Macro and "Trap Focus"

Mongoose
Posted 21/04/2007 - 07:24 Link
This idea occurred to me last week when I was taking hand held macros. I expect many of the very clever people here have already thought of this, but I'll post it anyway in case I'm not the only one who's never thought of it before.

First, the problem. SR is great, it gives we Pentaxians something which Canonites cannot have and Nikonians must pay top dollar for. That is, a stabilised Macro lens. Hand held macro here we come!

The problem is that SR can only take care of your shake in two dimensions, and you are moving in three. At normal shooting distances DoF is large enough that this is irrelevant to even the pickiest of us, but at macro distances keeping the subject in focus while hand holding is a nightmare.

What we need is a way to fire the shutter at the precise instant the image comes into focus. Enter Trap Focus. Unfortunatly for the rich among us, this will only work with older Manual focus macro lenses, though it may work with newer lenses if you turn off AF when shutter button pressed in the custom menus (I haven't tried this as my Macro lens is MF).

1. set the camera to AF-S mode

2. Frame the subject slightly out of focus. Unfortunatly the point of focus must be centred since you can only use the centre focus point with an MF lens. If this is not a satisfactory composition you will have to correct it with cropping.

3.Press and hold the shutter button. Nothing should happen

4. Still holding the shutter button, adjust the focus very slowly, either using the focus ring or Krytens Patent Manual Zoom mode (move your head closer to the object).

When the portion of the subject in the centre focus point comes into focus, the shutter should fire, and if all goes well you should have a nicely focussed hand held macro shot. It's not perfect, but I have found this method improves my hand held macro hit rate significantly.

hope this helps someone out
Rodger Fooks
Posted 21/04/2007 - 08:35 Link
I use AF-C mode most of the time for wildlife images and combine it with continuous shooting mode.

Seems to work fine.

If you turn off AF when shutter button pressed half way you can fire the shutter regardless of focus point.
Old wood best to burn, old wine to drink, old friends to trust, and old authors to read.
fatspider
Posted 21/04/2007 - 09:43 Link
I was under the impression that SR was not suitable for macro work? have I misread something somewhere or has Mongoose just proven it wrong?
As for the "trap" focus, I used this method quite often with my old K mount stuff on my istD and my film bodies, and not just for macro.

There is no way (that I have found) to do this with an AF lens tho'
My Names Alan, and I'm a lensaholic.
My PPG link
My Flckr link
Mongoose
Posted 21/04/2007 - 23:36 Link
Quote:
I use AF-C mode most of the time for wildlife images and combine it with continuous shooting mode.

Seems to work fine.

If you turn off AF when shutter button pressed half way you can fire the shutter regardless of focus point.
I don't think you have quite understood what I suggested, the point is that you don't want the camera to fire until focus is correct.

Impotentspider, the wording as I remember it is that SR is less effective in the macro range. I have found it to be good for at least 2 stops with my Tamron macro at 1:1, where I might expect 3 or 4 at longer ranges.

I think trap focus might work with a DA lens if you set the camera not to focus when the shutter is pressed, since the DA lenses have full time manual override. I haven't tested that though.
Kimbo
Posted 22/04/2007 - 10:39 Link
Hmm, I wonder why trap focus only works with K and KA lenses - I'd have thought that F or FA (and presumably DA) lenses would effectively become KAs when set to MF!

I've just tried my DL with F 50mm 1.7, set to manual and the shutter fires regardless of focus position - so there's a definate reason for having a couple of MF lenses in your collection

DOH, just realised that it's a function of AF cameras and so the camera itself has to be set to AF but the lens must be manual - well I was still drowsy when I posted the above comments!

BTW Mongoose, 'trap focus' is the name used by Yashica (and probably others) but the correct terminology for us Pentaxians is 'Snap-in focus', please get it right as some of us are a little sensitive about such things
Die my dear doctor, that's the last thing I shall do!
Mongoose
Posted 23/04/2007 - 10:38 Link
Quote:


BTW Mongoose, 'trap focus' is the name used by Yashica (and probably others) but the correct terminology for us Pentaxians is 'Snap-in focus', please get it right as some of us are a little sensitive about such things
really? I could have sworn my MZ-7 manual called it Trap focus, still it's been a long time since I read said document so you're probably right.

Apologies to all those I may have offended by this flagrant disregard for correct terminology
golfdiesel
Posted 23/04/2007 - 11:06 Link
This only works in the standard setup. I have moved the AF actuation to the ok button on the back. This way the shutter allways fires when you depress the shutter release button.
Camera:K20D|Ist*DS|Spotmatic II|MZ-10
Pentax Lenses: DA16-45|DA50-200|50A 1.7
Tamron Lenses: 28-200
Takumar Lenses: SMC 55 1.8
Sigma Lenses: EX DG 50-500 'Bigma'|EX 50mm Macro
Flashes: Metz 58 AF-1|Samsung SEF-36PZF|Pentax AF-220T
Mannesty
Posted 16/08/2007 - 17:37 Link
I know this is an old'ish thread but I thought I'd add the following:-

I was explaining to my son the possible uses of trap focus at the weekend and I tried to demonstrate it, and failed because I have only AF lenses with me at the moment.

Snap-in or trap focus doesn't work with the 16-50 DA* lens either. I was rather hoping that the AF/MF switch might fool the lens into behaving like a manual focus lens in this respect. It doesn't.

I can't actually think of a good reason for putting this switch on the lens body other than facilitating the choice of lens or camera body setting of AF/MF.

EDIT: I can't seem to make trap focus work on the K10D, even with an old Vivitar manual K mount lens. Has anybody actually got this to work on a K10D?
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream
ChrisA
Posted 16/08/2007 - 17:52 Link
Quote:
EDIT: I can't seem to make trap focus work on the K10D, even with an old Vivitar manual K mount lens. Has anybody actually got this to work on a K10D?
Yep.
Don
Posted 16/08/2007 - 17:57 Link
I have used it on the k10.
I suggest that if you want snap-in focus with your af lenses, that a little peice of cello/scotch tape (or even a strip of paper) over the contacts on the lensmount will do it, providing it's not too thick...
Fired many shots. Didn't kill anything.
Mannesty
Posted 16/08/2007 - 18:38 Link
Quote:
Mannesty wrote:
EDIT: I can't seem to make trap focus work on the K10D, even with an old Vivitar manual K mount lens. Has anybody actually got this to work on a K10D?
Yep.
Thanks Chris, any chance you can add to that. I thought all that was needed was a MF lens and AF on the body. Clearly there is more to it. Do tell . . .
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream
Mannesty
Posted 16/08/2007 - 18:41 Link
Quote:
I have used it on the k10.
I suggest that if you want snap-in focus with your af lenses, that a little peice of cello/scotch tape (or even a strip of paper) over the contacts on the lensmount will do it, providing it's not too thick...
Thanks Don, I have enough manual lenses to try, just not with me at the moment. Your sticky tape/paper idea may well work but I'd rather not mess with my AF lenses. I was just curious to know which settings need to be turned on/off to achieve it.
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream
Don
Posted 16/08/2007 - 18:44 Link
camera body set to af
manual focus lens set to whatever distance you need.
press and hold shutterbutton or lock the remote release.
when camera or subject moves ito the correct focus, the shutter fires.
that simple.
Fired many shots. Didn't kill anything.
ChrisA
Posted 16/08/2007 - 18:57 Link
Quote:
ChrisA wrote:
Quote:
EDIT: I can't seem to make trap focus work on the K10D, even with an old Vivitar manual K mount lens. Has anybody actually got this to work on a K10D?
Yep.
Thanks Chris, any chance you can add to that. I thought all that was needed was a MF lens and AF on the body. Clearly there is more to it. Do tell . . .
My apologies. I didn't realise you didn't already know the technique, I thought you were trying it and it wasn't working.

It's exactly as Don says.

Well, almost. The MF lens needs to start a bit out of focus, not in focus. Otherwise it'll fire straight away.

The point is that when the camera's set to MF, it'll release whenever you press the button. When set to AF, it only releases when it thinks it's in focus.

Incidentally, you have to be moving the focus ring very slowly, otherwise you'll have moved it a bit too far by the time the shutter fires.
Mannesty
Posted 16/08/2007 - 19:09 Link
Quote:
camera body set to af
manual focus lens set to whatever distance you need.
press and hold shutterbutton or lock the remote release.
when camera or subject moves ito the correct focus, the shutter fires.
that simple.
Sorted. I had my 'AF when shutter button halfway' set to off. This technique requires it to be set to on, and the MF switch on the DA* 16-50mm still doesn't allow this to work. As somebody else has already stated, it's not a half bad reason to keep a smattering of MF lenses for when this might be useful.

I was actually trying to use this technique on Monday to capture birds of prey in flight at a zoo demonstration.

I had an excellent shot of an eagle owl with its wings outstretched, at eye level, about 6 feet in front of me. Yep, completely out of focus.
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo