This proves I have no clue

GivingTree
Posted 16/06/2008 - 08:57 Link
So there's a pretty waterfall that I want to photograph. The sky is overcast in the afternoon. I'm thinking I'd like to have as much as possible in focus. Camera is set to Tv priority. K100d with 18-55 lens, no tripod. Took multiple shots as I started at f/11 and ended at f/4. Everything except f/4.0 blows out the highlights in the water. After checking the LCD at f/5.6 (first pic) the water is still obliterated and I'm thinking "how far do I have to go?", well the second pic is as far as the lens will go and even then I'm not so sure about it.

Comment Image

f/5.6, 31mm, 1/10sec, iso 200

Comment Image

f/4.0, 31mm. 1/30sec, iso 200

How should I have done this to get it right? Or is it right at f/4? I'm stumped, any advice will help.
BTW, I realize this is not the best perspective, it would be much better if I had shot straight up the falls, but that water was COLD!!! Oh, and if I had taken the plunge and shot these long, low falls, how would I have reconciled f/4 with such a deep landscape?
"Just put your eye to the camera and push the button-thingy."
Flickr page:
link
Gwyn
Posted 16/06/2008 - 09:44 Link
Surely if you wanted to change the aperture only on the photos you should have set the camera to Av not Tv? Maybe that was your problem?
Mac
Posted 16/06/2008 - 10:47 Link
It looks to me as if you were shooting with the zoom lens set as wide as possible (18mm?).

With wide angle lenses, unless you are quite close to the subject, just about everything will be in focus at f4. This allows you to use higher shutter speeds if you want to "freeze" the water.

I find that whether the water is blurred or static is a matter of taste. I usually shoot a selection and choose later. Kinda like you've done.

Watch those slippery rocks

Cheers
Mac from Montreal

SP, SPII, SPF, PZ-10, P30, SFX, K110D, istDS, Optio 60, Z-10, H90, RZ10, I-10, f3.5 28mm, f1.8 55mm, f1.4 50mm, f3.5 135mm, f2.5 135mm, f4 50mm Macro, f4.5 80-200 F, f4 35-70, f3.5 28-80, f3.5 35-135, f3.5 18-55, f1.8 31mm Ltd., two Auto 110's, Auto 110 lenses and filters, tubes, bellows, Manfrottos and a sore back.
mikew
Posted 16/06/2008 - 11:11 Link
I thought that the question was about the exposure as much as anything.

In the top shot the water is blown out but at 1/10 at 5.6 that's more exposure than f4 at 1/30 (I think) and hence the highlights blow out.

Shouldn't you switch to spot metering in this case when the whites of the water will get the correct exposure being central and you hope the rest of it is recoverable?

As a by product you'd be able to choose a smaller aperture if the shutter speed remains the same and allegedly get more in focus.

Mike
beakynet
Posted 16/06/2008 - 11:19 Link
With challenging exposures such as this I always regret not carrying my Polorisor or ND filter! Often these are required to get the shuter/apature combination you want under this situation.

Spot meter from the trees (background), spot metre from the water and you will likely find a several stop difference - that said, what about combining the two images for background exposure and forgroung exposure using layers and masking?
Bodies: K5IIs, K7, MZ5n, LX, MV
Lenses: DA*16-50, DA18-55WR, DA18-135, DAL35, M50 F2, A50 f1.4, FA50 f1.4, DA*50-135, DA55-300, Tamron 70-300, DFA 100 WR Macro, M135 f3.5, Sigma 120-400 APO DG HSM, Tokina 500 f8.0
Flash: Metz 58, Metz 48
Accessories: BG4, Pentax right angle finder, Pentax mirror adaptor lens, O-ME53 Viewfinder Loupe
Auto 110 System: Auto 110, Winder, 18mm, 24mm, 50mm, 70mm, 20-40mm, AF100P, 1.7x telecon
amoringello
Posted 16/06/2008 - 11:22 Link
I you are OK with freezing the water with every detail, a faster shutter speed might help to cut down the light.

Otherwise you have not much choice but to tack on a couple of ND filters to bring the light down to a level to which your camera can handle. Even on overcast days, the highlights reflecting off water can easily blow out the image.

If the contrast of background is too great, even ND filters will not help -- you'll simply make the background too dark.
You may need ND Grads which will go from clear to dark. You can position such that the dark area is over the bright water to knock it down a couple of stops but leaving the rest rather untouched.
But that probably would not work well for this scene with its inconsistent shape and foreground.

You would probably simply need to take two or three images and piece the acceptable portions back together or use HDR software to do it automatically. Of course to get the initial acceptable images it sounds like you still need, at least, some ND filters.


[edit]
Too slow! Yeah, polariser would be a great choice as well!
[/edit]
GaryMoffat
Posted 16/06/2008 - 14:01 Link
Your basically having issues with exposure.

I read these books and "understood" much more of what I needed to do to get the correctcreative results:-

Understanding Exposure:
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Understanding-Exposure-Photographs-Digital-Camera/dp/081...=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1213621554&sr=1-1

Understanding Shutter Speed:
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Understanding-Shutter-Speed-Low-Light-Photography/dp/081...=sr_1_4?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1213621554&sr=1-4

The books are priced well also and a easy entertaining read.

Rgds,

Gary.
GivingTree
Posted 16/06/2008 - 15:05 Link
Thanks for the tips, I have some reading and research to do.

Yes, of course, Av is what I was using. Typo (it was late when I posted this)!
"Just put your eye to the camera and push the button-thingy."
Flickr page:
link

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo