Old question, new slant. Help needed please.

Gedski
Posted 10/10/2014 - 17:39 Link
stu62 wrote:
look on dpreview after looking at the k50 i would go for the k5 or the varients of it as you can do a lot more with the k5 than the k50 and there should be a photo of a falcon on there and a top fuel dragster which i have taken in full flight so to speak
stu
1. Found the falcon. That looked a rather dark day but the bird looks clear and sharp.

2. Just had a look at dpreview. The K5's seem to be the way forward but I will be governed by price. We shall see.

3. After much reading about auto focus and BIF, I am coming to this conclusion. Whether it is a K50 or better, provided I set the shutter speed to plus 1000th and use auto focus continuous, It will then be down to me as to whether or not I get my shot. Am I right or wrong?

4. My procedure with my 700D is as above but using the AI servo mode. I usually get some half decent shots. I am going to try to put up a couple of my best BIF shots onto my gallery, wish me luck. Thanks for all of the help.

PS. Managed to upload a shot of a heron. It is in my gallery and the wildlife section.

Mike, Exactly what do you mean by 'fast moving subjects'? I have found that the definition can vary, depending upon who is reading it.

Is the difference in focusing on moving targets really noticeable between your Pentax and the Canon? These things will be the defining factor as to what I do, regarding cameras. Thanks.
Edited by Gedski: 10/10/2014 - 17:53
Mike-P
Posted 10/10/2014 - 19:47 Link
Gedski wrote:

Mike, Exactly what do you mean by 'fast moving subjects'? I have found that the definition can vary, depending upon who is reading it.
Expanding it a bit more what I really mean is anything moving unpredictably ... and this is where Pentax is at it's weakest, focus tracking. Yes you will maybe lock on to a bird in flight and the first and second shot will usually be nice and sharp so providing you are happy with that then all well and good. What the other systems do much better is a continuation of that first/second shot so if you are using 6/7/8 fps you will find the majority of pictures from there on in are still sharp where the Pentax will lose focus lock a lot quicker.
Canon and Nikon (even their cheapest bodies) will give you a lot more keepers (and therefore a lot more choice) at the end so if you prefer say the fifth shot in sequence (because the bird was swallowing a fish for instance) then it will still be sharp and not a blur.

I just did a quick search on Google ... Canon vs Pentax focus tracking and basically it was like I wrote this blog word for word, it sums up my feelings exactly and it's why I use a K-5IIs and a 7D.
Gedski
Posted 10/10/2014 - 20:05 Link
Mike-P wrote:
Gedski wrote:

Mike, Exactly what do you mean by 'fast moving subjects'? I have found that the definition can vary, depending upon who is reading it.
Expanding it a bit more what I really mean is anything moving unpredictably ... and this is where Pentax is at it's weakest, focus tracking. Yes you will maybe lock on to a bird in flight and the first and second shot will usually be nice and sharp so providing you are happy with that then all well and good. What the other systems do much better is a continuation of that first/second shot so if you are using 6/7/8 fps you will find the majority of pictures from there on in are still sharp where the Pentax will lose focus lock a lot quicker.
Canon and Nikon (even their cheapest bodies) will give you a lot more keepers (and therefore a lot more choice) at the end so if you prefer say the fifth shot in sequence (because the bird was swallowing a fish for instance) then it will still be sharp and not a blur.

I just did a quick search on Google ... Canon vs Pentax focus tracking and basically it was like I wrote this blog word for word, it sums up my feelings exactly and it's why I use a K-5IIs and a 7D.
Mike-P, I've just read your blog and I thank you for some sensible and enlightening information. I had some idea that Pentax tracking might be as you said but wasn't sure.

Two things you have brought to my attention. One is that I am thinking along the lines of the K5 II. The other is whether or not to upgrade my 700D to either the 70D or even the 'newly' priced 7D.

I now feel that I have just to make a choice. I think that I might be able to come to terms with the Pentax auto tracking. As I have arthritic fingers, the two easily accessible mode wheels will be a boon to me. I find that the 700D one front wheel and that dreadful Button at the rear to press while fiddling with the two can sometimes spoil my shots.

I am leaning more towards the K5 II the more I think about it but we shall see. Many thanks for your help.
Mike-P
Posted 10/10/2014 - 20:11 Link
Gedski wrote:


Mike-P, I've just read your blog and I thank you for some sensible and enlightening information. I had some idea that Pentax tracking might be as you said but wasn't sure.

Just to be clear, it's not my blog (although I could have been as it summed up my feelings almost word for word)
Mike-P
Posted 10/10/2014 - 20:18 Link
Gedski wrote:


Two things you have brought to my attention. One is that I am thinking along the lines of the K5 II. The other is whether or not to upgrade my 700D to either the 70D or even the 'newly' priced 7D.

I now feel that I have just to make a choice. I think that I might be able to come to terms with the Pentax auto tracking.
If you can come to terms with the tracking then The K-5II is a far better camera IMO. At the end of the day if it came right down to it I would keep My Pentax over the 7D every time.
Gedski
Posted 11/10/2014 - 11:28 Link
Firstly, Teaka53 [Malc] and stu62. Thanks for taking a look at my 'pic'. I posted it just so people reading my posts could have some idea of the general standard of my photography.

I would be looking at least the same standard using a Pentax K5/II.

Mike-P, I've really enjoyed our 'meetings'. I have understood more about the K5/II and feel happier about what it can do and maybe can't do. I am assuming that you are of the opinion that the Pentax K5II is superior to the Canon 700D as well as the others you mention.

I've gone through a lot of your flickr shots, mainly taking a great deal of interest in your birds in flight shots. The most interesting thing about them and your moving boat, car and 'plane shots is this.

Their is a big difference in the shutter speed in all of your moving shots and in mine. I don't think that I have one bird in flight shot with a shutter speed of less than 1500th. I see that you are getting super shots at no more than +/- 800th when using the K5II.

After I have done this, I shall go out on the back field, round up a few birds, feathered variety that is, at my age it is all I can hope for! I shall have a go at using around 800th for some bif shots. Your assistance has been invaluable.
stu62
Posted 11/10/2014 - 16:31 Link
have you conssiderd the k3 and read the review on here
Gedski
Posted 11/10/2014 - 16:47 Link
stu62, I have but it is just out of my reach. Also, I offered all of my 'stuff' to a reputable dealer but they came up £100 short of what I wanted.

To compound the situation the person that wanted to buy my stuff, after testing it all for an hour or so on Wednesday and shook hands on a fair price, rang me this morning and offered over £100 less than we agreed.

I shall now stick with my canon 700D and 'stuff'. Not to worry, worse things happen at sea. Thanks for all the guidance you guys have given me, it has been appreciated.
stu62
Posted 11/10/2014 - 18:42 Link
may i ask what they offed youif you want you can pm me
dcweather
Posted 11/10/2014 - 21:26 Link
stu62 wrote:
look on dpreview after looking at the k50 i would go for the k5 or the varients of it as you can do a lot more with the k5 than the k50 and there should be a photo of a falcon on there and a top fuel dragster which i have taken in full flight so to speak
stu
-----------------------------------------
I think with a car you know where it is coming from and going to and it is big. If the falcon is close or is semi-captive again it is predictable to an extent. The biggest problem I get - and it happened today in good light is a Kestrel appears in the sky, a fair way distant, you point the camera at it and press autofocus (Continuous, but same in other modes) and you just get a hunt through blue sky, you then have to look again to see where it has gone, now out of frame and try again - if you get lucky and it finds it you can usually track it.
dcweather
Posted 13/10/2014 - 11:30 Link
Further to the above I have found that all my screw lens do track better than the DA*300 to the extent I wonder if there is a fault. I wouldn't want to mislead the OP and I might get the lens checked out.
Edited by dcweather: 13/10/2014 - 11:33
Gedski
Posted 13/10/2014 - 16:51 Link
dcweather, I hope there is not any problem with your 'stuff'.

Jan

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo