Boat 2

Reminds me of the so called moon landing shots - shadows here but not there! The original was clearly composed with the shadow as a factor and this clearly is not. Stick with the original, I suggest.
Paul.

You have done this very well but I can't make my mind up if this is better,
anyway still a nice shot,
Jack

Nice shot Magnus, lovely colours especially the water and the depth of field is spot on

Nice crisp shot, but I prefer the shadow. Looks like a manatee.

Don't really like the selective blurring of the background. Just looks unnatural to me, especially the difference in sharpness between the motor and the orange buoy.

Nice colours and subject though.

Dan