My first lunar photography session

TallNHairyDave
Posted 21/10/2007 - 00:39 Link
Went up to Box Hill tonight with the K10D and my Sigma f/8 600mm mirror lens. Have just weeded the 30 or so photos down to this one (the RAW has been cropped, sharpened and the exposure tweaked slightly)...

Comment Image


What do folks reckon?
Dave Appleton

Happy Pentax K10D owner since 21-08-2007
http://www.davidappleton.co.uk/photos/
johnriley
Posted 21/10/2007 - 09:37 Link
I reckon it's big in the frame, but not sharp by a long way.

This could be due to atmospheric conditions, shake even on a tripod with such a long lens, or the moon moving during the exposure. The moon moves very quickly and needs a reasonable shutter speed to arrest that, or a proper astronomical motorised mount for the camera.

Well worth working on though. Getting a really crisp image like the ones in Astronomy books would be quite something.
Best regards, John
ChrisA
Posted 21/10/2007 - 12:26 Link
Quote:
I reckon it's big in the frame, but not sharp by a long way.

This could be due to atmospheric conditions, shake even on a tripod with such a long lens, or the moon moving during the exposure. The moon moves very quickly and needs a reasonable shutter speed to arrest that, or a proper astronomical motorised mount for the camera.
I've had several goes at taking pictures of the moon. One of the things I've noticed is that with a manual focus lens, it's much, much more difficult than you'd think to focus accurately.

Several times, I've taken several shots, all apparently in focus, but only about 1 in 3 is Ok. I do all the rest, of course - tripod, remote, 3s mirror-up mode, short exposures.

It may be that there's another variable that I haven't considered, but I'm tentatively suspecting that getting focus confirmation from the camera is not enough - it has to be right in the middle of the very narrow range over which the camera thinks it's in focus.

John's point about short exposures is a good one though. I'd be inclined to try shorter ones than the 1/45s used for this one. You don't need as much light as you'd think - ISO 400, F8 and 1/45s is several stops more light than I tend to go for (more like ISO 100, F11 and 1/80), although I realise that you can't stop the lens down .
TallNHairyDave
Posted 21/10/2007 - 13:29 Link
John & Chris,

Thanks to you both for your helpful feedback.

Re sharpness, I think Chris has hit the nail on the head with his thought
Quote:
It may be that there's another variable that I haven't considered, but I'm tentatively suspecting that getting focus confirmation from the camera is not enough - it has to be right in the middle of the very narrow range over which the camera thinks it's in focus.
because that image did have focus confirmation from the camera, and even though it's not as sharp as I'd want it was the best of the outing - and this was my first attempt!

I'll try changing the ISO and seeing how I get on with shorter exposures and once my angle-finder arrives I'll be able to shorten the tripod down to it's lowest height to see if that helps with stability (I'm using a Benbo 1, so it's fairly beefy!). I was using the 12s timer option to try and combat shake because I couldn't find my cable release; so hopefully by the next outing it will have turned up and I can use the 2s mirror up instead.

Anyway, thanks again for the tips!
Dave Appleton

Happy Pentax K10D owner since 21-08-2007
http://www.davidappleton.co.uk/photos/
Kim C
Posted 22/10/2007 - 09:23 Link
I might be missing something here but apart from the stars, the moon should be about the the one subject that is really is "infinity". Providing the focus system of the camera is accurate, surely you just need to set it at infinity.

I would be more inclined to look at the atmosherics, movement (camera or moon) or even light pollution.

Kim
ChrisA
Posted 22/10/2007 - 10:36 Link
Quote:
Providing the focus system of the camera is accurate, surely you just need to set it at infinity.

I would be more inclined to look at the atmosherics, movement (camera or moon) or even light pollution.

Kim
Not all lenses' infinity setting is at the end of the focus ring's travel. It often goes a bit further. So focusing at infinity is often no different from focusing at any other distance in practical terms.

What I haven't got my head round is whether the very narrow range over which the focus confirmation indicator is lit is really relevant - whether in reality the circle of confusion is going to be acceptably small anywhere in that range.

If it is, then it's not the focusing. But if it's not that then I don't know why I still get the variation in sharpness I find. I think I've eliminated the atmospherics, movement and light pollution as a source of variation.

I wonder if it's just that the mirror lens, although very light and compact for its focal length, is just not quite good enough, wide open as it has to be, to achieve the sort of sharpness hoped for.
ChrisA
Posted 22/10/2007 - 10:37 Link
By the way, I've taken the liberty of doing a bit of resizing and editing to the OP's photograph.

The first is just after the resize, and the second is after adding a duplicate layer in overlay mode, running a high-pass filter on it (thanks Matt, for the idea some time ago), applying USM to the post-filter layer, flattening the layers and adding a little more USM to the result.

It's still not Astronomy text book standard, but worth persevering with on another day, I think.

Comment Image


Comment Image
TallNHairyDave
Posted 22/10/2007 - 12:28 Link
Quote:
Kim C wrote:
Providing the focus system of the camera is accurate, surely you just need to set it at infinity.

I would be more inclined to look at the atmosherics, movement (camera or moon) or even light pollution.

Kim
Not all lenses' infinity setting is at the end of the focus ring's travel. It often goes a bit further. So focusing at infinity is often no different from focusing at any other distance in practical terms.
Yeah, my Sigma will focus just a little past the infinity mark on the focus ring.

Quote:
What I haven't got my head round is whether the very narrow range over which the focus confirmation indicator is lit is really relevant - whether in reality the circle of confusion is going to be acceptably small anywhere in that range.

If it is, then it's not the focusing. But if it's not that then I don't know why I still get the variation in sharpness I find. I think I've eliminated the atmospherics, movement and light pollution as a source of variation.

I wonder if it's just that the mirror lens, although very light and compact for its focal length, is just not quite good enough, wide open as it has to be, to achieve the sort of sharpness hoped for.
When my angle finder turns up (courtesy of royal mail delays) I'll see whether that makes any difference - it has a 2x magnification option on it and I'll give it a try to see whether or not that will assist manual focussing ignoring the focus confirmation. I did find on that outing that the camera would often rapidly show that it had attained focus, and then lose it again to the point that the green diamond appeared to be flashing on and off...

I'd be inclined to agree that a camera mirror lens might not be good enough to get maximum sharpness. Especially considering that astronomical telescopes are also mirror "lenses" but they are made to far higher levels of precision.

Ho hum, looks like I might have to convince the Mrs that the Meade ETX 125 would be a good purchase. (Fortunately, she's also a bit of a stargazing fan, so I might be able to convince her on the telescope front). Thing is, that's a lot more expensive than my Sigma lens cost me. (And there I was hoping for a cheap shortcut!)

Dave
Dave Appleton

Happy Pentax K10D owner since 21-08-2007
http://www.davidappleton.co.uk/photos/
TallNHairyDave
Posted 22/10/2007 - 12:30 Link
Quote:
By the way, I've taken the liberty of doing a bit of resizing and editing to the OP's photograph.

The first is just after the resize, and the second is after adding a duplicate layer in overlay mode, running a high-pass filter on it (thanks Matt, for the idea some time ago), applying USM to the post-filter layer, flattening the layers and adding a little more USM to the result.

It's still not Astronomy text book standard, but worth persevering with on another day, I think.
Flipping heck! if it wasn't for the watermark I'd not be sure that was the same image!

*makes mental note to try that photoshoppery on next set of lunar photos!*

Thanks for the tip!
Dave Appleton

Happy Pentax K10D owner since 21-08-2007
http://www.davidappleton.co.uk/photos/
ChrisA
Posted 22/10/2007 - 12:42 Link
Quote:
Flipping heck! if it wasn't for the watermark I'd not be sure that was the same image!

Thanks for the tip!
You're welcome. I was quite surprised myself that it came up so well.

No sharpening technique can put in detail that wasn't there already. I've noticed if I attempt to sharpen pictures of my own that are out of focus, all I achieve is noise.

Given that, it occurs to me that the problem with the lens, if there is one, isn't so much a lack of sharpness (ie resolution), but a lack of contrast.
TallNHairyDave
Posted 22/10/2007 - 13:09 Link
Quote:
TallNHairyDave wrote:
Flipping heck! if it wasn't for the watermark I'd not be sure that was the same image!

Thanks for the tip!
You're welcome. I was quite surprised myself that it came up so well.

No sharpening technique can put in detail that wasn't there already. I've noticed if I attempt to sharpen pictures of my own that are out of focus, all I achieve is noise.

Given that, it occurs to me that the problem with the lens, if there is one, isn't so much a lack of sharpness (ie resolution), but a lack of contrast.
Hmm; given that once I'd adjusted the exposure downwards by -1.5 or so in Lightroom to get rid of a couple of very bright areas on the lower right of the moon, I had to tweak the contrast to bring out the detail a little better, I think you might have a point about lack of contrast with the lens.

When I get home tonight I'll try re-exporting the original from Lightroom out to Photoshop (only Elements 4 on my Mac I'm afraid) and see whether or not I can replicate the effect of your Layer Overlay, High-Pass filter, Unsharp Mask, Flatten, Unsharp Mask tweakery on the full size one.

If it works, I'll repost it.

Thanks again for that Photoshop tip - I've got to grips with Lightroom, but I'm still pretty much a Photoshop novice.

Regards
Dave Appleton

Happy Pentax K10D owner since 21-08-2007
http://www.davidappleton.co.uk/photos/
johnriley
Posted 22/10/2007 - 13:16 Link
The reason for long telephotos going past infinity is that expansion and contraction of the lens makes a difference to the infinity point. It becomes critical with some designs, hence the leeway provided.

As for mirror lenses, many of the 500mm ones are not impressive. I'd prefer a standard 500mm telephoto any day.
Best regards, John
TallNHairyDave
Posted 22/10/2007 - 22:16 Link
Well, it's definately not astrophotography textbook material, but it certainly scrubs up a lot better with a bit of photoshoppery...

Thank you once again to Chris A for his top tip

Comment Image
Dave Appleton

Happy Pentax K10D owner since 21-08-2007
http://www.davidappleton.co.uk/photos/
TallNHairyDave
Posted 22/10/2007 - 22:34 Link
Quote:
The reason for long telephotos going past infinity is that expansion and contraction of the lens makes a difference to the infinity point. It becomes critical with some designs, hence the leeway provided.

As for mirror lenses, many of the 500mm ones are not impressive. I'd prefer a standard 500mm telephoto any day.
I did a little research and the sigma came out as one of the few mirror lenses with a decent reputation. Yes, I'd far prefer a Pentax A* prime of around 600mm if I could lay my hands on one, but that sort of glass is well out of my budget at the moment.

But, there's a way round it... one of my other hobbies is stargazing, so I feel an upgrade coming on so I can really combine the two! I've taken some advice from a few astronuts I know, and with a little luck, come this yuletide I'll be adding a much better quality "mirror lens" to my collection...

Comment Image


Cue the Meade ETX 90PE telescope - once the K10D goes onto the T mount on the back of that beastie, it's an 1875mm prime (it's 1250mm on a full frame 35mm) so it's ideal for comets, lunar and planetary observations.

It's not so good for deep sky observation, but I'm more interested in near space objects at the moment and if I'm going to upgrade to a better scope I want something that I can get in the boot of the car easily to get out to somewhere with less light pollution.

That should do the job nicely, until then I'll persevere with the sigma and photoshop and see what I manage to capture
Dave Appleton

Happy Pentax K10D owner since 21-08-2007
http://www.davidappleton.co.uk/photos/
ChrisA
Posted 22/10/2007 - 22:53 Link
Quote:
Thank you once again to Chris A for his top tip
Most kind, but credit should really go to MattMatic, who passed the technique to me.

Your latest version is certainly contrastier, but at the expense of additional noise. I can't help feeling that it would look better smaller. (Resampling, bicubic, sharper), which would mean you wouldn't need to be so aggressive with the sharpening.

When you use every available pixel like this, it's really pushing the limits of the lens/sensor combination. Better IMHO to pick a smaller final image, which looks sharper even though it isn't.

I took this, for instance, back in August, with only a 400mm lens. It looks a lot better than the 100% crop (ie before I reduced it in size). I've overdone this one a bit, since the noise is just starting to appear. But you can get away with a bit less when it's smaller, and end up still with quite a pleasing image.

Comment Image


If you want to go large, there's no alternative (with a sensible price tag, at least) to going to a proper telescope. Look forward to seeing the results when you do..

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo