Which Limited lens?

kingfisher
Posted 14/07/2011 - 20:28 Link
well i had all fa limiteds, none da limited yet.....so if I can pick up only one from 3 fa lenses I'll go for FA43. If you want reasons here they are: rendering, colours, sharpness, allround (fa77 and fa31 are more specialized i think)
if i could choose 2 lenses ....probably FA31 + DA70 will be my choice
Edited by kingfisher: 14/07/2011 - 20:40
Posted 15/07/2011 - 09:52 Link
kingfisher wrote:
well i had all fa limiteds, none da limited yet.....so if I can pick up only one from 3 fa lenses I'll go for FA43. If you want reasons here they are: rendering, colours, sharpness, allround (fa77 and fa31 are more specialized i think)
if i could choose 2 lenses ....probably FA31 + DA70 will be my choice
Having recently acquired the 43 and the 77 I would go for the 43 out of the 2 as it is more general purpose (good for torso and full body portraits and as an inconspicuous walkaround lens). As Kingfisher points out - the 77 is more specialised in that the focal length is more geared towards portraits. Unless you take lots of portraits the 43 would probably get more use.

However, I think I would disagree with the 31 being more specialised than the 43. I would have said 31mm is more useful as a general purpose "normal" focal length. The main reason I don't have the 31 is the cost.

I've never used the 31Ltd but, going on other people's rave reviews, if you are going for one limited lens and cost is no barrier then the 31 may be one you'd get the most use out of. Alternatively, get the 43 (you'll be happy with it) and put the price difference towards your next limited lens...
You will only prise my 43Ltd from my cold, dead hands...
Posted 15/07/2011 - 09:58 Link
=Illustration========

Going on new prices from SRS, for the price of the 31ltd you could get the 43ltd plus:

- for £15 the DA70
- for £29 the DA21

Both also on your list.

If the 31ltd is in your budget then you might want to consider that you could instead afford two from your wishlist.
You will only prise my 43Ltd from my cold, dead hands...
Posted 15/07/2011 - 16:29 Link
43mm ltd, if the rendering is as good as rparmar and kingfisher says it is then why not. Anyone else agree with them? I have used Zeiss Distagon and Makro Planar 100mm and loved how they rendered the images. If its anything like them the 43mm then its a definate buy for me

will have a look at sample images from 77mm and 43mm.
Posted 15/07/2011 - 17:15 Link
Just gone for the 77mm myself as I plan to start doing portraits alot more.
PPGlink
Pentax K-5 with 18-50mm & 50-200mm Kit Lenses, Pentax 55mm f1.4 SMC DA* SDM Lens, Pentax DA 12-24mm , Pentax DA 35mm macro, Pentax SMC FA 77mm Limited, Pentax SMC FA 43mm Ltd, Pentax SMC F 50mm, Sigma 24-70mm, Metz 58 af-2
giofi
Posted 15/07/2011 - 20:15 Link
richardhurst wrote:
Just gone for the 77mm myself as I plan to start doing portraits alot more.
IMO this is the point, depending on your photographic priorities the conclusion might be different.

Personally, I think the FA 31 Limited is really special and I would always recommend it. If interested, there is one for sale for 740 euros.
kingfisher
Posted 17/07/2011 - 16:33 Link
Waheed_Sadaf wrote:
43mm ltd, if the rendering is as good as rparmar and kingfisher says it is then why not. Anyone else agree with them? I have used Zeiss Distagon and Makro Planar 100mm and loved how they rendered the images. If its anything like them the 43mm then its a definate buy for me

will have a look at sample images from 77mm and 43mm.
43limited's rendering is very close to rendering of Zeiss lenses AFAIK - i used to have Contax/Yashica Zeiss lenses - Plannar 50 1.7 and Sonnar 85mm 2.8.
Posted 17/07/2011 - 16:38 Link
Just ordered myself a 43mm to go with the 77mm that's on it's way. This lens buying it far too addictive for my liking!
PPGlink
Pentax K-5 with 18-50mm & 50-200mm Kit Lenses, Pentax 55mm f1.4 SMC DA* SDM Lens, Pentax DA 12-24mm , Pentax DA 35mm macro, Pentax SMC FA 77mm Limited, Pentax SMC FA 43mm Ltd, Pentax SMC F 50mm, Sigma 24-70mm, Metz 58 af-2
kingfisher
Posted 17/07/2011 - 17:04 Link
richardhurst wrote:
Just ordered myself a 43mm to go with the 77mm that's on it's way. This lens buying it far too addictive for my liking!
Oh boy, I have a dejavu
I did exactly the same, won auction for 77 and then when i put my hands on my first limited I ordered 43 immediately. I end up selling them for FA31 + DA50-135 eventually. But I miss 43 in some situations.
Edited by kingfisher: 17/07/2011 - 17:09

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo