Various Lenses & Their Uses.
Posted 22/08/2008 - 20:34
Link
OK , i can get a pair of 360's around the price of one 540.
Id like to see some of your shots , especially any martial art ones?
I didnt realise that recycle time was that long - i thought the strobe on the 540 enabled you to fire at around 2 fps , is that something differnt then?
Id like to see some of your shots , especially any martial art ones?
I didnt realise that recycle time was that long - i thought the strobe on the 540 enabled you to fire at around 2 fps , is that something differnt then?
Posted 22/08/2008 - 21:00
Link
Quote:
i thought the strobe on the 540 enabled you to fire at around 2 fps
Well, technically you can. i thought the strobe on the 540 enabled you to fire at around 2 fps
In theory, the lower power you set the flash, the less reserve power it uses. Thus if you set the flash to one half power, you should be able to get two flashes in a row before a recycle is necessary. If you set the flash to 1/16 power, you should be able to fire almost until you blow up the bulb due to overheating.
I have been able to keep the flash down to 1/2 power and shoot maybe two frames in a row, but I have not had consistent luck in practice. It seems PTTL will attempt to override the visible settings and try to push more power from the flash than you'd expect.
I haven't done measurements but it seems to work that way in real life, unless I'm failing to understand another factor that might be changing (and causing power to drain faster than expected).
Sometimes I'll use the trick to set the flash in manual mode at 1/4 power, and the camera in manual mode. This seems to work better.
(turn off the camera, turn on the flash and put in manual mode, then turn on the camera. If the camera times out or you turn the camera on first, the flash will go back to PTTL mode. Sorry, more info than you really want right now, but note it down for later. You'll find it handy if not necessary. )
If you're within a few (ten?) feet or so, you might find 1/4 power good enough. I've been able to shoot four to ten shots in a row before it started to slow down and need a recycle -- same camera settings, manual mode, yet number of flashes is not always consistent. Odd! ( I wouldn't shot for too long without a good cool down anyway!)
I'll try to dig up some old shots.
Looking forward to seeing what you get.
Again, practice a bit up front and see what will work for the environment you'll be in.
Posted 22/08/2008 - 21:20
Link
Interesting , i didnt realise i thought you could just hold the button down and fire away for more than a handfull of shots. So in actual fact, the 360 might fire a few more shots off before needing recharging than the 540 - I wonder if anyone else can comment.
How long do you let the 360 recharge for between your bursts?
One of the locations is going to be the London Excel centre later in the year and i doubt very much ill be able to practice there! so the dojo's will have to do for now.
Cheers.
How long do you let the 360 recharge for between your bursts?
One of the locations is going to be the London Excel centre later in the year and i doubt very much ill be able to practice there! so the dojo's will have to do for now.
Cheers.
Posted 22/08/2008 - 23:27
Link
For the same light output, the 540 should manage at least as many shots as the 360 and perhaps more. But if it's pumping out twice as much light (on max power) the number of shots might well be less.
One thing to remember about high-powered flashguns is that they use a lot of power. Batteries don't last long, and recycling takes a while.
G
One thing to remember about high-powered flashguns is that they use a lot of power. Batteries don't last long, and recycling takes a while.
G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
Posted 22/08/2008 - 23:38
Link
Hi George,
So if i was to use a prime say the 50mm f1.4 ringside with poor lighting would i not then have to use a flash?
So if i was to use a prime say the 50mm f1.4 ringside with poor lighting would i not then have to use a flash?
Posted 23/08/2008 - 00:15
Link
duroo72 wrote:
So if i was to use a prime say the 50mm f1.4 ringside with poor lighting would i not then have to use a flash?
If you want to stop the action, you're going to need a high shutter speed. If the f1.4 can give you 1/250s shutter speed, then no "need" for flash.So if i was to use a prime say the 50mm f1.4 ringside with poor lighting would i not then have to use a flash?
Technically, the shutter speed doesn't have to be very fast since the flash is so much faster than your shutter could ever possibly go. The flash will/should out-blast the ambient light and the ambient light will not expose to make much difference.
The K10D will sync at /180s which is not very fast, but will help cut down motion blur if the ambient light is moderately high. You're still likely to get slight blur on fast action like the snap of a front kick unless the ambient light is quite low in relation to the flash output.
At f4.5 I was getting 1/60s in a gymnasium under fluorescent tubes about 15 feet overhead. With a f1.4 lens, you could get away with 1/250s or even 1/500s, which I would personally find quite acceptable for most shots without a flash.
Sadly, not many lenses come down to f1.4.
Probably a good thing... I'd be living on the street corner with a bag of f1.4 long range lenses.
Posted 23/08/2008 - 01:09
Link
I posted about half a dozen images giving a somewhat broad range of lighting and settings. Hopefully they will give somewhat of a baseline to help visualize possible outcomes.
Obviously you're milage will vary. Also these were back in my istD days. By the time I got the K10D I was roped into to judging if I was not competing and it never got much use.
I wouldn't say they were pro-quality, I was probably using a Tamron 28-300 or Sigma 18-200 lens at the time. Oh how I would like a re-do with the K10 and DA*16-50!! Also with the heads in the shots, I didn't have the best seat in the house.
Anyway, hopefully they help.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/91954128@N00/sets/72157606894014400
BTW: I'll probably take these down in a few days.
Obviously you're milage will vary. Also these were back in my istD days. By the time I got the K10D I was roped into to judging if I was not competing and it never got much use.
I wouldn't say they were pro-quality, I was probably using a Tamron 28-300 or Sigma 18-200 lens at the time. Oh how I would like a re-do with the K10 and DA*16-50!! Also with the heads in the shots, I didn't have the best seat in the house.
Anyway, hopefully they help.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/91954128@N00/sets/72157606894014400
BTW: I'll probably take these down in a few days.
Posted 23/08/2008 - 09:50
Link
You're facing the age-old problem;
low light = low shutter speed
low shutter speed = motion blur
low light = wide aperture
wide aperture = soft pictures
wide aperture = reduced DOF
wide aperture = expensive zoom or no zoom
low light = high ISO
high ISO = low quality
low light = flash
flash = may not be permitted
flash = possible exposure problems (in P-TTL mode)
flash = blinded performers
In other words, compromises have to be made, and your job, as photographer, is to decide which compromises are acceptable.
One thing is for sure. A wide range zoom, with its small maximum aperture and lower optical quality, would not appeal to me.
So, the preferred solution:
K20D for good high ISO
DA* 16-50 for large aperture, swift focussing and high quality
AF 500FTZ (if appropriate) used on manual to avoid exposure problems. Only use P-TTL in variable light.
Now for the bank manager.
G
low light = low shutter speed
low shutter speed = motion blur
low light = wide aperture
wide aperture = soft pictures
wide aperture = reduced DOF
wide aperture = expensive zoom or no zoom
low light = high ISO
high ISO = low quality
low light = flash
flash = may not be permitted
flash = possible exposure problems (in P-TTL mode)
flash = blinded performers
In other words, compromises have to be made, and your job, as photographer, is to decide which compromises are acceptable.
One thing is for sure. A wide range zoom, with its small maximum aperture and lower optical quality, would not appeal to me.
So, the preferred solution:
K20D for good high ISO
DA* 16-50 for large aperture, swift focussing and high quality
AF 500FTZ (if appropriate) used on manual to avoid exposure problems. Only use P-TTL in variable light.
Now for the bank manager.
G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
Posted 23/08/2008 - 10:19
Link
I'll just add to that
Flash = destroyed atmosphere
Meaning that I find flash exposures effectively wreck the ambience of a scene. Personally I would rather have a grainy (noisy) less sharp picture oozing atmosphere than a sharp sterile flash shot. It's a matter of preference and the photographer's style.
It's amazing what you can do with a 50mm f1.4 lens and a high ISO setting!
Flash = destroyed atmosphere
Meaning that I find flash exposures effectively wreck the ambience of a scene. Personally I would rather have a grainy (noisy) less sharp picture oozing atmosphere than a sharp sterile flash shot. It's a matter of preference and the photographer's style.
It's amazing what you can do with a 50mm f1.4 lens and a high ISO setting!
Best regards, John
Posted 23/08/2008 - 10:41
Link
johnriley wrote:
I'll just add to that
Flash = destroyed atmosphere
Meaning that I find flash exposures effectively wreck the ambience of a scene. Personally I would rather have a grainy (noisy) less sharp picture oozing atmosphere than a sharp sterile flash shot. It's a matter of preference and the photographer's style.
It's amazing what you can do with a 50mm f1.4 lens and a high ISO setting!
I don't disagree. But performers often want something bright. The answer is to try and use a mixture of ambient and fill-flash.I'll just add to that
Flash = destroyed atmosphere
Meaning that I find flash exposures effectively wreck the ambience of a scene. Personally I would rather have a grainy (noisy) less sharp picture oozing atmosphere than a sharp sterile flash shot. It's a matter of preference and the photographer's style.
It's amazing what you can do with a 50mm f1.4 lens and a high ISO setting!
G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
Posted 23/08/2008 - 10:59
Link
Thankyou everyone for your contributions , i now feel more informed and aware of what is available and relevant for my next project.
For the Dojo club night shots ill prob see how my kit and 70-300mm with studio lights go for now as i am going to be doing not only fight shots but also creative pose shots as below. If im finding im not getting the result i desire then ill know exactly what i need - ish!


For the Actual Competition shots i will be buying the 50mm f1.4 as after reading the comments posted here i did a search for boxing photography settings and the pros said this was their first choice second was the 1-70mm f2.8 but some found this wasnt fast enough in certain darker locations.
Thankyou
For the Dojo club night shots ill prob see how my kit and 70-300mm with studio lights go for now as i am going to be doing not only fight shots but also creative pose shots as below. If im finding im not getting the result i desire then ill know exactly what i need - ish!

For the Actual Competition shots i will be buying the 50mm f1.4 as after reading the comments posted here i did a search for boxing photography settings and the pros said this was their first choice second was the 1-70mm f2.8 but some found this wasnt fast enough in certain darker locations.
Thankyou
Posted 23/08/2008 - 13:02
Link
Can't disagree about flash ruining the atmosphere, (I think I did mention how awful some of the shots looked), but as also mentioned you still need a certain amount of light. Its all about deciding what you need and how you're going to get it.
For static shots, maybe weddings 1/100s is a good shutter speed. For a band jumping and kicking maniacs you really need close to 1/250 - 1/500s or better, assuming you're not using flash.
If you look at the one photo where I didn't use flash, even ISO 1600 it was unuseable due to lack of available light. Bring F4 down to F1.4 I could likely have brought the ambient light up to an acceptable level to brighten it more in Photoshop. Still, the blur at that shutter speed would likely have been unacceptable without flash to freeze some part of the action.
Unfortunately when you're dealing with a mat 40+ feet square, I don't know that a prime lens would work very well. It is usually not like a wedding or studio where you are free to walk just about anywhere you want to re-frame a shot. I would feel crippled with a non-zoom lens, especially if I don't know in advance where you will end up being seated.
Hopefully duroo72 will have the option to move around, or at least get front row seats. It would certainly help.
Hey, just remembered duroo72... if you have not shot at an event yet, be prepared to pay an extra fee for using a camera.
I have been to a few without such fees, but many do charge extra.
Being a team member I've been bypassed at our school-hosted national events. So you might want to check with the school. If they are hosting or helping to host the event, you may get breaks on fees, etc... Well, its worth asking anyway.
For static shots, maybe weddings 1/100s is a good shutter speed. For a band jumping and kicking maniacs you really need close to 1/250 - 1/500s or better, assuming you're not using flash.
If you look at the one photo where I didn't use flash, even ISO 1600 it was unuseable due to lack of available light. Bring F4 down to F1.4 I could likely have brought the ambient light up to an acceptable level to brighten it more in Photoshop. Still, the blur at that shutter speed would likely have been unacceptable without flash to freeze some part of the action.
Unfortunately when you're dealing with a mat 40+ feet square, I don't know that a prime lens would work very well. It is usually not like a wedding or studio where you are free to walk just about anywhere you want to re-frame a shot. I would feel crippled with a non-zoom lens, especially if I don't know in advance where you will end up being seated.
Hopefully duroo72 will have the option to move around, or at least get front row seats. It would certainly help.
Hey, just remembered duroo72... if you have not shot at an event yet, be prepared to pay an extra fee for using a camera.
I have been to a few without such fees, but many do charge extra.
Being a team member I've been bypassed at our school-hosted national events. So you might want to check with the school. If they are hosting or helping to host the event, you may get breaks on fees, etc... Well, its worth asking anyway.
Posted 23/08/2008 - 15:30
Link
I hope you're not expecting to replicate the above shots, outside the studio....
That first girl is going to break her knuckles, if she tries to hit somebody with her hands like that..... (me I'd aim for the opponents forearm, just so I could laugh at him, as he hits himself in the face, if I saw him hold his gaurd like that).obviously a model, not an athlete. so I'd say that the photog shot that in a studio. Pays to know about your subject, if you want your audience to buy into a staged shot.
The second shot looks like a horrible cut and paste.
That first girl is going to break her knuckles, if she tries to hit somebody with her hands like that..... (me I'd aim for the opponents forearm, just so I could laugh at him, as he hits himself in the face, if I saw him hold his gaurd like that).obviously a model, not an athlete. so I'd say that the photog shot that in a studio. Pays to know about your subject, if you want your audience to buy into a staged shot.
The second shot looks like a horrible cut and paste.
Fired many shots. Didn't kill anything.
Posted 23/08/2008 - 16:51
Link
Hi Amoringello , cheers for posting those shots - what kind of apertures and shutter speeds and iso were you using as i think the clubs i goto will be very similar (bug mats) - depending on how that goes i may look at the sigma 17-70mm f2.8 with a strobe flash.I see your point about the 50mm and it may end being the larger lens as they fight in a cage.
I spoke to my friend today and hopefullly ill be going along next wednesday to take some test shots mainly of grappling so not to fast moving.
Hi Don , they were only examples of style that i want to create yes content is dodgy by looks of things - and the second one yes cut and paste but aint she gorgoeeous!!! my other friend has a similar body shes a hotty!!
I spoke to my friend today and hopefullly ill be going along next wednesday to take some test shots mainly of grappling so not to fast moving.
Hi Don , they were only examples of style that i want to create yes content is dodgy by looks of things - and the second one yes cut and paste but aint she gorgoeeous!!! my other friend has a similar body shes a hotty!!
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


967 posts
20 years
Virginia,
USA
(The 540 should be, what, one half a stop brighter than the 360? Not a whole lot on paper either. Is my math correct?)
I've got some pretty good lighting from the 360, bare flash, twenty to thirty feet away, blazing shadows onto the back wall behind the subject.
One of the earlier competition photos I posted here had a good example... I'll have to dig that up again, as I think my server stopped hosting those for some reason.
One additional thing to be aware of, is that the 360 and 540 recycle at about 5-7 seconds. From what I hear the external power supply available for the 540 does not help the recycle times by much. So when you want to take a shot, make it count! Not like the competitor's flash that can recycle full power in about 1-2 seconds!!
Someone might have some better options for brand of flash if you feel you might want faster recycle times (I know I did). Although they will likely have to be set in manual mode and you loose the automated PTTL functionality. Probably not a big loss but it takes some practice or at least some up front time to see what will work in the current location. (or good knowledge of the math involved... I'm still a bit of a hunt and peck kind of shooter, myself -- but getting better )