New lens choices
Posted 02/04/2009 - 20:21
Link
I haven't used any of the lenses you have mentioned above but am in the same situation.
I think I have finally decided on the Pentax 17-70mm. My only concern is the sample variation that I have been reading about with this lens. Hopefully I will get a good 'un when I finally order it.
As long as it is reasonably sharp at f/4.0 I will be a happy bunny.
Jason
I think I have finally decided on the Pentax 17-70mm. My only concern is the sample variation that I have been reading about with this lens. Hopefully I will get a good 'un when I finally order it.
As long as it is reasonably sharp at f/4.0 I will be a happy bunny.
Jason
K30 & 18-55mm WR.
Posted 02/04/2009 - 20:23
Link
Hi jason i'm thinking about the 17-70mm but there's £130 difference
Posted 02/04/2009 - 20:25
Link
Oh, it's sharp
Even at f/4. Though watch the very shallow DoF at 70mm at f/4!
Matt
Even at f/4. Though watch the very shallow DoF at 70mm at f/4!
Matt
http://www.mattmatic.co.uk
(For gallery, tips and links)
(For gallery, tips and links)
Posted 02/04/2009 - 20:25
Link
I'm hoping the SDM will make up for the price difference.
K30 & 18-55mm WR.
Posted 02/04/2009 - 20:27
Link
What about giving the Tamron 17-50mm f2.8 a go ?
Or perhaps a 30mm or 35mm prime to fit the gap there ? I have the Sigma 30mm f1.4 & like it very much. Plus you could always get a used 18-55 II to accompany it if you really need the zoom flexibility. Well you have a Sigma 50mm & 50-150mm so you'll already know if your a prime or zoom guy !
Or perhaps a 30mm or 35mm prime to fit the gap there ? I have the Sigma 30mm f1.4 & like it very much. Plus you could always get a used 18-55 II to accompany it if you really need the zoom flexibility. Well you have a Sigma 50mm & 50-150mm so you'll already know if your a prime or zoom guy !
Posted 02/04/2009 - 21:10
Link
MattMatic wrote:
Oh, it's sharp
Even at f/4. Though watch the very shallow DoF at 70mm at f/4!
Matt
That's what i was hoping for Matt cause the sigma was an f2.8.I would probably only use the wide say from 17mm to 50mm as its only for landscapes
Oh, it's sharp
Even at f/4. Though watch the very shallow DoF at 70mm at f/4!
Matt
Posted 02/04/2009 - 21:12
Link
Sorry RR i have this severe phobia of kit lenses don't know why really
Posted 03/04/2009 - 00:15
Link
Maybe i shall have a total re-think and go for a k200 which is in the same price region as the 17-70mm
Posted 03/04/2009 - 00:48
Link
I would recommend the Tamron 17-50mm f2.8 to you, but I had unpredictable inconsistent AF performance with mine on a K10D. It's consistent on my K20D though, and the image quality is excellent.
K10D to a K200D would not be much of an upgrade. In fact it would be a downgrade in terms of the viewfinder and number of control dials.
K10D to a K200D would not be much of an upgrade. In fact it would be a downgrade in terms of the viewfinder and number of control dials.
~Pete
Posted 03/04/2009 - 12:47
Link
I have just arrived home having travelled up to Watford to buy a Pentax 17-70mm lens. (2 Hours there/ 1 Hour return, bloody M25 !)
I have mounted it on the camera and just tried a few test shots, I like the colours and silent motor too (it was that quiet I had to double check it was working).
It also just seems to be the right size/fit to compliment the K20D with grip, not too small or too overpowering.
I will be doing some sharpness tests with it shortly to see if it is as good as I hope.
Jason
ps. Was told at SRS that prices are going up pretty soon so if you want a good bargain get in quick.
I have mounted it on the camera and just tried a few test shots, I like the colours and silent motor too (it was that quiet I had to double check it was working).
It also just seems to be the right size/fit to compliment the K20D with grip, not too small or too overpowering.
I will be doing some sharpness tests with it shortly to see if it is as good as I hope.
Jason
ps. Was told at SRS that prices are going up pretty soon so if you want a good bargain get in quick.
K30 & 18-55mm WR.
Posted 03/04/2009 - 13:40
Link
Just done a quick sharpness check (very non scientific brick wall). This lens is very sharp wide open most of the range, but at the longer end (50mm-70mm) needs stopping down a bit to get best sharpness, especially in the corners.
Can't say I'm at all disappointed in this lens though, but will be giving it a thorough workout.
Also Bokeh seems to me to be very impressive.
Anyone with this lens confirm this is normal for it ?
Jason
Can't say I'm at all disappointed in this lens though, but will be giving it a thorough workout.
Also Bokeh seems to me to be very impressive.
Anyone with this lens confirm this is normal for it ?
Jason
K30 & 18-55mm WR.
Posted 03/04/2009 - 14:40
Link
Jason,
Sounds about right to me. Just stopping down by a third of stop usually brings up the sharpness. But, yes, shooting at wide open isn't really a problem at all.
Bokeh, for me, is sublime. It's up there with the 50/1.4 and the FA24-90
Haven't got any test shots at the moment, but the images really do "pop" with sharpness and contrast.
Matt
Sounds about right to me. Just stopping down by a third of stop usually brings up the sharpness. But, yes, shooting at wide open isn't really a problem at all.
Bokeh, for me, is sublime. It's up there with the 50/1.4 and the FA24-90
Haven't got any test shots at the moment, but the images really do "pop" with sharpness and contrast.
Matt
http://www.mattmatic.co.uk
(For gallery, tips and links)
(For gallery, tips and links)
Posted 03/04/2009 - 16:48
Link
I have the 17-70 and had the 16-45. I think they're both fine but the 17-70 has a range that makes it a good "walk-around" lens. The 16-45 was a tad too short. I gave it to my sister.
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


1046 posts
18 years
I am now looking for any ideas around these focal lengths maybe the pentax 17-70mm sdm £329 lens or the famous 16-45mm £199 lens.Does anyone use these lenses? and what do they think?
All replies welcome