which Fast Fifty
Posted 10/10/2010 - 22:26
Link
There are certainly many options. On the cheapest end, if you want the sharpest image, get an older generation f/1.7. An F might run as much as the FA, but an A 50/1.7 will be a lot cheaper if you do not mind forsaking auto-focus. One went here for 90 pounds, which is the bargain of a lifetime.
You could also get an older generation f/1.4. These lose out a tiny bit in sharpness in order to gain the extra bit of light. Choose which is more important to you.
Anything faster than f/2 is difficult to focus, especially in the very low light conditions you will want to use them. Images are unlikely to have the clarity you would otherwise achieve. I think that, all in all, f/2 is fast enough with the small viewfinders we have to deal with. And this from someone with two f/1.2 lenses!
Of course incremental improvements cost substantially more money. Whether they are worth it to you or not is a subjective matter. Some prefer to just buy the best lens once and then forget about the whole issue. That's why the FA Limiteds exist.
You could also get an older generation f/1.4. These lose out a tiny bit in sharpness in order to gain the extra bit of light. Choose which is more important to you.
Anything faster than f/2 is difficult to focus, especially in the very low light conditions you will want to use them. Images are unlikely to have the clarity you would otherwise achieve. I think that, all in all, f/2 is fast enough with the small viewfinders we have to deal with. And this from someone with two f/1.2 lenses!
Of course incremental improvements cost substantially more money. Whether they are worth it to you or not is a subjective matter. Some prefer to just buy the best lens once and then forget about the whole issue. That's why the FA Limiteds exist.
Posted 10/10/2010 - 22:45
Link
I have just realised that several additional choices exist, unmentioned so far. I was going to edit my previous post but then realised a couple more responses had happened in the meantime. So I'll weave them into this new post instead.
However one disadvantage to the FA50 is the build, which I find both ugly and unappealing to use. Tactility and design matter to me. That is one superior aspect of the old Takumars, though their coatings and imaging have been improved on significantly since.
If the FA50 is "pin sharp" then I wonder what a better lens would be classified as? The FA43 is the sharpest Pentax lens tested at Photozone from f/2.8 through to f/5.6. (Though I imagine the 50mm macro is sharper.) Even at f/2.0 it is as sharp as the FA 50/1.4 in the centre. Some prefer the DA40 to save a few bucks, but the FA43 is sharper wide open at f/1.9 than the DA40 is at f/2.8!
But sharpness is not everything. The FA Limiteds were purposefully designed to image in a different fashion from standard lenses. In the right conditions, this shows.
Offertonhatter wrote:
FA50 F1.4
Advantages - Light, small, can be used with film SLRs, cheaper, Pin sharp after F2.5
Disadvantages - No weather sealing, no hood (although you can get one for a fiver), no SDM.
You cannot go wrong with the FA 50/1.4 for the price. From my perspective none of the disadvantages listed actually are downers in use. SDM is a toss-up, since sometimes it results in slower focusing or less accurate focusing, even if it is quieter. Weather-sealing for a prime is entirely optional, unless you really are in the habit of shooting in the pouring rain. It is far more important to have the body weather-sealed. Zooms too -- though I took the DA12-24 under Niagara Falls. Your mileage may vary. Don't try this at home (unless you have Niagara Falls at home). Etc. Etc. FA50 F1.4
Advantages - Light, small, can be used with film SLRs, cheaper, Pin sharp after F2.5
Disadvantages - No weather sealing, no hood (although you can get one for a fiver), no SDM.
However one disadvantage to the FA50 is the build, which I find both ugly and unappealing to use. Tactility and design matter to me. That is one superior aspect of the old Takumars, though their coatings and imaging have been improved on significantly since.
If the FA50 is "pin sharp" then I wonder what a better lens would be classified as? The FA43 is the sharpest Pentax lens tested at Photozone from f/2.8 through to f/5.6. (Though I imagine the 50mm macro is sharper.) Even at f/2.0 it is as sharp as the FA 50/1.4 in the centre. Some prefer the DA40 to save a few bucks, but the FA43 is sharper wide open at f/1.9 than the DA40 is at f/2.8!
But sharpness is not everything. The FA Limiteds were purposefully designed to image in a different fashion from standard lenses. In the right conditions, this shows.
Posted 10/10/2010 - 23:39
Link
I tend to find that smaller, faster lenses auto focus faster than longer, slower ones. Presumably the greater light levels make life easier for the camera, and of course the smaller lenses have lighter elements to move.
Matt
Shooting the Welsh Wilderness with K-m, KX, MX, ME Super and assorted lenses.
Shooting the Welsh Wilderness with K-m, KX, MX, ME Super and assorted lenses.
Posted 11/10/2010 - 00:30
Link
To give a real idea of cost, have a look at used pricing. I have bought most of my lenses this way. Right now (or recently, depending on when you read this) the following are/were on offer over at Pentax Forums:
A 50/1.7 for $80
FA 43 Limited for $480
Makes the retail prices look silly.
A 50/1.7 for $80
FA 43 Limited for $480
Makes the retail prices look silly.
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


1172 posts
18 years
UK
FA50 F1.4
Advantages - Light, small, can be used with film SLRs, cheaper, Pin sharp after F2.5
Disadvantages - No weather sealing, no hood (although you can get one for a fiver), no SDM.
DA*55mm F1.4.
Advantages - Weather sealing, SDM focus, hood, fast.
Disadvantages - Longer, (maybe) slower AF, can't be used on film SLR's(although some have said that theyt have been able to, you can't use on Mz-5n and MZ-3 which require an aperture ring), pricier, bigger, heavier.
The other two to consider are sigmas.
Sigma 50mm F1.4 EX DG HSM
Advantages - HSM focus, very good wide open, Able to be used on film SLRs
Disadvantages - Large, not as good stopped down as the Pentax duo, no AF on none SDM cameras.
Sigma 30mm F1.4 EX DC
Advantages - gives the EFOV 45mm in 35mm terms (but remember its still a 30mm), fast
Disadvantages - Not a Fifty, only Digital, no SDM/HSM, larger than the FA
All are good, but difficult choice. Personally, the FA50 is an excellent lens, and someone said the FA50 F1.7 is a tad sharper.
However, I would go for the FA50, not only for its size, but also its versatility.