Pentax or Nikon ? please help me choose
Posted 27/12/2010 - 16:52
Link
It would be strange if a Pentax forum suggested buying anything but the Pentax option. So, buy the Pentax option is good advice anyway as it happens. The K-x is excellent, gives access to a wide variety of new and old lenses and is amazing value for money.
Lens hoods are not provided with the DA-L lenses in the package but can be obtained either at a low cost (copies on eBay and Amazon) or a higher cost (Pentax ones from SRS)
Either way, the K-x will not diappoint and is arguably a more elegant design than the Nikon.
Use the centre point focus option and you know where the camera is focusing - you can see it click into sharpness anyway in the viewfinder, using human eyes!
Lens hoods are not provided with the DA-L lenses in the package but can be obtained either at a low cost (copies on eBay and Amazon) or a higher cost (Pentax ones from SRS)
Either way, the K-x will not diappoint and is arguably a more elegant design than the Nikon.
Use the centre point focus option and you know where the camera is focusing - you can see it click into sharpness anyway in the viewfinder, using human eyes!
Best regards, John
Posted 27/12/2010 - 17:03
Link
Hi, John was is right. Any pentax loyalist will recommend pentax and certainly in this forum where you have, i think, all the pentax lovers in the world. If you go for pentax, you can get lenses which are reasonably priced, compared to other makes. So plan-long term as photography is, i presume, a life-long love affair. regards, srini
K-5, K-7 and K10D, Pentax 18-135 WR,18-55 WR,Pentax 28-105,Sigma 28-300, Sigma 28-80 (Macro) and Pentax 50-200 WR.
Posted 27/12/2010 - 19:34
Link
Donald,
Remember that the new K-r with 18-55 is available with a £70 Cashback meaning a final cost of around £420. That would be a better buy than the Nikon D3000 IMHO. Have a look at Ken Rockwell's website. If my memory serves me correctly, he thinks it is a duffer.
Dave
Remember that the new K-r with 18-55 is available with a £70 Cashback meaning a final cost of around £420. That would be a better buy than the Nikon D3000 IMHO. Have a look at Ken Rockwell's website. If my memory serves me correctly, he thinks it is a duffer.
Dave
Posted 27/12/2010 - 19:42
Link
Defiantly a no brainer! For only £25 more.
The Pentax gives you two lenses across a range of 18 - 300mm. Both good lenses.
The Pentax will have the image stabilisation on every lens you use on it with, including any older ones you may like to use.
The Pentax will let you use lenses from pentax and many other brands going back over many years.(PK, PKA and with a simple adaptor M42 lenses).
Mind you I could be biased!
The Pentax gives you two lenses across a range of 18 - 300mm. Both good lenses.
The Pentax will have the image stabilisation on every lens you use on it with, including any older ones you may like to use.
The Pentax will let you use lenses from pentax and many other brands going back over many years.(PK, PKA and with a simple adaptor M42 lenses).
Mind you I could be biased!
Bob
Posted 27/12/2010 - 20:20
Link
Not to mention the Pentax comes with in body shake reduction so you don't need to keep paying for it again and again with every new lens.
But have you actually held either? You may find if you do that one feels better to you than the other. Look at how easy they are to operate, whether you have to keep going into the menus to change minor things, how they feel in the hand and so on.
But have you actually held either? You may find if you do that one feels better to you than the other. Look at how easy they are to operate, whether you have to keep going into the menus to change minor things, how they feel in the hand and so on.
Posted 27/12/2010 - 20:51
Link
Many thanks for the replies. I had a D3000, briefly, in the past and a K200D before it. The D3000 with the 18-55mm VR was sharp,noticeably more so than the K200D,and I think they may have had the same sensor.
I have a slight reservation on the Pentax for IQ compared to the Nikon but as one reply above points out its pretty nuts to be looking at two dslrs one with an 18-105 and the other with 18-55 and 55-300 and the difference to be only £25.How is the IQ of the AL lenses ?
I found the Nikon well built and easy to use but changing settings did involve some menu delving.
I have a slight reservation on the Pentax for IQ compared to the Nikon but as one reply above points out its pretty nuts to be looking at two dslrs one with an 18-105 and the other with 18-55 and 55-300 and the difference to be only £25.How is the IQ of the AL lenses ?
I found the Nikon well built and easy to use but changing settings did involve some menu delving.
Posted 27/12/2010 - 21:17
Link
Posted 27/12/2010 - 21:25
Link
As a Nikon user for 20 years or more I too faced a similar question when wanting to go digital.
Th cameras in question were the D40 and the K100D. At the time I had a Nikon FA and a load of lenses. I looked into the feature sets and test results of both cameras and there was almost nothing in it.
Almost. Pentax meant I could use some of my lenses from my FA - Tamron adaptalls - plus they would benefit from the built in SR. (I was also able to use my Micro-Nikkor 55mm)
Now these features maybe unimportant to you but they illustrate the Pentax idea that all Pentax mount lenses fit and work on the digital bodies. For me - priceless!
There are the technical differences between the two system, both with their merits. But one thing that you will benefit from with Pentax and that is the community spirit between Pentax users, with all of the quirks that you will find on this forum.
With Nikon - you buy into a system
With Pentax - you buy into a community.
I still use my beloved FA but the new love of my life is my K7.
MZ
Th cameras in question were the D40 and the K100D. At the time I had a Nikon FA and a load of lenses. I looked into the feature sets and test results of both cameras and there was almost nothing in it.
Almost. Pentax meant I could use some of my lenses from my FA - Tamron adaptalls - plus they would benefit from the built in SR. (I was also able to use my Micro-Nikkor 55mm)
Now these features maybe unimportant to you but they illustrate the Pentax idea that all Pentax mount lenses fit and work on the digital bodies. For me - priceless!
There are the technical differences between the two system, both with their merits. But one thing that you will benefit from with Pentax and that is the community spirit between Pentax users, with all of the quirks that you will find on this forum.
With Nikon - you buy into a system
With Pentax - you buy into a community.
I still use my beloved FA but the new love of my life is my K7.
MZ
K5, K7, Nikon FA.
AF Lenses: DA15mm Ltd, DA21mm Limited, DA35mmAL, DA50mm f1.8, DA18-55mmWR, FA28-70mm f4AL, DA50-200mmWR,Tamron SP70-200mm f2.8, AF70-300mm LD Di, SP10-24mm, SP90mm Macro.
MF Lenses: SMC-A 50mm, Adaptall 24mm(CW-24), 135mm(03B), 35-70mm(17A) 80-210mm(03A), Micro-Nikkor55mm, Soligor I-S 200mm f2.8 AIS
My Flickr - link
My Photobucket - link
AF Lenses: DA15mm Ltd, DA21mm Limited, DA35mmAL, DA50mm f1.8, DA18-55mmWR, FA28-70mm f4AL, DA50-200mmWR,Tamron SP70-200mm f2.8, AF70-300mm LD Di, SP10-24mm, SP90mm Macro.
MF Lenses: SMC-A 50mm, Adaptall 24mm(CW-24), 135mm(03B), 35-70mm(17A) 80-210mm(03A), Micro-Nikkor55mm, Soligor I-S 200mm f2.8 AIS
My Flickr - link
My Photobucket - link
Posted 27/12/2010 - 21:28
Link
I find that he can be way off the mark and I honestly believe he is exactly that with his analysis of the D3000. It is basically an evolved D40 which he raves about, and has a 3" screen,and 11 point AF as its main improvements over the D40. I enjoy Rockwell but on this occasion I think he is way off.
Anyone know how the Pentax 18-55 performs against the Nikon 18-55 ?
Anyone know how the Pentax 18-55 performs against the Nikon 18-55 ?
Posted 27/12/2010 - 21:35
Link
From reading your posts it seems to me that you were quite happy with the D3000 and had more or less made up your mind anyway.
Buy the Nikon.
Buy the Nikon.
Posted 27/12/2010 - 21:41
Link
I've looked at both (I work in camera shop) and compared actual image quality - both capable of excellent quality, however the Pentax is the clear winner at higher iso's.
Posted 27/12/2010 - 21:54
Link
In terms of image quality, it will be more dependent on the skill of the photographer than any difference between Pentax and Nikon lenses. Both will have different characteristics, both will be good.
The skill is something else and that comes from practice, practice practice...whichever camera you have there will be advantages that can be exploited or missed depending on the user.
The skill is something else and that comes from practice, practice practice...whichever camera you have there will be advantages that can be exploited or missed depending on the user.
Best regards, John
Posted 27/12/2010 - 21:57
Link
I have a K200d and am more than happy with the results, the IQ is sharp and bright as this image shows

When it comes to entry level models Pentax win out every time, the feature set is better than most, the in body shake reduction being the best system going (canon are starting to use it now!) and the standard lenses are the best on ANY camera at entry level.
Go semi or full pro then it gets difficult, the high end Pentax,Nikon, Sony and canon bodies all have faults, but also have their own advantages.
As a system Pentax takes some beating.

When it comes to entry level models Pentax win out every time, the feature set is better than most, the in body shake reduction being the best system going (canon are starting to use it now!) and the standard lenses are the best on ANY camera at entry level.
Go semi or full pro then it gets difficult, the high end Pentax,Nikon, Sony and canon bodies all have faults, but also have their own advantages.
As a system Pentax takes some beating.
Cheers, HG
K110+DA40, K200+DA35, K3 and a bag of lenses, bodies and other bits.
Mustn't forget the Zenits, or folders, or...
PPG entries.
K110+DA40, K200+DA35, K3 and a bag of lenses, bodies and other bits.
Mustn't forget the Zenits, or folders, or...
PPG entries.
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


248 posts
18 years
Is this a no brainer ?
I would value the forums help and advice with the following,how good is the K-X and is the AF viewfinder thing an issue for doing landscape at base ISO 95% of the time /
does the 18-55mm come with a lens hood ?
I know the 55-300mm does not but that one from the ED version can be bought for about £10