RHS Harlow Carr Reflections

PRYorkshire
Posted 17/09/2020 - 22:01 Link
Welcome comments on whether you think colour or black and white works best on this reflection shot at RHS Harlow Carr. I found the sign board on left distracting in the colour shot so tried black and white to see if it improves things. Welcome your thoughts.

Comment Image


Comment Image
Paul

K1000, Espio 140, ist, istD, K70, K3iii and numerous lenses, just don't tell my wife.
danofmk
Posted 17/09/2020 - 23:05 Link
Colour for me - doubt I would have even noticed the board if you hadn't mentioned it!
JAK
Posted 17/09/2020 - 23:20 Link
If it worries you, couldn't you just crop that bit off? IMHO You'll loose nothing of importance.
John K
pschlute
Posted 18/09/2020 - 00:03 Link
Personally I would crop to remove the foreground and the sign on the left, and even up the building/reflection. Increase the contrast/saturation a little. Tone down the bright areas in the top half and boost them in the lower half.

Your image as posted was in AdobeRGB colour space. For posting to the web you are best posting in sRGB, as anyone viewing in a non-colour managed browser will be seeing colours out of whack.

Comment Image
Edited by pschlute: 18/09/2020 - 00:04
MrB
Posted 18/09/2020 - 03:05 Link
The colour shot seems preferable to me but with saturation reduced a bit (and a bit more in the reds). The sign board seems insignificant compared with the distraction of the overhanging leaves. Although use of such a feature to help frame a subject can work, for me their intrusion seems untidy in this case.

Philip
LennyBloke
Posted 18/09/2020 - 08:52 Link
Like both versions - but I think Peters crop improves the image
LennyBloke
PRYorkshire
Posted 18/09/2020 - 09:53 Link
Many thanks for the comments. I agree that the crop improves the shot. When sitting down and visualising the shot my attention was drawn by the reflection in the water as people walked past, however obviously with a static photo that movement is lost and the attention is then drawn more to the building.
Paul

K1000, Espio 140, ist, istD, K70, K3iii and numerous lenses, just don't tell my wife.
cardiffgareth
Posted 21/09/2020 - 10:20 Link
pschlute wrote:
Personally I would crop to remove the foreground and the sign on the left, and even up the building/reflection. Increase the contrast/saturation a little. Tone down the bright areas in the top half and boost them in the lower half.
Comment Image
This
Gareth Williams ARPS

My outfit: K1ii - Pentax D FA 24-70mm f2.8 - Pentax DA* 300mm f4 - Pentax modified DA* 60-250mm f4 - Irix 15mm Firefly - Pentax FA 35mm - FA 50mm f1.4 - Tamron SP 90mm macro - Pentax AF 540 FGZ II

Welsh Photographer
Flickr
Instagram
My PPG
Foundation NFT

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo