Mountain Panorama converted to mono

simonkit
Posted 03/08/2009 - 21:00 Link
This is a shot I took last year whilst hiking in the Glyderau mountains in North Wales, it was quite a hazy day so I've converted the shot to mono & added quite a bit of contrast to try & rescue it...appreciate all opinions on this one

thanks

Simon

[IMG]http://i37.photobucket.com/albums/e68/STKITCHIN/G105409_mono_nosharp.jpg[/IMG]
Darkmunk
Posted 03/08/2009 - 21:03 Link
beautiful image, very striking.
Maybe the foreground lakes are a little black
George Lazarette
Posted 03/08/2009 - 22:25 Link
Not bad, but diluted by the left foreground, which doesn't really do anything for the picture.

Hard to crop it out though.

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
Utopia Poppy
Posted 03/08/2009 - 22:52 Link
I agree with Darkmunk and George. The rocks in the foreground are a little distracting, as is the lake on the right with the white edging.

The rocks in the foreground are too pale, and stop me from viewing the landscape as a whole, and the lake on the right is too dark and the white outline to it draws my attention away from the rest of the shot.

I'm no expert when it comes to black and white, but is it possible to tweak the levels or curves or both to adjust the strength of the black lakes and also darken the foreground rocks?

As you can probably tell, I am no expert!

Fiona
"Creativity is allowing yourself to make mistakes. Art is knowing which ones to keep". ~Scott Adams

Q | Various Q lenses & filters | KP | 35mm 2.8 Macro
davidtrout
Posted 03/08/2009 - 23:44 Link
I'm no expert on mono photography either having only done it since I went digital in the last three years but I love the contrasty blacks and whites in this photo. I'm a soot and whitewash enthusiast in black and white prints and this suits my taste just fine. The white rocks in the foreground may be slightly distracting but I love the black lake, or should I say llyn?, in the bottom right. Is it called Llyn Padarn? Those finely sculptured clouds above Tryfan and the Carneddau are pure delight.
david.
doingthebobs
Posted 04/08/2009 - 00:00 Link
I think the clouds are great but knowing this view well I think there is a fundamental flaw in the picture. The mountains look flat!

There are hundreds of metres of vertical hight between the lakes and they now look as if they are next to each other.

The wide angle lens has flattened the landscape in the first instance. The high contrast is just flatening it further by reducing the tonal range of the vegetation and rocks, particularly in the foreground. This is why the slope looks flat, there is no change in tone to suggest depth and distance. Although contrast adds drama to a picture, it also lowers the range of tones in the picture as well.

It may be better in colour? Not always the case as the vegitation can be a bit monotonous at times when the sheep have eaten it all! Often there is marked differences in the tones and that difference is multiplyed by three in colour.
Bob
doingthebobs
Posted 04/08/2009 - 00:26 Link
Just seen your website, you have some great shots on there.

I noticed that you have the same picture, in colour, from the top of Yr Garn. That picture is of different proportions to the one on this thread and I think that is the first problem. The picture above is streched, distorting the picture and is flatening the landscape.

In your colour picture the foreground slope has a much greater tonal range, adding depth and distance to the picture. The subtle differences in the colour of the grass add depth that has been removed in the mono high contrast view above. Try lowering the contrast, mono is not only about black and white, drama is good but it's not everything.

By the way how can you posibly suggest that this shot was taken on a hazy day. Most day i'm out in snowdonia i don't dare getting the camera out of its waterproof case as the 'haze' tends to soak it in seconds!
Bob
George Lazarette
Posted 04/08/2009 - 00:29 Link
Bob, you're quite right, it is not an accurate representation of the scene in geographical terms, but it's still a good picture on its own merits (save for the rather dull bottom left quarter).

It's my favourite part of Britain, south of Hadrian's Wall. Tryfan has special memories for me as it was the first time I led a difficult climb. But that's many years ago.

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
simonkit
Posted 04/08/2009 - 09:23 Link
Thanks for the feedback, the Glyderau are a great place for hiking and photography and certainly my favourite area in Wales. The reason I tried the B&W conversion is that I'm not particularly happy with the lighting in the colour version, bit too harsh - even though it does show the contours/landscape more accurately.

As coincidence I've just become involved in a "project" to put a book together from "Wainwrights Snowdonia viewpoints" and this one of the views he sketched so I'll be reshooting this anyway, the feedback here will help me improve on this one

thanks

Simon
George Lazarette
Posted 04/08/2009 - 11:52 Link
I wonder if it would look better if the camera had been level? You would of course have to crop out more sky, and you might need a wider lens.

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
simonkit
Posted 04/08/2009 - 17:46 Link
George Lazarette wrote:
I wonder if it would look better if the camera had been level? You would of course have to crop out more sky, and you might need a wider lens.

G
Hi George,

If the camera had been level the only scenery in the shot would have been the very top of tryfan & Pen yr olwen, would'nt be any lakes

I've also tried these vantage points with my previous Sigma 10-20 & it's the main reason I sold it...just too wide - the mountains disappear into the distance and don't have any prescence. What may well be worth a try though is a pano

simon
George Lazarette
Posted 04/08/2009 - 17:59 Link
Yes, I did wonder. It occurred to me that to get the depth, while holding the camera horizontal, you would also get a lot of width.

But I still like the pic, even if it's not perfect. We're judging it by your high standards.

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
paulyrichard
Posted 05/08/2009 - 11:22 Link
Great shot Simon, I find nothin' distractin' in this shot. The rocks in the foreground strike a nice analogy with the mountains.

I don't like the tones in this though, its too contrasty for me.
"All the technique in the world doesn’t compensate for the inability to notice." - Elliott Erwitt

http://paulyrichard.wordpress.com/

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo