Pentax DA 16-45

gartmore
Posted 24/09/2009 - 17:35 Link
I'm another one who wasn't that impressed, everything I read about the 16-45 was extremely positive, everything I read about the 18-55 was generally negative. I have a theory:

I had always been impressed with my 18-55, maybe I have an exceptionally good one, I dont know.

I was lucky to pick up the 16-45 in Jessops Pentax clearance for £139 and having used it quite a lot I have come to the conclusion that wide open at the wide end it is considerably sharper than the 18-55, at f8 at 45mm it is razor sharp but overall, stopped down a couple of stops I cant see much to choose between them. The constant aperture is great but the purple fringing in the usual situations at 16mm is very disappointing although I do like those extra 2mms.
Ken
“We must avoid however, snapping away, shooting quickly and without thought, overloading ourselves with unnecessary images that clutter our memory and diminish the clarity of the whole.” - Henri Cartier-Bresson -
Edited by gartmore: 24/09/2009 - 17:37
Hythloday
Posted 24/09/2009 - 18:06 Link
Dr. Mhuni wrote:

It was my default lens until I returned to the UK last Xmas and was too tempted by the versatility - and £50 cashback + VAT refund - of the DA17-70. However, at current prices there's no question I'd go for the DA16-45. The 17-70 is a tad sharper, has a more useful range (though I sometimes miss the extra 1mm), and is much better built (the 16-45 being on a par with the kit lens) - but it's not worth twice the price, which it is now.

Was going to sell my 16-45 earlier this year, but in the end decided that the £185 quid I was offered wasn't enough to prevent me keeping it. Mostly because I thought it would be good to keep as a back up if something was to happen to the SDM on the 17-70 (was reading about problems with this at the time) here in Colombo, where it would be difficult to obtain any replacement. But also because I'd simply developed a fondness for it!
I feel exactly the same about the DA16-45mm and the DA17-70mm. The DA16-45mm is a WA zoom, whereas the DA17-70mm is really a standard zoom lens. I hardly used the DA16-45mm this summer, but I won't sell it.
Edited by Hythloday: 24/09/2009 - 18:18
Dr. Mhuni
Posted 24/09/2009 - 18:36 Link
Quote:
I had always been impressed with my 18-55, maybe I have an exceptionally good one, I dont know.
I came to the conclusion a while back that there must have been quite wide variation in this lens (I'm talking about the one that came with the K10D/100D, not later incarnations). There's such diversity of opinion about it. Spotted this before I even bought my camera - having read loads of reviews of both cameras, reviewers were split between those who praised the kit lens and those who criticised it (especially for vignetting). And this seems to be reflected by the similarly conflicting views of Pentax owners.

Mine performed fine in the centre and from about 30mm. But at a wide angle it vignetted badly at any aperture, and wide open the performance wasn't good at any length.
Mhuni

500px
lidy
Posted 24/09/2009 - 21:41 Link
Erm - it's not getting any easier. Thank you all for your review/opinion. I think I would still like to buy it - just hoping I'll be able to find a good copy.
Dodging and burning are steps to take care of mistakes God made in establishing tonal relationships. - Ansel Adams -
Edited by lidy: 24/09/2009 - 21:42
TonyM
Posted 25/09/2009 - 07:58 Link
Just to make it even harder, I had and then sold the 16-45. It is a good lens, but I did find all the problems that others have mentioned and the real disappointment was that it just wasn't that much better than my 18-55mm mkII! So I now have the 12-24 (courtesy of our very good friend Amin), 18-55 mkII and 40mm Ltd. Together they cover this range perfectly.

Regards

Tony
thoughton
Posted 25/09/2009 - 10:04 Link
I've also been tempted by the 16-45 as a replacement for the kit 18-55 lens. The main attraction for me is the generally good reviews (apart from in this thread :mrgreen and the price. I regularly see used ones on eBay and elsewhere in the £150-£180 region.

However I haven't gone for it yet, as I am also considering the Tamron 17-50 which is faster and supposedly sharper for not much more money. I'm just not sure if I will miss that extra 1mm. Obviously the Pentax 16-50 would solve this dilemma, but the ridiculous price rules it out.
Tim
AF - Pentax K5, Sigma 10-20/4-5.6, Tamron 17-50/2.8, Sigma 30/1.4, Sigma 70-200/2.8, Tamron 70-300/4-5.6
MF - Vivitar CF 28/2.8, Tamron AD2 90/2.5, MTO 1000/11
Stuff - Metz 58 AF1, Cactus v4, Nikon SB24, Raynox 150, Sigma 1.4x TC, Sigma 2x TC, Kenko 2x macro TC, Redsnapper 283 tripod, iMac 27”, Macbook Pro 17”, iPad, iPhone 3G
Flickr • Fluidr • PPG • Street • Portfolio site
Feel free to edit any of my posted photos! If I post a photo for critique, I want brutal honesty. If you don't like it, please say so and tell me why!
MattMatic
Posted 25/09/2009 - 10:15 Link
I have a very early 16-45 (bought it when it came out) and have been very impressed with the quality of images produced. The out of focus rendition isn't as nice as the DA17-70 and FA24-90, but it's a very capable lens indeed.

Maybe the variation is down to where they're made??

It's true that the 18-55 is a very good lens as well, but my wife prefers the feel and look of the 16-45 on her *ist-Ds

Matt
http://www.mattmatic.co.uk
(For gallery, tips and links)
Dr. Mhuni
Posted 25/09/2009 - 14:30 Link
Right here are my images, Darkmunk - though I have to admit to having -ed up with the FA35 one (don't have a nifty fifty). This was the first image I took and I had the camera set up for continuous shooting as opposed to 2 sec delay (so it may have been prone to trigger shake, and whatever effect there is when the SR is on while using a tripod). The 16-45 shot was taken with the delay on. I did switch lenses again and try to take another shot with the delay on with the 35, however, I failed to check if it was alright - and it's horrible. Don't know what happened - but it hasn't locked focus properly for some reason. By the time I opened it up on the computer it was too late (dark) to re-do the images. So, FWIW, I'm posting them as is - not perfect I know regarding comparison with the FA35. However, to my eye from just the 16-45 image alone, my copy is performing significantly better than yours - so perhaps you did get a duff one.

(Images all at f4 and converted unadjusted from RAW to jpegs in Silkypix, then re-sized unadjusted in PE)

DA16-45

(This would have vignetted with my 18-55 - but no sign of that here. There is some slight evidence of underexposure compared to the 35, but nothing like yours. And I wouldn't say it was serious particularly if you're shooting RAW)

Comment Image


FA35

Comment Image


16-45 crop

(By the way, don't know what % crop this is as I don't know how to effect 100% crop in PE [still getting to grips with this], and my PSP has packed up unfortunately).

Comment Image


35 crop (You can see the impact of either the SR being on or the trigger shake, so this is pretty useless as a comparison)

Comment Image
Mhuni

500px
Edited by Dr. Mhuni: 25/09/2009 - 14:45
Darkmunk
Posted 25/09/2009 - 14:56 Link
Thanks Doc,
Really good of you to take the time.
You do appear to have a better copy of the lens.
I can see how your scene might fool the exposure but I can't see any excuse for mine. (it was set to spot metering and focus)

Not sure how PSE works but in PhotoShop, just marquee any section and keep an eye on the 'Info' to check you haven't gone over 800px then copy it into new file or go - 'Image - Crop'

Photoshop can also set the rectangular marquee to a fixed size (something under 800px) then you can just click anywhere to grab your 100% crop.

Cheers
M
Darkmunk
Posted 25/09/2009 - 15:19 Link
Just to get a slightly better comparison I set my 16-45 to about 35mm and shot some closer houses.
As with all my tests these are JPEGs totally untouched.
These two 100% crops were on the tripod like all the others but the first is without mirror lock-up. Quite a difference!
But both pretty murky and 'orrible
Comment Image

Comment Image

.
By the way nothing in the rest of the image is any more in focus.
.
.
[edit] just tried getting a really nice shot at f8, 1stop exposure comp and processed properly.... It was softer than f4 (even the JPEG) !!... I give up.
.
Edited by Darkmunk: 25/09/2009 - 15:36
lidy
Posted 25/09/2009 - 22:15 Link
Thank you very much for all the testing and comparing. I've found a 16-45 and I'm going to buy it. It's second-hand, but hardly used - for testing purposes only. The person who's selling it, is someone I 'know' (through another forum) and trust, so I'm really happy with it. I should get it sometime next week.

Really sorry about your bad copy, Darkmunk.
Dodging and burning are steps to take care of mistakes God made in establishing tonal relationships. - Ansel Adams -
Dr. Mhuni
Posted 26/09/2009 - 08:37 Link
Good luck with your lens Lidy - hope you get a good one.

I should have posted larger size images for comparison with Darkmunk's, so am posting the 16-45 crop again here in case anyone else is considering this lens.


BTW, the other thing to bear in mind is that this focal length (36mm) isn't even the 16-45's strength. Unusually, the lens performs better at the shorter end, which
- especially if you don't have a 12-24 - is a real boon. The wide performance was what I liked most about the lens when using it regularly, which probably means you'll really appreciate it
Lidy. This is where it really does constitute a step up from the 18-55 (even a good copy).


Comment Image
Mhuni

500px
lidy
Posted 26/09/2009 - 17:49 Link
Thank you very much! I appreciate any and all tips as to how to best use this lens.

I'm really looking forward to it. I'm pretty sure it'll be a good copy, as it has been tested by someone who's very critical and has been in photography for donkey's years.

The only downer is that I'll have to wait till next Saturday - he can't post it any sooner. But I can live with that.
Dodging and burning are steps to take care of mistakes God made in establishing tonal relationships. - Ansel Adams -
Edited by lidy: 26/09/2009 - 17:50

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo