Which one? speed or FL?
This topic has a poll - login to enter
Posted 07/12/2012 - 01:17
Link
You can't compare apples and lemons. They're two different fruits. Same goes for your lens choice.
Yves (another one of those crazy Canucks)
Posted 07/12/2012 - 07:03
Link
I wouldn't be able to choose between them because they have different purposes.
If you had asked which would I find most useful, it'd be the 30mm.
If I wanted/needed both focal lengths, then I'd buy both lenses, or more probably, a zoom covering both lengths.
Pentax has a number of zoom options, DA 16-45mm, DA17-70mm, and DA*16-50mm. There are also plenty of third party zooms covering those two lengths.
With regard to shutter speed, the lenses have a difference of 1.5 f-stops wide open, so for any given scenario, the 30mm 1:1.7 lens could use 1.5 stops faster shutter speed than the 18mm 1:2.8 to achieve the same exposure.
Here's a chart showing the correlation between f stop, shutter speed, ISO, and Exposure Value (EV).
Though at those apertures, depth of field (DOF) is perhaps more important and the 30mm wide open will have a quite shallow DOF.
If you had asked which would I find most useful, it'd be the 30mm.
If I wanted/needed both focal lengths, then I'd buy both lenses, or more probably, a zoom covering both lengths.
Pentax has a number of zoom options, DA 16-45mm, DA17-70mm, and DA*16-50mm. There are also plenty of third party zooms covering those two lengths.
With regard to shutter speed, the lenses have a difference of 1.5 f-stops wide open, so for any given scenario, the 30mm 1:1.7 lens could use 1.5 stops faster shutter speed than the 18mm 1:2.8 to achieve the same exposure.
Here's a chart showing the correlation between f stop, shutter speed, ISO, and Exposure Value (EV).
Though at those apertures, depth of field (DOF) is perhaps more important and the 30mm wide open will have a quite shallow DOF.
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream
Posted 07/12/2012 - 07:34
Link
Agree with the comments above....
I would not recommend a 18mm lens for portraits, so if it would have to be one, then I would recommend a 30mm.
But as Mannesty said, you would be better off with a zoom lens (with a 2.8 min aperture?)
What camera do you use? If you have a K-5 or a K-30 the difference in aperture can be compensated by increasing ISO and still having good results.
But out of curiousity: where do you find a 30mm 1.7 or a 18mm 2.8 for Pentax?
I would not recommend a 18mm lens for portraits, so if it would have to be one, then I would recommend a 30mm.
But as Mannesty said, you would be better off with a zoom lens (with a 2.8 min aperture?)
What camera do you use? If you have a K-5 or a K-30 the difference in aperture can be compensated by increasing ISO and still having good results.
But out of curiousity: where do you find a 30mm 1.7 or a 18mm 2.8 for Pentax?
Posted 07/12/2012 - 08:17
Link
As others said, this is like comparing Tuesday to a ball of string
Ken
“We must avoid however, snapping away, shooting quickly and without thought, overloading ourselves with unnecessary images that clutter our memory and diminish the clarity of the whole.” - Henri Cartier-Bresson -
“We must avoid however, snapping away, shooting quickly and without thought, overloading ourselves with unnecessary images that clutter our memory and diminish the clarity of the whole.” - Henri Cartier-Bresson -
Posted 07/12/2012 - 10:00
Link
Well the point is I cant have both, a choice must be made so i think that a "comparison" is valid
Posted 07/12/2012 - 10:26
Link
dannyh wrote:
Well the point is I cant have both, a choice must be made so i think that a "comparison" is valid
As has been said, you can't really compare the two. You'll need to decide which you would use more or accept the compromise of a zoom.Well the point is I cant have both, a choice must be made so i think that a "comparison" is valid
From what you have told us about it's intended use, the 30mm would be my choice as it's a reasonable length for portraits, though not ideal, yet wide enough for most street scenes, though again, not ideal.
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream
Posted 07/12/2012 - 10:41
Link
Get a Tamron 17-50mm f2.8 to have both a reasonably fast aperture and cover both focal lengths.
If I wanted both......,
then I already have a Pentax 35mm f2.4. And a few zooms that would cover the wide end (10-20,12-24, 16-45, 18-55, 18-135). Two of which give WR too.
The 35mm would do instead of the 30mm, and the zoom would do for street because most of the time it would be at f8. Kit lens would do for street
Would like a DA 21mm for street, but its a lot of money
If I wanted both......,
then I already have a Pentax 35mm f2.4. And a few zooms that would cover the wide end (10-20,12-24, 16-45, 18-55, 18-135). Two of which give WR too.
The 35mm would do instead of the 30mm, and the zoom would do for street because most of the time it would be at f8. Kit lens would do for street
Would like a DA 21mm for street, but its a lot of money
Posted 07/12/2012 - 11:06
Link
It does occur to me that there is no 30 1.7 Pentax fit lens that I am aware of, and indeed apart from 3rd party manual lenses, no 18 2.8 either. So the question is - what body are you planning on putting them on? - if it is a film camera that changes the equation somewhat!
Tony Milner
Super A, ME Super, MZ6, K5II, Ricoh GR & lenses from 8-500mm
www.amilner.org
www.flickr.com/photos/tonymilner
Super A, ME Super, MZ6, K5II, Ricoh GR & lenses from 8-500mm
www.amilner.org
www.flickr.com/photos/tonymilner
Posted 07/12/2012 - 11:40
Link
dannyh wrote:
Just a general Question/canvassing opinion if you had a choice between a 30mm lens at 1.7, or an 18mm lens at 2.8 which would you go for?
Just an aside what difference on shutter speed would these two give wide open in the same light?
The lens to be used for street shooting and portraits in dimly lit interiors
Daniel.
In terms of 'Pentax' branded prime lenses you closest options are probably DA35mm 2.4 (or the older FA35mm f2) and either the DA15 or DA21... At f3.2 the DA21 is slightly faster than the DA15 (f4 I think) and both would be good choices for street shooting IMO (as is the 35mm and my DFA100mm depending on what I'm going for)Just a general Question/canvassing opinion if you had a choice between a 30mm lens at 1.7, or an 18mm lens at 2.8 which would you go for?
Just an aside what difference on shutter speed would these two give wide open in the same light?
The lens to be used for street shooting and portraits in dimly lit interiors
Daniel.
I would not think the DA15 would be great for 'portrait' (at least in the traditional sense) due to the distortion a ultra-wide lens naturally brings...
I've seen nice portraits from the DA21 and made nice portraits with my FA35
If you're shooting with primes you need more than one of them and each play fairly specific roles in your photography (for you as an artist to decide upon)
If you are on a budget the Tamron 17-50 offer both speed and adaptability and is a fine lens (I have previously owned)
However in my experience, (and not necessarily in line with your own style of photography) speed is not a major factor given the high image quality available at higher ISOs... As such, mine is currently the only vote for 'wider and slower'
Both the DA15 and 21 are on my list of 'must have' lenses although I may be tempted to 'settle' on the DA12-24 despite personally preferring to shoot with primes...
Posted 07/12/2012 - 12:01
Link
Just a point about the poll. If you give two choices and neither is really the right one, some may be tempted to vote randomly as that's the only way to see how the results are going. This makes the poll meaningless.
If you want a poll, then making at least one choice of "no opinion" would enable some of this to be avoided.
If you want a poll, then making at least one choice of "no opinion" would enable some of this to be avoided.
Best regards, John
Posted 07/12/2012 - 13:32
Link
johnriley wrote:
Just a point about the poll. If you give two choices and neither is really the right one, some may be tempted to vote randomly as that's the only way to see how the results are going. This makes the poll meaningless.
If you want a poll, then making at least one choice of "no opinion" would enable some of this to be avoided.
Good point. I haven't voted and therefore can't see how everybody else votes.Just a point about the poll. If you give two choices and neither is really the right one, some may be tempted to vote randomly as that's the only way to see how the results are going. This makes the poll meaningless.
If you want a poll, then making at least one choice of "no opinion" would enable some of this to be avoided.
It might be nice to have a "View the poll results without voting" option within the voting system. As it is, we have to vote to view.
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream
Posted 07/12/2012 - 14:35
Link
We digress, but the reason that polls are secret until you've voted are that there are some people who would want to skew the vote. There are even some, hopefully not on PU!, who like to vote for the "winning side", which is a bit bizarre, but that's what people tell me....
Best regards, John
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


490 posts
15 years
Just an aside what difference on shutter speed would these two give wide open in the same light?
The lens to be used for street shooting and portraits in dimly lit interiors
Daniel.