SIGMA 18-125mm *istDS

SteveLedger
Posted 14/09/2005 - 13:44 Link
Anyone else find that this lens on the *istDS is a bit disappointing?
Mine has very noticable (and very irritating) Barrell/Pillow on edges and is also not sharp on the left side of the pics. Cam is well looked after and never been dropped. I'm the only owner.
I don't mind buying another lens if I have to, though I do have to work on a budget - I just don't know which brand to trust.
George Lazarette
Posted 14/09/2005 - 21:42 Link
Try the brand whose name is inscribed on your camera.

If you're on a budget, the best advice is to buy top quality brands second-hand, not third-rate brands new.

In fairness, Sigma do make some good lenses. But a large proportion of their output is, and always has been, pretty poor. I speak from experience, having bought Sigmas too when I was on a tight budget.

If you frequent Ebay, you will find loads of Pentax-M prime lenses at very modest prices, as well as some very good Pentax-F zooms, like the 70-210 f4-5.6, and the 35-135, both of which go for around £40 or so.

Another excellent Pentax zoom is the M 75-150, and so is the A 70-210 f4.

Power zoom lenses are out of favour, and the 28-105 is pretty good and pretty cheap.

If you don't have a 50mm lens, make that a priority. The quality is staggering, and the price miniscule.

Finally, if you want a modern lens, the new FAJ 18:35 lens is not too bad, despite the scorn sometimes heaped upon it.

And finally, avoid zooms with a ratio of more than four times (like your 18-125). The design challenge means that they will either be expensive, or bad, or both.

Good luck

George
SteveLedger
Posted 14/09/2005 - 23:02 Link
Thanks for you rely - appreciated.

I live in a rural area, so larger shopping malls are far away for me. It's suprisingly difficult to find a source of Pentax lens in Australia 'on the web'.. I'm also a newbie to dSLR's so haven't quite got a handle on lens jargon yet, or what type will suit the *istDS best.
Yes I do check ebay and have infact bought an Astron 1 : 3.5 - 4.5 autofocus lens to fit Pentax KAF fitting at a good price [hoping the lens will also be good ]
Image here http://i24.ebayimg.com/02/i/04/cf/9f/7f_1_b.JPG

The zoom factor is less as important as the photo result factor for me, however - inspite of it's shortcomings, I do like the zoom range of the 18-128mm
George Lazarette
Posted 14/09/2005 - 23:31 Link
I don't think you have understood a word I wrote!

You can't have high quality and low cost, unless you buy a good lens second-hand.

Your Astron lens is another cheapo, which will inevitably disappoint you. If you're going to buy rubbishy lenses, you might as well buy a point and shoot camera.

It's like buying a putting a Daewoo engine in a Ferrari.

George
SteveLedger
Posted 15/09/2005 - 00:10 Link
Ouch! Cranky aren't we

Sorry to annoy you, but I fully understood and appreciated your post.
To sumarize the KEY WORDS of my posts:

BUDGET
NEWBIE

Also Key phrases are:
* don't know which brand to trust*
* haven't quite got a handle on lens jargon*
* what type will suit the *istDS best*

Now if ASTRON are another cheapo, then you have the benefit of prior knowledge that I have yet to atain. I thank you for this info and feel lucky the (cheapo) lens and learning process only cost me a few dollars.

So please be gentle on me during my learning curve

PS: I wonder how many FIAT engines are in FERRARI's now ??
johnriley
Posted 15/09/2005 - 00:22 Link
I've bought plenty of non-Pentax lenses over the years, and I think there are only a very few that reach the Pentax quality levels.

It would be fantastic if I'd known at the atrt that I wanted pentax branded lenses, I would have saved a fortune. However, life ain't like that and there is a learning curve to negotiate.

A good lens to start with on the *istDs is the bundled 18-55mm, which, although a little soft wide open, crisps up nicely when stopped down and is capable of producing excellent results. It is also very low cost when purchased with the camera.

Otherwise, perhaps keep a look out on eBay for a modestly priced but tidy Pentax lens or two. For the easiest use, choose one with an "A" setting on the aperture ring, or one of the new lenses with no aperture ring.

Even on a budget I believe that buying Pentax will save you money in the long run, but it's better to have a couple of lenses you can afford and actually take some pictures. So whatever you decide, shoot lots of images and have fun!

If you need more help, just use the forum and there will be lots of help from us all.
Best regards, John
George Lazarette
Posted 15/09/2005 - 01:09 Link
Sledger,

Sorry for being cranky!

There's no such thing as one lens that will do everything, and chasing after such a mythical beast will get you nowhere.

A few points:

1 A prime (fixed focal length) lens is much easier to make than a zoom, so primes will always be cheaper, faster (this means having a wider maximum aperture, which will permit you to use a faster shutter speed), sharper, smaller, lighter, mechanically more robust, and generally better in every way than a zoom. But, of course, you have to change lenses if you want a different angle of view. That's the downside.

2 The 18-125 focal length range is wonderful - in theory. In practice, it is impossible to make a good lens with such a wide zoom range, so if you care about quality, forget wide-range zooms.

3 Very few third-party lens makers can match Pentax quality, even occasionally. So stick to Pentax, and always buy second-hand (while budget-constrained).

4 I suggested the Pentax 18-35 zoom on the grounds of cost, and JR suggested the the 18-55, which is better, but more expensive. In your shoes, I would buy one of these two zooms, mainly because it gives you access to a cheap wide-angle (a Pentax 20mm prime would cost more), plus any SMC Pentax 50mm (they're all excellent) and the SMC Pentax-F 70-210 1:4-5.6. That'll give you quality ranging from good to superb, and it'll cover the spectrum fairly well at the cheapest possible price.

Cheers cobber

George

PS: SMC refers to the lens coating, and is an indicator of quality generally. Lens suffices F, FA, DA, FAJ and D-FA are all auto-focus lenses that will work fully with the *ist DS. No suffix, or an M, indicate early (but still good) lenses with no automation. They only work in manual mode on the DS, but are often a very good budget buy. Lenses with an A suffix work in (almost) all modes, but are also manual focus.
Kimbo
Posted 15/09/2005 - 13:47 Link
I concur with what has been said so far, most manufacturers have produced some very good lenses esp. Sigma, Vivitar and Tokina but you have to choose carefully!
Here in the UK, Jessops 'Centon' brand are 'cheap and nasty' but the 50mm is actually pretty good and represents excellent value for money if you want to buy new but this just confirms that it is easier to produce a decent prime lens than a quality zoom.
The only independant that I've found to be consistantly good is Tamron, one of my first being the Adaptall2 28mm f2.5. I was prompted to buy it after a photo mag. suggested that it was good enough for professionals and I was not disappointed although it is susceptible to flare and a hood is a must.
You can expect to pay more for a top marque such as Pentax but you can be assured of very high quality and perfect compatability to the camera body.
I have a number of Pentax lenses - (used to have M 50mm f2) A 50mm f2, A 50mm f1.4, F 50mm f1.7, F 35-135mm and FA 28-105 power-zoom.
All are superb, the 35-135 is a touch softer than the 28-105 but still excellent for a close to 4x zoom.

In summary, always look for a Pentax but if you fancy an independant, do a bit of research and if possible, 'try before you buy'.
Die my dear doctor, that's the last thing I shall do!
MattMatic
Posted 15/09/2005 - 14:17 Link
I'd agree with most of what's been said.
Search out a second hand older Pentax (like the F series lenses). Here are some of the better older Pentax lenses:

SMC-F & -FA 50mm/f1.7 - astonishingly sharp. I've seen them for around £50. Well worth it, especially for the discipline of using a prime

SMC-F 70-210 - very contrasty, and very sharp. I got this for next to nothing in an ebay bundle (sold what I didn't want back on ebay ) Can be seen secondhand for as much as £90. Suffers from flare quite a bit, so you need a hood, but uses 49mm filters which is handy.

SMC-FA 80-320 - wonderful sharpness and colour. Around £90 second hand.

SMC-F 35-70 - I had this for a while in the above mentioned kit. Took some super sharp images, especially as it has a close-focus mode. Limited range, but very cheap

SMC-FA 28-70/f4 - well repected lens. However, I've had two of these go fungused (could have been storage).

SMC-F & -FA 100mm f2.8 macro - wonderful lens, super sharp. Around £200 second hand (had a £550 rrp tho', and for good reason).

I have had other lenses (including Sigma and Tokina), but chosen to sell them because I have always had better overall results from genuine Pentax lenses, especially on the digital body (*ist-D).

As for the newer lenses, here are some that I am mighty pleased with:

SMC-FA 24-90 - lovely lens. Not as sharp as the 50mm/f1.7, but very useable. Excellent for portraiture. The price might shock you, but believe me, it's worth it

SMC-DA 16-45 - one of my favourites, especially for landscapes. It really shines on the *ist-D. Razor sharp. I've had several A3 photographic prints at true 300dpi printed. Price is reasonably high, but again, for good reason.


So, to summarise, you only get what you pay for, and searching around eBay or other second hand places you can get good deals on older series Pentax lenses that work an absolute treat on the *ist-D/DS/DL

Hope that helps,
Matt
George Lazarette
Posted 15/09/2005 - 16:07 Link
Nothing wrong with any of the lenses you mention, Matt, but they don't all fit into the budget category!

G

PS: One fairly frequent bargain bundle to be found on Ebay is the SFX body plus 35-70 and 70-210. Usually worth the price even if you don't want the body.
MattMatic
Posted 15/09/2005 - 16:46 Link
Quote:
PS: One fairly frequent bargain bundle to be found on Ebay is the SFX body plus 35-70 and 70-210. Usually worth the price even if you don't want the body.
Absolutely. That was my point, George.
Quote:
...they don't all fit into the budget category!
I know that many don't fit into the "budget" category, but once I'd started listing the ones, like the 35-70 & 70-210 that are cheaply available, I thought I'd do the whole lot.
I can still remember the time when I thought that £150 was a lot for a lens, and couldn't understand why I should pay any more
Matt
Anonymous
Posted 16/09/2005 - 01:57 Link
Sledger, I too am in Aus and know where you are coming from!!! I recently picked up 2 new Pentax SMC lenses cheap ($99 for the 2!!!) at a local camera store. Unfortunately Pentax lenses in Australia (and especially on Ebay) are few and far between.
George Lazarette
Posted 16/09/2005 - 09:53 Link
As I've mentioned before, that's because Pentax stupidly use CR Kennedy as their agent in Oz, and Kennedy are also agents for Sigma, on which they presumably have some volume-pricing deal. That means they always push Sigma at the expense of Pentax.

From what I have seen, most UK and US sellers on Ebay are prepared to ship internationally (if they don't explicitly say so, just ask), and postage charges from the UK to OZ are, I think, reasonable.

Also, KEH in the States is regarded as a very ethical seller, whose "bargain" category often includes some very good stuff.

Don't give up.

G
Anonymous
Posted 16/09/2005 - 14:01 Link
Quote:
As I've mentioned before, that's because Pentax stupidly use CR Kennedy as their agent in Oz, and Kennedy are also agents for Sigma, on which they presumably have some volume-pricing deal. That means they always push Sigma at the expense of Pentax.
Well CRKENNEDY are obviously not in favour 'by George'..
However, to defend this Australian distributor a little, I can confirm that they indeed do bundle SIGMA Lens' with the *istDS/L kits - but note they also have kit's with PENTAX-DA 18-55 and PENTAX FAJ 18-35mm to mention two. Being a new dSLR user - I just made a choice based on what little knowledge I had at the time. It happened to be the kit with the 18-125mm SIGMA.

FYI: CRKENNEDY distribute a full range of PENTAX lens as well as the SIGMA, they also distribute HASSELBLAD, ZEISS and SCHNEIDER, along with a huge array of associated acc's. Plus they distribute the very excellent iRiver range of MultiMedia products.

We newbies understand that the pro's amongst us have arrived at their wisdom by lengthy experience and experimentation - likely at some monetary cost along the way, like us all (oops to my ASTRON buy).
I'm just starting on this journey, so can really appreciate usefull comments from anyone prepared to give it. Hopefully one day - I'll be able to pass on my learned knowledge in an equally sharing manner.
I hope I don't get cynical though, I'd not want to be trading good advice for opinions based on critical emotions.
Quote:

From what I have seen, most UK and US sellers on Ebay are prepared to ship internationally (if they don't explicitly say so, just ask), and postage charges from the UK to OZ are, I think, reasonable.

Also, KEH in the States is regarded as a very ethical seller, whose "bargain" category often includes some very good stuff.

Don't give up.

G
Thanks for that - can you be more detailed with KEH though? I can't seem to find an eBay seller by that name?
SteveLedger
Posted 16/09/2005 - 14:04 Link
Sorry - that was my post above, I was obviously not logged in

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo