at 14/02/2010 - 12:01

aminstar
I think calling the Pentax AF slow must be a bit misleading as most pentax users are quite happy with it and achieve everything that they want from it, and even some manage to focus accurately and fast enough as many using D300s and 7Ds.

I think the question is only if someone wants to adapt themselves and learn ways that are not straightforward to lock the AF on the subjects or not.

For most things usually D300 and 7D users just have to aim and AF and it gets there faster than the pentax. But let me tell you one thing that prehaps only a 7D or D300 user knows, to achieve that little extra that many people sometimes think that you can get from the 7D or D300 camera and lenses if they think its just purely the same way as point and press the shutter release button then they will have a huge disappointment. And I am sure there are a few who changed systems who might have started finding this out, and then regretting moving over sacrificing other better aspects that the Pentax gear has in comparision to their new kit.

In order to take full advantage of the faster Af system of the 7D for example is quite complicated. The tweaks and menu systems and so many small details that one has to be constantly on top of it and keep changing depending on circumstances its enough to put someone who doesn't like to keep dwelling and learning and updating on it totally off. Unless you are prepared to do it then forget about a generally faster system than the pentax. I have seen many who just jump into a system simply because they thought Ahh, faster AF and then keep complaining that they can't lock focus on a moving subject. Forget flying birds and moving cars, I know some complain even of not locking AF on moving kids. And then they keep complaining also that they were better off with their older models.
So, overall its not exactly plain sailing. I am absolutely sure that a good proportion of people who move systems they just do it without properly researching and have higher expectations and then regret it.

Comment by aminstar posted on Slow AF? at 14/02/2010 - 11:55

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo