OK - so what / who is a Pro ?
Posted 17/12/2009 - 07:29
Link
A prostitute is a professional sex worker, a member of the 'oldest profession'. Your close friend presumably doesn't charge and therefore isn't a professional.
Dare I suggest QED?
Incidentally my 'close friend' doesn't provide a service at all, we enjoy a shared relationship in the fullest sense in all aspects of life otherwise I would not count her as my 'close friend'.
Mike
Dare I suggest QED?
Incidentally my 'close friend' doesn't provide a service at all, we enjoy a shared relationship in the fullest sense in all aspects of life otherwise I would not count her as my 'close friend'.
Mike
---------------------------------------------------
You can see some of my shots at my Flickr account.
You can see some of my shots at my Flickr account.
Posted 17/12/2009 - 09:46
Link
Better a competent amateur than an incompetent "professional".
At my youngest daughter's wedding, a "Professional" was engaged. He had all the right stuff: Brochure, Website, Client List, Square Swedish box thingy, etc. Me, I'm just the bride's father clutching an MZ-50.
The "Professional" delivers an Album, I just hand over two packs of 7x5 prints. The album that they show people is mostly 7x5 prints, with one or two Photoshop enlargements.
The "Professional" is faffing around getting the composition right (they wish he had paid that much attention to the focus); I'm just framing and shooting.
Now I don't even rate myself as competent (compared to a lot of amateurs), but I suggest:
A "Pro" does it for money.
A "pro" is someone who really knows what they are doing - and does it!
Hence: a "pro" can also be a "Pro", but the reverse is not always true.
And one last thought - in the "Pro"'s family group, you cannot see my right arm - that's the one hiding the MZ-50
Geoff
At my youngest daughter's wedding, a "Professional" was engaged. He had all the right stuff: Brochure, Website, Client List, Square Swedish box thingy, etc. Me, I'm just the bride's father clutching an MZ-50.
The "Professional" delivers an Album, I just hand over two packs of 7x5 prints. The album that they show people is mostly 7x5 prints, with one or two Photoshop enlargements.
The "Professional" is faffing around getting the composition right (they wish he had paid that much attention to the focus); I'm just framing and shooting.
Now I don't even rate myself as competent (compared to a lot of amateurs), but I suggest:
A "Pro" does it for money.
A "pro" is someone who really knows what they are doing - and does it!
Hence: a "pro" can also be a "Pro", but the reverse is not always true.
And one last thought - in the "Pro"'s family group, you cannot see my right arm - that's the one hiding the MZ-50
Geoff
Water can wear away a stone - but it can't cook lunch
X-5
istDS
K2000
P50.
Lenses Digital: 50-200, 18-55 KAF: 28-80.
Lenses KA & K: SMC-KA f2.0, SMC-K f1.4, SMC-K f1.7 Tokina KA 28-70 , SMC Pentax 70-210 F4, Sigma KA 75-300 , Hanimex 500mm Mirror, and the Tamron Adaptall-2 stuff.
and then there's all the M42 kit, and the accessories ...
X-5
istDS
K2000
P50.
Lenses Digital: 50-200, 18-55 KAF: 28-80.
Lenses KA & K: SMC-KA f2.0, SMC-K f1.4, SMC-K f1.7 Tokina KA 28-70 , SMC Pentax 70-210 F4, Sigma KA 75-300 , Hanimex 500mm Mirror, and the Tamron Adaptall-2 stuff.
and then there's all the M42 kit, and the accessories ...
Posted 17/12/2009 - 11:41
Link
imagesteve wrote:
No offence to the amateurs, guys you take great pictures but the issue of pro and amateur is wearing thin! Take images, not snapshots and someday you might earn a buck for it.
I'm sure you didn't mean it (well at least I hope you didn't), but I for one find this comment somewhat offensive. It's patronising, and implies that amateurs aren't professionals because they aren't good enough. Which is clearly a load of bull.No offence to the amateurs, guys you take great pictures but the issue of pro and amateur is wearing thin! Take images, not snapshots and someday you might earn a buck for it.
I can think of half a dozen members here who are amateurs but could easily compete with our "pro" members when it comes to producing "images". In fact I can think of a couple of pros here whose portfolios are shockingly bad.
Like Mike says, if we wanted to be professional photographers we'd have a go at it. We're not amateurs photographers just because we aren't "good enough" to be pro photographers. We're amateurs because we have careers in fields other than photography.
Tim
AF - Pentax K5, Sigma 10-20/4-5.6, Tamron 17-50/2.8, Sigma 30/1.4, Sigma 70-200/2.8, Tamron 70-300/4-5.6
MF - Vivitar CF 28/2.8, Tamron AD2 90/2.5, MTO 1000/11
Stuff - Metz 58 AF1, Cactus v4, Nikon SB24, Raynox 150, Sigma 1.4x TC, Sigma 2x TC, Kenko 2x macro TC, Redsnapper 283 tripod, iMac 27”, Macbook Pro 17”, iPad, iPhone 3G
Flickr • Fluidr • PPG • Street • Portfolio site
Feel free to edit any of my posted photos! If I post a photo for critique, I want brutal honesty. If you don't like it, please say so and tell me why!
AF - Pentax K5, Sigma 10-20/4-5.6, Tamron 17-50/2.8, Sigma 30/1.4, Sigma 70-200/2.8, Tamron 70-300/4-5.6
MF - Vivitar CF 28/2.8, Tamron AD2 90/2.5, MTO 1000/11
Stuff - Metz 58 AF1, Cactus v4, Nikon SB24, Raynox 150, Sigma 1.4x TC, Sigma 2x TC, Kenko 2x macro TC, Redsnapper 283 tripod, iMac 27”, Macbook Pro 17”, iPad, iPhone 3G
Flickr • Fluidr • PPG • Street • Portfolio site
Feel free to edit any of my posted photos! If I post a photo for critique, I want brutal honesty. If you don't like it, please say so and tell me why!
Posted 17/12/2009 - 11:52
Link
Then Stefan you are a semi-pro ??
because I earn money from my shoot and images but don't need to pay the rent ect I do it because I love it
James
Quote:
But you don't need to sell or earn your living with photography to be a pro.
If you've a great understanding about photography and shoot great photos then you can be called a pro as well.
I class my self as a semi-proBut you don't need to sell or earn your living with photography to be a pro.
If you've a great understanding about photography and shoot great photos then you can be called a pro as well.
because I earn money from my shoot and images but don't need to pay the rent ect I do it because I love it
James
My Fluidr
"To see in colour is a delight for the eye, But to see in black and white is a delight for the soul" ANDRI HERY
"To see in colour is a delight for the eye, But to see in black and white is a delight for the soul" ANDRI HERY
Posted 17/12/2009 - 12:31
Link
Guys ,
I didn't mean this to turn into a fight
I really was looking seriously at the differences between pro and amateur - and I still don't think I've got it all straight yet .
It strikes me that there are several definitions of 'Pro' as distinct from 'pro' . This isn't easy to try and explain - but when it comes to big exhibitions etc - who decides who is and who is not, a pro for the days when it's not open to the general public - do you have to prove your 'Pro' status - and if so how ?
I didn't mean this to turn into a fight
I really was looking seriously at the differences between pro and amateur - and I still don't think I've got it all straight yet .
It strikes me that there are several definitions of 'Pro' as distinct from 'pro' . This isn't easy to try and explain - but when it comes to big exhibitions etc - who decides who is and who is not, a pro for the days when it's not open to the general public - do you have to prove your 'Pro' status - and if so how ?
let the education continue
proud owner of a couple of cameras and a few bits and bobs
proud owner of a couple of cameras and a few bits and bobs
Posted 17/12/2009 - 12:58
Link
pink wrote:
I class my self as a semi-pro because I earn money from my shoot and images but don't need to pay the rent ect I do it because I love it
What utter nonsense - you're either professional, or you're not. As Photomonk said: "Anyone that thinks because they make some money off some photos makes them a pro needs a reality check."I class my self as a semi-pro because I earn money from my shoot and images but don't need to pay the rent ect I do it because I love it
"Professional" means - to me at least - "following an occupation as a means of livelihood or for gain." Your definition is that if you make money from it, you're a professional (*see post) so that if you make some but not all of your money from it, then you're semi-pro. That's exactly what misleads prospective clients and that is - at best - UNprofessional and - at worst - fraudulent.
Since I've been a member here I've seen a couple of classic examples of people who:
1) buy a decent camera and
2) whang up a website and advertise themselves
- all the while asking all sorts of basic questions on here that simply prove their lack of knowledge and experience. They benefit from the generousity of the membership here in answering those questions, then might also pay to join an on-line "association" - membership of which, they think, will add to their credibility. Of course, their poor clients don't get to see the total lack of professionalism this attitude reveals.
*The very act of advertising - by whatever method - for paid work, implies professional aptitude, yet I've seen so-called "pros" and "semi-pros" who have no qualifications or genuine commissions to prove either experience or competence. I'd want proof of both.
The fact that some don't "need to pay the rent" and "do it because they love it" also probably means that:
:arrow:They have no actual professional experience or qualifications of competence, however gained (Uni or apprenticeship).
:arrow:They don't carry public or professional liability insurance in the event of injury, loss or damage, equipment failure, litigation, etc.
:arrow:They think that just low-priced work, on recommendation, for example, indemnifies you if anything goes pear-shaped - "Well, I don't make a living from it, so I'm not really responsible."
If I had an important commission for a photographer, guess who I'd ask (not that I have any strong feelings, either way :roll?
Ray
Z1, K10D, D-BG2 Grip, DA 1:3.5-5.6 18-55mm AL, DA 1:3.5-6.3 18-250mm ED AL(IF), AF540FGZ Flash, FA 1:1.7 50mm, DA 1:2.4 70mm Limited, Wireless Remote (Did I offend you? Click here).
Posted 17/12/2009 - 14:38
Link
wow Ray that some hard comments you have their.
But I've not getting into an argument with you over it.
Why
Because
One I haven't got the time (two busy getting ready for my next shoot
Two Got to go to the bank and deposit fee's from the last shoot.
end of story
and I wouldn't do studio shoots if i didn't enjoy it, nothing can beat the feeling when you see a clients face when you've capture a moment, a feeling, emotion (that's what I love and shoot for)
not Cynical sad people that need labels on everything.
James
But I've not getting into an argument with you over it.
Why
Because
One I haven't got the time (two busy getting ready for my next shoot
Two Got to go to the bank and deposit fee's from the last shoot.
end of story
and I wouldn't do studio shoots if i didn't enjoy it, nothing can beat the feeling when you see a clients face when you've capture a moment, a feeling, emotion (that's what I love and shoot for)
not Cynical sad people that need labels on everything.
James
My Fluidr
"To see in colour is a delight for the eye, But to see in black and white is a delight for the soul" ANDRI HERY
"To see in colour is a delight for the eye, But to see in black and white is a delight for the soul" ANDRI HERY
Posted 17/12/2009 - 15:02
Link
Now we are running against another problem, the profession photographer isn't protected any more and anyone can call themselves that.
They need to protect that profession again so that you need to have the right papers to be a photographer. Still it does say nothing about the quality of the photos but at least the paper shows someone has the or needs to have the knowledge and you also make the market smaller, since that's a big problem.
Amateurs who are good at photographing or get a lucky shot are taking away the market for the professional photographer who needs to sell his photos to get food on the table.
Also the harm done by so called professionals who think they are because they have the gear and hire themselves like that isn't pleasant either for the "real" pro's.
I'm not a professional and won't go to lends to call myself that, semi-pro isn't the word either, enthusiastic amateur suits me the most and many of us here.
So I don't have the great understanding of the professional world but I hope I've laid my finger on the problem here.
They need to protect that profession again so that you need to have the right papers to be a photographer. Still it does say nothing about the quality of the photos but at least the paper shows someone has the or needs to have the knowledge and you also make the market smaller, since that's a big problem.
Amateurs who are good at photographing or get a lucky shot are taking away the market for the professional photographer who needs to sell his photos to get food on the table.
Also the harm done by so called professionals who think they are because they have the gear and hire themselves like that isn't pleasant either for the "real" pro's.
I'm not a professional and won't go to lends to call myself that, semi-pro isn't the word either, enthusiastic amateur suits me the most and many of us here.
So I don't have the great understanding of the professional world but I hope I've laid my finger on the problem here.
Posted 17/12/2009 - 17:08
Link
In the beginning - for me that would be the '60s - if one wanted some photographs taken that were better than snapshots, one engaged the services of a "Commercial Photographer".
Working with a real pro was an eyeopener: tell the guy what you wanted, and he would show you what could be done to achieve this.
I do not think that the possession of a certificate or two means more than "well I've done the course".
This sounds like a parallel argument running elsewhere about Engineers and Technicians. Engineers, of course, being those who got a degree in Engineering, while Technicians had only been taught how to fix the screw-ups made by the Engineers. And, if this sounds like I am engaging in anti-snobbery, I hold both sorts of qualifications. Neither "qualify" me to get inside a piece of machinery to photograph the wear on some conveyor chains - but I have done exactly that.
Most of the Great British Engineers did not study to get a qualification. Nor did some of the really World Class photographers.
H C-B studied in the studio of a painter (Lhote)
Ansel Adams was effectively self-taught, but practiced as a Commercial Photographer for 30-odd years.
So, to get back to where this started, a Pro does it for money, a "real pro" is an expert.
Geoff
Working with a real pro was an eyeopener: tell the guy what you wanted, and he would show you what could be done to achieve this.
I do not think that the possession of a certificate or two means more than "well I've done the course".
This sounds like a parallel argument running elsewhere about Engineers and Technicians. Engineers, of course, being those who got a degree in Engineering, while Technicians had only been taught how to fix the screw-ups made by the Engineers. And, if this sounds like I am engaging in anti-snobbery, I hold both sorts of qualifications. Neither "qualify" me to get inside a piece of machinery to photograph the wear on some conveyor chains - but I have done exactly that.
Most of the Great British Engineers did not study to get a qualification. Nor did some of the really World Class photographers.
H C-B studied in the studio of a painter (Lhote)
Ansel Adams was effectively self-taught, but practiced as a Commercial Photographer for 30-odd years.
So, to get back to where this started, a Pro does it for money, a "real pro" is an expert.
Geoff
Water can wear away a stone - but it can't cook lunch
X-5
istDS
K2000
P50.
Lenses Digital: 50-200, 18-55 KAF: 28-80.
Lenses KA & K: SMC-KA f2.0, SMC-K f1.4, SMC-K f1.7 Tokina KA 28-70 , SMC Pentax 70-210 F4, Sigma KA 75-300 , Hanimex 500mm Mirror, and the Tamron Adaptall-2 stuff.
and then there's all the M42 kit, and the accessories ...
X-5
istDS
K2000
P50.
Lenses Digital: 50-200, 18-55 KAF: 28-80.
Lenses KA & K: SMC-KA f2.0, SMC-K f1.4, SMC-K f1.7 Tokina KA 28-70 , SMC Pentax 70-210 F4, Sigma KA 75-300 , Hanimex 500mm Mirror, and the Tamron Adaptall-2 stuff.
and then there's all the M42 kit, and the accessories ...
Posted 17/12/2009 - 17:10
Link
pink wrote:
wow Ray that some hard comments you have their.
But I've not getting into an argument with you over it.
Why
Because
One I haven't got the time (two busy getting ready for my next shoot
Two Got to go to the bank and deposit fee's from the last shoot.
end of story
and I wouldn't do studio shoots if i didn't enjoy it, nothing can beat the feeling when you see a clients face when you've capture a moment, a feeling, emotion (that's what I love and shoot for)
not Cynical sad people that need labels on everything.
My comments were general and well-reasoned, I believe. If they struck a nerve, that's hardly my fault. I've no objection to an argument, when you can find some of your valuable time, but if you are going to have a pop by calling me a sad cynical person, at least have the decency to get the rest of the spelling, punctuation and layout to look like it's English, please.wow Ray that some hard comments you have their.
But I've not getting into an argument with you over it.
Why
Because
One I haven't got the time (two busy getting ready for my next shoot
Two Got to go to the bank and deposit fee's from the last shoot.
end of story
and I wouldn't do studio shoots if i didn't enjoy it, nothing can beat the feeling when you see a clients face when you've capture a moment, a feeling, emotion (that's what I love and shoot for)
not Cynical sad people that need labels on everything.
RG
Z1, K10D, D-BG2 Grip, DA 1:3.5-5.6 18-55mm AL, DA 1:3.5-6.3 18-250mm ED AL(IF), AF540FGZ Flash, FA 1:1.7 50mm, DA 1:2.4 70mm Limited, Wireless Remote (Did I offend you? Click here).
Posted 17/12/2009 - 17:15
Link
Settle down please - quoting someone and saying "what utter nonsense" isn't excatly general or well reasoned, is it?
Best regards, John
Posted 17/12/2009 - 17:24
Link
sorry but it did look like it was directed at your's truly
Quote:
I class my self as a semi-pro
because I earn money from my shoot and images but don't need to pay the rent ect I do it because I love it
And then the commentI class my self as a semi-pro
because I earn money from my shoot and images but don't need to pay the rent ect I do it because I love it
Quote:
What utter nonsense
James
What utter nonsense
My Fluidr
"To see in colour is a delight for the eye, But to see in black and white is a delight for the soul" ANDRI HERY
"To see in colour is a delight for the eye, But to see in black and white is a delight for the soul" ANDRI HERY
Posted 17/12/2009 - 17:42
Link
johnriley wrote:
Settle down please - quoting someone and saying "what utter nonsense" isn't excatly general or well reasoned, is it?
The nonsense is in the definition of "professional," as would be seen if read (or, in this case, quoted) in context. Please excuse the emboldening, which highlights another part of my response.
Settle down please - quoting someone and saying "what utter nonsense" isn't excatly general or well reasoned, is it?
Z1, K10D, D-BG2 Grip, DA 1:3.5-5.6 18-55mm AL, DA 1:3.5-6.3 18-250mm ED AL(IF), AF540FGZ Flash, FA 1:1.7 50mm, DA 1:2.4 70mm Limited, Wireless Remote (Did I offend you? Click here).
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



238 posts
16 years
But you don't need to sell or earn your living with photography to be a pro.
If you've a great understanding about photography and shoot great photos then you can be called a pro as well.
So if money is the only factor in determining a pro, then that is also the same thing that would differentiate a close friend and a prostitute. They give the same service, but may not be artists at what they do, just do it for the money.
The Photomonk