Wide Angle or Fish Eyes?

simonkit
Posted 18/08/2010 - 12:05 Link
Regarding the wide angle, if I were in your position I would spend a bit more time taking landscape shots before deciding on a UWA lens. Personally I've owned and then sold one (Sigma 10-20)as I just found that it didn't suit my photography "style" - as Banjo mentioned too much lost detail in the distance & "effects" caused by the perspective(I much prefer the Pentax DA 17-70 for landscapes.

Also with landscapes the chances are that you will be using apertures around F11/F16 to emphasise depth, at these apertures the IQ difference between primes and zooms is not quite so significant as it is when using larger apertures (F2.8 etc) so the added flexibility of a zoom may well be more beneficial.

Simon
BigJacko
Posted 18/08/2010 - 13:31 Link
Some crackingly good comments on this thread, imho. Especially the words of warning.

I too have recently purchased a K-x and have fallen in love with photgraphy all over again, because of it.

I've got a bunch of old lenses hanging around from film days, including a Vivitar 28mm f2.8 (with Ricoh P-pin removed!) which probably isn't as pin-sharp as the Pentax equivalent that Dangermouse is referring to, but which is pretty good, all the same. Price on Ebay? Probably less than a tenner.

I've also got an old Ricoh/Rikonen 50mm f1.7 (also with the P-pin removed) which does a fine job, although again, it's probably not quite as excellent as a Pentax-M f1.7 - but it is a bit cheaper, and probably is worth about a tenner also.

But the thing is, despite specifically buying a Pentax so that I could re-use these old lenses, because they are both manual focus, manual aperture lenses, they're a bit of a pain to operate. Sure, you can use stop-down metering to get the K-x to set the right shutter speed for the aperture you've dialled in, and this process is little more than the press of the Green Button. And, sure, manual-focus isn't that tough either - the green hexagon and the bleep still works...

... but for me, the extra complication, on top of getting to grips with the K-x itself, was really something I didn't enjoy much - because the results were so unpredictable and variable (at first).

This is something you might want to think about if you're new to the K-x (and indeed, new to SLR photography as well). Fully manual lenses take some practice, and are unforgiving at first... and your 18-55mm fully-autofocus/autoaperture zoom is, by comparison, MUCH more user-friendly and MUCH more likely to get you some initial results that'll boost confidence and make you happy.

When you're so slick with the 18-55 that it's virtually boring, perhaps then's the time to go playing with manual lenses? There'll still be plenty on eBay.

Alternatively, I managed to pick up a Pentax-A 50mm f2.0 from this very forum (thanks again, Simon!) for next to nothing - and at least that means all I have to worry about is the manual focus (the aperture is controlled by the K-x). On eBay, these are going from anywhere between 20 and 40 quid. The benefit (and imho, sole purpose) of fast 50mm primes, whether fully-manual (Pentax-M) or auto-aperture (Pentax-A) is that the wide apertures are great for throwing the background into massive defocus when taking head-and-shoulders portraits. Call me a luddite, but for anything else, I'd personally not bother to take my 18-55 kit lens off. My Ricoh (f1.7) is 'technically' better at that job than the Pentax-A (f2.0), by a third-of-stop - but the added hassle of working the manual aperture/stop-down-metering means I rarely use it. If I'm doing a portrait, and the kit lens doesn't give me enough background bokeh, then it's on with the Pentax-A.

As for my 28mm lens, I virtually don't use it at all. I can do pretty much everything it does, with my kit lens - and more so. I can come out wider - to 18mm (effective 27mm in 35mm terms) - whereas the Vivitar 28mm will only get me down to an effective 42mm in 35mm terms - and frankly, that's not far off what used to be a portrait lens on my old film SLR camera! The difference in aperture wideness on the Vivitar 28mm (f2.8 at its max) compared to the kit lens (f3.5 at 18mm) is only 2/3rds of a stop - which isn't *that* crucial, really. Ok, so it is 60% more light available on the Vivitar at max aperature - but what I'm getting it is that the situations where this is going to be a 'deal-breaker' are few and far between. You're unlikely to require the extra aperture width for background blur if you're taking a landscape, and you're unlikely to find that the extra light is required - if the light's that bad, either lens is not going to give the best result on a landscape/wide-angle shot. It would only really make a difference if the Vivitar was being used for portraiture, imho - in which case, the whole 'wide-angle' argument is moot.

Ok - so down to the bottom end (but the top end pricewise) - Fisheyes vs UWAs... I was lucky enough to be lent a Pentax 10-17 fisheye last weekend by Steve Chasey (thanks Steve) at a meetup. Sure, it's a fun little lens, and I was able to take some really cool 180-degree wide-angle shots in the cafe, and experience the 'fisheye' effect in full. But it was very obvious, very quickly, that this lens was a one-trick pony. It makes 'fisheye' photos - nothing more, nothing less. I would very quickly tire of that effect - even though it's very creative, and lots of fun - because it's so unnatural, and so obviously, er, fisheye!

Then and there, I decided once and for all, that if I was going to go for a lens 'below' my 18-55mm K-x kit lens, it would be the Sigma 10-20mm UWA, which has perspective correction built into it. I've ruled out the Pentax 12-24 for the same reasons you have - it doesn't go down far enough, and it overlaps the kit lens too much, whereas the Sigma 10-20 is 2mm 'better off!'. And most importantly, as seen in the posts above, it renders straight verticals - which means the shots it makes are (broadly speaking) conventional. The 'gimmick' is gone, and the creativity is more about what you do with it, than the effect. And of course, if you really want a fisheye effect, you can knock that up in Photoshop in seconds anyway!

So... in my opinion - stick with what you have for now. Learn it. Play with it. Push it to its limits. You'll be able to do most things that you want with it. When you've found the boundaries, think again about what lenses you want. If you want a 'reasonable' portrait lens for cheap prices, there are hundreds of decent f2s & f1.7 50mms to be had (but a Pentax-A f1.4 50mm will of course set you back hundreds of pounds, even now!). Same goes for 28mm lenses - they can be had for peanuts.

If you really run into problems stitching together panoramas taken with your kit-lens, and really, really decide you need a wide-angle, I'd go for one that will get used a lot, rather than played with a few times and then put back in the case... the straight-vertical, rather than the fisheye.

Of course, this is just my opinion, and I fully expect to be jumped on for it - but I really would say, either way - save your money for now, and look at it later when you've squeezed all the juice out of your current kit... I don't think anyone would argue with that bit!
Neil
≡≡≡≡
Pentax K-x ♥ Pentax DA L 18-55mm f3.5-5.6 AL ♣ Pentax DA L 55-300mm f4-5.8 ED ♦ Pentax A 50mm f2.0 ♠ Pentax AF360FGZ flash ♥ Rikenon P 50mm f1.7 ♣ Vivitar CF 28mm f2.8 (K02 Komine) ♦ Tokina 80-200mm f4 ♠ Vivitar MC 2x22 Tele Converter

"Rules are for the obedience of fools and the guidance of wise men" - Douglas 'Tin-Legs' Bader
Rowmac
Posted 18/08/2010 - 13:42 Link
simonkit wrote:

Also with landscapes the chances are that you will be using apertures around F11/F16 to emphasise depth, at these apertures the IQ difference between primes and zooms is not quite so significant as it is when using larger apertures (F2.8 etc) so the added flexibility of a zoom may well be more beneficial.

Simon
Pardon my lack of knowledge but IQ?
Had a brief look at some of your landscape photos and they look very good. If I may ask, how did you balance exposure between land and sky? Every time I make an attempt at landscapes, my K-x either adjusts according to the sky and land comes out underexposed or it picks land and the sky is far too bright. Any tips?
Pentax K-x, 18-55mm & 50-200mm Kit lenses, Pentax FA 50mm F1.4 Prime "DSLR & Photography for Dummies", Gorillapod SLR-Zoom, Hama Profil Duo II Tripod
Anvh
Posted 18/08/2010 - 14:31 Link
Rowmac wrote:
Pardon my lack of knowledge but IQ?
Had a brief look at some of your landscape photos and they look very good. If I may ask, how did you balance exposure between land and sky? Every time I make an attempt at landscapes, my K-x either adjusts according to the sky and land comes out underexposed or it picks land and the sky is far too bright. Any tips?
IQ = Image Quality

For the exposure problems, that's why there are GND (graduated neutral density) filters.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graduated_neutral_density_filter
Stefan
Comment Image

K10D, K5
DA* 16-50, DA* 50-135, D-FA 100 Macro, DA 40 Ltd, DA 18-55
AF-540FGZ
Edited by Anvh: 18/08/2010 - 14:32
Rowmac
Posted 18/08/2010 - 14:34 Link
Anvh wrote:
Rowmac wrote:
Pardon my lack of knowledge but IQ?
Had a brief look at some of your landscape photos and they look very good. If I may ask, how did you balance exposure between land and sky? Every time I make an attempt at landscapes, my K-x either adjusts according to the sky and land comes out underexposed or it picks land and the sky is far too bright. Any tips?
IQ = Image Quality

For the exposure problems, that's why there are GND (graduated neutral density) filters.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graduated_neutral_density_filter
Cheers!
Pentax K-x, 18-55mm & 50-200mm Kit lenses, Pentax FA 50mm F1.4 Prime "DSLR & Photography for Dummies", Gorillapod SLR-Zoom, Hama Profil Duo II Tripod
Dr. Mhuni
Posted 18/08/2010 - 15:56 Link
Quote:
I was lucky enough to be lent a Pentax 10-17 fisheye last weekend by Steve Chasey (thanks Steve) at a meetup. Sure, it's a fun little lens, and I was able to take some really cool 180-degree wide-angle shots in the cafe, and experience the 'fisheye' effect in full. But it was very obvious, very quickly, that this lens was a one-trick pony. It makes 'fisheye' photos - nothing more, nothing less. I would very quickly tire of that effect - even though it's very creative, and lots of fun - because it's so unnatural, and so obviously, er, fisheye!
To be fair, the 10-17 is more than just a one trick pony - it also doesn't have to bend everything and can be used for interesting landscapes, though you do have to be careful. Here's a few examples of mine - link link link. None of these have been defished - if you keep the horizon near the centre that won't be distorted at all and the distortion at the edges won't necessarily be obvious.

For more examples of the adaptability and quality of this lens see this thread: link

Having said that, it's not the most obvious landscape lens. But I certainly wouldn't dismiss it entirely.
Mhuni

500px
BigJacko
Posted 18/08/2010 - 18:29 Link
Dr. Mhuni wrote:
Quote:
But it was very obvious, very quickly, that this lens was a one-trick pony. It makes 'fisheye' photos - nothing more, nothing less. I would very quickly tire of that effect - even though it's very creative, and lots of fun - because it's so unnatural, and so obviously, er, fisheye!
To be fair, the 10-17 is more than just a one trick pony - it also doesn't have to bend everything and can be used for interesting landscapes, though you do have to be careful. Here's a few examples of mine - link link link. None of these have been defished - if you keep the horizon near the centre that won't be distorted at all and the distortion at the edges won't necessarily be obvious.

For more examples of the adaptability and quality of this lens see this thread: link

Having said that, it's not the most obvious landscape lens. But I certainly wouldn't dismiss it entirely.
Fair points, Mhuni - certainly your photos are all very classy, and conceal the fisheye-ness extremely well, despite being very much at or near the 'short' end in all three cases. However, you've concealed the effect principally because there's little or no foreground detail anywhere near the edges (side, top or bottom) of the frame, hence the 'crazy verticals' problem doesn't show up. In the middle-to-far distance, I agree, the problem goes away to a much greater extent, but I can still see just a hint of 'fishyness' about them - though it's hard to pin it down as to what gives it away.

Conversely, the beer-bottle shot in the thread you mentioned, is a classic example of a time when I'd prefer a straight-vertical rather than a fisheye. Ok, so the shooter has aimed for a particular effect and got it, creating an interesting and funky photo in the process - but I hate to say it... to me, that effect is rather cliché and hackneyed now, and this is what I meant about it being a bit of a one-trick pony. Other than by the methods you used above, it can't really escape from the fact that it's a bit of a bendy-lens, if there's frame-edge stuff closer than a few tens of yards!

Certainly, if money was no object, I would have one of these 10-17 fisheyes in my collection though, without a doubt. Who wouldn't? But alas, money is an object, and I'd personally elect for the 10-20 Sigma first, if I was going down that route. Yes, I'd love to have both; but I'd also love to do a bare-nekkid photo-shoot with Angeline Jolie, but I can't see that happening soon, either! I live in perpetual hope, though, like most of us...
Neil
≡≡≡≡
Pentax K-x ♥ Pentax DA L 18-55mm f3.5-5.6 AL ♣ Pentax DA L 55-300mm f4-5.8 ED ♦ Pentax A 50mm f2.0 ♠ Pentax AF360FGZ flash ♥ Rikenon P 50mm f1.7 ♣ Vivitar CF 28mm f2.8 (K02 Komine) ♦ Tokina 80-200mm f4 ♠ Vivitar MC 2x22 Tele Converter

"Rules are for the obedience of fools and the guidance of wise men" - Douglas 'Tin-Legs' Bader
Dangermouse
Posted 18/08/2010 - 19:34 Link
Some of the Tokina PK-A 28mm f2.8 lenses aren't bad either. I bought one as "spares or repairs, focus jammed" for £7, after fixing that (I think it had been dropped on a beach as the focussing mechanism had jumped its bearing and there was a fair bit of sand in the helicoil too) it's not a bad performer. It doesn't feel anything like as nice as a Pentax lens but it cost a good deal less than even a damaged Pentax-A 28mm f2.8 and I think it's pretty close behind in terms of IQ. I would have to post a photo of it for a positive ID as I know there have been several different series of Tokina lenses - does anyone know of a site like the K mount one covering them?

Angelina Jolie? I think I'd rather Dita von Teese...
Matt

Shooting the Welsh Wilderness with K-m, KX, MX, ME Super and assorted lenses.
BigJacko
Posted 18/08/2010 - 20:18 Link
Been looking for a Tokina data-site myself - if you find one, do please let me know, too!

Dita von Teese? Hmmm... had her.. she was rubbish. Bit '19-Forties' for my tastes.
Neil
≡≡≡≡
Pentax K-x ♥ Pentax DA L 18-55mm f3.5-5.6 AL ♣ Pentax DA L 55-300mm f4-5.8 ED ♦ Pentax A 50mm f2.0 ♠ Pentax AF360FGZ flash ♥ Rikenon P 50mm f1.7 ♣ Vivitar CF 28mm f2.8 (K02 Komine) ♦ Tokina 80-200mm f4 ♠ Vivitar MC 2x22 Tele Converter

"Rules are for the obedience of fools and the guidance of wise men" - Douglas 'Tin-Legs' Bader
Rowmac
Posted 18/08/2010 - 20:43 Link
Dangermouse wrote:

Angelina Jolie? I think I'd rather Dita von Teese...
Hear hear!
Pentax K-x, 18-55mm & 50-200mm Kit lenses, Pentax FA 50mm F1.4 Prime "DSLR & Photography for Dummies", Gorillapod SLR-Zoom, Hama Profil Duo II Tripod
Edited by Rowmac: 18/08/2010 - 20:44
Dangermouse
Posted 18/08/2010 - 22:35 Link
BigJacko wrote:
Been looking for a Tokina data-site myself - if you find one, do please let me know, too!
Veering off into a discussion of Tokina K-fit lenses now - I have the 28mm prime and a 28-85 zoom, which I acquired by accident as I was after the black ME Super behind it. The latter is an AT-X which from what I can work out was their premium range, it produced some very respectable results on my Super A with black and white film when tried, although as it was fairly bright daylight I was hovering around the f8 sweet spot of most lenses. It also takes 62mm filters which is larger than anything else I own!
Matt

Shooting the Welsh Wilderness with K-m, KX, MX, ME Super and assorted lenses.
petrochemist
Posted 20/08/2010 - 10:12 Link
Dangermouse wrote:


Wide angle does eventually become fisheye, although I'm not sure at what point.
Actually this is wrong.
Wide angles are rectilinear. Fisheyes use different designs (4 basic types - orthogonal, equidistant and two others I cant remember) which give much greater field of view.
From the online field of view calculators I've played with even with an impossibly short focal length of 0.1mm you don't get close to 180° FOV with rectilinear.
Pentax's 10-17 fisheye manages 180 on the diagonal, & Sigma do one thats 180 all round.

Mike
Mike
.
Pentax:K5ii, K7, K100D, DA18-55, DA10-17, DA55-300, DA50-200, F100-300, F50, DA35 AL, 4* M50, 2* M135, Helicoid extension, Tak 300 f4 (& 6 film bodies)
3rd Party: Bigmos (Sigma 150-500mm OS HSM),2* 28mm, 100mm macro, 28-200 zoom, 35-80 zoom, 80-200 zoom, 80-210 zoom, 300mm M42, 600 mirror, 1000-4000 scope, 50mm M42, enlarger lenses, Sony & micro 4/3 cameras with various PK mounts, Zenit E...
Far to many tele-converters, adapters, project parts & extension tubes etc.

.[size=11:].Flickr• WPF• Panoramio
johnwhit
Posted 20/08/2010 - 10:58 Link
http://www.bobatkins.com/photography/technical/field_of_view.html

Probably the most common is the equisolid angle projection, and the FOV at infinity focus is given by:

FOV (equisolid fisheye) = 4 * arcsin (frame size/(focal length * 4))

Also popular is the equidistance projection, and for the the field of view is given by:

FOV (equidistance fisheye) = (frame size/focal length)*57.3
(the 57.3 is to convert from radians to degrees).

Less common are the orthogonal projection which gives the following field of view:

FOV (orthogonal fisheye) = 2 * arcsin (frame size/(focal length *2)

and the stereographic projection which gives:

FOV (stereographic fisheye) = 4 * arctan (frame size/(focal length * 4))

Regards,

John
PPG link

In LBA hiatus.
Rowmac
Posted 20/08/2010 - 13:34 Link
Mike and John,

You've cleared it up a little better for me. Fisheyes have a much greater initial curvature on the front lens than rectilinear giving fish eyes their 180 degree advantage. I now know it's possible to go for a short focal length without going full fisheye. Thanks guys!
Pentax K-x, 18-55mm & 50-200mm Kit lenses, Pentax FA 50mm F1.4 Prime "DSLR & Photography for Dummies", Gorillapod SLR-Zoom, Hama Profil Duo II Tripod
robbie_d
Posted 20/08/2010 - 14:48 Link
johnwhit wrote:
http://www.bobatkins.com/photography/technical/field_of_view.html

Probably the most common is the equisolid angle projection, and the FOV at infinity focus is given by:

FOV (equisolid fisheye) = 4 * arcsin (frame size/(focal length * 4))

Also popular is the equidistance projection, and for the the field of view is given by:

FOV (equidistance fisheye) = (frame size/focal length)*57.3
(the 57.3 is to convert from radians to degrees).

Less common are the orthogonal projection which gives the following field of view:

FOV (orthogonal fisheye) = 2 * arcsin (frame size/(focal length *2)

and the stereographic projection which gives:

FOV (stereographic fisheye) = 4 * arctan (frame size/(focal length * 4))

Regards,

John
Damn, you beat me to it...
If you can't say something nice about Pentax, you won't say anything at all.

Apparently.

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo