Printing 6mp to A3

Anonymous
Posted 16/01/2006 - 14:55 Link
I was wondering if I could get some oppinions regarding resampling of a 6mp shot to A3

I know all the technicals of how to do it (ie image size to 420x297mm @ 300dpi etc.) but I was wondering what is the best dpi to use whilst keeping the size as near to 420x297mm for A3.

From what I understand from talking to various printers and photographers is that you can drop the dpi to as little as 230- 250dpi without being able to tell the difference when compared a 300dpi print.

It is clear that with every byte of information added due to resampling, the image is ultimately loosing quality, so my question is:-
is it better to have an A3 image at 250dpi instead of 300dpi so that less resampling is required?
MattMatic
Posted 16/01/2006 - 15:07 Link
Ordinarily you should optimise the DPI according to the output device.

If the output is 402dpi, then you're best off upsampling to A3 at 402dpi (ie 6647 x 4700 pixels). You also have the opportunity to apply some sharpening at the output resolution which will increase the perceived resolution.

I recently upsized some *ist-D images from RAW to 16"x20" at 402dpi, sharpened in PS-CS2, and the results were great!

So, in answer to your question - forget how much you are resizing by, just resize it to match the output device (because a mismatch will likely be worse, and you have no control over what happens).

Hope that helps,
Matt
johnriley
Posted 16/01/2006 - 16:44 Link
I think there can be a lot of confusion about this, and certainly I regularly go over these issues in the Digital Nights that I run at ADAPS.

This is what I recommend:

1) Create the image size in Photoshop. Select A3, select 300 pixels/inch, select bicubic resampling and let PS do its work.

2) Set the printer perameters. On my Epson, this means 2880 dots per inch, correct size of paper, correct paper profile (Photo Quality Glossy Film) and a -7 reduction on magenta. Always the same paper, always the same finish. The parameters are saved as a Custom Setting "Photo Printing" just as my black and white setting is saved as "Monochrome".

Now that's the essence of it, but I also do relatively little work on an image, preferring to make the original in-camera JPEG as good as possible from the start. That also includes proper exposure in camera, and I really haven'y felt any urgent need to use RAW.

After I have copied the card to the hard drive, as soon as any file is opened and worked on it is always saved a a TIFF. My golden rule is never save as a JPEG, as you are introducing compression and artifacts at a stage where it is unecessary.
Best regards, John
Joshua Hakin
Posted 16/01/2006 - 22:23 Link
Quote:
From what I understand from talking to various printers and photographers is that you can drop the dpi to as little as 230- 250dpi
I do ALL my inkjet prints at this resolution and rarely use 300dpi.
The quality is just fine.
Anonymous
Posted 17/01/2006 - 08:02 Link
don't forget that the larger you print the greater the usual viewing distance. Therefore the ppi becomes less crucial. 300 is what i use for small prints that will be viewed closely but even 240 is often good enough for this.
johnriley
Posted 17/01/2006 - 08:06 Link
In theory, a greater viewing distance will indeed mean you could use a lower pixels/inch setting (not to be confused with the dots/inch values of the printer) but people have a tendency to peer closely at even A3 prints, so I still use 300ppi. There's really no reason not to - it's the computer that's doing the work!
Best regards, John
Anonymous
Posted 18/01/2006 - 20:05 Link
Thanks for all the feedback.

A related issue that has also plagued me is whether it is better to upsize an image in the raw conversion software or to do it after the conversion has already take place into a tiff or jpg.

Ps. I attended the a Hasselblad show at canary wharf yday as they unveiled their new 39mp H2 and back and the quality is amazing, lets all hope future Pentax digital medium format can match!
MattMatic
Posted 18/01/2006 - 20:43 Link
Yes, it's better to upsize in the conversion software (especially with Capture One Pro). Interpolation is better at that stage.

That said, the upsizing in PS-CS/CS2 is very good indeed (bicubic smoother usually). Depending on the image, it may be very hard to tell the difference between RAW upsampling and PS upsampling.

With careful sharpening you can still get some seriously sharp images out of the *ist-D. I stagger to think what the Hasselblad can do with 39Mpixels! (Except completely stuff up your storage )

Perhaps I should qualify my statements above: if you are printing to photographic output, then upsample to the exact output dpi. If you are printing on an inkjet, then this is a judgement call - 250dpi properly sharpened may be great. Personally, I haven't seen anything sharper than ProAM Imaging's output at 402 dpi (for which you need to upsample to the exact size). Most definitely sharper than 300dpi from Photobox

Matt
Joshua Hakin
Posted 18/01/2006 - 21:49 Link
Quote:
Thanks for all the feedback.

A related issue that has also plagued me is whether it is better to upsize an image in the raw conversion software or to do it after the conversion has already take place into a tiff or jpg.
Always upsize in the RAW converter! ALWAYS!
Just do a test and you'll see what I mean.

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo