which lens would YOU choose?
Posted 08/02/2010 - 01:45
Link
Difficult one James, I've heard good reports about both but never owned either (although I briefly played with a 16-45). I guess that doesn't help much
I think you may find a spread of recommendations for both lenses....
Any particular reason you're not considering the DA 17-70?
I think you may find a spread of recommendations for both lenses....
Any particular reason you're not considering the DA 17-70?
Posted 08/02/2010 - 03:08
Link
Hey Huw! Thanks!....
I don't know. I am thinking the Pentax 17-70 and the 16-50 too are a little past my budget, all things being equal....that is, if the optics are basically equal....why not go for the cheaper?
I don't know. I am thinking the Pentax 17-70 and the 16-50 too are a little past my budget, all things being equal....that is, if the optics are basically equal....why not go for the cheaper?
Pentax K-5, Tamron 17-50, Tamron 70-300, Metz 50 AF-1 flash, and working on buying more lenses in the future. It never ends.
Posted 08/02/2010 - 06:58
Link
The extra range of the 17-70 is very useful for a walkaround lens and at it's "old" price was a no brainer, however following last years price increases it is not such an attractive proposition. For the money I'd go for the Tamron. It's a 2.8 for a start and has had good reviews. (mostly!)
.........all the gear, no idea!
Me super, MX, LX, K5,DA 18-55WR, DA 17-70, DA 55-300, DA40 Ltd, FA50 1.4, Samsung D-Xenon 12-24,Samsung 100mm macro M50 1.7(x3), M28 3.5, M35 2.8, M100macro f4, M135 3.5(+others)
Me super, MX, LX, K5,DA 18-55WR, DA 17-70, DA 55-300, DA40 Ltd, FA50 1.4, Samsung D-Xenon 12-24,Samsung 100mm macro M50 1.7(x3), M28 3.5, M35 2.8, M100macro f4, M135 3.5(+others)
Posted 08/02/2010 - 09:22
Link
I have the Pentax 17-70 F4 SDM. OK it costs more than the Tamron but that extra 20mm at the long end makes it an excellent walk around lens. And it has SDM which makes it quiet too.
It really depends on what you use it for though. I like that little extra zoom on it as I can also use it as a portrait lens (just) if I want to.
It really depends on what you use it for though. I like that little extra zoom on it as I can also use it as a portrait lens (just) if I want to.
Posted 08/02/2010 - 10:34
Link
Hi Vjay,
What prices are you being quoted over there? We have ridiculously high prices here in the UK, but what are they like in the US?
Peter
What prices are you being quoted over there? We have ridiculously high prices here in the UK, but what are they like in the US?
Peter
Z-1p, K-1, P50
F50 1.7. SMC-FAs 24, 35, 50 1.4, 85, 135. HD-FA15-30, DFA24-70, D-FA*70-200. The SMC-FA Limited Trinity.
Metz 45 CL-4, AF500FTZ. AF540FGZ.
Some Mamiya and some Nikon, and a Canon T70.
F50 1.7. SMC-FAs 24, 35, 50 1.4, 85, 135. HD-FA15-30, DFA24-70, D-FA*70-200. The SMC-FA Limited Trinity.
Metz 45 CL-4, AF500FTZ. AF540FGZ.
Some Mamiya and some Nikon, and a Canon T70.
Posted 08/02/2010 - 11:01
Link
I'd be wary of SDM for now - I've read too many reports of it failing. Pentax seem to be good about warranty repairs but if I have a choice between an SDM and non-SDM lens I'll pick the latter.
Matt
Shooting the Welsh Wilderness with K-m, KX, MX, ME Super and assorted lenses.
Shooting the Welsh Wilderness with K-m, KX, MX, ME Super and assorted lenses.
Posted 08/02/2010 - 11:17
Link
Dangermouse wrote:
I'd be wary of SDM for now - I've read too many reports of it failing. Pentax seem to be good about warranty repairs but if I have a choice between an SDM and non-SDM lens I'll pick the latter.
I've had two screw drive failures and none with SDM! I'd be wary of SDM for now - I've read too many reports of it failing. Pentax seem to be good about warranty repairs but if I have a choice between an SDM and non-SDM lens I'll pick the latter.
Okay, I've only had SDM lenses for about a year now, but I have no issue with either system. Even if one fails, you still have MF for the rest of your days shooting and if it's out of warranty, Asahi Photo in Brentford can quickly repair it for a very reasonable cost.
It's a total non issue as far as I'm concerned.
Posted 08/02/2010 - 11:19
Link
I chose a Tamron 17-50mm for the constant f2.8 aperture for low light and shallow depth-of-field. It virtually takes the place of a set of primes.
But you might prefer the greater range of a 17-70mm. If the Pentax is too expensive, there is a Sigma 17-70mm f2.8-4.5. This gets great reviews and user reports. I came pretty close to getting one instead of the Tamron. It's was almost decided with a toss of a coin!
The Pentax 16-45mm would be another good choice if 45mm wasn't too short for you, a highly respected lens. It's a little lighter and cheaper than the others mentioned, and the 16mm is valuable for wide angle photography - more difference from 17 and 18mm than you might think.
I also have a Sigma 18-125mm for when I don't want to change lenses so often, but I wouldn't recommend it over any of the above.
EDIT: corrected specs.
But you might prefer the greater range of a 17-70mm. If the Pentax is too expensive, there is a Sigma 17-70mm f2.8-4.5. This gets great reviews and user reports. I came pretty close to getting one instead of the Tamron. It's was almost decided with a toss of a coin!
The Pentax 16-45mm would be another good choice if 45mm wasn't too short for you, a highly respected lens. It's a little lighter and cheaper than the others mentioned, and the 16mm is valuable for wide angle photography - more difference from 17 and 18mm than you might think.
I also have a Sigma 18-125mm for when I don't want to change lenses so often, but I wouldn't recommend it over any of the above.
EDIT: corrected specs.
~Pete
Posted 08/02/2010 - 11:28
Link
I was facing the same decision as you about 6 months ago (Pentax 16-45, Tamron 17-50 or Sigma 17-70), and I went for the Tamron 17-50. I've never regretted it, it's a great lens and outstanding value for money. I chose it for speed, constant aperture, and sharpness.
I might have been tempted by the Sigma if it was constant aperture (it's 2.8 - 4.5, iceblinker has a typo there). The semi macro facility would have been useful for me in a walkabout lens.
I might have been tempted by the Sigma if it was constant aperture (it's 2.8 - 4.5, iceblinker has a typo there). The semi macro facility would have been useful for me in a walkabout lens.
Tim
AF - Pentax K5, Sigma 10-20/4-5.6, Tamron 17-50/2.8, Sigma 30/1.4, Sigma 70-200/2.8, Tamron 70-300/4-5.6
MF - Vivitar CF 28/2.8, Tamron AD2 90/2.5, MTO 1000/11
Stuff - Metz 58 AF1, Cactus v4, Nikon SB24, Raynox 150, Sigma 1.4x TC, Sigma 2x TC, Kenko 2x macro TC, Redsnapper 283 tripod, iMac 27”, Macbook Pro 17”, iPad, iPhone 3G
Flickr • Fluidr • PPG • Street • Portfolio site
Feel free to edit any of my posted photos! If I post a photo for critique, I want brutal honesty. If you don't like it, please say so and tell me why!
AF - Pentax K5, Sigma 10-20/4-5.6, Tamron 17-50/2.8, Sigma 30/1.4, Sigma 70-200/2.8, Tamron 70-300/4-5.6
MF - Vivitar CF 28/2.8, Tamron AD2 90/2.5, MTO 1000/11
Stuff - Metz 58 AF1, Cactus v4, Nikon SB24, Raynox 150, Sigma 1.4x TC, Sigma 2x TC, Kenko 2x macro TC, Redsnapper 283 tripod, iMac 27”, Macbook Pro 17”, iPad, iPhone 3G
Flickr • Fluidr • PPG • Street • Portfolio site
Feel free to edit any of my posted photos! If I post a photo for critique, I want brutal honesty. If you don't like it, please say so and tell me why!
Posted 08/02/2010 - 13:48
Link
I'll be facing the same decision in a couple of months (30th birthday present time ).
I really am stuck because the Tamron 17-50 has such great reviews (plus Tim has confirmed the IQ as excellent), but I'm so tempted by the DA 17-70 for that little bit of extra range. In terms of 70mm being a good portrait length, though, is F4 wide enough to throw the background out?
As I'm not a big lens swapper, I'm hoping to eventually have a 2 lens walk around kit from 16/17mm - 200/300mm.
I really am stuck because the Tamron 17-50 has such great reviews (plus Tim has confirmed the IQ as excellent), but I'm so tempted by the DA 17-70 for that little bit of extra range. In terms of 70mm being a good portrait length, though, is F4 wide enough to throw the background out?
As I'm not a big lens swapper, I'm hoping to eventually have a 2 lens walk around kit from 16/17mm - 200/300mm.
Matt
GX20; DA 17-70 F4; 18-55 kit; Ricoh 50mm F2; Vivitar 75-205mm F3.8
GX20; DA 17-70 F4; 18-55 kit; Ricoh 50mm F2; Vivitar 75-205mm F3.8
Posted 08/02/2010 - 14:18
Link
I've had the DA16-45 & the DA17-70 - they're both great lenses. The latter being slightly superior optically and considerably better constructed. And it is of course a lot more convenient range wise (though the extra 1mm wide on the former is probably more useful than you would probably think).
However, if I had to choose between the 16-45 & the Tammy, I think I'd go for the latter. I might even opt for it over the DA17-70. The f2.8 is what would decide it for me. Though optically it's no slouch either, judging by photos I've seen taken with it.
However, if I had to choose between the 16-45 & the Tammy, I think I'd go for the latter. I might even opt for it over the DA17-70. The f2.8 is what would decide it for me. Though optically it's no slouch either, judging by photos I've seen taken with it.
Posted 08/02/2010 - 15:18
Link
Pwynnej wrote:
Hi Vjay,
What prices are you being quoted over there? We have ridiculously high prices here in the UK, but what are they like in the US?
Peter
Hi Peter!Hi Vjay,
What prices are you being quoted over there? We have ridiculously high prices here in the UK, but what are they like in the US?
Peter
I am looking at around $400 for either the Tamron 17-50 or the Pentax 16-45. The Pentax 17-70 is around 200 bucks more, and the 16-50 is ridiculously priced IMO. Like around a thousand?
Pentax K-5, Tamron 17-50, Tamron 70-300, Metz 50 AF-1 flash, and working on buying more lenses in the future. It never ends.
Posted 08/02/2010 - 15:19
Link
Dangermouse wrote:
I'd be wary of SDM for now - I've read too many reports of it failing. Pentax seem to be good about warranty repairs but if I have a choice between an SDM and non-SDM lens I'll pick the latter.
exactly my opinion. The SDM drives on Pentax lenses freak me out a little with all the bad news I'm hearing about the failures.
I'd be wary of SDM for now - I've read too many reports of it failing. Pentax seem to be good about warranty repairs but if I have a choice between an SDM and non-SDM lens I'll pick the latter.
Pentax K-5, Tamron 17-50, Tamron 70-300, Metz 50 AF-1 flash, and working on buying more lenses in the future. It never ends.
Posted 08/02/2010 - 15:24
Link
Ok, well thanks to all the good comments about the Pentax 17-70, so its now between that and the Tamron 17-50 (fear of SDM, notwithstanding. LOL)
Thanks to ALL!
Thanks to ALL!
Pentax K-5, Tamron 17-50, Tamron 70-300, Metz 50 AF-1 flash, and working on buying more lenses in the future. It never ends.
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


103 posts
17 years
Boise,
Idaho USA
BTW...getting a good telephoto zoom is step two in my plan.